BIOL 113 Exam 1 Flashcards
(59 cards)
What is retraction?
When a journal pulls a previously published paper because new information has shown the paper has incorrect information
Your cousin wants some company at her appointment at the acupuncture
office. While sitting in the waiting room, you read the following in a pamphlet
regarding acupuncture:
Acupuncture restores your Chi Life Energy, unblocking your meridians, and
healing illness and disease.
Mayo Clinic, Web MD and Medical News Today all agree that acupuncture
can reduce pain caused by a variety of illnesses.
You wonder about how acupuncture works and since you don’t see any
primary literature listed in the pamphlet you ask the acupuncturist about it
when your cousin is finished with the session. The acupuncturist says patients
report experiencing a reduction in pain following acupuncture sessions. After
this dual experience (pamphlet + conversation), you are skeptical of
acupuncture as a medical treatment because
a) Mechanism has not been explained
b) There are no sources given
c) There is no evidence given
Evaluate the following claim:
Choose all that apply
A & C - No mechanism is explained, additionally, evidence is not given in a quantifiable, consistent manner
On February 1, 2019, NPR reported that a scientist at
Columbia University was using new DNA-editing technology
to repair mutations in human embryos to prevent genetic
diseases such as Tay Sachs and Cystic Fibrosis from being
passed from one generation to the next. The scientist used
a procedure first developed by another group of scientists
at a university in Oregon. This demonstrates which strength
of science?
a) Peer review during publication
b) Scientists use each other’s work
c) Testing falsifiable hypothesis
d) Strict methodology
b) Scientists use each other’s work
The process of Hydroxychloroquine research (just
described) demonstrates which strength of science?
a) Scientists design experiments that can falsify their
hypothesis.
b) Conclusions change based on new evidence.
c) Peer review during publication.
d) Science is objective
b) Conclusions change based on new evidence.
What is belief perseverance?
The tendency to cling to untrue/initial beliefs when faced with conflicting evidence
Bella Water, PHD & MD, is a medical scientist who specializes in
brain disorders. She has 25 years of accumulated knowledge about
which treatments work best for brain disorders. Her patient, Steve,
suffers from frequent seizures. At his appointment, Bella talks to
Steve about a new medication that has been demonstrated in
multiple studies to greatly reduce seizures. Steve is skeptical. He
read online that taking large doses of vitamin B1 can reduce seizures
and he insists on trying that course of treatment instead. Bella knows
that there is no scientific evidence that shows that vitamin B1 works.
Using which approach will give Bella the best chance of convincing
Steve to try the new medication?
a) Hand Steve the published scientific papers about the new drug
and point out the figures that show it reduces seizures.
b) Listen carefully to Steve. Validate his feelings. Then, describe
what can happen if he does not take the new medication.
b) Listen carefully to Steve. Validate his feelings. Then, describe
what can happen if he does not take the new medication.
Binary pair of hypothesis
either the hypothesis (A affects B) and/or the null (A does not affect B) –> only two options
Is it true that CBD reduces
swelling? Write a pair of hypothesis
H: CBD reduces swelling
N: CBD does not reduce swelling
Prediction
what we expect to measure if the hypothesis is correct - there can be more than one
What 3 things make a prediction robust?
Measure, dosage, duration
If the hypothesis is (accepted as) correct, is the null
a) rejected
b) failed to be rejected
a) rejected
After pondering the CBD display for several moments, you pick up a
bottle of CBD oil that, among other things, claims to boost immunity.
You are interested in taking this product, but you initially regard the
claims on the label with some skepticism. You decide to do your own
research to see if there is good reason to believe that ingesting CBD oil
regularly will reduce illness. Which source is most likely to contain the
most accurate information?
a) Peer reviewed scientific journal articles.
b) Blogs that collect anecdotal (informal) experiences from readers.
c) Studies published by the CBD company on their website.
This means-linking
several lectures
a) Peer reviewed scientific journal articles.
You remain interested in using a scientific approach to quantify CBD’s effects on
human health. Since you are an undergraduate research assistant you have access to
a mouse lab to conduct research. Which of the following are predictions that could
be made from the hypothesis that consuming CBD oil will boost immunity? (Choose
all that apply)
a) Ingesting CBD oil regularly for 1 year will reduce the number of cold and flu
diagnoses.
b) Administering 2 mL of CBD oil sublingually (under tongue) once daily for one year
will significantly reduce the number cold and flu diagnoses in mice.
c) Administering 2 mL of CBD oil sublingually (under tongue) once daily for one year
will significantly increase the percent of white blood cells (immune cells) in the
blood in mice.
b and c
(A doesn’t have required features)
You randomly select 10 mice to be in your experimental group and 10
to be in your negative control group. The mice are kept in identical
cages and given the exact same amount of food and water daily. The
experimental mice are also given 2 mL of CBD oil under the tongue
from the same jar every morning at 8am for a year.
What is the most scientifically robust procedure for the negative control
mice?
Give mice a placebo oil at the same time and in the same dosage daily
A neurologist hypothesizes that a compound from a rainforest tree can reduce
seizures in epileptic humans. First, she collects samples from trees in the same
acre of land in the Columbian rainforest. She brings these samples back to her
lab and isolates the compound of interest. She inserts 100mg of the compound
into a gelatin capsules thus creating her experimental drug. Next, she develops
her experimental methodology. Her experimental group is composed of 200
epileptic women aged 25-50. These patients ingest the 100 mg experimental
drug twice per day for 6 months. Her negative control group is also composed
of 200 epileptic women aged 25-50. Which of the following is the most robust
protocol for the negative control group to follow for 6 months?
a) Ingest the 100 mg experimental drug twice per day.
b) Ingest a gelatin capsule without the compound twice per day.
c) Ingest another drug which is already known to reduce the instances of
seizures twice per day.
d) Ingest nothing; no herbs, vitamins or drugs.
b) Ingest a gelatin capsule without the compound twice per day.
X/ is a symbol which means sample mean. Scientists try to design experiments such that
X/ = m or X/ =/= m
X/ = m
What do we want the sample to represent?
The entire population
In a narrower range, a larger/smaller sample size is more sufficient (compared to a broader range) to capture full variation
smaller
Standard deviation
range of the data - how close the majority of the population sits to the mean
Standard error
how sample size relates to SD - Low SE indicates SS was sufficient (capture full variability and range of measurments)
what does an increasing number of asterisks represent?
greater # asterisks = greater statistical significance
scientific theory
hypothesis that provides a framework
which explains a widespread phenomenon has
been tested many times,
and in all those times the null
hypothesis was rejected
natural selection
the process by which species change over time
four requirements for evolution by natural selection
- variation
- heritability/genetics
- differential survival
- differential reproduction