Finals Overview Flashcards
Standards of Review
1) Mere-rationality
2) Strict scrutiny
3) Middle-level review
Mere-rationality
Court will uphold government action if 2 requirements are met 1) Legitimate state objective 2) Minimal rational relation BOP: individual challenging gov. action Examples: a. Dormant Commerce Clause b. Substantive Due Process c. Equal Protection d. Contracts Clause
Strict scrutiny
Only satisfied if governmental act satisfies 2 tough requirements:
1) Compelling objective
2) Necessary means (must not be a less restrictive means of accomplishing
BOP: Government
Examples:
a. Substantive Due Process / Fundamental Rights
b. Equal Protection Review
c. Freedom of Expression
d. Freedom of Religion / Free Exercise Clause
Intermediate Scrutiny
Must be 1) Important objective (between legitimate and compelling) 2) Substantially related BOP: usually government Examples: a. Equal Protection / Semi-suspect b. Contracts Clause c. Free expression/ non-content based
Main Powers of Congress
1) Regulate interstate commerce and foreign commerce
2) Taxing and spending
3) District of Columbia
4) Regulate and dispose of federal property
5) Declare war, establish & fund armed services
6) Enforce post-civil war amendments
Main Powers of President
1) Execution of laws
2) Commander in chief of armed forces
3) Treaty and foreign affairs
4) Appointment of federal officers
5) Pardons
6) Veto
Dormant Commerce Clause
- Prohibits a state from discriminating against interstate commerce for purely economic reasons
- Allows states to incidentally discriminate against interstate commerce in furtherance of a legitimate state interest
3 Part Test
1) Regulation must pursue a legitimate state end
2) Regulation must be rationally related to that legitimate state interest and
3) Regulatory burden imposed by the state on interstate commerce must be outweighed by the state’s interest in enforcing its regulation
Equal Protection
“No state shall make or enforce any law which shall…deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”
- 14th Amendment
Affirmative Action
Race-based affirmative action must be:
1) narrowly tailored and
2) serve a compelling government interest
Selective enforcement of law
1) Prove that the law has a discriminatory effect,
2) Prove that the law has a discriminatory purpose
3) Make at least a credible showing of different treatment of similarly situated persons
Brown v. Board of Education
Separate educational facilities for black students are inherently unequal and violate equal protection guarantees in the US Constitution
Gender Discrimination - When Intermediate Scrutiny Applies
Either:
1) a gender-based classification on the face of the statute or
2) an intent to discriminate based on gender
Equal Protection Federal v. State
State: 14th
Federal: 5th
Supremacy Clause
- If there is a conflict between federal and state law, the state law is invalid
- State law must yield to federal law
Express Preemption
- Congress sometimes states explicitly that the statute is intended to preempt some area of state or local law
- Any state or local law that falls within the zone intended by Congress to be exclusively federal will be invalid under the Supremacy Clause