approaches Flashcards
(67 cards)
Wundt and introspection - William Wundt established the first psychology lab
opened in Leipzig, Germany in 1879. The aim was to describe the nature of human consciousness in a carefully controlled and scientific environment - a lab.
what is introspection
The examination of one’s own conscious thoughts and feelings using a scientific method.
The first systematic experimental attempt to study the mind by breaking up conscious awareness into basic structures of thoughts, images and sensations.
Explain the emergence of psychology as a science
Wundt first applied empirical methods (i.e based on evidence) to study human behaviour. Wundt and his colleagues opened the first scientific laboratory dedicated to understanding the mind (introspection). this was done by recording their own conscious thoughts which were broken down into different parts (structuralism). this was followed by behaviourism (e.g Watson) who focused on learning using experimental methods in labs. this meant that they had adopted a scientific approach and results could be replicated. finally, the biological approach can use sophisticated technology e.g PET scans to understand the brain.
controlled procedures:
the same standardised instructions were given to all participants and stimuli (objects and sounds) were presented in the same order (standardised procedure)
for instance, participants were given a ticking metronome and they would report their thoughts, images and sensations, which were then recorded.
structuralism:
introspection led to identifying the stature of consciousness by breaking it up into the basic structures: thoughts, images and sensations
this marked the beginning of scientific psychology, separating it from its broader philosophical roots.
The emergence of psychology as a science: early behaviourists rejected introspection
Watson (1913) argued that introspection was subjective,
L in that it is influenced by a personal perspective.
According to the behaviourist approach, ‘scientific psychology should only study phenomena that can be observed and measured..
1950s Behaviourist scientific approach dominated psychology.
Skinner (1953) brought the language and rigour of the natural sciences into psychology. The behaviourists’ focus on learning, and the use of carefully controlled lab studies, would dominate psychology for 50 years..
1950s Cognitive approach studied mental processes scientifically.
Following the computer revolution of the 19505, the study of mental processes was seen as legitimate within psychology.
Cognitive psychologists likened the mind to a computer and tested their predictions about memory and attention using experiments..
1980’s Biological approach introduced technological advances
Biological psychologists have taken advantage of recent
advances in technology, including recording brain
activity, using scanning techniques such as fMRI and
advances
EEG. and advanced genetic research..
One strength of wundts work (controlled)
- aspects of Wundt’s work are scientific
for instance, he recorded the introspections within a controlled lab environment
he also standardised his procedures so that all participants recieved the same information and were tested in the same way
therefore Wundt’s research can be considered a forerunner to the later scientific approach in psychology that were to come.
Limitation of Wundt’s research (subjective)
- other aspects of his research are subjective
Wundt relied on participants self reporting their ‘private’ mental processes. Such data is subjective. Participants may also have hidden some of their thoughts
this makes it difficult to establish meaningful ‘laws of behaviour’, one of the aims of science
therefore Wundt’s early efforts to study the mind were naive and would not meet the criteria of scientific enquiry.
strength of emergence of psychology as a science (scientific)
- research in modern psychology can claim to be scientific
psychology has the same aims as the natural sciences- to describe, understand and predict and control behaviour
Learning, cognitive and biological approaches all use scientific methods e.g lab studies and uncontrolled and unbiased
throughout the 20th century and beyond, psychology has established itself as a scientific discipline.
Limitation of psychology as a science (unrepresentative)
- some approaches use subjective data
humanistic approach does not formulate general laws of behaviour. Psychodynamic approach uses case studies with unrepresentative samples
Psychologist who study humans are active participants and therefore respond to demand characteristics
therefore a scientific approach to the study of human thought and experience is not desirable or possible.
the behaviourist approach -focus on observable behaviour only
The behaviourist approach is only concerned with studying behaviour that can be observed and measured.
It is not concerned with mental processes of the mind.
Introspection was rejected by behaviourists as its concepts were vague and difficult to measure..
Controlled lab studies.
Behaviourists tried to maintain more control and objectivity within their research and relied on lab studies to achieve this..
Use of non-human animals
Behaviourists suggest the processes that govern learning are the same in all species, so animals can replace humans as experimental subjects.
Classical Conditioning (Pavlov)
Classical conditioning Pavlov’s research - conditioning refers to learning by dogs to salivate when a bell rings:
association.
Before conditioning:
UCS = food, UCR = salivation,
NS = bell
During conditioning:
Bell and food occur at same time.
After conditioning:
CS = bell, CR = salivation
Pavlov showed how a neutral
stimulus (bell) can come to elicit a new learned response (conditioned response, CR)
through association..
Operant conditioning.
Skinner’s research.
Operant conditioning
refers to learning processes whereby humans and animals operate on their environment.
Behaviour is shaped and maintained by its consequences
Skinner’s research - rats and
refers to learning
pigeons, in specially designed
as an active process cages (Skinner boxes).
When a rat activated a lever (or
animals operate on a pigeon pecked a disc) it was
rewarded with a food pellet.
A desirable consequence led to
and maintained by its behaviour being repeated.
If pressing a lever meant an animal avoided an electric shock, the behaviour would also be repeated..
Three types of consequences of behaviour.
Positive reinforcement - receiving a reward when behaviour is performed.
Negative reinforcement - avoiding something unpleasant when a behaviour is performed.
Punishment - an unpleasant consequence of behaviour
Positive reinforcement and negative reinforcement increase the likelihood that behaviour will be repeated.
Punishment decreases it..
Strength of behaviourism + CP (controlled / oversimplify)
- it uses well controlled research
the approach has focused on the careful measurement of observable behaviour within controlled lab settings
behaviourists have broken behaviour down into stimulus response units and studied casual relationships
this suggests that behaviourist experiments have scientific credibility
CP
However this approach may oversimplify learning and ignore important influences of behaviour (e.g thought)z other approaches e.g social learning and cognitive incorporate mental processes
this suggests learning is more complex than just what we can observe.
Strength of behaviourist approach (real world application)
- behaviourist laws of learning have real world application
the principles of conditioning have been applied to a broad range of real world behaviours and problems
token economy reward systems reward appropriate behaviour with tokens that are exchanged for privileges (operant conditioning). Successfully used in prisons and psychiatric wards
this increases the value of the behaviourist approach because it has widespread application.
Limitation of behaviourist approach (ignored free will)
- behaviourism is a form of environmental determinism
the approach sees all behaviour as determined by past experiences that have been conditioned and ignores any influence that free will may have on behaviour
skinner suggested that free will was an illusion. When something happens we may think ‘I have made the decision to do that’ but our past conditioning determined the outcome
this is an extreme position and ignores the influence of conscious decision making processes on behaviour (as suggested by the cognitive approach).
Social learning theory - learning that occurs indirectly
Albert Bandura agreed with the behaviourist approach
that learning occurs through experience.
However, he also proposed that learning takes place in a social context through observation and imitation of others behaviour..
Learning related to consequences of behaviour - vicarious reinforcement
Children (and adults) observe other people’s behaviour
consequences of and take note of its consequences. Behaviour that is seen to be rewarded (reinforced) is more likely to be
copied = vicarious reinforcement..