1.3 Law Making Flashcards
(117 cards)
What is the tripartite body of UK Parliament comprised of
The monarch, House of Commons and House of Lords
Where do rules originate for the UK
In the conventions, practices and precedents of Parliament -> Form the Constitution of the United Kingdom
What is the Monarch’s role in Parliament
- The King is a ceremonial figurehead - a theoretical source of executive power who does not actually exercise executive powers
- Executive powers may be exercised in the monarch’s name by Parliament and the government
- No person may accept significant public office without swearing an oath of allegiance to the monarch
What is the House of Commons’ role in Parliament
- The seat of government, the House of Commons is Parliament’s only democratically elected element
- 650 constituencies, each of which votes for an MP to represent it - General election
- The government is formed by the political party with the majority of MPs in the House of Commons -> Leader of this political party is invited by the monarch to be his Prime Minister
- The government has the main say in formulating new Acts of Parliament
What is the House of Lords’ role in Parliament
- Non-elected body
- Made up of 92 hereditary peers who inherit their title and pass it down through their family
- ≈ 700 life peers appointed on a non-partisan (not biased towards a political party) basis by the House of Lords Appointments Commission
- 26 most senior bishops in the Church of England
- Can be overridden by the House of Commons under the Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949. Known as imperfect bicameralism as the two houses are not equal in power
What are Green Papers
Consultative documents issued by the government putting forward proposals for reform of the law and often inviting suggestions
What are White Papers
Documents issued by the government stating its decisions as to how it is going to reform the law - This is for information, not consultation
What are Public Bills
- Involve matters of public policy affecting the whole country or a large section of it
- Most government Bills are in this category e.g. Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012
What are Private Members’ Bills
- Individual (private) MPs introduce a Bill - can be from any political party and are known as ‘backbenchers’ as they don’t sit in the front row in the House of Commons with the government
Two ways a private MP can introduce a Bill:
- By ballot
- Through the ‘ten-minute rule’
What are Private Bills
Designed to create a law which will affect only individual people or corporations - don’t affect the whole community
What are Hybrid Bills
A cross between Public Bills and Private Bills - Introduced by the government, but if they become law they will affect a particular person, organisation or place
What are the steps for passing an Act of Parliament (8)
- Bill is drafted
- 1st reading in the HoC
- 2nd reading in the HoC
- Committee stage
- Report stage
- 3rd reading in the HoC
- Same procedures in the HoL
- Royal Assent
Name 5 influences on Parliament
- Political
- Media
- Pressure groups
- Public opinion
- Lobbyists/lobbying firms
Describe the political influence on Parliament
When a general election is called, the political parties publish a manifesto, which amounts to a promise of what new laws they will introduce
EXAMPLE: The Hunting Act 2004 - Followed a Labour Party promise to outlaw fox hunting if elected
PROS:
- Each political party has its proposals ready
- A government with a majority means that most of the Bills it introduces will be passed
CONS:
- Easy to make a promise -> more difficult to fulfil a promise, particularly without an overall majority
Describe the media’s influence on Parliament
When there is strong public opinion about an issue, the government may bow to it
Where an issue is given a high profile in the media, it may add the weight of public opinion
EXAMPLE: Following the Dunblane massacre 1996, private ownership of handguns was banned
PROS:
- UK’s free press is able to criticise government policy or bring any other issue to the attention of the government using public opinion
CONS:
- Responding too quickly to high-profile incidents leads to poorly drafted law e.g. the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991
- Media companies can manipulate the news to create public opinion
Describe pressure groups’ influence on Parliament
Sectional: represent the interests of a particular group of people
Cause: promote a particular cause
EXAMPLE: 2007 - laws against smoking in public places introduced because of public and medical opinion
PROS:
- Pressure groups often bring important scientific discoveries to the government’s attention e.g. the damage being done by greenhouse gases and other pollutants
CONS:
- Occasions where two pressure groups have conflicting interests e.g. the League Against Cruel Sports wanted to ban fox hunting but the Countryside Alliance wanted it to continue
Describe the influence of public opinion on Parliament
These are the views of the general public in the UK
Strong influence upon Parliament, as 18+ are entitled to vote in general elections
EXAMPLE: Mixed opinion about leaving the EU -> national referendum in 2016 with majority voting to leave the EU, allowing Parliament to legislate in 2017 to allow this to happen
PROS:
- Where the majority of the public has certain beliefs or demands, then Parliament an safely pass legislation on that issue
CONS:
- Gauging public opinion can be notoriously difficult; realistically no-one can definitively say that the majority of the public believe one way or another in a specific issue
Describe the influence of lobbyists on Parliament
Usually professionals or organisations who try to persuade or influence governments to enact, amend or repeal legislation that affects their or their representatives’ interests
EXAMPLE: Most multinational companies have or use lobbyists e.g. Bell Pottinger Private
PROS:
- Citizens and organisations can approach a lobbyist to represent and present their interests direct to government ministers or their departments, where lobbyists have political contacts
CONS:
- Expensive and may only represent people who can afford to pay for their services
- Accusations of dubious and corrupt methods have been made against lobbyists
British Railways Board v Pickin
Set out that Parliament cannot control the actions of its future self and the courts have no power to question the legality of an Act of Parliament
Contradicted by a number of current Acts that DO give the courts power to declare new parliamentary laws incompatible with them
Acts allowing a declaration of incompatibility
Human Rights Act 1998:
PROVISION - Section 4: the courts have the power to declare an Act incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights
CASE EXAMPLE:
H v Mental Health Review Tribunal declared that the Mental Health Act 1983 was incompatible
European Communities Act 1972:
PROVISION - Section 2: Where EU law exists on a particular subject, it can override any inconsistent UK law, including Acts of Parliament
CASE EXAMPLE:
Factortame v Secretary of State for Transport cases held the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 to be contrary to EU law
What is a constitutional monarchy
A system of government that is ruled by a king or queen whose power is limited by its country’s constitution
Definition of delegated legislation
Secondary legislation - laws passed in a specific area by a secondary body to which Parliament has passed its power
What are the 3 types of delegated legislation
- Orders in Council - passed by Privy Council
- Statutory Instruments (SIs) - passed by government ministers
- By-laws - Passed by local authorities and public corporations for matters within their jurisdiction
Why have Orders in Council
There can be a quick response in emergency situations