belief system (2) Flashcards
what is the phenomenological perspective ?
reli is just one of many belief sytem s
belief systems are socially constructed , created by the society they come from
belief system share our universe meaning the meaning people give to their social world in order to understand it
belief systems are not absolute theyre very fragile and can be shattered
what is universe of meaning ?
whcih organise their experiences makes snese of their lives , they construct their own social worlds amdd work to maintain them against the threat of uncertainty and dsiruption
what does the universe of meaning require ?
it requires constant legitamation , it needs repeted reinforcement and justification , members of society msut be told and retold that their universe of meaning is legitamate without this support
life would crumble and become meanigless , stability of society is threatened
how is belief system constructed ?
belief sytem is socially constructed form bases of unom and they feedback and reinforce the society that constructed them
how does science offer support ?
science offers suport for universe of meaning by grounding them in reason and evdience e.g darwin hteory of revoluton based on evidece fosills
what does berger and luckman say ?
the social construction of reality human beings construct their belies in social context
people manufacture universe of meaninf in order to structure and make sense of their social worlds
universe of meaning requrire constant legitamisation to be told and ajvomng ot conformed that its right true and correct
what is a belief system ?
belief system are set of ideas that claim to have knowledge about reality
what are the difference between science and religion ?
science - factual evidence , fossil, experiments, lab, vause and effect , objectice , open to challenge-new evidence
reli - sacred and fixed ideas , not open to challened , belief and faith, based on past knowledge , books , reli texts , reli scholars /leaders
what is an open system of belief ?
where knowledge claims are open to questioning and to be questioned- popper falsfication
what is a clsoed system of belief ?
closed system of belief where knowledge claims cant be challenged or overturned
why is science an open belief system according to popper ?
because every scientist theory can/ is open to scrutinity , criticism and testing by others
what is falsification ?
scientist set out and try to falsify existing theories , delibrately seeking evidence that would disprove them
what is the mertons cudos norms ?
communism - scientific knowledge isnt private property - dcientist must share it with the community by publishing
universalism - truth or falsify of scientific knowledge is judged by universal , objective criteria and not by particular race , sex etc of scientist who produces it
disinterestedness - being commited to discovery knowleddge for its own sake , having to publish their own findings makes it harder for scientist to practice fraud , enables others to check their claims
organised scepticism - no knowledge claim is regarded as sacred - every idea is open to questioning and criticism and obj ,investigation
what are some similarities between popper and merton cudos
science as an insituition or organised social activity needs an ethos or set of norms that make scientists act in a way that increases knowledge of science
what did popper argue
popper argued that they rest on a solid bedrock fabrication of facts - systematic obervation and measurements made by scientist arent objective
what did knor cetina say ?
facts are fabricated - cinstructed by scientsits - facts are based off theories observed
closed belief system
what does hurton say ?
sees science as on open beleif system one where knowledge is provisional , open to challenge and potentially disprovable
religion has get out clauses = which makes it a close system = reinforce the system and prevent it from being disproved e.g witchcraft belief
who else does hurton agree with ?
popper, he sees science as an open system one where knowledge claims are open to criticism and can be dsiprove4d bytestting
reli = closed belief system = whenever its fundamental beliefs are threatened a closed belief system has get out clauses that reinforce the system and prevent ot from being disproved = witchcraft belief
who studied the azande people and who are they ?
pitchard = people of sudan
believe that natural events have natural causes they dont belienve in coincidence
whebn misfortune befalls them the azande someone a jealous neighbour is practicing witchcraft on them
what does pitchard argue ?
this belief system performs useful social functions not only clears the air and prevents grudges from festering ,
it encourages neighbour to behave considerately towards one another to reduce the risk of an accusation
what does hortan say ?
the witch craft among the azande are a closed system of beleifs as they all highly resistant to challenges cannot be overturned by the evidence
reli justifies itself and prevents it from being disproved
what is closed system ?
knowledge claims cannot be challenged or overturned
what does the polyani say ?
all beleif syst have 3 devices to sustain themselves in the face of apparently contradictory evi- all system are closed because they all use self sustaining belief = not open to change
circularity = each idea in the syst is explained in terms of another idea within the syst and so on round and round
subsidary- useless justification , justifable for azande within the bs
denial of legitamacy = to rival belief system reject alt worldviews by refusing to grant any legitamacy to theior basic assumption e.g evolution = dont want to believe in other thoeries or reli even if they have evidence but they still refuse to believe them
what is the paradigm ?
paradigm is the body of knowledge
science work in a shared paradigm - kuhn
science is a closed sys
rejects evidence that challenges its claim
outside of the paradigm
e.g dr
eventualy create new para chyms
science is not open - rejexct info if it contradicts the existing body
not object = reject accpet depends on field
= socially constructed by those reviewing
influenced by external factos - reject info