couples Flashcards
Parsons (functionalist)
clear division of labour - husband is instrumental role, wife is expressive role
how do Young & Willmott criticise Parsons
men are now taking a greater share of domestic tasks, women are becoming wage earners
how does feminists criticise Parsons
it only benefits men
Bott
2 types of conjugal roles - segregated and joint
define segregated conjugal roles (Bott)
couple has separate roles
define joint conjugal roles (Bott)
couple share tasks
Young & Willmott’s study into working class families in Bethnal Green
Men were breadwinners, played little part in home life, spent leisure time with workmates at pubs or working mens clubs
Women were fulltime housewives, helped by female relatives, limited leisure time with female kin
what view does Young & Willmott have
march of progress view
Young & Willmott
Family is gradually improving for all members, becoming equal and democratic
Long term trend away from segregated roles and towards joint conjugal roles
Found symmetrical couple was more common among young couples, those who are geographically and socially isolated and affluent
Rise of symmetrical family as result of significant social changes
Rise of symmetrical family as result of significant social changes - Young & Willmott
changes in women’s position, geographic mobility, new technology, higher standards of living
what view do feminists reject
march of progress view
feminists view
Little has changed
Inequality stems from the fact that family and wider society are patriarchal
Women occupy subordinate and dependent role
why do feminists say little has changed
men and women remain unequal within family and women do most of the housework
Oakley criticises Young & Willmott
Claims are exaggerated
Young & Willmott found that most of the husbands they interviewed ‘helped’ their wives at least once per week - hardly convincing evidence
Oakley’s study into husbands and wives roles in household
15% husbands - high level of participation in housework
25% husbands - high level of participation in childcare
Husbands were more likely to share childcare, but only more pleasurable aspects
‘good father’ was one who would play with the children and take them off the wife’s hands but this meant mothers lost the rewards of childcare and left with more time for housework
Boulton
Less than 20% husbands had major role in childcare
Young & Willmott exaggerate men’s contribution
Almost always the mother who was responsible for child’s security and wellbeing
Warde & Hetherington
Sex typing of domestic tasks remained strong
Men would only carry out routine ‘female’ tasks when the partner wasn’t around
Evidence for a slight change of attitude among younger men, no longer assumed women should do housework
Gershuny (are couples becoming more equal)
Women working full time is leading to a more equal division of labour
Women working full time did less domestic work
Sullivan (are couples becoming more equal)
Increase in couples with equal division of labour (1975-1997)
Increase in men participating more in traditional women (1975-1997)
feminist view (are couples becoming more equal)
Usually women who do majority of household tasks
Men do very little of households unless they do it equally or making small repairs
Boulton (are couples becoming more equal)
mother usually takes responsibility for Childs security and wellbeing
Ferri & Smith (are couples becoming more equal)
fathers took responsibility for childcare in less than 4% families
Dex & Ward (are couples becoming more equal)
78& fathers have high involvement in activities
1% fathers taking care of sick child
Braun, Vincent & Ball (are couples becoming more equal)
3/70 families, father is main caregiver
Southerton (are couples becoming more equal)
managing family quality time has become more difficult in todays late modern society with recent social changes - led to peoples time becoming more fragmented and de-routinised
Men and women now have more or less equal amounts of leisure time, but have different experiences - Women carry dual burden
Crompton & Lyonette (are couples becoming more equal)
cultural explanation of inequality and material explanation of inequality
cultural explanation of inequality (Crompton & Lyonette)
Division of labour is determined by patriarchal norms and values that shape gender roles
Women perform more domestic labour because society expects them to and they’ve been socialised to
Material explanation of inequality (Crompton & Lyonette)
Women earn less than men means its economically rational for women to do housework and childcare
cultural explanation of inequality - Gershuny
Couples whose parents had more equal relationship are more likely to share housework
Parental role models are important
Social values are gradually adapting to the fact women are now working full time, establishing new norm that men should do domestic work
cultural explanation of inequality - Man Yee Kan
Younger men do more domestic work
Suggests generational shift in behaviour is occurring