Test 3 Flashcards
what ethical theories is a moral concern for truth related to
deontology
feminist ethics
relational ethics
how is deontology related to a moral concern for truth
if nobody tells the truth, then who can we trust? if you tell the truth in one situation you need to be able to tell the truth in all situations
how is FE related to a moral concern for truth
having truth gives you power, thus creating a power differential
relational ethics and a moral concern for telling the truth
you build relationships on truth, not lies
historically how was truth regarded in health care
it was once considered a distant priority
how is truth telling perceived in health care currently, why
it is a priority as the right to autonomy by patients has now been recognized
what is to be said about autonomy and truth telling in terms of priority
the right pts have to autonomy is recongized at higher value then beneficence and shifts away from paternalism
what is the philosophical argument for limited disclosure
not telling somebody or withholding information in attempt to increase the beneficence/NM to the pt
objections to the philosophical argument for limited disclosure
we can tell the truth in different ways. knowing the whole truth may actually benefit the patient
what is ot telling somebody or withholding information in attempt to increase the beneficence/NM to the pt an example of
strong paternalism
what are the philosophical arguments we considered for telling the truth in a healhtcare context
autonomy - they need to know all the information to make a decision
what is the significance of ulyssess and the sirens
the question that were the crew man allowing him to be autonomous? are they respecting it? recognition that you are respecting the autonomous descsion while the person has capacity
obejection to ulysses and the sirens
is him asking to be let go an authentic descion? does he have the capacity to be let go?
What is the distinction between factual truth and truthfulness
Accurate statement using facts. Truthfulness is the intention to tell the truth
eg of factual truth but not truthful
seeing people that are together but are not actually TOGETHER
statement that’s neither factually true nor truthful
the sky is green
statement thats factually true but not truthful
i saw somebody kissing your girlfriend (misleading)
statement thats factually false but truthful
honestly believing that blood transfusions will make you not go to heaven (you are trying to tell the truth but its not actually a fact);
statement thats both truthful and factually true
both truthful and factually true
Can you explain the difference between the various ways we might depart from the truth, both accidentally and on purpose
On purpose or accidental, withholding information, not telling the whole truth, not being factual, refusing to research the right information.
what is the definition of confidentiality in a healthcare context
Protection and control of information that health care worker has become privy too in the role of nurse
What other concepts and principles is confidentiality related to as a moral ideal or principle
Autonomy
relational ethics
truth
trust
trust
when somebody discloses a piece of info that is self regarding and valuable to that person, trust is required if the information is to be protected or controlled
What is the definition of privacy
Self regarding information (learning things you aren’t suppose to know, learning about personal information that a person has a right to withhold)
what kinds of information may be kept private/access to limited
anything that you as a person deem private
Can you give examples of situations where privacy is in question and situations where confidentiality is in question?
Privacy – looking at somebodies chart when they aren’t your patient. Confidentiality – telling somebody about the chart you weren’t supposed to look at (accidental or on purpose)
What is the connection between a moral consideration for privacy and a moral consideration for confidentiality?
You need to respect the right of the patient to not disclose information.
what ethical theories are related to moral concern for confidentiality and privacy
deontology
feminist
relational