Biological Approach Flashcards
(65 cards)
Antonova et al. (2011) full details
Aim: Test whether blocking acetylcholine receptors impairs spatial memory.
Method: Double-blind, placebo-controlled, within-subjects; 20 males; scopolamine vs placebo before virtual Morris Water Maze inside fMRI; counterbalanced two weeks apart.
Findings: Scopolamine increased latency and errors, reduced hippocampal activation.
Conclusion: Acetylcholine is critical for encoding spatial memories via hippocampal circuits.
Evaluation:
- Causality & Control: High internal validity (double-blind, within-subjects).
- Validity: High internal; moderate external (virtual task); low ecological.
- Reliability: High standardization of dosing and fMRI protocols.
- Ethics: Potential side effects; screened participants; debrief.
- Reductionism vs Holism: Reductionist focus on one neurotransmitter.
- Generalizability: Limited to young adult males.
Antonova et al. (2011) aim?
Test whether blocking acetylcholine receptors impairs spatial memory.
Antonova et al. (2011) Method?
Double-blind procedure, placebo-controlled, within-subjects, 20 males, scopolamine vs placebos before virtual Morris Water Maze inside fMRI, counterbalanced two weeks
Antonova et al. (2011) findings?
Scopolamine increased latency and errors, reduced hippocampal activation.
Antonova et al. (2011) conclusion?
Acetylcholine is critical for encoding spatial memories via hippocampal circuits.
Antonova et al. (2011) evaluation?
- Causality & Control: High internal validity (double-blind, within-subjects).
- Validity: High internal; moderate external (virtual task); low ecological.
- Reliability: High standardization of dosing and fMRI protocols.
- Ethics: Potential side effects; screened participants; debrief.
- Reductionism vs Holism: Reductionist focus on one neurotransmitter.
- Generalizability: Limited to young adult males.
Maguire et al. (2000) full?
Aim: Test whether long-term spatial navigation affects hippocampal anatomy.
Method: Quasi-experiment. MRI scans of 16 male London taxi drivers (mean 14 years’ experience) vs. 50 matched controls. Voxel-based morphometry measured grey matter volume.
Findings: Taxi drivers had larger posterior hippocampi (and smaller anterior hippocampi); posterior volume correlated with years on the job.
Conclusion: Spatial navigation expertise induces experience-dependent neuroplastic changes localized in the hippocampus.
Evaluation:
• Causality & Control: No random assignment; self‐selection bias.
• Validity: High ecological; good internal control for age/education; limited external (male Londoners).
• Reliability: MRI measures are standardized; correlational consistency.
• Ethics: Non-invasive; informed consent.
• Reductionism: Structural focus; doesn’t assess cognitive strategies.
• Generalizability: Specific to this population and city layout.
Maguire et al. (2000) aim?
Test whether long-term spatial navigation affects hippocampal anatomy.
Maguire et al. (2000) method?
Quasi-experiment. MRI scans of 16 male right-handed London taxi drivers (mean 14 years’ experience) vs. 50 matched controls. Voxel-based morphometry measured grey matter volume.
Maguire et al. (2000) findings?
Taxi drivers had larger posterior hippocampi (and smaller anterior hippocampi); posterior volume correlated with years on the job.
Maguire et al. (2000) conclusion?
Spatial navigation expertise induces experience-dependent neuroplastic changes localized in the hippocampus.
Maguire et al. (2000) evaluation?
• Causality & Control: No random assignment; self‐selection bias.
• Validity: High ecological; good internal control for age/education; limited external (male Londoners).
• Reliability: MRI measures are standardized; correlational consistency.
• Ethics: Non-invasive; informed consent.
• Reductionism: Structural focus; doesn’t assess cognitive strategies.
• Generalizability: Specific to this population and city layout.
Zhou et al. (2014) full?
Aim: Examine whether ANDrostadienone (AND) acts as a human pheromone affecting women’s mood.
Method: Repeated-measures, double-blind. 50 heterosexual women exposed to AND, vanillin, or no odor; mood questionnaires and skin conductance recorded.
Findings: AND increased positive mood and physiological arousal near ovulation.
Conclusion: AND may function as a pheromone influencing mood hormonally.
Evaluation:
• Causality & Control: Good internal validity; double-blind.
• Validity: High internal; low ecological; artificial lab odor.
• Reliability: Repeated measures; precise dosing.
• Ethics: Informed consent; minimal risk.
• Reductionism vs Holism: Chemical focus; ignores cognitive factors.
• Generalizability: Specific to heterosexual women; hormonal timing matters.
Zhou et al. (2014) aim?
Examine whether ANDrostadienone (AND) acts as a human pheromone affecting women’s mood.
Zhou et al. (2014) method?
Repeated-measures, double-blind. 50 heterosexual women exposed to AND, vanillin, or no odor; mood questionnaires and skin conductance recorded.
Zhou et al. (2014) findings?
AND increased positive mood and physiological arousal near ovulation.
Zhou et al. (2014) conclusion?
AND increased positive mood and physiological arousal near ovulation.
Zhou et al. (2014) evaluation?
• Causality & Control: Good internal validity; double-blind.
• Validity: High internal; low ecological; artificial lab odor.
• Reliability: Repeated measures; precise dosing.
• Ethics: Informed consent; minimal risk.
• Reductionism vs Holism: Chemical focus; ignores cognitive factors.
• Generalizability: Specific to heterosexual women; hormonal timing matters.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) full?
Aim: Test whether oxytocin increases trust after betrayal.
Method: Double-blind, placebo-controlled. 49 participants received intranasal oxytocin or placebo, then played a trust game during fMRI scanning.
Findings: Oxytocin group invested more after betrayal; showed reduced amygdala activation.
Conclusion: Oxytocin modulates fear circuitry to promote social trust.
Evaluation:
• Causality & Control: High internal validity (double-blind, placebo).
• Validity: High internal; low ecological; lab game context.
• Reliability: Standard dosing; fMRI protocols.
• Ethics: Consent; debrief emotional manipulation.
• Reductionism vs Holism: Neurochemical focus; social context minimal.
• Generalizability: Cultural differences in trust exist.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) method?
Double-blind, placebo-controlled. 49 participants received intranasal oxytocin or placebo, then played a trust game during fMRI scanning.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) findings?
Oxytocin group invested more after betrayal; showed reduced amygdala activation.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) aim?
Test whether oxytocin increases trust after betrayal.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) conclusion?
Oxytocin modulates fear circuitry to promote social trust.
Baumgartner et al. (2008) evaluation?
• Causality & Control: High internal validity (double-blind, placebo).
• Validity: High internal; low ecological; lab game context.
• Reliability: Standard dosing; fMRI protocols.
• Ethics: Consent; debrief emotional manipulation.
• Reductionism vs Holism: Neurochemical focus; social context minimal.
• Generalizability: Cultural differences in trust exist.