ppw 2 Flashcards
fiction crime vs. crime fiction
f
detective fiction
Its modern origins are found in three stories by Edgar Allan Poe (1809-1849):
• “The Murders in the Rue Morgue”
• “The Mystery of Marie Roget”
• “The Purloined Letter”
Poe laid the groundwork for the detective
archetype through his hero, the Chevalier
C. Auguste Dupin
this is an graphic novel book
Detective Fiction: Poe introduced what would become some defining features:
• a crime set in a city where potentially criminal elements lurk
• a set of clues, which the detective assesses one by one then uses to successfully
“ratiocinate” (or deduce) the criminal’s identity
• a reassuring theme that, despite the perceived rise in crime in the big bad city,
certain individuals (e.g. the lone amateur detective) have the power to maintain
law and order
• reassuring evidence that, through observation, research, and logical reasoning,
one can deduce the sequence of events that resulted in an imbalance in the
“natural order of things”
the genre of detective fiction concedes with..
with the rise of cities in the 19th century.
Killing Floor:
We begin in medias res: in the middle of things, a crime fiction convention. (See p. 1.) How does this convention affect the mood?
At mosphere and mood refer to the emotions a reader experiences while reading a section of a literary work
conflict in crime fiction
Three reasons why crimes occur in crime fiction:
- incompetence
- evil
- bureaucracy
incompetence
Incompetent people (e.g. lazy, unobservant police officers) fail to predict the likelihood of a crime’s occurrence Competent people (i.e. the lone detective) know what to look for and what not to look for. “In detective fiction everything that is repeatable and obvious ceases to be criminal and is, therefore, unworthy of ‘investigation’.” Franco Moretti
incompetence : what to look for ?
what not to look for ?
What not to look for?
Any human behaviour that occurs within a predictable routine (i.e. conformity).
What to look for?
Any human behaviour that does not occur within a predictable routine (i.e. individuality).
Evil : what is evil in crime fiction
It’s an individual’s belief that his or her peers are all a means to his own personal gain.
How does crime fiction’s depiction of evil differ from horror fiction’s depiction of evil?
The individual is isolated from his or her community.
The individual strikes fear into the community because he or she sets out to deny the community’s need for social stability.
Evil : competence detective
A competent detective sees evil where others do not, because the detective is a student of human behaviour and is able to see the evil individual who strays from everyone else’s adherence to a predictable, daily routine.
the scariest criminal…
The scariest criminals blend in with the crowd. At first,
they slip by undetected, because they abide by a
predictable routine. They lack signs betraying their
criminality.
Does reacher like crowds ? Explains
“Reacher didn’t like crowds. He enjoyed solitude and was a mild agoraphobic, which didn’t mean he was afraid of wide-open spaces. . . . Instead, he was unsettled by the ago ra, which was an ancient Greek word for a crowded public marketplace.”
(book 12)
when you’re in a crowd, you’re surrounded by a sea of strangers.
• and that terrifies reacher
• they could be criminals
Consider the overrepresentation of serial killers in popular culture. Why do readers love learning about serial killers?
check recordings
whats scarier that individual criminality ?
Even scarier than individual criminality (one bad apple) is systemic criminality, whereby an entire institution (e.g. the justice system) supports unlawful behaviour.
bureaucracy
A bureaucracy refers to a system of government where the government’s most impactful decisions are largely
made by unelected officials (bureaucrats).
Traditional institutions (e.g. the justice system, schools, religious centres, businesses, families, political bodies) tend to abide by rules that prohibit individuals from
exercising their power to detect and anticipate criminal activity.
Se e p. 216.
crime fiction is filled with bureaucrats that makes it harder for cops to get the criminals
rules that suppose to keep us safe is betrayed in the crime fiction as an inconvenience, gets in the way