Exam 3 Flashcards
Tuskegee study purpose
What happens if we don’t treat syphillis? Difference between effects in white and black people.
Characteristics of the research subjects in the Tuskegee study
Poor, primarily black population in Alabama
Access to penicillin during the Tuskegee study
Physicians were told not to give people in the study penicillin
Implication of the Tuskegee study?
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research was created, creating the Institutional Review Board (IRB)
-Protect the rights and welfare of humans participating in the research study
Three Principles of the Belmont Report?
- Respect for Persons
- Subjects choose to participate or drop out freely
- Autonomy: people must be empowered to make decisions for their own well being - Beneficence
- Maximize possible benefits and minimize possible harms.
- Physiological distress honored through the process of de-indentification and secure data storage
- Physical harm honored through cross-over trial or comparative effectiveness trial - Justice
- Honored through the process of equitable subject selection
Four basic principles of ethical practice
- Autonomy: the patient’s ability to determine their care, free of coercion
- Beneficence: The treatment that the health care professional provides should benefit the patient
- Non-maleficence: Do no harm
- Justice: Fair distribution of scarce resources, competing needs, rights and obligations, and potential conflicts with established laws
Steps of the innovator drug approval process
- Drug Discovery
- Preclinical testing
- Investigational New Drug (IND): document describing preclinical test results, manufacturing information and clinical trial protocols
- Phase 1 Clinical Trials: to evaluate safety and determine the safe dosing range
- Phase II Clinical Trial: to determine efficacy/effectiveness of the compound, examine possible short-term side effects/risks, and identifying optimal dose and schedule
- Phase III Clinical Trial: to determine efficacy/effectiveness and safety of the compound in a longer term
- New Drug Application (NDA) review by the FDA
- Post Marketing Surveillance
Fixed Cost
Cost that does not change with an increase or decrease in the amount of goods produced (ex. cost to design, R&D, office desk, printer, website)
Variable (production) cost
A cost that changes following the quantity of goods produced (costs or material, labor, duties, transportation)
How is the cost structure set up for the drug industry
Not based on cost, it is based on demand
When are people more sensitive to price?
During times of high competition, when there are many alternatives available
When are people less sensitive to price?
During times of low competition when there are few or no alternatives available
Describe differential pricing practice by drug companies, specifically the effect on other countries
Companies’ pricing strategy is to charge the maximum price that the market can bear. Drug companies charge different prices for the same drug, to different countries
Where is the world’s single largest market for innovative drugs?
U.S. @ 33.9% of the world
Lab results; x-ray results, etc
Clinical outcomes
MD palpation during a physical examination; RN report of a vomitting episode
Clinician reported outcome
Total costs spent on cancer treatment, work days lost due to illness, etc.
Economic outcome
Patient reported symptoms/functions
Patient reported outcome
Why are PRO’s important?
- Some treatment effects are known only to the patient
- Mortality as the ultimate outcome indicator is becoming less attractive
- Consumerism in health care where traditional assessments made by clinicians or lab values are not sufficient to evaluate patient preferences
- Patient perspective may not coincide with objective assessments
What are PROs?
Patient reported outcome: any endpoint/observation derived from the patient
How are PROs used?
- Measuring drug effectiveness
- Monitoring drug safety
- Indicator of quality
- Decision maker for treatment types
Two types of health related quality of life (HRQOL) instruments
- General instruments: broadly applicable to general population with a summarized range of basic domains (SF-36)
- Disease or condition specific instruments: Relevant to the patient with specific disease (Asthma quality of life questionnaire AQLQ)
What is health state utility?
Measures the patient preference of a specific health state or health outcome (higher is more desirable)
How is it different that HRQOL?
Rating scale from 0-100 to avoid small numbers
What is QLAYS and how do you calculate it?
(Additional life years gained) x (Utility of those life years)
Four categories of cost with examples
- Directed medical costs: diagnostic tests, drug costs, physician costs, etc.
- Direct nonmedical costs: costs directly associated with treatment but not medical in nature (traveling to doctor’s office)
- Indirect costs: cost that results from the loss of productivity because of illness (missing work days = wage x missed time)
- Intangible costs: cost of pain, suffering, anxiety, or fatigue due to illness or treatment
How is cost effectiveness used in the UK?
Drug price regulation, clinical guidelines
How is cost effectiveness used in the U.S?
Used as the decision criteria in prescription drug coverage - drug that achieves the higher drug outcome at a lower cost is preferred in the formulary
IND
Investigational new drug document describing preclinical test results, manufacturing information, and clinical trial protocols
Phase I Clinical trial purpose
Evaluate safety and determine the safe dosing range
Phase II Clinical trial purpose
Determine efficacy/effectiveness while looking at possible short-term side effects and optimal dosing schedule (months-2 years)