Philo Final Flashcards
Identity Theory
Every mental state is identical to some physical state.
Physically possible
Something that is possible according to the laws of nature.
Metaphysically possible
Something that is possible in a conceivable in some world/universe.
Curruther’s Identity Theory Argument
- Some mental states are the causes of some physical events.
- But all physical events can be causally explained in terms of other physical events.
- If 1,2 then some mental states must be identical to some physical states.
- Therefore, some mental states are identical to some physical states.
- If some, then all…
Gertler’s Disembodiment Argument
- I can conceive of experiencing pain without a body.
- If 1 then it is possible to experience pain without a body.
- If it is possible to experience pain without having a body, then pin is not identical to any physical state.
- If pain is not identical to any physical state then the identity theory is false.
- Therefore, the identity theory is false.
Jackson’s Mary Argument (against physicalism)
- Marry will learn what it is to experience color first hand.
- If 1 then there is a mental state associated with seeing color.
- If 1&2 then physicalism is false.
- Therefore, physicalism is false.
Qualia
Mental states that have a particular feel to them (pain, tasting food, experiencing color/music)
Physicalism
The view that ALL facts come from the complete biological, chemical, and physical sciences.
Mcbrayer on Mora Facts
Children taught that things are either facts (something that is true about a subject and can be tested or proven) or opinion (What someone thinks, feels, or believes).
This is wrong. There are no moral facts or truths. Any claim with good, right, wrong, etc. is not a fact.
Define God
Omniscient-knowing all that is true Omnipresent-necessarily existent Omnipotent-can do anything metaphysical Omnibenevolent-always knows better from worse Creative Incorporeal
Pascal’s Wager
- The expected value of believing in God is far greater than not believing.
- If 1 then we all have good reason to believe in God.
- Therefore we all have good reason to believe in God.
Believe/Disbelief vs God Exists/Doesn’t Exist
If you believe you win everything, but if you don’t you lose nothing
Prudential evidence
You have reason to believe in P if you believe in P makes you better off.
Evidential reason
You have reason to believe in P if there is some evidence for P.
Aquainas revised Cosmological Argument
- There are contingent things and events happening now in the natural world.
- Every contingent thing and every event has a cause.
- Causes precede their effects.
- If 123 then there is a necessarily existing first cause.
- If there is a necessarily existing first cause then God exists.
- Therefore God exists.
Paley’s Human Eye Argument
- The amazingly intricate and useful human eye exists (evidence)
- This is a highly improbable if there is no god. 3. this is highly probable if there is a God.
- If evidence is much more likely given the God hypothesis, then given it’s denial, evident strongly supports the God hypothesis.
- Therefore evidence strongly supports the God hypothesis.
H1-God exist.
H2-God does not exist
-Paramus two is compromised by Darwins evolution