Case Names

Question 1

Whyte (1988)

Answer 1

Care and control in relation to charter infringement

Question 2

Naglik (1993)

Answer 2

Section 215, necessities of life - objective standard

Question 3

Nette (2001)

Answer 3

Test of causation - hog tied old lady

Question 4

Harbottle

Answer 4

Substantial and integral cause - held girls legs

Question 5

Latimer (2001)

Answer 5

Mercy killings - 12 daughter ? Should there be an exception

Question 6

Martineau (1990)

Answer 6

During a robbery - his buddy killed people, he didn’t didn’t intend for any deaths - no forseeability

Question 7

Theroux (1993)

Answer 7

Fraud - must prove mental state along with action (dishonestly and deprivation)

Question 8

Hundal (1993)

Answer 8

Ran red light with heavy load - modified objective test - must take into account the circumstances of case

Question 9

Creighton

Answer 9

Cocaine in buddy’s arm, didn’t call ems until several hours later - mens rea for manslaughter is objective foresight of bodily harm that is neither trivial nor transitory in nature

Question 10

Tutton/Tutton and Waite

Answer 10

Couldn’t decide if mens rea for crim neg is subjective or objective