ANSC 3210 ANIMAL WELFARE Flashcards
<p>ANIMAL WELFARE</p>
<p>ANSC 3210</p>
<p>What are the three approaches for the scientific study of animal welfare?</p>
<p>1) Feelings-based 2) Functioning-based 3) Nature of species </p>
<p>1) Feelings-based</p>
<p>Animal experiences, emphasize reduction of negative feelings and promote positive ones</p>
<p>How do we moniter feelings-based?</p>
<p>Preferences, motivations, behavioural and physiological indicators </p>
<p>2) Functioning-based </p>
<p>health, longevity, reproductive, (heavilty debated)</p>
<p>3) Nature of the animal </p>
<p>Animal to perform full repetoire of behabiour</p>
<p>Why did animal welfare arise?</p>
<p>Not scientific orignially, arose to express ethical concerns </p>
<p>What does welfare refer to ?</p>
<p>Quality of an animals life, health, happiness, longevity</p>
<p>First reference to animal welfare?</p>
<p>Bible </p>
<p>Why is longevity not a satisfactory welfare measure?</p>
<p>McCay et al (1939) found rats with restricted intake had longer lives. Chronic hunger and inadequate nutrition increased longevity. </p>
<p>What did Mendl and Deag determine in 1995?</p>
<p>'there are significantproblemsin amalgam- atingallthe differenttypesof measures. . . into a single"welfare"currency'. </p>
<p>What does 'telos' mean?</p>
<p>Conditional rules </p>
<p>What are the five moral philosophies?</p>
<p>1) Contractarian 2) Utilitarian 3)Relational 4) Animal Rights 5) Respect for Nature</p>
<p>Which three will we focus on in class? </p>
<p>2)Utilitarian 4) Animal Rights 5) Respect for nature </p>
<p>Contractarian ?</p>
<p>Everyone acts in their own interest. "Care about welfare because the consumer cares and we want to make a profit"</p>
<p>Utilitarian?</p>
<p>Maximize animal and human well being. "Some animal research may be justified by vital importance to cure painful disease"</p>
<p>Relational?</p>
<p>Views based on relation we have with animals. "Dog is mans best friend. Dog deserves to be treated better than farm animals"</p>
<p>Animal Rights?</p>
<p>Only doing what is right. Some debate "Animals are not out slaves"</p>
<p>Respect for nature?</p>
<p>We have the duty to protect not only individual animals but the species. Do not genetically modify nature</p>
<p>What does our class results tell us about these philosphies?</p>
<p>95.8% of the class used three+ philophies, suggesting no philosphy is perfect </p>
<p>What are the two considered real animal welfare philosphies?</p>
<p>Utilitarian and Animal Rights</p>
<p>If you pick Utilitarian what are you picking?</p>
<p>You believe that the consequences of your actions are most important </p>
<p>If you pick Animal Rights what are you picking?</p>
<p>You believe that your actions themselves are most important </p>
<p>If you have some contractarian?</p>
<p>Pay attention to the effect of your actions on yourself</p>
<p>If you have some Relational?</p>
<p>Pay attention to how close you are to the animal ( horses closer than rats)</p>
<p>If you have some Respect for Nature?</p>
<p>Pay attention to the effect your actions may have on the ecosyste,. </p>
<p>What other university did Dr. Duncan teach at?</p>
<p>Pingtung in the south of Taiwan</p>
<p>What was surprsing about the survey results from Taiwan?</p>
<p>Very similar to our views even though many finacial, thical and religious differences. </p>
<p>What word captures the essence of ethics?</p>
<p>OUGHT. "how we ought to behave"</p>
<p>What two acts does ethical behaviour include?</p>
<p>Acts of commission and acts of omission</p>
<p>Discuss the History of Ethics</p>
<p>Name, year, key pints</p>
<p>Aristotle (384-322 BC)</p>
<p>The ability to reason sets humans abouve all other creatures. Everything in nature has a reason. Humans should have absolute authority over animals</p>
<p>Thomas Aquinas (1224-1274)</p>
<p>Christian twist. No direct obligations, some indirect moral obligations. No moral standing in animals only instrumental value. </p>
<p>Rene Descartes (1596-1650)</p>
<p>Animals are machines. Animals are not sentient. Unconcious emotions</p>
<p>Immanuel Kant (1724-1804)</p>
<p>Following absolute rules. </p>
<p>Kant and the Inquiring Murderer</p>
<p>Woman hiding from murder you know where she hid, murderer asks, lie about her whereabouts. Kant maintained morally obligated</p>
<p>OUGHT: Hypothetical Imperative</p>
<p>Tell us what do do to provide desired result. If you don't want result you are not obligated. If you want better grades you ought to do the readings. Ought is a reference to a moral obligation if we want the results </p>
<p>OUGHT: Categorical Imperative</p>
<p>You ought to tell the truth. Obligations binding now matter how you personally feel </p>
<p>What does Kant say about Rationality?</p>
<p>It is rational for everyone to act according to categorical imperatives. Humans have intrinsic and instrumental value because we can reason. Animals cannot and therefore only have an instrumental value. </p>
<p>Instrumental value.</p>
<p>The value that something has because of what it can be used for </p>