Term 2 Flashcards
What are the flows in neoclassical theory
Physical
Inputs - Production - Outputs
Monetary Flow
Revenue - Profit - Cost
What are the assumptions of Neoclassical Theory?
1 plant, 1 Product
PC Market
Owner = Entrepreneur
Max Profit
How do you max profit>
Set P=MC and find quantity
What are the criticisms of neoclassical theory?
Do firms really profit max?
Do we have perfect information
Is the entrepreneur the only actor
What is did Ronald Harry Coases theory consider?
Intra firm v Free market transactions
The Puzzle: if markets exist, how do we explain the existence of the firm
What assumptions does Coase challenge?
Perfect Information
Global Rational
What determines if a firm exists?
If transaction costs are greater than management costs, use firm
What determines the size of the firm
Managerial Dis economies
Misallocation of resources
Dissimilarity of Transactions
Expand until Management Costs = Transaction Costs
What are Williamsons Critiques of Coase?
No quantification of transaction cost
Multiple governance structures available
What assumptions does Williamson have and what are their implications?
Bounded Rationalisation: Satisfying instead of maximising and contracts insufficient
Opportunistic Behaviour: People are dishonest thus contracts need safeguards
How does williamson define a firm?
A governance structure
How do we consider a transaction
Identify the Attributes: Frequency, uncertainty, idiosyncratic investments
Choose the best structure: Market, Hybrid, Hierarchy
What are the attributes we use to consider governance structures, how does each type perform?
Incentive Intensity Admin Controls Adaptation via Autonamy Adaptation via Coordination Contract Law
Market = Alternating, Strong First
Hybrid - Semi
Hierarchy - Alternating, Weak First
What governance structures goes best with each type of transaction?
Occasional and Nonspecific - Market Governance
Reccurent and Nonspecific - Market governance
Recurrent and Idiosyncratic - Unified Governance
What is market governance?
Classical Contract Law
Legally Binding
What is Unified Governance
Internal to a firm
issues sorted by entrepreneur
What is bilateral governance?
Autonomy of parties is maintained?
What is trilateral governance?
Neoclassical Contract Law
What are the criticisms of williamson?
Identification of transaction costs
Opportunism as a universal phenomenon
Reputation and prior cooperation as mechanisms to reduce opportunism
Limited predictable power
Define Vertical Boundaries?
What activities are performed internally v externally
What are the reasons for buying v Make?
Buy:
Economies of Scale and Learning
Bureaucracy
Make
Incomplete Contracts
Opportunism
Idiosyncratic Investments
Discuss economies of scale and learning?
Firms can aggregate the demand of buyers, reducing AC
Discuss the reduction of bureaucracy?
Agency Costs: Slack effort and admin controls designed to stop it
Influence Costs: The costs generated by internal resource lobbying and bad decisions
Discuss Contracts
A contract reduces the opportunity for opportunistic behaviour and protects against it
Effectiveness depedends on completeness and contract law
Discuss a complete contract?
Protects 100% against opportunistic behaviour by specifying every possible contingency
Fails in Practice due to bounded rationality and asymmetric information
What are the consequences of asymmetric contracts?
Problems in coordination of production flows
Possible leak of private information
Transaction costs
Discuss co-ordination problems?
Co-ordination rises costs
Solved by Penalties and Bonuses
If problem is that bad, vertically integrate
Discuss information leakage problems?
Using markets to source suppies can leak information
Solved by patents
If problem is that bad, vertically integrate
Why are incomplete contracts a problem?
Not in isolation, due to opportunistic behaviour
However, if one party cheats, the other can leave
What is the implied contracting process
If no bounded rationality: Planning
If no Opportunism: Promise
If no Asset Specificity: Competition
If all issues, Create a firm
Define a relationship specific asset
Idiosyncratic investments made to support a trasaction
If redeployed
Loose some productivity and a cost
What are the types of asset specificity?
Site: Side by side location
Physical Asset: Design characteristics specific to a transaction
Dedicated: Made based on a relationship, if fail spare capacity
Human Asset: Employees gain skills dealing with a customer
What are the consequences of asset specificity?
Fundemental Transofmraiton: Locked into relationship
Rent and Quasi-Rent
What is Quasi rent?
Profit earned from deploying an asset in its intended use - Its next best
How do you calculate rent, Quasi-Rent and Relationship specific investments
Rent:
X∗(P∗−C)−I
Quasi-Rent:
X∗(P∗−Pm)
Relationship:
I−X*(Pm−C)
P*: price of the good X*: quantity Pm: next best price C: variable cost I: cost of the specific investment
What is the hold up problem
If a good has a large quasi rent, their is the possibility of falling victim to opportunistic behaviour -renegotiating
What is the difference between the neoclassical and TC apprach
Neoclassical Emphasise production costs
Views the firm as a transaction
TC Approach
Focuses on TC
Firm is viewed as one governance structure
What are the two major efficiency that make up a decision?
Technical and Agency
Discuss Technical Efficiency?
Efficiency in the physical produciton of the good
Effected by economies of scale
Discuss Agency Efficecy?
Efficiency of transacting - Choosing the best governance structure
Effected by vertical integration