Criminal Practice - Brief Remaining Chapters Flashcards
Sentencing - Seriousness
What 2 things does the court consider in determining seriousness?
a. Offender Culpability
b. Harm caused/intended to be caused/foreseeably have caused
Sentencing - Seriousness
What 4 levels of culpability are there?
- Intention to cause harm
- Recklessness as to harm
- Knowledge of risk of harm.
- Negligence
Sentencing - Seriousness - Aggravating Factors
What are the four situations in which the court is obliged to treat an offence more seriously?
(a) Previous convictions
(b) Offence was commited on bail
(c) Racial/religious aggravation
(D) Hostility based on sexual orientation or disability
Sentencing - Seriousness
What are some other potential aggravating factors the court may consider?
- planning/premeditation
- group/gang membership
- targeting vulnerable groups
- drink/drugs
- use of weapon
- violence/damage beyond that required for offence
- position of trust
- offence against those working in public sector
- value of property for property offence
- failure to respond to previous sentences
Sentencing - Seriousness
What are 7 mitigating factors?
- acted on impulse
- greater degree of provocation than expected
- particularly young or old
- minor role in offence
- genuine fear
- attempted to make reparation with victim.
Sentencing - Seriousness
When is there a reduction in sentence of one-third for a guilty plea?
- At first hearing in Magistrates’
- Indication at Magistrates’ for indictment-only, followed by guilty plea at Crown Court.
Sentencing - Seriousness
- When is there a 1/4 reduction on sentence for a guilty plea?
- When is it 1/10?
- When is it possibly zero reduction?
- After the first stage of proceedings
- On first day of trial
- During trial
Sentencing - Totality
What is the totality principle?
The court takes into account associated offences.
Sentencing Guidelines
What are the 8 steps given in the Sentencing Guidelines?
- Determining offence category (level of harm and culpability)
- Starting point and category range (aggravating and mitigating factors)
- Factors indicating a reduction of sentence
- Reduction for guilty plea
- Extended sentence
- Totality
- Compensation
- Reasons
Sentencing
What are five types of sentences?
- custody
- suspended sentence
- community sentence
- fine
- discharge
Custodial Sentence
What is the threshold test used to determine whether or not to pass a custodial sentence?
The court must not pass a custodial sentence unless it is of the opinion that the offence (or a combination of the offence and one or more offences associated) was so serious that neither a fine nor community sentence is justified.
Custodial sentence
If the custodial threshold is passed, is it automatically applied?
When is the custodial threshold disapplied?
No. A guilty plea or strong mitigation may make a non-custodial more appropriate.
When an offender fails to express willingness to partake in community sentence.
Custodial sentence
A custodial sentence must be for the ____ term that is commensurate with the seriousness of offence.
What is the maximum custodial sentence a magistrate can impose for a summary only offence? What about an either-way?
Shortest.
6 months; 12 months.
Suspended sentence
When can a suspended sentence be imposed?
How long can the suspension (the operational period) be?
During the suspended sentence, what two things trigger the sentence of imprisonment?
When a custodial sentence of minimum 14 days and maximum 2 years (or 1 year for magistrates) is imposed.
Operational period: 0.5 - 2 years.
- defendant fails to comply with requirements imposed.
- defendant commits an offence during operational period and the court sentencing the new offence orders the original sentence of imprisonment to take effect.
Custodial sentence
A court dealing with a defendant who breached a suspended sentence must: (4 options)
Which of these are required unless unjust to do so?
(a) order original custodial sentence to take effect immediately;
(b) order original custodial sentence to take effect, but for a shorter period
(c) amend original order and impose more onerous community requirements;
(d) amend original order by extending operational or supervision period.
(a) and (b)