week 5 Flashcards
Interpatient Variability in Response
In an ideal world the response to medications would be the same for every patient.
Unfortunately in reality, response to medications is quite variable between patients.
Because response to medications is variable, every patient’s response must be evaluated to ensure an adequate therapeutic response.
The response to medication is influenced by genetics, disease state, and the environment.
Determining Interpatient Variability
Clinical trials are an important first step in determining interpatient variability to drug response
To determine interpatient variability in response to medications, we first set an endpoint. For example, if we were talking about an analgesic drug, the
endpoint would be pain relief.
From phase II clinical trial data we can evaluate the number of patients that experience pain relief from each dose of the drug.
This data is plotted on a frequency distribution curve.
The average effective dose (ED50) is at the peak of
the frequency distribution curve. The ED50 is the
dose required to produce a response in 50% of the
population.
The ED50 is often used as the initial dose for therapy
clinical trials phase I
- 20-100 healthy volunteers
- evaluation of pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics
- animal studies guide dosing
clinical trials phase II
- 300-500 patients w disorder
- short term trial to determine efficacy and side effects
- dose-response is determined
- Phase II clinical trials establish dose response information over a range of doses.
clinical trails phase III
- 500 - 5000 patients w target disorder
- efficacy verified and long term side effects evaluated
clinical trials phase IV
- post-marketing surveillance
dosing implications
If all patients are given the ED50 as a starting dose, some patients will have more drug than they need and others will not have enough as seen in the graph below.
The initial dose of a drug is a starting point, however many patients will require dose adjustments to optimize efficacy and minimize adverse events.
Most importantly, responses to medication can be quite variable. It is more important to adjust dosing based on the patient’s response rather than simply using a dosing reference.
When is it okay to use the
ED50 as a starting dose?
When the drug has a wide therapeutic range. If the
drug has a wide therapeutic range there will be a decreased risk of adverse events.
How do we dose drugs
that have a narrow
therapeutic range?
Drugs with a narrow therapeutic range should have their dose titrated (start low and increase slowly until the desired response is achieved)
toxic and lethal doses
Up until now we have always looked at a response as a measure of efficacy (i.e. pain relief).
Responses can also include toxicity or even death due to drug treatment.
We obviously do not want to test for toxic or lethal responses in humans. For this reason, these tests are carried out in experimental animals.
Acute (short term) and chronic (6 month – 2 year) animal testing is carried out to determine the doses that produce toxicity or death in multiple animal species.
The average toxic dose (TD50) is the dose in which 50% of animals experience drug toxicity.
The average lethal dose (LD50) is the dose in which 50% of animals die.
TD50 and LD50 are typically expressed in mg drug/kg body weight.
therapeutic index
Therapeutic index is an indicator of a drug’s safety.
The therapeutic index is calculated by determining the ratio of the TD50 or LD50 to the ED50.
TI = TD50/ED50
or
TI = LD50/ED50
Drugs with a high therapeutic index are considered safe whereas those with a low therapeutic index are
considered unsafe.
Drugs that are safe have a large space in between the dose that produces a therapeutic response and the
dose that produces a toxic or lethal response.
Factors Affecting Interpatient Variation in Response
- Body Weight and Composition
- Genetics
- Gender
- Race
- Kidney Disease
- Liver Disease
- Environment
Body Weight and Composition
We know that the response to medications is largely determined by the concentration of the drug in the body, with the higher concentrations giving a
greater response.
For many drugs, the dose is adjusted for the body weight of the patient (i.e. mg drug/kg body weight) in order to compensate for differences in size.
Normal BSA for an adult is 1.73m2 so some drugs are dosed as mg/1.73m2.
Although body weight helps to normalize dose, what happens when two people have the same body weight but different body composition?
Percentage body fat can change the distribution of the
drug so obese patients may respond differently.
Clinicians often adjust the dose of drugs by body surface area (BSA) because this partially accounts for body composition as well.
genetics
Pharmacogenetics is the study of the effect of DNA sequence variation to the clinical response of drugs.
Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP, pronounced “SNIP”) is a change in DNA sequence that involves a single nucleotide (A,T,C or G).
SNPs can exist in genes that regulate drug metabolism, drug transport or drug receptors, as you have already seen in Module 4.
Genetic variation such as SNPs can explain some of the intersubject variation in drug response.
Doses of some drugs are adjusted based on a patient’s genotype (genetic makeup).
gender
This may seem like an obvious statement but
women and men are different. This is may be
true in terms of drug effects as well.
A drug may be more effective in women than a
man or vice versa
For many drugs the effect of gender is unknown. Why?
Until relatively recently, the majority of drug research was conducted in men.
In 1997 drug regulatory bodies (Health Canada and the US FDA) put pressure on drug companies to include women in trials of new drugs.
A few differences between women and men that
we know of in terms of variation in drug
response are:
o Alcohol metabolism is slower in females.
o Certain opioids are more effective in women, therefore they require lower doses.
o Certain drugs used to treat irregular heart beat cause prolongation of the QT interval on the electrocardiogram of women. This means it is more likely for women to have a fatal cardiac dysrhythmia.
race
The effect of race or ethnicity is difficult to relate to variability of drug response.
One reason is that race is difficult to define.
Many people in our society are from an ethnically heterogeneous background so they cannot simply be categorized by a single race.
There are some instances where generalizations are made by race because of convincing data. For example, concentrations of the cholesterol lowering drug rosuvastatin are 2-3 times higher in Asian compared to Caucasian patients. This can (and has) led to drastic side effects and even death. Therefore doses of rosuvastatin should be decreased in Asian patients.
kidney disease
The kidney is the primary organ responsible for drug elimination.
In patients with kidney disease, drug excretion is significantly decreased.
Decreased drug excretion causes an increase in the half life for drugs that are renally excreted.
Recent evidence also suggests that hepatic and intestinal drug metabolism is also decreased in renal failure.
The net effect of renal failure is increased oral bioavailability and decreased excretion.
Therefore, the dosage of many drugs must be decreased in patients with kidney disease.
liver disease
cirrhotic liver
The liver is the primary organ responsible for drug metabolism.
Patients with liver diseases such as cirrhosis or hepatitis exhibit decreased hepatic drug metabolism.
For drugs that are extensively metabolized, half life
may be significantly increased in patients with liver
disease.
environment
Environmental exposures can significantly change the way patients respond to drugs.
Environmental exposure can be voluntary (smoking, alcohol, diet, exercise) or involuntary (environmental pesticides).
e.g, of environment
- Cigarette smoke induces some drug metabolizing enzymes and can make some drugs less effective.
- Alcohol can exacerbate the toxicity of some other drugs.
- Exercise improves the actions of insulin.
- Some commonly used pesticides can induce CYPs and therefore decrease the response to drugs that are metabolized by CYP enzymes.
adverse drug reactions
Adverse drug reactions (ADRs) are the unintended and undesired responses from drugs.
Adverse drug reactions are an enormous societal health problem.
Canadian research suggests that 7.5% of hospital admissions in Canada are attributed to adverse
drug reactions. This represents 185,000 people per year!
Adverse drug reactions can include:
- Side effects
- Drug toxicity
- Allergic Reaction
- Idiosyncratic Reaction
- Carcinogenic Effects
- Mutagenic Effects
- Teratogenic Effects
side effects
Side effects are secondary to the main therapeutic effect of the drug and are expected.
Side effects occur at normal therapeutic doses and are often unavoidable.
Side effects are often due to poor specificity or selectivity of the drug.
side effects example
antihistamines act by blocking H1 histamine receptors to prevent the symptoms of allergy (i.e. runny nose, watery eyes).
Side effects include drowsiness, dry mouth and urinary
retention.
In the figure you can see that histamine binding to the histamine receptor in sinuses causes vasodilation which results in runny nose and watery eyes.
Antihistamines act by blocking the effect of histamine. Side effects occur when antihistamines bind to either histamine receptors or other receptors in the brain. This produces sedation, dry mouth and urinary
retention. These are side effects of antihistamines.
drug toxicity
Drug toxicity can be considered as any severe adverse drug event.
Drug toxicity is often mediated by overdose where
patients unintentionally or intentionally take too much
medication.
These types of reactions are often extensions of the
therapeutic effect.
For example, a patient who takes too much insulin will experience hypoglycemia (low blood glucose).
allergic reaction
Allergic reactions are mediated by the immune system.
Allergy requires a prior sensitization where a patient is exposed to the allergen (i.e. drug).
Upon subsequent exposure to the drug an allergic reaction will occur. During allergic reactions, mast cells
release chemical mediators such as histamine.
Allergic reactions can vary from itching and rash, to life threatening anaphylaxis (bronchospasm, edema
and severe hypotension).
The intensity of allergic reactions are independent of dosage size. Therefore small doses can produce severe allergy.
~ 10% of all ADRs are related to drug allergy.
Very few drugs cause allergic reactions. The most common drug class to cause drug allergy are the penicillins. Sulfonamides (an antibiotic) and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID) are also known to cause drug allergy.
Idiosyncratic Reaction
These are reactions that occur rarely and unpredictably in the population.
Recent evidence suggests that genetic polymorphisms account for the majority of idiosyncratic reactions.
The majority of polymorphisms causing idiosyncratic reactions occur in drug metabolizing enzymes and drug transport proteins.
It is hoped that one day, routine blood test will be able to determine people at risk for idiosyncratic reactions due to genetic polymorphisms. This already occurs in some centres for the drugs warfarin and 6-mercaptopurine which are metabolized by CYP2C9 and thiopurine methyltransferase (TPMT) respectively
Example of genetic polymorphisms that cause idiosyncratic reactions:
CYP2C9
– Approximately 15% of Caucasians have a polymorphism that decreases metabolism
Example of genetic polymorphisms that cause idiosyncratic reactions:
CYP2D6
10% of Caucasian and African Americans are poor metabolizers. These patients do not
experience pain relief when they take codeine. Codeine is a prodrug that is metabolized by
CYP2D6 to morphine.
Example of genetic polymorphisms that cause idiosyncratic reactions:
Thiopurine methyltransferase (TPMT)
– Approximately 10% of patients have decreased activity and 0.3% have no activity.
Treatment with thiopurine drugs in patients with low or absent TPMT can result in life threatening bone marrow suppression
Example of genetic polymorphisms that cause idiosyncratic reactions:
OATP1B1
– An uptake drug transporter in the liver. 15% of Asian and Caucasian patients have a polymorphism that decreases function.
This leads to an increase in plasma drug concentrations.
This polymorphism has been implicated in causing myopathy (muscle toxicity) in patients taking statin drugs
Example of genetic polymorphisms that cause idiosyncratic reactions:
Glucose 6-Phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency (G6PDH)
– An enzyme important in red blood
cell metabolism.
Deficiency is common in people of African and Middle Eastern descent.
Patients with deficiency may have red blood cell hemolysis following treatment with certain
analgesics (i.e. Aspirin) or anti-malarial drugs.
Carcinogenic Effects
Carcinogenic means the ability of a drug to cause cancer.
Relatively few drugs are carcinogenic.
Determining whether a drug is carcinogenic is difficult because it normally takes years after the initial dose to appear.
The drug diethylstilbestrol (DES) used to be prescribed to prevent spontaneous abortion in high risk pregnancies. Years later it was determined that the female offspring developed vaginal or uterine cancer.
Mutagenic Effects
If a drug is mutagenic it is able to change DNA.
Often when a drug is mutagenic it is also carcinogenic or teratogenic.
Sometimes drugs that are mutagenic are not carcinogenic or teratogenic. These drugs may receive approval for use from regulatory agencies if there is sufficient evidence of safety from preclinical studies.
Drugs are tested for their potential as mutagens by the Ames test.
The Ames test evaluates the ability of the test compound (i.e. a drug) to cause a mutation in specialized strains of bacteria.
Teratogenic Effects
Compounds that are teratogens are known to produce birth defects or impair fertility.
Typically we think of birth defects as major physical malformations, but birth defects also include behavioural and metabolic defects.
Less than 1% of all birth defects are caused by drugs.
Sensitivity to teratogens changes during development.
The United States Food and Drug Administration has categorized drugs according to their risk. In Canada we use the American table as a guideline.
exposure to tertogen during diff pregnancy stages
Gross malformations typically occur when exposure to a teratogen is in the 1st trimester.
Teratogen exposure during the second and third trimesters usually disrupts function as opposed to gross anatomy.
Transfer of drugs across the placenta is thought to be greatest in the third trimester because as the placenta develops, the surface area for transfer between maternal and fetal circulation increases. In addition, the placental-fetal barrier becomes progressively thinner.
pregnancy risk categories - A
well controlled human studies have failed to show risk to fetus in 1st trimester
no evidence of harm later in pregnancy
pregnancy risk categories - B
animal reproduction studies have failed to show harm to the fetus and there are no well controlled studies in preg women
OR
animals studies have shown an adverse effect but well controlled studies in preg women fail to how any harm
pregnancy risk categories - C
animal studies have shown harm to the fetus but there are no well-controlled studies in preg women
potential benefits of the drug outweigh the potential risk
pregnancy risk categories - D
clear evidence of risk to the fetus from studies in humans
potential benefits of drug outweigh the potential risk
pregnancy risk categories - X
studies in animals and humans clearly demonstrate risk to the fetus
risks of using the drug clearly outweigh the benefits
these drugs should never be used in preg women