Part 4 Flashcards
EU CSR definition [2001 - desired]
A concept whereby companies integrate social and environmental concerns in their business operations and in their interaction with their stakeholders on a voluntary basis
Carroll’s CSR pyramid:
FROM TOP DOWN:
- Philanthropic = be good corporate citizen, contribute to community [desired] [do good]
- Ethical responsibilities = be ethical, obligation to do what is right & fair [expected] [do no harm]
- Legal responsibilities = obey the law, law is society’s codification of right and wrong [required]
- Economic responsibilities = be profitable, foundation on which all the others are build [required]
→ Responsibilities are changing! Degree of obligation is changing! CSR is a moving target
EU CSR definition [2010 - expected]
CSR is the responsibility of enterprises for their impacts on society = enterprises should have in place a process to integrate social, environmental, ethical, human rights and consumer concerns into their business operations and core strategy in close collaboration with their stakeholders
What has changed from EU CSR definition?
Not voluntary anymore but expected, broadened scope, collaboration with stakeholders, core strategy
EU Directive [2017] legal/required
EU passed directive that requires large companies to disclose certain information on the way they operate and manage social and environmental challenges, EU states implemented directive by passing corresponding national laws, large public interest companies with more than 500 employees, publish reports on policies implemented in relation to environmental protection, social responsibility, treatment of employees, respect for human rights, anti-corruption, bribery, diversity on company boards
EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive [2021]
Scope of reporting entities has expanded, report contents have increased, introduction of limited assurance [auditing], sustainability reporting must be included in management report and is subject to digital tagging, management and supervisory boards bear explicit responsibility.
CSR development process – Stages of CSR
according to who?
(Simon Zadek) | Stages:
• Defensive (trade-off) - Deny practices, outcomes, responsibilities
• Compliance (trade-off) - Adopt a policy-based compliance approach, as a cost of doing business
• Managerial (in between) - Embed the societal issue in
their core management processes
• Strategic (win-win) - Integrate societal issue into core business strategies
• Civil (win-win-win) - Promote broad industry
participation in corporate responsibility
Doing well by doing good - Friedman
economic responsibilities [agree], legal responsibilities [agree], ethical responsibilities [depends],
philanthropic responsibilities [disagree]
Corporate citizenship =
contribute resources to the community = social case [benefits for society] & business case [benefits for the company] = create win-win
Potential business benefits of corporate citizenship:
Philanthropy can create value for the firm:
▪ Improving the productivity of the firm’s location = increase quality of living, improve human capital basis,
cluster development
▪ Risk-management to avoid negative social standing = establish strong relations to stakeholders and networks,
investment in goodwill as some form of insurance to de-escalate crises
▪ Internal capacity building and development of firm resources = leadership competence and team/social skills, interpersonal/communicative skills, employee motivation and loyalty
▪ Differentiation in the product market = more customer loyalty, new customer base
Components of designing a corporate citizenship strategy:
Philanthropy can be many things, give different resources in different areas to different partners → be strategic and find spot where social and business case are aligned
▪ Instruments = corporate giving, corporate sponsoring, corporate volunteering, corporate support
▪ Issue areas = education, arts and culture, environment, …
▪ Community partners = public/municipal institutions, NGOs, other companies, …
Philanthropy = Link between business and society
According to …
Explain it.
[Porter & Kramer]
Successful corporations need a healthy society & a healthy society needs successful companies
Role for strategic management:
remember graph
- Identify linkages between business and society
a. Inside-out linkages
b. Outside-in linkages - Prioritize fields for action
- Devise strategy
Porter’s Value Chain (Looking inside-out )
Role for strategic management (1a)
Focus on do no harm & do not violate societal expectations [ethical responsibility in Carroll’s
CSR pyramid] = compliance does not distinguish you, focus on efficiency, no need to re-invent the wheel, try to learn from best practice & established standards
Examples o Porter’s Value Chain =
▪ Inbound logistics = Emissions
▪ Operations = Worker safety, labor relations, energy & water usage
▪ Outbound logistics = Packaging use & disposal
▪ Marketing & Sales = Truthful advertising, pricing practices
▪ After-Sales Service = Disposal of obsolete products, customer privacy
Looking inside-out – Mapping negative impact of the value chain:
Role for strategic management (1a)
Porter’s Value Chain
Looking outside-in – Influence of social issues on competitiveness =
Role for strategic management (1b)
Porter’s Diamond Model
Porter’s Diamond Model (Looking outside-in) =
Role for strategic management (1b)
4 different aspects that characterize location and influence ability to be competitive there = how do social/environmental issues influence the competitiveness of a company at a given location?
▪ Context for firm strategy and rivalry = rules and incentives that govern competition
▪ Local demand conditions = nature and sophistication of local customer needs
▪ Related and supporting industries = local availability of supporting industries
▪ Factor input conditions = presence of high-quality, specialized inputs available to firms
Prioritize fields for action:
Role for strategic management (2)
- Generic social issues - Social issues that are not significantly affected by a company’s operations nor materially affect its long-term competitiveness - CO2: bank, service company
- Value chain social impacts - Social issues that are significantly affected by a company’s activities in the ordinary course of business - CO2: logistics company
- Social dimensions of competitive context - Social issues in the external environment that significantly affect the underlying drivers of a company’s competitiveness in the locations where it operates - CO2: automobile company, airlines