changing family patterns Flashcards
explanations for increase in divorce
changes in the law, declining stigma and changing attitudes, secularisation, rising expectations of marriage, women’s increased financial independence, feminist explanations, modernity & individualisation
changes in the law - 1957
men could divorce unfaithful wives, women had to prove husbands cruelty
changes in the law - 1923
grounds for divorce equalised became more easier for women to divorce
changes in the law - 1937
grounds widened to include desertion and cruelty - more reasons to be able to divorce
changes in the law - 1949
divorce more affordable - more accessible
changes in the law - 1969
Divorce Law Reform Act passed
changes in the law - 2004
Civil Partnership Act
changes in the law - 2014
same sex marriage became legal
define stigma
negative label, social disapproval or shame attached to a person, action or relationship
declining stigma and changing attitudes as explanations for increase in divorce
As stigma declines, divorce becomes more socially acceptable and couples become willing to resort to divorce
As divorce has became more common, it reduces stigma
declining stigma and changing attitudes as explanations for increase in divorce - Mitchell & Goody
Important change since 1960s has been rapid decline in stigma
define secularisation
decline in the influence of religion in society
secularisation as explanation of increase in divorce
Sociologists argue religious institutions are losing influence and society is becoming more secular
Traditional opposition of churches to divorce carried less weight in society and people are less likely to be influenced by religious teachings when making decisions about personal matters
Many churches have began to soften their view on divorce, perhaps as they fear losing credibility
rising expectations of marriage as explanation of increase in divorce
In the past, individuals had little choice in who they married as the family was unit of production, marriages were contracted for economic reasons. Individuals were unlikely to have high expectations, entering marriage with low expectations, they were less likely to be dissatisfied by absence of romance
Today, marriage is viewed as a relationship in which individuals seek personal fulfilment
rising expectations of marriage as explanation of increase in divorce - Fletcher
Higher expectations people place on marriage are major cause of rising divorce rates
Links to ideology of romantic love - idea that has become dominant over last couple of centuries. Belief that marriage should be based solely on love
rising expectations of marriage as explanation of increase in divorce criticisms
Feminists criticise functionalists as too rosy a view - oppression of women within the family is main cause of divorce
Functionalists fail to explain why its mainly women who seek divorce
women’s increased financial independence as explanation of increase in divorce
Improvements in women’s economic position have made them less financially dependent on their husbands and freer to end unsatisfactory marriage
Women are more likely to be in paid work - 53% (1971)-67% (2013)
Equal pay and anti-discrimination laws have helped narrow pay gap
Girls greater success in education helps achieve better paid jobs
Availability of welfare benefits means women no longer have to remain financially dependent on husbands
women’s increased financial independence as explanation of increase in divorce - Allen & Crow
Marriage is less embedded within economic system
Fewer family firms and family isn’t a unit of production, so spouses aren’t dependent on each other economically
Women now have own separate source of income
Women don’t have to rely on husbands financially so they don’t have to tolerate conflict and are more willing to seek divorce
Feminist explanations for increase in divorce - Hochschild
Home compares with work
Work - women feels valued
Home - men continuing resistance to doing housework is source of frustration and makes marriage more stable
Both partners go to work, leaving less time and energy for emotion work
Contributes to divorce rates
Feminist explanations for increase in divorce - Sigle-Rushton
Mothers who have dual burden of paid work and domestic work are likely to divorce than non working mothers
Feminist explanations for increase in divorce - Cooke & Gash
No evidence that working women are more likely to divorce
Working has now become the accepted norm
Feminist explanations for increase in divorce - Bernard
Women are becoming conscious of patriarchal oppression and more confident about rejecting it
modernity & individualisation as explanation for increase in divorce
individualisation thesis
relationships become more fragile because individuals become unwilling to remain with a partner if relationship fails to deliver personal fulfilment
pure relationship
Modern society encourages individualism in other ways - work, education - which can cause conflict of interests between spouses and contribute to martial breakdown
Modernity encourages people to adopt neoliberal, consumerist identity based on idea of freedom to follow one’s own self interest
individualisation thesis - Beck & Giddens
Traditional norms lose their hold over individuals
As a result, individual becomes free to pursue their own self interest
pure relationship - Giddens
Relationship that exists solely to satisfy each partners needs and not out of sense of duty, tradition or sake of children
Results in higher divorce rates
other solutions rather than divorce
desertion, legal seperation, empty shell marriage
define desertion
where one partner leaves the other but remain legally married
define legal separation
where court separates financial and legal affairs but remain married
define empty shell marriage
couples continue to live together but remain married in name only
new right - divorce
High divorce rate is undesirable because it undermines marriage and traditional nuclear family which is vital to social stability
High divorce rate creates growing underclass of welfare dependent female lone parents who are a burden on state and leaves boys without male adult role model
feminists - divorce
High divorce rate is desirable because it shows women are finally breaking free from oppression of patriarchal nuclear family
postmodernists & individualisation thesis - divorce
High divorce rate is showing individuals now have freedom to choose to end a relationship when it no longer meets their needs
Major cause of greater family diversity
functionalists - divorce
High divorce rates aren’t a threat to marriage as social institution
Result of peoples higher expectations of marriage
High rate of remarriages shows peoples continuing commitment to marriage
interactionists - divorce
Aim to understand what divorce means to the individual
Morgan (interactionist) - divorce
Can’t generalise about meaning of divorce because individual’s interpretation is different