Midterm Flashcards
The Zenger trial was the first?
American free speech dispute
Hamilton’s Arguement
for Zenger to be guilty, his libel must be false
Zenger published
several seditions libels in the new york weekly journal
zenger was acquitted because
the members of the jury ignored the law
when members of the jury ignore what the law says and do what they believe is justice this is called
jury nullification
what is the basic purpose of the articles of the constitution
articulate the powers of the branches of the federal government
article 1 of the constitution gives who power?
congress
article 2 of the constitution gives who power?
the executive branch
article 3 of the constitution gives who power?
the judiciary
what is the purpose of the bill of rights?
limit the power of the federal government by stating what it cannot do
the bill of rights specifically lists
the rights enjoyed by individuals
who was the major driving force behind the bill of rights
george mason
two level analysis by supreme court part 1
Is the law constitutional as written? (unconstitutional on its face)
two level analysis by supreme court part 2
if yes, is the law being enforced discriminatorily? (unconstitutional as applied)
what were two of the acts of the first free speech crisis?
sedition and alien acts of 1789
purpose of the sedition act
to outlaw written or spoken expression critical of the federal government and other and other persons and institutions when the united states is at war
define the alien act
us may expel any alien at any time, without cause
Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions ruled
sedition acts are illegal, passed by state legislatures
Kentucky Resolution
sedition is illegal
Virginia Resolution
sedition act violates the FA
Adams role in the bill of rights
opposed bill of rights
adams role in sedition and alien act
passed acts to silence political dissent in prep for an undeclared war on France
Jefferson and the bill of rights and sedition acts
supported bill of rights, hated alien and sedition acts
Madison created this plan for the three-branch government
the virginia plan
Marbury vs. Madison
established that courts have power to say what the law is, and to declare laws unconstitutional if they do not agree with the federal constitution
why was marbury v. madison important
gave the power to the supreme court to declare laws unconstitutional (previously the supreme court had no power)
habeas corpus
legal proceeding in which a person who has been detained has the right to demand that the government articulate the reason for the arrest
exception to habeas corpus
cases of rebellion or invasion the public safety may require it
power of congress v. power of president
only congress could suspend h/c because clause is in article 1 (outlines the power of congress)
what were the principal issues in Merryman and Vallandigham?
restrictions on free speech during wartime
14th amendment liberty clause applies to the first amendment to the states?
yes
Gitlow v. New York
involved a conviction for iolation of new york’s criminal anarchy law - distinction between advocacy of overthrow, and advocacy of use of violence in overthrow
content restrictions (3)
sedition, fighting words/inciting language, symbolic speech and speech plus
sedition
expression that is critical of the government and/or government officials
sedition is _______ by the first amendment
generally protected
the espionage act of 1917 dealt with
Whoever, whenever the United States… shall willfully cause or attempt to cause insubordination, disloyalty, mutiny, refusal of duty,…, or shall willfully obstruct the recruiting or enlistment service of the United States”
the sedition act of 1918 did what with the espionage act
covered a broader range of offenses, notably speech and the expression of opinion that cast the government or the war effort in a negative light or interfered
Schenk v. US was an example of what standard through WWII
Sedition - Clear and present danger - schenck
Abrams v. US was an example of what standard through WWII
sedition - clear and imminent danger - russian immigrants
The Whitney v. California case is an example of
state criminal syndicalism laws
whitney provided a distinction between ___ and ___
advocacy of overthrow and advocacy of use of violence in overthrow
Fiske refines a distinction between?
mere advocacy and violent action
Throughout WWII there was a movement along the spectrum for
protection of seditious language
What case brings to question does the first amendment apply to the states?
gitlow v. new york also was used in de jonge v. oregon
why does the 1st amendment apply to the states
14th amendment liberty clause, incorporation doctrine
What did the Smith Act of 1940 do?
rendered unlawful any advocacy of overthrow of U.S government by force or violence
“overthrow by force or violence” applies to what act?
smith act of 1940
Smith Act put into statutory form the holdings of the supreme court from what 2 cases?
Schenck and DeJonge
Dennis vs. deals with what act and why
Smith Act, communist doctrine fear in the overthrowing of the US government
Yates vs. deals with what act
Smith act