Social influence Flashcards
conformity
changes in idiv. behaviour an/or belief as a result of real/imagined group behaviour
types of conformity
compliance
identification
internalisation
compliance definition
-most superficial and least permanent change
-publicly change and privately revert back when group pressure stops
-NSI link
identification definition
-possible private as well as public appearance
-indiv. look to a group for guidance
-adjust their behaviour because membership of the group is desirable and they take on a role in the group
-when membership is no longer desirable, behaviour may revert back
internalisation definition
-deepest more permanent change in attitude
-indiv. publicly and privately change their behaviour to go along with the group norm
-accept them into our own cognitions
-ISI link
two explanations of conformity
-Informational social influence
-normative social influence
ISI definition
-desire to be right
-indiv. is unsure about how to behave
-conform by seeking info from the group
-assume its right
-cognitive process
NSI definition
-desire to be liked
-indiv. go along with group behav. to avoid ridicule and gain acceptance and fit in
-emotional process
AO3-RTS ISI as an expl. of conformity
-RTS ISI as an expl. of conformity conducted by Jenness
-ppts asked to indiv. estimate no. jelly beans in the jar
-group estimate
-last private individual guess
-Jenness found ppts second guess closer to groups estimate then original
-suggests ISI as an expl. of conformity because
-task was ambiguous as all ppts unaware so ppt sought infrp from the group and changed publicly and privately to be right
AO3-limitation of RTS ISI as an expl. of conformity-eco val
-lacks ecological validity
-took place in an artificial environment
-difficult to generalise findings to real life examples of ISI
-people may be less likely to conform for a group if there may be consequences for their actions, unlike a lab setting
-reducing external validity of the research in to ISIS and questioning ISI as an expl. for conformity
AO3-RTS NSI as an expl. for conformity
-conducted by Asch
-ppt asked to state which line A,B,C was closest in length to stimulus line ‘x’
-confederates answered first and gave an incorrect answer
-ppt conformed and said the same wrong answer 37% of the time
-supporting NSI as an expl. because
-the task was unambiguous the ppts later stated that they knew the answer but conformed in order to avoid ridicule
AO3-RTS NSI limitation
-gender bias
-difficult to generslise findings to female
-as suggested that women may be more conformist because they are more concerned about social relationships (Netto 1995)
-shows that NSI underlies conformity for some people (female) more than others (males)
-lowers external vakidity
Asch experiment on conformity AO1
-Lab experiment
-123 American male students
-ppt placed into groups with 7 to 9 confederates
-shown standard line ‘x’ and comparison lines A B C
-one of the lines were the same and the other two were substantially different
-ppts asked to say which was the same length
-ppt were always last or second last
-12/18 trials the confederates gave the same wrong answers
-37% the ppt gave the same wrong answers
-Post-experiment interviews found that the majority of participants conformed publicly during the experiment not privately as they wanted to avoid ridicule
variables affecting conformity
group size
unanimity
task difficulty
variables affecting conformity: group size AO1
-Conformity increases as size of majority group increases
-However, the size of the group stops having an effect on conformity once the group reaches a certain size.
-one real participant and one confederate conformity = 3%
-two confederates and one real participant conformity = 13%
-three confederates and one real participant conformity = 32%
-However, conformity plateaued after this.
-the size of the majority does have an effect on conformity but only to a point
variables affecting conformity: unanimity AO1
Unanimity = complete agreement from a group of people about an answer or viewpoint
-In the original conformity was 37%
-one confederate give the correct answers conformity = 5.5%
- ’lone’ confederate with an answer that was different from the majority and different to the correct answer, conformity = 9%
-Asch concluded that when a dissenter breaks the group’s unanimous position conformity decreases
variable affecting conformity: task difficulty AO1
-conformity increases when task difficulty increases
-made the stimulus line and comparison lines more similar in length
-the correct answer was less obvious and the task was harder
-ISI plays a greater role when the task becomes harder
-When situations are unclear, we are more likely to look to others for guidance.
-As the right answer becomes less obvious we lose confidence in our own ability and are more likely to conform
RTS variables affecting conformity-task difficulty
-Lucas et al
-asked students to solve ‘easy’ and ‘hard’ maths problems
-ppt given three other answers from other fake students
-ppt conformed more often when problems were difficult rather than easy
-supporting Asch’s research as it suggests that when the task is harder, conformity increases
limitation to RTS variables affecting conformity.
-Lucas et al’s study found that conformity is more complex than Asch suggested
-ppts with high confidence in their maths abilities conformed less on the hard math problems than those with low confidence
-this shows that an individual-level factor can influence conformity and interact with situational variables such as task difficulty
-limiting Asch’s research into variables affecting conformity, as he did not research the roles of individual factors
limitation to Asch’s research into variables affecting conformity
-gender bias
-as only males were tested
therefore difficult to generalise the findings to females
-as it is suggested that females might be more conformist, regardless of the variable affecting conformity
-because they are more concerned about social relationships and are more concerned with being liked by their peers (Neto, 1995)
-this weakens the external validity of research into variables affecting conformity.
conformity to social roles definition
-Social roles are the parts that people play as members of various social groups e.g. teachers and students
-These are accompanied by expectations that we, and others, have of what is appropriate behaviour in each role
-We internalise these expectations, so they shape our behaviour
Conformity to social roles AO1
AIM: To investigate how freely people would conform to the roles of guard and prisoner in a role-playing exercise that recreated prison life
-24 emotionally stable US male university students
-basement of stands uni psych department
-volunteers randomly allocated each student to the role of prisoner or guard
-prisoners were arrested at their homes,deloused and dressed in smock uniforms, number rather than by name
-guards were given uniforms, night stick and mirrored glasses, instructed to keep the prisoners under control but use no physical violence
-loss of personal identity, encouraging ppt to conform to social roles
-zimbardo took role as superintendent
-within a day the prisoners rebelled and ripped off their numbers
-as experiment continued, the punishments by the guards escalated
-prisoners started to refer to each other by their prisoner numbers
-3 prisoners were released early due to showing symptoms of psychological disturbance
-roe play was intended to run for two weeks but was called off after 6 days
limitation of research into conformity of social roles
-prone to demand characteristics
-zimbardo took role as prison superintendent
-zimbardo could have influenced how ppt act
-the ppt may have conformed to their roles because the this is what they believed zimbardo wanted them to do rather than because they were conforming to social roles
-the fact the ppts were paid for taking part in this experiment may have influenced this further
-therefore, lowering the internal validity of the research into conformity to social roles.
limitation of research into conformity to social roles
-ethical issues
-lack of informed consent- prisoners did not consent to be arrested at home
-lack of right to withdraw- when a prisoner wanted to leave, zimbardo acted like a superintendent rather than an experimenter with a responsibility to the ppt
-no protection from harm a some showed signs of psychological disturbance
-However zimbardo carried out debriefing sessions with the ppt for several years afterwards and concluded there were no long lasting effects
strength of research into conformity to social roles
-practical applications
-as it can be used to predict and explain behaviour in the real world
-actions displayed by soldiers in abu ghraib military prison in iraq were found to be similar to zimbardo’s findings as prisoners were tortured, humiliated and physically abused
-therefore zimbardo’s research can be used when developing prevention programmes to be used for training purposes
-good external validity as is an important part of applied psychology
obedience definition
type of social influence where somebody acts in response to a direct order from a figure with perceived authority
the person who receives the order may also respond in a way that they would have not done without the order
Milgram’s research into obedience
AIM: To investigate if individuals would obey the orders of an authority figure even if this led to negative consequences
-40 american males aged 20-50
-lab experiment at Yale university
-advert placed in a newspaper seeking volunteers supposedly researching memory on learning paid $4.50
-ppt introduced to another ppt who was actually a confederate
-they drew lots, which were rigged, and the real ppt was assigned the role of the ‘teacher’ and the confederate was always the learner
-teacher’s job was to administrate a learning task and deliver ‘electric shocks’ to the learner (in another room) if the learner got a question wrong
-shocks began at 15 volts and increased in increments of 15 volts to 450 volts
-The experimenter used prompts if the ‘teacher’ refused:
-“Please continue”
-“The experiment requires that you continue”
-Findings: All ppts went to at least 300 volts, with only 12.5% stopping at that point. 65% of ppts continued to the maximum 450 volts, showing high levels of obedience.
Conclusion: Ordinary people are obedient to authority when asked to behave in an inhumane way. It is not necessarily evil people who commit evil crimes but ordinary people who are just obeying orders.