AO3: Duchess Of Malfi Flashcards
(37 cards)
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: Perepeteia
A reversal of fortune; the hero will reverse from his initial excellent status
In Aristotelian tragedy, peripeteia is the sudden reversal of fortune or change in circumstances experienced by the protagonist. This shift is often ironic and unexpected by the character, though it may be foreshadowed for the audience. It’s a key element in creating pity and fear, leading to catharsis.
While The Duchess of Malfi doesn’t adhere strictly to all classical tragic structures, several moments could be interpreted as containing elements of peripeteia:
- The Discovery of the Duchess’s Marriage and Children (Act III, Scene II):
For the Duchess, her attempt to maintain a semblance of happiness and secrecy is shattered when Bosola, under Ferdinand’s orders, stages the discovery of her husband and child. This is a sudden and devastating reversal of her relatively secure (though hidden) domestic life. Her fortune shifts from a degree of personal contentment to imminent danger and exposure.
2. Ferdinand’s Descent into Madness (Act IV onwards):
For Ferdinand, his initial position of power and control undergoes a drastic and horrifying reversal. His obsessive pursuit and cruel torment of his sister lead him to a profound madness, specifically lycanthropy. This is an ironic twist, as the one who sought to inflict suffering becomes consumed by his own mental anguish. His fortune shifts from the powerful oppressor to a pitiable madman.
3. Bosola’s Change of Heart and Attempted Revenge (Act V):
Bosola experiences a peripeteia when he realizes the extent of the evil he has served and the injustice done to the Duchess and Antonio. This recognition leads to a reversal of his allegiance and intentions. He shifts from being a tool of the brothers’ cruelty to seeking revenge for the Duchess’s death. However, this reversal ultimately leads to his own tragic demise, highlighting the relentless nature of the play’s tragic trajectory.
4. The Killing of the Wrong Person (Act V, Scene V):
Bosola intends to kill the Cardinal but mistakenly kills Antonio. This is a crucial and ironic reversal of his plan, highlighting the chaos and tragic miscommunication that plague the final act. His attempt to rectify his past actions leads to further bloodshed and the acceleration of the tragedy.
Why these moments fit (with caveats):
Sudden Change: Each of these instances marks a significant and relatively abrupt shift in a character’s circumstances or intentions.
Ironic Element: There’s often an irony involved. The Duchess’s attempt at secrecy leads to a more brutal exposure. Ferdinand’s control leads to his own loss of control. Bosola’s attempt at justice results in further tragedy.
Impact on the Plot: These reversals are key turning points that drive the plot towards its catastrophic conclusion.
It’s important to note that The Duchess of Malfi is a Jacobean tragedy, and while it draws on classical elements, it also deviates from strict Aristotelian form. The play features multiple characters experiencing reversals, and the overall movement is a relentless downward spiral rather than a single protagonist’s fall. However, recognizing these moments of peripeteia helps us understand the play’s dramatic power and its exploration of fate, justice, and the consequences of human action
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: hubris
Excessive pride or confidence; the hero will often assume godlike status
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: Hamartia
A fatal flaw within the hero; their downfall will come from their own doing
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: Peripeteia
The idea that a tragic hero should come from a background of excellence
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: Anagnorisis
A movement of realisation; an insight into themselves, the situations, and others
LITERARY CONTEXT: TRAGEDY: Catharsis
The cleansing of the audience; they feel better after watching the tragedy
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - JAMES I COURT: Sycophants
a person who acts obsequiously towards someone important in order to gain advantage.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - JAMES I COURT: Basilikon Doron
James I treaty on how to be a good king.
IRONY as he surrounded himself with noble people
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - JAMES I COURT: Profligacy
Excessive + irresponsible spending of funds and money
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - JAMES I COURT: Sexual Licentiousness
Dirty deeds
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - JAMES I COURT: Robert Carr + George Villiers
Hugely sycophantic towards James I who he valued + gave titles and honours to them whose he didn’t deserve.
Sexual licentious letters sent to them
LITERARY CONTEXT - LINKED TEXTS: The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstruous Regiment of Women (1588)
John Knox’s pamphlet criticised women in power, saying it was a ‘monstrous in nature’.
When Elizabeth I became queen she banned Knox from coming over to England
LITERARY CONTEXT - LINKED TEXTS: The Spanish Tragedy (1587)
Thomas Kyd’s tragedy established the genre of Elizabethan Revenge Tragedy, bringing back traits from Senecan tragedy (themes such as horrors + violence)
LITERARY CONTEXT - LINKED TEXTS: Titus Andronicus (1588)
Shakespeare’s bloodies revenge tragedy; this play sees rape, body parts cut off, and mothers unwittingly eating their own children
LITERARY CONTEXT - LINKED TEXTS: Basilikon Doran (1599)
King James I’s treatise instructing his son on how to best run a court, including (ironically) to choose courtiers with care
LITERARY CONTEXT - LINKED TEXTS: The Devil’s Law Case (1623)
In Webster’s only other play, he asserts the importance of social order, particularly in terms of law
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - FIGURES: Queen Elizabeth I
Queen Elizabeth reserved the right to choose who she should marry – and whether she should marry at all.
Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603) was one of England’s most iconic and influential monarchs, reigning from 1558 until her death. Her 44-year rule, often referred to as the Elizabethan Age, is considered a golden period in English history, marked by relative peace, prosperity, and a flourishing of the arts.
Early Life and Accession:
Born in 1533, Elizabeth was the daughter of King Henry VIII and his second wife, Anne Boleyn.
Her early life was tumultuous. Her mother was executed when Elizabeth was only two, and she was declared illegitimate.
After the death of her half-sister, Queen Mary I, Elizabeth ascended to the throne in 1558 at the age of 25.
Key Accomplishments:
Religious Settlement: Elizabeth established a moderate Protestant Church of England, seeking to find a middle ground between Catholic and Puritan extremes. The Acts of Supremacy and Uniformity (1559) solidified this settlement.
Defeat of the Spanish Armada (1588): This decisive English naval victory against the powerful Spanish fleet secured England’s independence and marked a turning point in its rise as a global power.
Economic Prosperity: Elizabeth’s reign saw a period of economic growth, fueled by overseas exploration, trade, and the establishment of the Royal Exchange.
Patronage of the Arts: The Elizabethan Age witnessed a remarkable flourishing of literature, theatre, and music, with iconic figures like William Shakespeare, Christopher Marlowe, and Edmund Spenser. Elizabeth was a patron of the arts and her court was a center of cultural activity.
Exploration and Colonization: Elizabeth supported voyages of discovery to the New World, laying the groundwork for English colonization in North America, with Virginia named in her honor.
Character and Personality:
Elizabeth was highly intelligent and well-educated, fluent in several languages.
She was known for her strong will, determination, and shrewd political acumen.
Her image as the “Virgin Queen,” who never married and devoted herself to her kingdom, became a powerful symbol of national unity.
While capable of great charm and diplomacy, Elizabeth also possessed a formidable temper and could be ruthless when necessary.
She was a master of public image, using progresses and carefully crafted speeches to cultivate the loyalty and affection of her subjects.
Challenges and Difficulties:
Religious Divisions: Despite the religious settlement, Elizabeth faced ongoing challenges from both Catholics and radical Protestants.
Plots and Rebellions: Numerous plots against her reign, often involving her cousin Mary, Queen of Scots, threatened her rule.
War with Spain: The long and costly war with Spain, while ultimately successful, strained England’s resources.
Succession Crisis: Elizabeth’s unmarried status and lack of an heir created anxieties about the future of the monarchy.
Queen Elizabeth I died in 1603, leaving behind a legacy as one of England’s greatest and most beloved monarchs. Her reign is remembered as a time of strength, stability, and cultural achievement that shaped the course of English history.
While Queen Elizabeth I died in 1603, a decade before John Webster likely wrote The Duchess of Malfi (around 1612-1614), her long and impactful reign (1558-1603) provides a crucial backdrop for understanding the play’s social, political, and even literary landscape. Here’s how:
- The Powerful Female Monarch:
A Precedent of Female Rule: Elizabeth I’s successful rule as a powerful female monarch for over four decades challenged traditional patriarchal norms. While the play depicts a society where the Duchess’s brothers believe they have the right to control her life, the memory of a strong, independent queen like Elizabeth would have been fresh in the minds of Webster’s audience.
Contrasting Images of Female Authority: The play presents a stark contrast between the real-life example of a powerful and politically astute female ruler and the fictional Duchess, who, while possessing agency and a strong will in her personal life, ultimately falls victim to the patriarchal forces around her. This contrast might have prompted audiences to reflect on the different ways female authority could be exercised and the dangers it could face.
2. Concerns about Succession and Marriage:
Elizabeth’s Unmarried Status: Queen Elizabeth I famously remained unmarried, using the prospect of marriage as a political tool but ultimately choosing to rule alone. Her unmarried status was a constant source of anxiety about the succession.
The Duchess’s Marriage as a Political Act: In The Duchess of Malfi, the Duchess’s brothers are vehemently against her remarriage, not just out of familial pride but also due to concerns about who she might choose and the potential political implications of that union for their power. This reflects the broader historical anxieties surrounding royal and noble marriages.
3. The Court as a Site of Power and Intrigue:
Elizabeth’s Court: The Elizabethan court was a complex world of patronage, ambition, and political maneuvering. While often idealized, it also had its share of rivalries and power struggles.
The Corrupt Court of Malfi: Webster’s depiction of the court of Malfi as a place of corruption, spying, and moral decay resonates with the historical realities and dramatic portrayals of royal courts, including the awareness of potential abuses of power. Antonio’s initial praise of the French court as uncorrupt implicitly critiques the Italian (and perhaps contemporary English) courtly life.
4. Literary and Dramatic Landscape:
Elizabethan Golden Age of Theatre: Elizabeth’s reign fostered a vibrant theatrical culture that paved the way for the Jacobean drama of playwrights like Webster. The conventions of tragedy, character development, and dramatic language established during her time influenced Webster’s work.
The Rise of Revenge Tragedy: While revenge tragedy flourished in the Elizabethan and Jacobean eras, the anxieties about justice, order, and the consequences of private vengeance explored in plays like Hamlet (written during the transition from Elizabethan to Jacobean era) find echoes in The Duchess of Malfi. The play can be seen as a continuation and a darker exploration of these themes in a post-Elizabethan world.
5. Gender Roles and Expectations:
Elizabeth’s Defiance of Gender Norms: As a ruling queen, Elizabeth I inherently defied many of the traditional expectations placed upon women in her era. She projected an image of strength, intelligence, and independence.
The Duchess’s Transgression: The Duchess’s desire for personal happiness and her choice to marry for love, defying her brothers’ control, can be seen as a challenge to the patriarchal norms that Elizabeth, in her own way, also navigated. However, the tragic consequences for the Duchess highlight the dangers faced by those who transgress societal expectations, even those of high status.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - FIGURES: Lady Arbella Stuart
She married below her class for love and starved herself to death instead of renewing herself to death
The life of Lady Arabella Stuart (1575-1615), a cousin of King James I with a claim to the English throne, bears striking parallels to the tragic circumstances of John Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi. Examining these connections can illuminate the play’s historical and social resonance for a Jacobean audience:
Similarities in their “Crime” of Marriage:
Marriage Against Royal Will: Both Arabella Stuart and the Duchess of Malfi defied the wishes of their powerful male relatives (King James I and her brothers, respectively) by marrying men they chose for love, not political expediency or familial gain. Arabella secretly married William Seymour, who also had a distant claim to the throne, while the Duchess secretly married her steward, Antonio Bologna, who was of lower social standing.
Threat to Authority: Both marriages were perceived as threats to the existing power structures. King James feared Arabella’s union could produce a rival claimant, while the Duchess’s brothers were incensed by what they saw as a degradation of their noble bloodline and a loss of control over her inheritance and future.
Imprisonment: As a consequence of their defiance, both women were imprisoned. Arabella was confined in the Tower of London, where she eventually died. The Duchess was subjected to psychological torture and ultimately murdered at her brothers’ command.
Social Context of Forced Marriage and Control:
Royal Prerogative: In the Jacobean era, the monarch held significant authority over the marriages of those with royal blood or high social standing, as these unions could have political ramifications. Arabella’s situation highlights the constraints placed on even noblewomen in choosing their spouses. Similarly, the Duchess’s brothers believe they have the right to dictate her marital choices to protect their family’s status.
Class and Lineage: The Duchess’s marriage “beneath her” to Antonio would have been particularly scandalous in the rigid social hierarchy of the time. While Arabella married within the aristocracy, the secrecy and lack of royal consent were still seen as a grave offense.
Female Agency: Both women exhibit a degree of agency in choosing their husbands, defying the patriarchal expectations of their society. However, the tragic consequences they face underscore the limitations placed on female autonomy, even for those of high rank.
Literary Resonance for a Jacobean Audience:
Topicality: Lady Arabella Stuart’s imprisonment and death in 1615 would have been a relatively recent and well-known scandal for the audiences of The Duchess of Malfi, which was likely first performed around 1613-1614. The parallels between her story and the Duchess’s plight would have added a layer of contemporary political and social commentary to the play.
Tyranny and Injustice: Both narratives expose the potential for tyranny and injustice when those in power seek to control the lives and choices of others. The audience might have drawn parallels between King James’s treatment of his cousin and the brutal actions of Ferdinand and the Cardinal.
Sympathy for the Defiant Woman: Despite the societal norms against unauthorized marriages, the stories of Arabella and the Duchess could have also evoked sympathy for women who dared to assert their own desires for love and happiness against oppressive patriarchal control.
Professor Sara Jayne Steen’s Argument:
Scholar Sara Jayne Steen has extensively explored the connections between Lady Arabella Stuart’s life and The Duchess of Malfi, suggesting that the contemporary responses to Stuart’s case can offer insights into how Jacobean audiences might have viewed the Duchess’s actions. While some undoubtedly condemned both women for defying social conventions and royal authority, others may have sympathized with their desire for personal fulfillment.
In conclusion, the tragic story of Lady Arabella Stuart provides a compelling real-life parallel to the central conflict in The Duchess of Malfi. Her defiance of King James’s will and her subsequent imprisonment likely resonated with the play’s original audiences, adding a layer of historical and social significance to the Duchess’s similar struggle against her brothers’ tyranny. The play, therefore, can be seen not only as a fictional tragedy but also as a reflection on the constraints and dangers faced by individuals, particularly women of high status, who dared to challenge the established order in the Jacobean era.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - FIGURES: Giovanna d’Aragona
WHO DOM is based on
Giovanna d’Aragona married her state Stuart, had 2 children and a suspicious 3rd with him, chased by brothers and mysteriously died
HISTORICAL CONTEXT - FIGURES: King James I
A court full of sycophants mirroring the Aragonian brothers + Bosola’s nature
GENERAL CONTEXT: Stoicism
the endurance of pain or hardship without the display of feelings and without complaint.
GENERAL CONTEXT: What did Elizabeth I say during her 1588 Tilbury Docks speech?
“I know I have the body but of a weak and feeble woman; but I have the heart and stomach of a king, and of a king of England too”.
GENERAL CONTEXT: What is a malcontent?
a person who is dissatisfied and rebellious. (With the court)
GENERAL CONTEXT: Who is the malcontent in DOM?
Bosola