Contracts Flashcards
What is the framework of analysis for contracts questions?
- Has an enforceable contract been formed?
- Has the contract been performed?
- What are the remedies for breach?
Common law applies to:
Real estate and service contracts
The UCC applies to:
Goods contracts
How do you deal with mixed contracts?
- All-or-Nothing Rule: contract is governed by either the UCC or the common law, not both (unless divisible)
- Predominant Purpose Rule: choose which body of law governs the contract by looking at the main reason for entering the contract - does the good or service play a bigger role?
Things to consider when answering “Has an enforceable contract been formed?”
[All Contracts Don’t Stink]
- Agreement
- Consideration
- Defenses
- Statute of Frauds
Agreement =
Offer + Acceptance
Offer =
Manifestation of willingness to enter into an agreement (by the offeror) + creates the power of acceptance (in offeree)
What is the Objective Test?
Whether the offeror displays an objectively serious intent to be bound
To whom must an offer be directed?
A specific offeree
Exception: rewards and contests
Specificity of the Offer - Common Law
All Essential Terms - parties, subject, PRICE, and quantity
Specificity of the Offer - UCC
Need only state the parties and the quantity
UCC has default rules for gap-filling
Power to accept =
Accept and know the deal has been concluded
Invitation to deal
Preliminary communications that still reserve a final round of approval for the speaker
They do not confer the power of acceptance
An offer in can be terminated by -
- Revocation by Express Communication
- Constructive Revocation
- Rejection of the Offer
- Counteroffer
- Death of the Offeror
- Passage of Time
Irrevocable Offers include -
- Options
- Firm Offers
- Partial Performance
- Detrimental Reliance
Requirements for a Firm Offer
- Offeror is a merchant
- Offer is in writing
- Contains an explicit promise not to revoke
- Signed by the merchant
[+ Offer for goods b/c UCC]
Detrimental Reliance
An offer cannot revoked if the offeree reasonably and detrimentally relies on the offer in a foreseeable manner
Partial Performance
A unilateral offer cannot be revoked if the offeree has started performance
Acceptance =
A manifestation of a willingness to enter into the agreement by the offeree
Governed by the objective test
Where there is ambiguity as to the method of acceptance requested by the offeror…
Either method of acceptance (action or return promise) is permissible
What is the consequence of an offeree shipping the wrong goods?
Considered both an acceptance and a breach of the contract.
The Mailbox Rule
An acceptance sent by mail is valid when sent.
The Mailbox Rule does not apply to:
- When the offeree sends something else first
- Other types of communications (rejections, revocations)
- Option Contracts
- Potentially other methods of communication
Implied-in-fact contracts
Acceptance by action
Mirror-Image Rule
Common Law
An acceptance must match the terms of the offer exactly. If not, it is a counteroffer.
UCC § 2-207
A definite and seasonable expression of acceptance [or a written confirmation] which is sent within a reasonable time operates as an acceptance even though it states terms additional to or different from those offered or agreed upon, unless acceptance is expressly made conditional upon assent to the additional or different terms.
Under UCC § 2-207, new terms will govern only if -
- Both parties are merchants
- The new term does not materially alter the deal
- The initial offer did not expressly limit acceptance to its terms
- The offeror does not object within a reasonable time to the new term
If there is not a real contract, but the parties act as if there is, what terms apply?
Only the terms that the writings agree on
Other terms coming from the UCC default rules
Bargained for consideration =
a deal in which the parties exchange promises involving a legal benefit or detriment
Framework of analysis for bargained-for-consideration
- Who is making the promise that needs to be supported by law?
- Is there a benefit to the promisor or a detriment to the promisee?
- Was this bargained for?
Modification - Common Law
Pre-existing Duty Rule - a promise to do something that you are already legally obligated to do is not consideration.
Modification will need bargained-for-consideration.
The Pre-existing duty rule does not apply to -
- Change in performance
- Third party promising to pay
- Unforeseen difficulties that would excuse performance
Modification - UCC
Whether the modification was made in good faith
Consideration Substitutes
- Promissory Estoppel
- Quasi-Contract
- [Moral Obligation + Subsequent Promise to Pay]
Promissory Estoppel
- A promise is made that would reasonably be expected to induce reliance
- The promisee does indeed take detrimental action in reliance on the promise
- Injustice can be avoided by enforcement of the promise
Quasi-Contract
- π confers a measurable benefit on ∆
- π reasonably expected to get paid
- It would be unfair to let the ∆ keep the benefit without paying
Defenses to Contract Formation
- Misunderstanding
- Incapacity
- Mistake
- Fraud/Misrepresentation/Nondisclosure
- Duress
- Illegality
- Unconscionability
Defense of Misunderstanding
- The parties use a material term that is open to 2 or more reasonable interpretations
- Each side attaches a different meaning to the term
- Neither party knows, or should know, of the confusion
Defense of Incapacity
Minors, Mentally Ill, and Intoxicated persons
Contract is voidable, meaning the incapacitated party can disaffirm.
Exception: contracts for necessities
Defense of Mistake
A mistake is a belief that is not in accord with a present fact.
Only the adversely affected party can claim the defense of mistake.
Mutual Mistake
- There is a mistake of fact, existing at the time that the deal is made
- The mistake relates to a basic assumption of the contract and has a material impact on the deal
- The impacted party did not assume the risk of mistake