2.6 The international economy Flashcards

(99 cards)

1
Q

Globalisation

A

the process of increasing economic integration of the world’s economies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Causes of globalisation (6)

A
  • containerisation
  • change in communication technology
  • increasing economies of scale, causing thee MES to rise
  • global production standards
  • reduction in protectionism
  • growth strategies of MNCS

See Econplusdal Video for All Causes/Benefits/Costs/Def

Containerisation:

Mechanism: The development and widespread adoption of standardised shipping containers has drastically reduced the costs and time associated with transporting goods internationally.
Impact: Lower shipping costs make international trade more viable and profitable, encouraging firms to source materials and sell products across the globe. It has facilitated the growth of complex global supply chains.

Change in communication technology:

Mechanism: Advancements in telecommunications, the internet, and related technologies have significantly lowered the cost and increased the speed of communication across borders.
Impact: This makes it easier for businesses to coordinate operations in different countries, manage global supply chains, and access international markets. It also facilitates the exchange of information, ideas, and services globally.

Increasing economies of scale, causing the MES to rise:

Mechanism: Economies of scale refer to the cost advantages that firms gain as they increase their scale of production. A rising Minimum Efficient Scale (MES) suggests that firms need to produce at a larger scale to be cost-competitive.
Impact: To achieve these larger scales of production and remain competitive, firms often need to access international markets to sell their goods and services. This drives them to expand globally.

Global production standards:

Mechanism: The establishment and adoption of international standards for products, processes, and quality control facilitate international trade by ensuring a degree of compatibility and trust between producers and consumers in different countries.
Impact: These standards reduce the need for country-specific adaptations, making it easier and more cost-effective for firms to operate and sell their products globally. They also contribute to the development of global supply chains.

Reduction in protectionism:

Mechanism: Over time, many countries have reduced trade barriers such as tariffs, quotas, and subsidies, often through bilateral or multilateral trade agreements and the influence of organizations like the World Trade Organization (WTO).
Impact: Lower trade barriers make it easier and cheaper for goods and services to flow between countries, encouraging international trade and investment, a key driver of globalisation.

Growth strategies of MNCs (Multinational Corporations):

Mechanism: Multinational corporations aim to grow their revenue, profits, and market share by expanding their operations into new countries. This can involve setting up production facilities, distribution networks, or sales offices in foreign markets.
Impact: The expansion of MNCs drives globalisation by increasing foreign direct investment (FDI), creating international production networks, and facilitating the transfer of technology, skills, and knowledge across borders. Their global reach also helps to integrate markets and cultures.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Export

A

goods and services produced domestically and sold to residents abroad

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Import

A

goods and services produced abroad and sold to residents in the domestic country

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Trade

A

the buying and selling of goods and services

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Terms of trade

A

the ratio of export prices to import prices

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Multinational corporation (MNC)

A

a firm which operates in at least two countries

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Containerisation

A

moving goods through multiple different modes of transport in containers of a standard size. They can be transported efficiently over long distances and are tracked.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

WTO

A

World Trade Organisation. An international body whose purpose is to promote free trade by persuading countries to abolish import tariffs and other barriers to trade.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

WTO Most Favoured Nation Principle

A

Most Favoured Nation Principle (MFN) says that any tariff reduction offered to one country must be offered to all (against trade discrimination)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Protectionism

A

approaches used by governments to protect domestic producers

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Capital goods

A

manufactured goods which are used to produce other goods

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Quality of life

A

the level of wealth, comfort, material goods, and necessities available in a country

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Economic development

A

the expansion of total economic welfare in a country

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

More developed countries

A

countries with a relatively high degree of economic development, average income per capita, quality of life, and historic level of investment in human capital and infractructute

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

more developed countries

A

countries with a relatively high degree of economic development, average income per capita, quality of life, and historic level of investment in human capital and infractructute

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Dependency theory

A

economic events in history have meant that resources flow from a “periphery” of poor and underdeveloped states to a “core” of wealthy states, enriching the later at the expense of the former

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Describe how changing terms of trade affect development

A
  • terms of trade have generally moved in favour of more developed countries and against less developed countries.
  • by exporting the same amount of manufactured goods to the developing world, a more developed country can import a greater quantity of raw materials in exchange
  • developing countries must export increasingly more in order to import the same quantity of capital goods or energy needed for economic development
  • Therefore levels of income and quality of life in more developed countries have improved at the expense of less developed countries.

a) Terms of trade have generally moved in favour of more developed countries and against less developed countries.

This reflects the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis, which suggests that the relative price of primary commodities (often exported by less developed countries - LDCs) tends to decline over the long run compared to the price of manufactured goods (often exported by more developed countries - MDCs).

b) By exporting the same amount of manufactured goods to the developing world, a more developed country can import a greater quantity of raw materials in exchange.

This illustrates the consequence of the terms of trade moving in favour of MDCs. If the price of manufactured goods increases relative to raw materials, then for every unit of manufactured goods sold, an MDC can obtain more units of raw materials. This increases their purchasing power in terms of raw materials.

c) Developing countries must export increasingly more in order to import the same quantity of capital goods or energy needed for economic development.

This highlights the adverse impact on LDCs. If the price of their primary commodity exports falls relative to the price of essential imports like capital goods (machinery, technology) and energy, they need to sell a larger volume of their exports to afford the same amount of imports. This can act as a significant constraint on their development.

d) Therefore levels of income and quality of life in more developed countries have improved at the expense of less developed countries.

This is the core argument regarding the developmental impact. If the terms of trade consistently favour MDCs, they can enjoy higher real incomes and potentially a better quality of life due to cheaper access to raw materials. Conversely, LDCs may experience slower income growth and find it harder to improve living standards as the value of their exports diminishes relative to their import needs. This can exacerbate existing inequalities in the global economy.

Impact on Development:

Reduced Export Earnings: A decline in the terms of trade for LDCs means lower revenue from their exports for the same volume sold. This can limit their ability to finance crucial imports, including those necessary for industrialization and infrastructure development.
Increased Debt Burden: If LDCs rely on borrowing to finance development and their export earnings decline, it becomes harder to service their debt, potentially leading to debt crises.
Constraint on Industrialization: The need to export more primary commodities to afford the same amount of capital goods can trap LDCs in a cycle of dependence on primary industries, hindering diversification and industrial development.
Lower Living Standards: As the purchasing power of their exports decreases, LDCs may find it difficult to improve the living standards of their population through increased consumption of imported goods and services.
Exacerbated Inequality: The divergence in the terms of trade can contribute to the widening income gap between developed and developing nations.
However, it’s important to note some nuances and criticisms of the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis:

Globalisation and Manufacturing Prices: The rise of globalisation and increased manufacturing in some developing countries have, to some extent, put downward pressure on the prices of some manufactured goods, potentially offsetting the trend for some LDCs.
Commodity Price Booms: There have been periods of commodity price booms where the terms of trade have moved in favour of commodity exporters, including some developing countries.
Diversification: Many developing countries have actively pursued strategies to diversify their economies away from primary commodity dependence towards manufacturing and services.
Quality and Value Addition: Focusing on higher-quality products and value addition in processing raw materials can help developing countries improve their export earnings.
Demand Elasticity: The impact of changes in the terms of trade also depends on the price elasticity of demand for a country’s exports and imports.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Absolute advantage

A

where a country can produce more of a good than other countries with the same amount of resources

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Comparative advantage

A

where a country has the least opportunity cost when producing a good

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Opportunity cost

A

the cost of giving up the next best alternative

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Double coincidence of wants

A

two people who want to exchange goods of equal value

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Specialisation

A

a worker only performing one task or a narrow range of tasks. Also different firms, regions, or countries specialising producing one or a narrow range of goods or services.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Protectionism

A

the act of guarding a country’s industries from foreign competition

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Examples of protectionist methods (8)
- administrative barriers - dumping - embargo - import quota - tariffs - subsidies - sunset industries - infant industries ## Footnote a) Administrative Barriers: These are non-tariff barriers that make it more difficult or costly to import goods. They can include: Complex customs procedures: Lengthy paperwork, inspections, and bureaucratic delays. Stringent health and safety regulations: Rules that are difficult or expensive for foreign producers to meet. Product standards: Requiring imported goods to meet specific technical standards. Quotas administered through licensing: Making it cumbersome to obtain the necessary licenses to import. b) Dumping: While dumping itself isn't a protectionist method used by the importing country, it's a practice by exporting countries that can lead importing countries to implement protectionist measures (like anti-dumping duties). Dumping occurs when a country or company exports a product at a price lower than its domestic price or below its cost of production. This can harm domestic producers in the importing country. c) Embargo: This is a complete ban on the import or export of certain goods or all goods to a specific country or from a specific country. Embargoes are often used for political reasons but are a very extreme form of trade protection. d) Import Quota: This is a physical limit on the quantity of a specific good that can be imported into a country over a given period. Once the quota is reached, no more of that good can be imported, regardless of demand. This directly restricts the supply of foreign goods. e) Tariffs: These are taxes imposed on imported goods. Tariffs increase the price of imports, making them less competitive with domestically produced goods. They also generate revenue for the government. f) Subsidies: While tariffs and quotas directly restrict imports, subsidies are a form of protectionism that supports domestic producers. By lowering their costs of production, subsidies make domestic goods more competitive against imports (both domestically and in export markets). g) Sunset Industries: Sunset industries are industries that are in long-term decline, often due to technological change or shifts in consumer demand. Governments might implement temporary protectionist measures to ease the decline, protect jobs in the short term, and allow time for restructuring or the retraining of workers. However, this can delay necessary economic adjustment. h) Infant Industries: Infant industries are new industries that are just starting up in a country. The infant industry argument suggests that these industries may need temporary protection from international competition to grow, achieve economies of scale, and become competitive in the long run. Tariffs, subsidies, and import quotas are common tools used to protect infant industries.
26
Infant industries
new industries that have yet to establish themselves
27
Sunset industries
old industries that are going through deindustrialisation and face competition from abroad
28
Subsidies for domestic producers
financial support given to a domestic producer to help compete with overseas firms. They may allow domestic industries to sell products at a lower price than imports
29
Tariffs/custom duties
a tax on imports to make them more expensive
30
Import quota
a physical limit on the quantity of imports into a country
31
Embargo
a complete ban on international trade - usually for political reasons
32
Dumping
where an overseas firm sells large quantities of a product below cost in the domestic market
33
Administrative barriers
Rules and regulations (such as trading standards and strict specifications) that make it difficult for importers to penetrate an overseas market
34
Advantages of free trade (5)
- Countries can exploit their comparative advantage, which leads to a higher output using fewer resources and increases world GDP. This improves living standards. - Free trade increases economic efficiency by establishing a competitive market. This lowers the cost of production and increases output. - By freely trading goods, there is trade creation because there are fewer barriers. This means there is more consumption and large increases in economic welfare. - More exports could lead to higher rates of economic growth. - Specialising means countries can exploit economies of scale, which will lower their average costs. ## Footnote Countries can exploit their comparative advantage, which leads to a higher output using fewer resources and increases world GDP. This improves living standards. This is a fundamental argument for free trade. Comparative advantage means countries specialize in producing goods and services where their opportunity cost is lower than other countries. This leads to greater global efficiency, higher overall production with the same amount of resources, and ultimately allows consumers worldwide to enjoy more goods and services at potentially lower prices, thus improving living standards. Free trade increases economic efficiency by establishing a competitive market. This lowers the cost of production and increases output. When markets are open to international competition, domestic monopolies and oligopolies face greater pressure to become efficient. They must innovate, adopt cost-effective production methods, and offer competitive prices to survive. This competitive environment drives down the cost of production across industries and encourages greater output to meet global demand. By freely trading goods, there is trade creation because there are fewer barriers. This means there is more consumption and large increases in economic welfare. Trade creation occurs when the removal of trade barriers (like tariffs or quotas) allows consumers to buy goods from the most efficient producer globally. This leads to a shift from higher-cost domestic production to lower-cost international production. Consumers benefit from lower prices and a wider variety of goods, resulting in an increase in overall economic welfare (often illustrated by consumer and producer surplus gains). More exports could lead to higher rates of economic growth. Exports are an injection into a country's circular flow of income, boosting aggregate demand (AD). Higher export revenue can lead to increased production, job creation, and higher profits for domestic firms. This multiplier effect can contribute significantly to a country's overall economic growth rate. Furthermore, access to larger international markets provides opportunities for expansion that might not exist within domestic borders. Specialising means countries can exploit economies of scale, which will lower their average costs. When countries specialize in producing a narrower range of goods and services due to free trade, they can often produce these goods and services on a much larger scale. This allows them to take advantage of economies of scale, where the average cost of production falls as output increases. These cost savings can then be passed on to consumers in the form of lower prices, further enhancing the benefits of free trade. CONS 1. Job Losses and Structural Unemployment: Argument: Increased competition from foreign producers can lead to the decline of domestic industries that cannot compete on price or efficiency. This can result in job losses and structural unemployment in those sectors. Explanation: When trade barriers are removed, domestic firms may struggle to compete with cheaper imports, forcing them to downsize or close down. Workers in these industries may lack the skills needed for jobs in expanding sectors, leading to prolonged periods of unemployment and economic hardship for affected regions. 2. Infant Industry Argument: Argument: New industries in developing countries may need protection from established foreign competitors to grow and become competitive themselves. Explanation: Without temporary protection (e.g., tariffs or subsidies), nascent industries may be overwhelmed by larger, more experienced international firms and may never reach their full potential. This can hinder diversification and long-term economic development in these countries. 3. Risk of Exploitation and Unequal Benefits: Argument: Free trade can lead to the exploitation of workers and resources in countries with lower labor and environmental standards. Explanation: Companies may move production to countries with lax regulations to reduce costs, leading to poor working conditions, low wages, and environmental degradation. The benefits of free trade may also be unevenly distributed, with wealthier countries and multinational corporations often gaining more than developing nations or small domestic businesses. 4. National Security Concerns: Argument: Dependence on foreign suppliers for essential goods (e.g., food, energy, defense) can create vulnerabilities in times of crisis or conflict. Explanation: Countries may choose to protect strategic industries to ensure a reliable domestic supply, even if it means higher costs in peacetime. This prioritizes national security over pure economic efficiency. 5. "Dumping" and Unfair Competition: Argument: Foreign firms may engage in "dumping," selling goods abroad at below their cost of production to gain market share, which can harm domestic producers. Explanation: This predatory pricing can drive domestic companies out of business, even if they are otherwise efficient. Protectionist measures may be implemented to prevent such unfair competition. 6. Balance of Payments Issues: Argument: Free trade can exacerbate trade imbalances, leading to large current account deficits in some countries. Explanation: If a country consistently imports more than it exports under free trade, it can face financing issues and potential downward pressure on its exchange rate. 7. Environmental Concerns: Argument: Increased production and transportation of goods due to free trade can lead to higher carbon emissions and environmental damage. Explanation: The pressure to compete internationally may also lead some countries to lower environmental standards to attract investment, resulting in a "race to the bottom."
35
Advantages of protectionism (5)
- protects infant, declining, and strategic industries - improves the country's balance of payments position - protects domestic employment - protects industries from low wage competition and from unfair foreign competition - avoids potential environmental harm of excessive free trade ## Footnote Protects infant, declining, and strategic industries: Infant Industries: The argument here is that new industries within a country may lack the scale and experience to compete effectively with established foreign firms. Temporary protection, like tariffs or subsidies, can give them the "breathing room" to grow, innovate, and eventually become competitive on a global scale. However, there's a risk that these industries become reliant on protection and never mature. Identifying which industries truly have long-term potential is also a challenge. Declining Industries: Protection can be used to slow the decline of industries facing structural changes (e.g., due to technological advancements or shifts in consumer demand). This can provide time for workers to retrain and for resources to be reallocated to other sectors, potentially reducing unemployment and social disruption. However, it can also delay necessary economic restructuring and keep resources tied up in inefficient sectors. Strategic Industries: These are industries deemed vital for national security or economic sovereignty (e.g., defense, energy, key technologies). Protectionist measures can ensure a reliable domestic supply, reducing dependence on potentially unreliable foreign sources. The definition of "strategic" can be broad and may be subject to political influence. Improves the country’s balance of payments position: Protectionist measures like tariffs and quotas can reduce the volume of imports, thereby decreasing expenditure on foreign goods and services. This can lead to an improvement in the current account balance (part of the balance of payments). However, this can also lead to retaliation from other countries, reducing a nation's exports and potentially offsetting any initial improvement. Furthermore, protectionism doesn't address the underlying reasons for a balance of payments deficit, such as a lack of international competitiveness. Protects domestic employment: By making imports more expensive or restricting their quantity, protectionist measures can shift demand towards domestically produced goods and services. This increased demand can lead to higher output and, consequently, the creation or preservation of jobs within the protected industries. However, this job creation in protected sectors may come at the expense of jobs in other sectors, such as those that rely on imported inputs or those that face retaliatory trade barriers in export markets. Consumers also face higher prices, reducing their real income and potentially leading to lower demand and job losses elsewhere in the economy. Protects industries from low wage competition and from unfair foreign competition: Low Wage Competition: Protectionism can shield domestic industries from competition from countries with significantly lower labor costs, which might otherwise lead to domestic firms being undercut and jobs being lost. However, economists often argue that this prevents consumers from benefiting from lower prices and hinders the reallocation of resources towards industries where the domestic economy has a comparative advantage. Unfair Foreign Competition (e.g., dumping, subsidies): Protectionist measures like anti-dumping duties and countervailing duties can be used to counteract what are deemed to be unfair trade practices by foreign firms or governments. Dumping (selling goods below cost in a foreign market) and subsidies can distort international competition and harm domestic producers. However, proving unfair competition can be complex, and such measures can be used as a pretext for general protectionism. Avoids potential environmental harm of excessive free trade: Protectionist measures can be used to limit the import of goods produced using environmentally damaging practices or from countries with lower environmental standards. This can incentivize domestic producers to adopt more sustainable methods and can put pressure on foreign producers to improve their environmental standards. However, this can also be seen as a form of disguised protectionism, and international cooperation on environmental standards is often considered a more effective solution than trade barriers. Key Considerations for A Level Analysis: Retaliation: A major drawback of protectionism is the potential for retaliatory measures from other countries, leading to trade wars where all countries involved may suffer. Consumer Welfare: Protectionism generally leads to higher prices and reduced choice for consumers. Efficiency: By shielding domestic industries from competition, protectionism can reduce the incentive for innovation and efficiency improvements. Opportunity Cost: Resources used to support protected industries could potentially be used more productively in other sectors of the economy. Long-Term Growth: Most economists argue that, in the long run, free trade fosters greater efficiency, innovation, and economic growth. When discussing the advantages of protectionism in your A Level essays, it's crucial to present these arguments with a balanced perspective, acknowledging the potential drawbacks and considering the economic theory that generally favors free trade. You should also be able to evaluate the effectiveness and potential unintended consequences of different protectionist measures.
36
Disadvantages of protectionism (4)
- higher input costs causing cost push inflation - reduced choice for consumers - risk of retaliation - higher prices
37
Free trade
international trade left to its natural course without tariffs, quotas, or other restrictions
38
Free trade area
member countries abolish tariffs on mutual trade, but each partner determines its own tariffs on trade with non-member countries
39
Customs union
a trading bloc in which member countries enjoy internal free trade in goods and services, with all the member countries protected by a common external tariff barrier
40
Eurozone
the group of EU countries that have replaced their national currencies with the euro
41
Single European Market (SEM)
intended to establish the 'four freedoms' - free movement of goods, services, workers, and capital between EU member states - from 1993 onwards.
42
Economic union
a trade block with free mobility of factors of production, harmonised trading standards, and a common currency
43
Trade creation
the switch from purchasing products from a high-cost producer to a lower-cost producer
44
Trade diversion
the switch from purchasing products from a low-cost producer to a higher-cost producer
45
Balance of payments (BOP)
a record of all the currency flows into and out of a country in a particular time period. Consists of three parts: current, capital, and financial accounts
46
Current account of the BOP
measures all the currency flows into and out of a country at a particular time period in payment for exports, imports, primary income flows, and secondary income flows
47
Capital account of the BOP
measures capital transfers and the acquisition or disposal of non-produced, non-financial assets such as patents, copyrights, and franchises
48
Financial account of the BOP
measures the net change in foreign ownership of domestic financial assets
49
Current account deficit
occurs when currency outflows in the current account exceed currency inflows
50
Current account surplus
occurs when currency inflows in the current account exceed currency inflows
51
Balance of trade
the difference between the money value of a country's imports and its exports in goods (called visibles) and services
52
Transfers
payments between countries in forms of foreign aid, grants, private transfers, and gifts. They are payments that are made without anything of economic value being received in return (called secondary income flows)
53
Net flows
the difference between inward and outward flows
54
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
money put into capital assets, such as manufacturing and service industry capacity, in a foreign country by a business with headquarters in another country. The firm with their headquarters in another country may establish a subsidiary to manage operations abroad.
55
Subsidiary
a company that is more than 50% owned by or is controlled by another company
56
Portfolio Investment
the purchase of one country's securities by the residents or financial institutes of another country
57
Hot money
money which is moved between countries with an aim of making speculative profit either due to changes in exchange rates or interest rates
58
Exchange rate
the external price of a currency, usually measured against another currency
59
Impacts of a persistent current account deficit (3)
- causes the exchange rate to fall - is financed through selling assets and/or taking on debt in the financial/capital account - indicates that the country is lagging behind in international competitiveness ## Footnote Causes the exchange rate to fall (Currency Depreciation): A current account deficit signifies that a country is importing more goods and services than it is exporting. This means there is a higher demand for foreign currency to pay for these imports than there is demand for the domestic currency from foreign buyers of exports. This imbalance in the supply and demand for the domestic currency in the foreign exchange market leads to a depreciation of the currency. The price of the domestic currency falls relative to other currencies. Is financed through selling assets and/or taking on debt in the financial/capital account: A current account deficit represents a net outflow of money from the country. To fund this deficit, the country must have a net inflow of money through the financial account (also known as the capital and financial account). This inflow can occur through: Selling assets: Domestic assets (like government bonds, shares in companies, or even property) are sold to foreign investors. Taking on debt: The government or domestic firms borrow money from foreign lenders. This means that the country is either increasing foreign ownership of its assets or increasing its foreign debt. Indicates that the country is lagging behind in international competitiveness: A persistent current account deficit can be a symptom of a lack of international competitiveness. If domestic firms are unable to produce goods and services that are attractive in terms of price, quality, or innovation compared to foreign firms, then consumers and businesses will tend to buy more imports. This suggests underlying structural weaknesses in the economy, such as: Lower productivity. Higher production costs. A lack of investment in research and development. Inadequate infrastructure. A failure to adapt to changing global demand. These three impacts are key considerations when evaluating the significance of a persistent current account deficit for the UK economy in your AQA A Level Economics studies. You should also consider the potential long-term implications of these impacts.
60
Impacts of a persistent current account surplus (3)
- causes the exchange rate to rise - means deficits in other countries - might mean that there is income not being spent on imported goods and services which generate utility ## Footnote A persistent current account surplus means that a country is consistently exporting more goods and services than it imports. While it might seem positive at first glance, it can have some significant economic consequences. Here are three key impacts: Causes the exchange rate to rise (Currency Appreciation): A current account surplus increases the demand for a country's currency in the foreign exchange market. This is because foreigners need the currency to buy the country's exports. Increased demand for the currency leads to its appreciation (its value rises relative to other currencies). Means deficits in other countries: The global economy operates on a balance. If one country has a persistent surplus, it means that other countries must have corresponding deficits. This can create imbalances in the global economy and lead to trade tensions. Countries with deficits may face pressure to devalue their currencies or implement contractionary policies to reduce their imports. Might mean that there is income not being spent on imported goods and services which generate utility: A large surplus can indicate that a country is saving more than it is investing domestically. This can mean that the country's consumers are not fully benefiting from the goods and services available in the global market. It could also suggest that the country's domestic demand is weak, leading to lower levels of consumption and potentially slower economic growth. The country could be foregoing the utility that would have been derived from the consumption of a wider variety of imported goods. In addition to these, here are some other potential impacts: Increased domestic savings: A surplus implies that a nation is saving more than it invests. Potential for undervalued currency: A persistent surplus might indicate that a country's currency is undervalued, which can make its exports artificially cheap and imports expensive. This can lead to trade disputes with other countries. Accumulation of foreign assets: Countries with surpluses accumulate foreign assets, which can provide a stream of income in the future but also carries risks.
61
Net capital inflow
occurs when currency inflows in the financial account exceed currency outflows (occurs when foreign ownership of domestic financial assets increases more quickly than domestic ownership of foreign financial assets) ## Footnote Here's why it's correct and a little more detail: Financial Account Focus: Net capital inflow is a concept within the financial account of a country's balance of payments. The financial account records transactions involving financial assets and liabilities between a country's residents and the rest of the world. Currency Inflows vs. Outflows: You're right to state that a net capital inflow occurs when currency inflows into the financial account are greater than currency outflows. Foreign vs. Domestic Ownership: Your explanation of this in terms of ownership is also spot on: Inflow: Currency flows into the country when foreigners purchase domestic financial assets (e.g., shares in UK companies, UK government bonds, deposits in UK banks). This increases foreign ownership of domestic assets. Outflow: Currency flows out of the country when domestic residents purchase foreign financial assets (e.g., shares in US companies, US government bonds, deposits in foreign banks). This increases domestic ownership of foreign assets. Net Inflow Defined: Therefore, a net capital inflow happens when the increase in foreign ownership of domestic financial assets is greater than the increase in domestic ownership of foreign financial assets. More money is coming into the country through these financial transactions than is leaving. In simpler terms: Imagine the UK as a company selling shares. If foreigners are buying more of these shares than UK residents are buying shares in foreign companies, there's a net inflow of money (capital) into the UK's financial account. Key takeaway for AQA Economics: Understand that net capital inflow is a component of the financial account. Be able to explain how it relates to the buying and selling of financial assets across borders. Recognize that a net capital inflow can help finance a current account deficit. Be aware that large and volatile capital flows can also pose risks to an economy.
62
Net capital outflow
occurs when currency outflows in the financial account exceed currency inflows (occurs when domestic ownership of foreign financial assets increases more quickly than foreign ownership of domestic financial assets)
63
Capital flight
when a large number of people in a country move capital and assets from one country to another. If many people feared that the banks of a country were to go bankrupt, they might take their money out of the bank accounts and into other country,
64
Expenditure-switching policy
government policy aimed at reducing deficit/increase a surplus on the current account by switching domestic demand away from imports to domestically produced goods
65
Expenditure-reducing demand
government policy aimed at reducing deficit/increase a surplus on the current account by reducing demand for imports by reducing the level of AD in the economy
66
Devaluation of a currency
when a government or central bank officially fixes a new lower exchange rate for the currency in a fixed or pegged system of exchange rates
67
Marshall-Lerner condition
a devaluation of a currency will lead to an improvement in the current account if the combined PED for exports and imports in greater than 1
68
J-curve effect
in the short run, a devaluation of a currency is likely to lead to a deterioration in the current account position before it starts to improve ## Footnote Here's a more detailed explanation for AQA A Level Economics: The J-Curve Effect The J-curve effect describes the typical short-run and long-run impact of a currency devaluation (or depreciation under a floating exchange rate) on a country's current account balance. Short Run Deterioration: Immediately after a devaluation, the value of imports tends to increase in domestic currency terms. This is because: Existing Contracts: Many import and export contracts are agreed upon in advance. So, even though the currency is now weaker, the prices and quantities being traded might not change immediately. Importers are still buying the same volume of goods, but they now have to pay more in their domestic currency due to the higher exchange rate. Price Inelasticity: In the short run, the demand for imports and exports may be relatively price inelastic. Consumers and businesses may take time to adjust their purchasing habits and find alternatives. Therefore, even though imports are now more expensive and exports are cheaper, the quantity bought and sold might not change significantly right away. As a result, the value of imports (in domestic currency) rises while the value of exports (initially unchanged in foreign currency, and thus also relatively unchanged in domestic currency in the very short run) doesn't increase enough to compensate. This leads to a worsening of the current account balance, making a deficit larger or a surplus smaller. Long Run Improvement: Over time, consumers and businesses respond to the change in relative prices: Increased Export Volumes: As exports become cheaper for foreign buyers, the quantity demanded for them starts to increase. Decreased Import Volumes: As imports become more expensive for domestic buyers, the quantity demanded for them starts to decrease as they switch to domestically produced alternatives. If the Marshall-Lerner condition is met (the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports is greater than one), the increase in the volume of exports and the decrease in the volume of imports will eventually outweigh the initial price effects. This leads to an improvement in the current account balance. The "J" Shape: When plotted on a graph with time on the x-axis and the current account balance on the y-axis, the effect resembles the shape of the letter "J": an initial dip (deterioration) followed by a recovery and eventual improvement. Key Factors Influencing the J-Curve Effect: Price Elasticity of Demand: The size and speed of the improvement in the current account depend heavily on the price elasticity of demand for exports and imports. If demand is very inelastic, the J-curve effect may be less pronounced or take longer to materialize. Time Lags: The time it takes for consumers and businesses to adjust their behavior and for new contracts to be negotiated is crucial in determining the shape and duration of the J-curve. State of the Global Economy: The overall economic conditions in trading partner countries will also influence the demand for a country's exports.
69
Trade weighted exchange rate
a measure of the exchange rate of a country's currency that takes into account the amount of trade between each of the countries involved
70
Foreign exchange markets
global, decentralised markets for the trading of currencies
71
Freely floating exchange rate
the exchange rate is determined by the interaction of supply and demand of the currency
72
Advantages of a floating exchange rate (3)
- Interest rates can be set on the needs of the UK rather than changing them to stabilise the exchange rate. - Automatic adjustment of the current account balance. A large deficit should see an outflow of pounds leading to a reduction in a pounds value, thus leading a restoration of export competitiveness. - No need for the government to hold extensive stocks foreign currency to influence the currency's value.
73
Disadvantages of freely floating exchange rates (3)
- Uncertainty for businesses - not knowing the value of the currency makes it harder for businesses to plan ahead. - Over/under valued currency - the exchange rate may remain high or low due to speculators deciding the either buy or sell the currency. Rather than real economic indicators. - Could cause cost-push and demand-pull inflation ## Footnote Let's elaborate on each: Uncertainty for businesses - not knowing the value of the currency makes it harder for businesses to plan ahead. Mechanism: In a freely floating exchange rate system, the value of a currency is determined by the forces of supply and demand in the foreign exchange market. These forces can be volatile and influenced by a wide range of factors, including economic data, interest rate changes, political events, and market sentiment. Impact: This volatility creates uncertainty for businesses involved in international trade and investment. For example, an exporter might agree on a price in a foreign currency, but by the time they receive payment, the exchange rate could have moved unfavourably, reducing their profit margin. Similarly, importers face uncertainty about the future cost of goods and services. This uncertainty can discourage international trade and investment, hindering economic growth. Businesses may need to spend more on hedging strategies to mitigate these risks, increasing their costs. Over/under valued currency - the exchange rate may remain high or low due to speculators deciding to either buy or sell the currency, rather than real economic indicators. Mechanism: While economic fundamentals (like inflation rates, interest rates, and trade balances) are key drivers of exchange rates in the long run, in the short run, the actions of speculators can have a significant impact. Speculators buy and sell currencies with the aim of making a profit from anticipated exchange rate movements. Impact: Speculative activity can sometimes lead to exchange rates that deviate significantly from their fundamental equilibrium values. A currency might become overvalued if speculators believe it will appreciate, leading to a surge in demand. This can make exports expensive and imports cheap, harming domestic industries and potentially leading to a current account deficit. Conversely, an undervalued currency, driven by speculation, can make imports expensive and potentially fuel inflation. These misalignments can distort trade flows and create instability. Could cause cost-push and demand-pull inflation: Mechanism: Fluctuations in the exchange rate can directly impact a country's inflation rate. Depreciation (a fall in the currency's value): Makes imports more expensive, leading to higher costs for businesses that use imported raw materials or components (cost-push inflation). It also makes domestically produced goods cheaper for foreign buyers, potentially increasing export demand and overall aggregate demand (demand-pull inflation). Appreciation (a rise in the currency's value): Makes imports cheaper, potentially reducing the cost of imported inputs and consumer goods, thus putting downward pressure on inflation. However, it also makes exports more expensive, potentially reducing export demand and dampening aggregate demand. Impact: The volatility of freely floating exchange rates can lead to unpredictable inflationary or deflationary pressures, making it more challenging for central banks to maintain price stability. This uncertainty can affect consumer and business confidence and complicate economic planning.
74
Methods of eliminating a BoP deficit (3)
- contractionary policy to decrease AD - trade protectionism - devaluation of currency ## Footnote Contractionary policy to decrease AD: Mechanism: This involves the government or central bank taking actions to reduce aggregate demand (AD) in the economy. Contractionary Fiscal Policy: Higher taxes (reducing disposable income), lower government spending. Contractionary Monetary Policy: Higher interest rates (increasing the cost of borrowing, encouraging saving), reducing the money supply. Impact on BoP Deficit: Lower AD leads to reduced consumer and business spending, including spending on imports. As import demand falls, the outflow of money on the current account decreases, helping to reduce the BoP deficit. Reduced domestic demand might also incentivize domestic firms to focus more on exporting. Considerations: Contractionary policies can lead to slower economic growth, higher unemployment, and potentially deflationary pressures. There's a trade-off between improving the BoP and achieving other macroeconomic objectives. Trade protectionism: Mechanism: Implementing measures to restrict the flow of imports into the country. Common methods include: Tariffs: Taxes on imported goods, increasing their price. Quotas: Physical limits on the quantity of imports allowed. Administrative barriers: Complex regulations and procedures that make importing difficult. Impact on BoP Deficit: By making imports more expensive or limiting their quantity, protectionism aims to reduce the volume and value of imports, thus decreasing the outflow of money on the current account and reducing the BoP deficit. Considerations: Protectionism can lead to retaliation from other countries, resulting in higher tariffs or quotas on a country's exports, potentially worsening the overall trade balance. It also reduces consumer choice, increases prices, and can protect inefficient domestic industries from competition, hindering long-run productivity and growth. Most economists generally advise against widespread protectionism. Devaluation of currency: Mechanism: In a fixed exchange rate system, devaluation is an official lowering of the value of a country's currency relative to other currencies. In a floating exchange rate system, a similar effect (currency depreciation) can occur due to market forces. Impact on BoP Deficit: A weaker currency makes a country's exports cheaper for foreign buyers, increasing their demand (volume and value of exports rise). Simultaneously, imports become more expensive for domestic consumers and firms, reducing their demand (volume and value of imports fall). Both these effects work to improve the trade balance (a significant component of the current account) and reduce the overall BoP deficit. The Marshall-Lerner condition suggests that a devaluation will improve the current account balance if the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports is greater than one. Considerations: Devaluation can lead to imported inflation as the price of foreign goods rises. It can also reduce the purchasing power of domestic consumers for foreign goods and may not be effective if the demand for exports and imports is price inelastic. For your AQA A Level Economics exams, it's important to understand these methods, how they work, and the potential advantages and disadvantages of each in addressing a BoP deficit. You should also be able to evaluate their effectiveness in different economic contexts.
75
Methods of eliminating a BoP surplus (3)
- expansionary policy to increase AD - liberalising trade - revaluation of currency ## Footnote Expansionary policy to increase AD: Mechanism: Expansionary fiscal policy (e.g., lower taxes, increased government spending) or expansionary monetary policy (e.g., lower interest rates, quantitative easing) aims to increase aggregate demand (AD) within the domestic economy. Impact on BoP Surplus: As domestic incomes rise, consumers and firms will likely increase their demand for imports, leading to a higher outflow of money on the current account. Increased investment due to lower interest rates might also attract more imports of capital goods. This increased spending on imports helps to reduce the BoP surplus. Considerations: This approach can lead to inflationary pressures within the domestic economy if the increase in AD outpaces the growth in aggregate supply (AS). There might also be time lags before the impact on imports is fully realized. Liberalising trade: Mechanism: Reducing or removing trade barriers such as tariffs, quotas, and subsidies makes imports cheaper and more accessible to domestic consumers and firms. Impact on BoP Surplus: With cheaper and more available imports, the value of imports is likely to rise, thus reducing the trade surplus (a key component of the overall BoP surplus). Considerations: This can lead to increased competition for domestic industries, potentially causing job losses in less competitive sectors. The speed and extent of trade liberalization need careful consideration to manage the impact on domestic producers. Revaluation of currency: Mechanism: A revaluation (in a fixed exchange rate system) or appreciation (in a floating exchange rate system) means the domestic currency becomes stronger relative to other currencies. Impact on BoP Surplus: A stronger currency makes exports more expensive for foreign buyers, likely reducing the volume and value of exports. Simultaneously, imports become cheaper for domestic consumers and firms, increasing the volume and value of imports. Both of these effects work to reduce the trade surplus and thus the overall BoP surplus. Considerations: While it can help reduce a BoP surplus and potentially lower imported inflation, a revaluation can negatively impact export-oriented industries, potentially leading to lower growth and employment in those sectors. Here are a couple of other methods often discussed: Encouraging outward investment: The government could implement policies to encourage domestic firms and individuals to invest more in foreign assets. This would lead to a greater outflow of capital on the financial account, helping to offset a current account surplus and reduce the overall BoP surplus. Increasing foreign aid or grants: If a country with a persistent BoP surplus increases its provision of aid or grants to other countries, this represents an outflow of money on the current account (specifically within secondary income), which would contribute to reducing the surplus.
76
Rigidly fixed exchange rate
an exchange rate fixed at a certain level by the country's central bank and maintained by the central bank's intervention in forex markets
77
Currency board system
an exchange rate system where a country fixes the value of its currency to another currency
78
Managed exchange rate
exchange rate systems which lie between being freely floating and rigidly fixed
79
Adjustable peg exchange rate
an exchange rate system where currencies are fixed in value in the short term but can be devalued or revalued in the longer term
80
Managed floating exchange rate
an exchange rate system where free markets determine the value of a currency but where central banks intervene from time time to change the value of their currency
81
ERM
a system of managed exchange rates used by most of the EU countries prior to adoption of the euro. Member's currencies were allowed to fluctuate against each other only with agreed bands. Collectively the floated against all other currencies.
82
Advantages of fixed exchange rates (2)
- encourage government responsibility as there is no correction of current account deficits - stability for firms and households
83
Disadvantages of fixed exchange rates (3)
- lose power over monetary policy - speculative pressure - Banks have to hold large reserves of currency to intervene in markets in response to fluctuation or attack. - unstable current account
84
Currency union
an agreement between a group of countries to share a common currency, and usually have a single monetary and foreign exchange policy
85
Impacts of merging currencies (4)
- exchange rate certainty - each nation loses the ability to use monetary policy to change their economic outlook - centrally set interest rate may not line up with what is best for individual countries' economies - political risk from conflicting trade partners ## Footnote Exchange rate certainty: Mechanism: When countries adopt a single currency, the exchange rates between their currencies are permanently fixed at a rate of 1:1 (or cease to exist altogether). Impact: This eliminates the uncertainty associated with fluctuating exchange rates. Businesses involved in trade and investment within the currency union benefit from reduced transaction costs and a more predictable financial environment, encouraging cross-border economic activity. Consumers also benefit from stable prices for goods and services from member countries. Each nation loses the ability to use monetary policy to change their economic outlook: Mechanism: With a single currency, individual member states no longer have independent control over their interest rates or money supply. Monetary policy is typically set by a central authority governing the entire currency union (e.g., the European Central Bank in the Eurozone). Impact: This is a major drawback as individual countries may face different economic conditions (e.g., varying levels of inflation or unemployment). A centrally determined interest rate might be appropriate for some member states but could be too high (stifling growth) or too low (fuelling inflation) for others. This loss of monetary policy sovereignty can limit a nation's ability to respond to country-specific economic shocks. Centrally set interest rate may not line up with what is best for individual countries’ economies: Mechanism: As mentioned above, the single monetary policy aims to achieve macroeconomic stability for the entire currency union. This often involves setting a single interest rate that is deemed appropriate for the average economic conditions across the bloc. Impact: This can lead to situations where some member countries experience interest rates that are not optimal for their specific circumstances. For example, a country experiencing a recession might need lower interest rates to stimulate borrowing and investment, but the central bank might maintain higher rates to control inflation in other, faster-growing member states. This can exacerbate economic problems within individual nations. Political risk from conflicting trade partners: Mechanism: A currency union often involves close economic integration and shared trade policies among member states. However, the individual trade priorities and relationships of member countries with nations outside the union might diverge. Impact: Disagreements over trade policies with external partners can create political tensions within the currency union. Member states might feel that the union's trade stance does not align with their national interests, potentially leading to friction and undermining the cohesion of the currency union. Furthermore, economic shocks or political instability in one member country can have spillover effects on others within the union, creating political challenges for the entire bloc.
86
Advantages of currency unions (4)
- lower transaction costs - increased investment in other nations - encourages fiscal responsibility - trade stability ## Footnote Lower transaction costs: Within a currency union, there's no need to exchange currencies, eliminating transaction costs associated with converting money. This makes trade and investment cheaper and easier. Increased trade and price transparency: A single currency makes it easier to compare prices across different regions, promoting competition and trade. Encourages fiscal responsibility: Member countries may be encouraged to maintain sound fiscal policies to maintain the stability of the currency union. Trade stability: Exchange rate fluctuations are eliminated within the union, providing greater certainty for businesses engaged in international trade.
87
Disadvantages of currency unions (3)
- lose monetary policy as a tool - If the countries’ economies are too different, then the appropriate value of their currency may be different from that of the union as a whole. - high initial costs in joining the union
88
Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
a measure of the output or value added of an economy which does not include output of income from investments abroad or an allowance for the depreciation of the nation's capital stock. It is the standard definition of output used by the UN
89
Economic development
the improvement of total economic welfare and quality of life within a country
90
Indicators of development
these include GDP, information on the distribution of income, mortality rates, and health statistics
91
Human development index (HDI)
an index based on life expectancy, education, and per capita income. A higher HDI indicates a better quality of life
92
Purchasing power parity (PPP)
the exchange rate needed for a quantity of money to buy the same quantity of goods in each country
93
Gross National Income (GNI)
the value of the goods produced by a country over a period of time (GDP) plus net factor income (wages, interest, rent, profit) from abroad
94
Gross National Product (GNP)
the market value of goods produced over a period of time through the factors supplied by citizens on a country both domestically and abroad ## Footnote GNP = GDP + NPIA Where: GNP stands for Gross National Product. This measures the total value of goods and services produced by a country's nationals (residents and businesses) regardless of where that production takes place (within the country or abroad). GDP stands for Gross Domestic Product. This measures the total value of goods and services produced within the geographical boundaries of a country, regardless of who owns the factors of production (domestic or foreign). NPIA stands for Net Property Income from Abroad (sometimes also referred to as Net Factor Income from Abroad or NFIA). This represents the difference between: Income earned by a country's residents from assets they own abroad (e.g., profits, dividends, interest). Income paid to foreign residents who own assets within the country. In simpler terms: To get from GDP (production within a country) to GNP (production by a country's nationals), you need to: Add the income earned by your country's people and businesses from their activities and investments in other countries. Subtract the income earned by foreigners from their activities and investments within your country (as this is included in your GDP but not your GNP). The term "Net Property Income from Abroad" (NPIA) already accounts for this addition and subtraction, hence the formula GNP = GDP + NPIA. Key takeaway for AQA Economics: Understanding this relationship helps you differentiate between these two important measures of national income and output and to analyze how a country's international investment position can affect its overall national income. For example, a country with significant investment abroad and relatively little foreign investment domestically will tend to have a GNP higher than its GDP, and vice versa.
95
Barriers to economic growth and development (9)
- poor infrastructure - corruption in command economies - inadequate human capital due to poor education - lack of property rights - primary product dependency - volatile earnings from commodities - undeveloped financial system making it hard to access funds for capital investment - institutional factors - conflict shifts LRAS left due to losses to human and physical capital ## Footnote Let's elaborate on each: Poor infrastructure: Impact: Inadequate transport networks (roads, railways, ports, airports), unreliable energy supplies, and poor communication systems increase the costs of doing business, limit market access, hinder the movement of goods and labor, and discourage investment. This directly constrains aggregate supply (AS) and reduces productivity. Development Link: Limits access to education, healthcare, and other essential services, hindering human capital development and overall quality of life. Corruption in command economies: Impact: While your note specifies command economies, corruption is a barrier in various economic systems. It involves the abuse of public office for private gain, leading to misallocation of resources, inefficient public spending, unfair competition, and reduced trust in institutions. This undermines both short-run aggregate supply (SRAS) and long-run aggregate supply (LRAS). Development Link: Diverts resources away from essential development projects, weakens governance, and discourages foreign investment. Inadequate human capital due to poor education: Impact: A poorly educated and unhealthy workforce is less productive, less innovative, and less adaptable to technological change. This directly limits the quality and quantity of labor, a key factor of production, thus constraining LRAS. Development Link: Low levels of literacy and numeracy hinder individuals' ability to participate fully in the economy and society, perpetuating poverty and inequality. Lack of property rights: Impact: Weak or unenforced property rights create uncertainty and discourage investment. Individuals and businesses are less likely to invest if they fear their assets could be confiscated or their contracts not upheld. This reduces both domestic and foreign investment, limiting capital accumulation and shifting LRAS to the left. Development Link: Without secure property rights, individuals have less incentive to save, invest in their land or businesses, or engage in long-term economic planning. Primary product dependency: Impact: Economies heavily reliant on the export of raw materials (e.g., agricultural products, minerals) are vulnerable to volatile global commodity prices. Price fluctuations can lead to unstable export earnings, making it difficult to plan government budgets and invest in diversification. Development Link: Often associated with lower value-added activities, limiting opportunities for technological upgrading and the development of higher-skill industries. Volatile earnings from commodities: Impact: The unpredictable nature of commodity prices creates uncertainty for producers, investors, and governments. Booms can lead to unsustainable spending and inflation, while busts can trigger recessions and debt crises. This instability hinders sustained economic growth. Development Link: Makes long-term development planning difficult and can trap countries in a cycle of boom and bust, hindering diversification efforts. Undeveloped financial system making it hard to access funds for capital investment: Impact: A weak financial system (e.g., poorly regulated banks, limited access to credit, underdeveloped capital markets) restricts the flow of savings into productive investment. This limits capital accumulation, a key driver of long-run economic growth (shifting LRAS left). Development Link: Small businesses and entrepreneurs often lack access to the finance needed to start or expand their operations, hindering job creation and innovation. Institutional factors: Impact: This is a broad category encompassing the quality of a country's institutions, including: Rule of law: Consistent and fair application of laws. Political stability: Absence of conflict and predictable political processes. Regulatory environment: Efficient and transparent regulations that encourage business activity without being overly burdensome. Bureaucracy: Efficient and accountable public administration. Weaknesses in these areas increase uncertainty, raise transaction costs, discourage investment, and hinder economic activity, impacting both SRAS and LRAS. Development Link: Strong institutions are crucial for creating a stable and predictable environment that fosters trust, encourages investment, and supports sustainable development. Conflict shifts LRAS left due to losses to human and physical capital: Impact: War and civil unrest directly destroy physical capital (infrastructure, factories, equipment) and lead to loss of life, displacement, and injury, reducing the size and productivity of the labor force (human capital). This severely damages a country's productive capacity, causing a significant leftward shift in the LRAS curve. Development Link: Conflict disrupts education, healthcare, and social structures, with long-lasting negative consequences for human development and economic prospects. Resources are diverted from productive activities to military spending and reconstruction. Your understanding of these barriers is accurate and covers the key areas relevant to AQA A Level Economics. When discussing these in essays, remember to provide explanations of how they impact aggregate supply, investment, productivity, and ultimately, economic growth and development.
96
Market based policies to promote economic growth and development (4) | See Dal Video for Clearer + EVAL
- Trade liberalisation. - Removal of subsidies. - Policies to attract inward investment. - Allowing the price mechanism to work more freely. ## Footnote Trade Liberalisation: Market-Based: This involves reducing barriers to international trade, such as tariffs, quotas, and subsidies on domestic industries. It allows market forces of supply and demand to determine the flow of goods and services across borders. Growth & Development: Increased Efficiency: Exposes domestic industries to greater competition, encouraging them to become more efficient to survive. This leads to a better allocation of resources globally based on comparative advantage. Access to Larger Markets: Opens up foreign markets for domestic producers, potentially leading to increased exports, higher production, and economies of scale. Lower Prices & Increased Choice: Consumers benefit from a wider variety of goods and services at potentially lower prices due to international competition. Technology Transfer: Increased trade can facilitate the diffusion of new technologies and ideas across countries. Removal of Subsidies: Market-Based: Government subsidies distort market signals by artificially lowering the costs of production for certain domestic industries. Removing them allows prices to reflect the true costs and benefits, leading to a more efficient allocation of resources. Growth & Development: Reduced Inefficiency: Prevents resources from being trapped in less productive industries that rely on government support. Fiscal Savings: Frees up government funds that can be used for other purposes like education, healthcare, or infrastructure, which are crucial for long-term development. Increased Competition: Forces domestic firms to become more competitive without the crutch of subsidies. Policies to Attract Inward Investment (FDI): Market-Based: These policies aim to create a more attractive environment for foreign companies to invest in the domestic economy. This often involves reducing bureaucracy, improving infrastructure, offering tax incentives (though these can be seen as a slight deviation from pure market-based), and ensuring political stability. Growth & Development: Capital Inflow: Provides much-needed capital for investment, especially in developing countries where domestic savings may be low. Technology & Skills Transfer: Foreign companies often bring advanced technologies, management expertise, and training opportunities, boosting productivity and human capital. Job Creation: FDI can lead to the creation of new jobs in various sectors. Access to Global Markets: Multinational corporations often have established global networks, providing access to international markets for locally produced goods. Allowing the Price Mechanism to Work More Freely: Market-Based: This involves minimizing government intervention in price controls (e.g., price ceilings, price floors) and allowing supply and demand to determine prices. Growth & Development: Efficient Resource Allocation: Prices act as signals, indicating where resources are most needed and profitable. This encourages producers to allocate resources efficiently to meet consumer demand. Incentives for Innovation: Higher potential profits in growing markets incentivize firms to innovate and develop new products and processes. Reduced Shortages and Surpluses: Freely fluctuating prices help to balance supply and demand, avoiding persistent shortages or surpluses that can hinder economic activity. Important Considerations for A Level Economics: Context Matters: The effectiveness of these policies can depend on the specific context of a country, its level of development, and the presence of other factors like institutional quality and infrastructure. Potential Drawbacks: While generally promoting efficiency and growth, these policies can sometimes have negative short-term consequences (e.g., job losses due to increased competition) or exacerbate inequalities if not implemented carefully alongside other supportive policies. Evaluation: In your essays, it's crucial to evaluate the strengths and limitations of these market-based policies and consider potential alternative or complementary approaches.
97
Interventionist policies to promote economic growth and development (6)
- Infrastructure investment. - education and training investment. - investment in tourism and other services. - overseas aid. - debt cancellation - state welfare system. ## Footnote Here's a breakdown of each, explaining how they work and their potential impacts: Infrastructure Investment: Mechanism: Government spending on improving essential infrastructure such as transport networks (roads, railways, ports, airports), energy supply (electricity grids), communication systems (internet, phone lines), and water sanitation. Growth & Development: Improved infrastructure reduces business costs, enhances productivity, connects markets, facilitates trade, attracts investment (both domestic and foreign), and improves the overall quality of life. It directly boosts aggregate supply (AS) in the long run. For development, it can improve access to education, healthcare, and other essential services. Education and Training Investment: Mechanism: Government spending on all levels of education (primary, secondary, tertiary) and vocational training programs to improve the skills, knowledge, and health of the workforce (human capital development). Growth & Development: A more educated and skilled workforce is more productive, innovative, and adaptable to technological change. This leads to higher wages, increased competitiveness, and long-run economic growth (shifting LRAS to the right). For development, it empowers individuals, reduces poverty, improves health outcomes, and promotes social progress. Investment in Tourism and Other Services: Mechanism: Government policies and spending aimed at developing specific service sectors like tourism, finance, and technology. This can include infrastructure development targeted at these sectors, tax incentives, and marketing campaigns. Growth & Development: Diversifying the economy beyond primary products into higher value-added services can lead to increased export earnings, job creation, and economic growth. Tourism, in particular, can generate significant foreign exchange and employment, especially in developing countries. Overseas Aid: Mechanism: Financial or in-kind assistance provided by governments of developed countries to developing countries. This can take various forms, including grants, concessional loans, technical assistance, and humanitarian aid. Growth & Development: Aid can help fill savings and foreign exchange gaps, finance investment in crucial sectors like infrastructure and education, provide humanitarian relief, and support policy reforms. However, the effectiveness of aid is debated, with concerns about dependency, corruption, and whether it truly fosters sustainable development. Debt Cancellation: Mechanism: Forgiving the outstanding debt of developing countries, often those facing severe financial distress. This is usually done by international organizations (like the IMF and World Bank) and bilateral donors. Growth & Development: High levels of debt can divert significant government revenue towards debt servicing, crowding out essential spending on development priorities like healthcare and education. Debt cancellation frees up these resources, allowing governments to invest in growth-enhancing activities and poverty reduction. However, concerns exist about moral hazard (countries might irresponsibly borrow if they expect future write-offs). State Welfare System: Mechanism: Government-funded programs that provide a safety net for citizens, including unemployment benefits, healthcare, social security, and poverty reduction schemes. Growth & Development: While primarily focused on social equity and reducing poverty, a well-designed welfare system can also support economic growth by ensuring a healthier and more secure workforce, reducing social unrest, and providing a basic level of demand in the economy during downturns. It can also improve human capital development by ensuring access to healthcare and basic necessities. Key Considerations for AQA A Level Economics: Trade-offs: Interventionist policies often involve trade-offs, such as increased government spending potentially leading to higher taxes or borrowing. Efficiency: There are debates about the efficiency of government intervention compared to market-based solutions. Long-run vs. Short-run impacts: Some policies may have more immediate effects, while others are focused on long-term sustainable development. Context: The effectiveness of these policies can vary significantly depending on the specific economic, social, and political context of a country.
98
Types of aid (5)
- bilateral aid - multilateral aid - tied/conditional aid - charitable aid - non-financial aid ## Footnote Bilateral Aid: This is aid given directly from one country to another. For example, the UK government might provide financial assistance or resources directly to the government of Tanzania. Multilateral Aid: This is aid given by international organizations that are funded by multiple countries. Examples of such organizations include the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and various agencies of the United Nations (e.g., UNICEF, WHO, WFP). The recipient country receives aid from the collective efforts of many donor countries. Tied/Conditional Aid: This type of aid comes with specific conditions attached by the donor country. These conditions might require the recipient country to spend the aid in a particular way (e.g., buying goods and services from the donor country - hence "tied"), or to implement certain economic or political policies. Charitable Aid (or Non-Governmental Aid): This aid is provided by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) or charities. These organizations raise funds from the public and other sources to support development projects and humanitarian relief efforts. Examples include Oxfam, Save the Children, and Médecins Sans Frontières. Non-Financial Aid (or Technical Assistance): This type of aid doesn't involve the direct transfer of money. Instead, it focuses on providing expertise, training, technology transfer, and other forms of assistance to build capacity and support development in the recipient country. This could include sending skilled professionals to advise on projects or providing equipment and training on its use.
99
Why is aid sometimes ineffective? (6)
- Money can get channelled into benefiting a small group of people. - Conditional aid may largely benefit the developed economy giving the aid if the money has to be spent on their exports. - Goods and services may not be suitable for the needs of the population. - Those receiving the money may not have the expertise to spend it wisely, which can lead to expenditure on inappropriate programs. - Risk of aid dependency - Market distortions can happen if firms focus their resources on trying to secure aid rather than putting them to their best use ## Footnote Let's break them down further: Money can get channelled into benefiting a small group of people (Corruption and Governance Issues): Mechanism: Weak governance, corruption, and lack of accountability in recipient countries can lead to aid funds being misappropriated by political elites, government officials, or specific interest groups. Impact: Instead of reaching the intended beneficiaries and projects, aid money can be diverted for personal gain, luxury goods, or to fund patronage networks. This reduces the impact of aid on overall development and can even exacerbate inequality. Conditional aid may largely benefit the developed economy giving the aid if the money has to be spent on their exports (Tied Aid): Mechanism: As you mentioned earlier, tied aid requires recipient countries to spend the aid on goods and services from the donor country. Impact: This can inflate the prices of goods and services procured, as the recipient country may not be able to seek the most cost-effective options on the global market. It primarily benefits the donor country's industries rather than necessarily addressing the most pressing needs of the recipient country. The goods and services provided might also not be the most appropriate for the local context. Goods and services may not be suitable for the needs of the population (Inappropriate Aid): Mechanism: Sometimes, aid projects are designed without sufficient understanding of the local context, culture, or specific needs of the population. This can result in the provision of goods, technologies, or infrastructure that are not useful, sustainable, or culturally appropriate. Impact: Resources are wasted on projects that do not address the real problems faced by the people. This can lead to low utilization rates, project failure, and a lack of lasting positive impact. Those receiving the money may not have the expertise to spend it wisely, which can lead to expenditure on inappropriate programs (Lack of Absorptive Capacity): Mechanism: Recipient countries may lack the skilled personnel, technical knowledge, or effective institutions to manage and implement aid projects efficiently and effectively. Impact: This can lead to poor planning, mismanagement of funds, the selection of unsuitable projects, and an inability to sustain projects in the long r]un. Aid money might be spent on programs that are not well-designed, lack clear objectives, or fail to deliver tangible benefits. Risk of aid dependency: Mechanism: Consistent reliance on aid can create a culture of dependency, where recipient countries become reliant on external assistance rather than developing their own capacity for sustainable growth. Impact: This can stifle local initiative, weaken domestic institutions, and make countries vulnerable to changes in donor priorities. It can also undermine the incentive for governments to implement sound economic policies and raise their own revenue. Market distortions can happen if firms focus their resources on trying to secure aid rather than putting them to their best use (Rent-Seeking Behavior): Mechanism: In environments where aid flows are significant, businesses and individuals may divert their efforts towards lobbying for aid funds or contracts related to aid projects, rather than focusing on productive activities that generate genuine economic value. Impact: This can lead to an inefficient allocation of resources, corruption, and a lack of focus on building competitive and sustainable industries. It can hinder the development of a vibrant private sector. These are critical points to consider when evaluating the effectiveness of aid in AQA A Level Economics. It's important to remember that while aid can be ineffective for these reasons, it can also be highly successful when well-targeted, managed effectively, and aligned with the needs and priorities of the recipient country.