Crime and Punishment Flashcards
What are absolute ethics?
A clear set of rules which are always right or wrong- e.g ‘Do not kill.’
What are relative ethics?
No definite set of rules, right and wrong change depending on the situation- e.g ‘Kill in self defence’
What is conscience?
What helps humans assess the right choice to make in a moral decision
Whats the difference between a sin and a crime?
A sin is against God, a crime is against the law
Why are laws needed?
- Humans live in groups, and groups need rules to organise the behaviour of individuals.
- Laws protect the weak from the strong
- Advanced civilisations need to laws to keep everything organised and safe
- If people think the legal system isn’t working, then they might start a civil war, so laws prevent violence
Should Christians obey God or the law of the land?
The law of the land
- However Thomas Aquinas argued that crimes that aren’t sins usually come about as a result of unjust laws- and if some laws are unjust, people may think all laws are unjust and break them.
Should Muslims obey God or the law of the land?
- Muslims believe they should follow Shariah law- religious law from Allah
- Often in line with Uk law- e.g killing is forbidden, but abortion is considered against Shariah Law
- Some UK laws are against Shariah law- such as relaxed laws surrounding alcohol.
Why is justice important in Islam?
- The Qur’an teaches that Allah wants people to act justly- ‘stand out firmly against injustice’
- Everyone is equal under Islamic Law
- The Prophet Muhammad acted with compassion and Muslims should follow his example
What is deterrence?
The idea that punishments will be of such a nature that they will put people off committing a crime
What is reformation?
The idea that punishments should try to change criminals so that they will not commit crimes again
What is retribution?
The idea that punishments should make criminals pay for what they have done wrong
What is protection?
The idea that society should be protected from the criminal and the offences that a criminal commits
What is vindication?
An aim or punishment that means offenders must be punished to show that the law must be respected and is right
What is reparation?
An aim of punishment designed to help an offender put something back into society
What does Christianity say about crime?
- Sin is a part of human nature and that all people have the potential to commit crime
What does Christianity say about punishment?
- Punishments ensure justice is done
- Christians don’t believe in taking revenge when they are wrong
- They belive they should forgive the sins of others in the same way they believe God forgives them for their sins
What forms of punishment do Christians support?
- Reform (as this is what Jesus tried to do)
- Protection and deterrence are also important aims
- Some Christians also follow the old Testament teaching - ‘an eye for an eye’ to show that retribution should also be considered
Why is punishment needed in Islam?
- To protect society from the dangers of crime
- Punishments should discourage crime