Block III - General Law & Claims Flashcards
(296 cards)
Cards labeled “PAC flashcard” denote flashcards pulled from my previous decks during PAC that may be useful and do not always contain information discussed in class.
PAC flashcard
Mark this one Blue (5).
Restate how Article 138, UCMJ complaints are processed. (W)
- Initial Application to CC.
- Commander’s Review
- Commander Notifies Member
- Member Makes Formal 138 Complaint
- GCMCA’s Review
- GCMCA Notifies Member & Forwards to JAA
- SECAF Review (JAA)
Cite examples of situations giving rise to complaints under Article 138, UCMJ. (W)
Unlawful pre-trial confinement
Deferral of post-trial confinement
Admin actions in lieu of C-M or NJP
Decoration type items
Who is the final authority for final review of formal complaints?
AF/JAA is the authority for final review for formal complaints
Who is responsible for submitting the Article 138 complaint?
The member, BUT ADC may assist and submit on behalf of member
What AFI covers Article 138 complaints?
AFI 51-505
How long does the member have from discovery of the wrong to submit, in writing, the complaint to their CC?
90 days
What must or can the initial CC receiving the Art 138 complaint do?
- Must consult with servicing SJA
- May initiate inquiries necessary for response
- May consider evidence in addition to matters member submitted before responding to member
- Everything used by CC MUST be sent to GCMCA as well.
When does an Article 138 complaint go from informal to formal?
When it is submitted to the GCMCA
How long does the CC have to respond to the member?
- No later than 30 days.
- CC may notify of additional time for fact gathering (and must be sent to member every 30 days as needed)
- Otherwise CC will notify of relief granted, relief denied in full or in part and CC must specify why, or of forwarding the complaint to appropriate office
When can the member submit the Article 138 complaint to the GCMCA?
When the informal complaint at the CC level dismisses the relief in whole or in part.
How long does the member have to apply in writing to the GCMCA review of the Article 138 complaint?
30 days from CC’s decision to dismiss the relief in whole or in part
What AFI and attachment must the member use to request GCMCA review of the Article 138 complaint?
AFI 51-505, attachment 3
Can the member add new allegations in the Article 138 complaint submitted to the GCMCA?
No
What must or will the GCMCA do upon receipt of the Article 138 complaint?
- Consult with GCMCA SJA and obtain written legal review
- May conduct an investigation as needed to respond
- May consider other authority’s findings on collateral matters
- must notify member, within 60 days of application for redress, of relief denied (and why), granted, part or whole, lack of authority and forwarding, or deferral for fact finding.
Who has ultimate authority on all Art 138 complaints?
AF/JAA
Who must the GCMCA send a copy of the Art 138 complaint file to, regardless of decision to grant in full or deny in whole or part?
AF/JAA
Who provides final decision to GCMCA for the Article 138 Complaint?
AF/JAA
What does AF/JAA notify member of?
- Completion of their review
- Further action on the complaint
- Reasons for that action (if applicable)
Explain key principles of tort law. (W)
- Tort
- Civil Wrong
- One party causes personal injury/damage to another
- May be held liable for damages
- Elements of tort
- Duty to do / not to do certain acts
- Breach or violation of that duty
- Breach caused/was proximate cause of damage
- Breach / violation caused damage, personal injury, death
Explain the statutory requirements of the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA). (W)
Stateside ONLY
- Proper Claimants
–Owners of property that was damaged, individual who was injured, an executor (if individual passed away), insurance company (subrogation)
-Improper Claimants
–Other federal agencies
- Statute of Limitations
- FTCA has a two-year limitation (Federal trumps state f/ Statute of limitations).
Differentiate between FTCA statutory and state law procedures. (W)
— State substantive law applies
* Damage limitation cause of action
* All defenses available to private person
* Cause of action (tort elements)
* Scope of employment
— Federal Procedural rules apply (and trump state)
* Two year statute of limitations
* Must file administrative claim first (some sort of written demand must be presented)
Explain the statutory requirements of the Military Claims Act (MCA). (W)
— Proper Claimants
* Citizens who are US inhabitants (dependents of military members)
* federal civilian employees temporarily assigned outside the U.S. on behalf of the U.S.,
* Military personnel and federal civilians
— Improper Claimants
* Governments of a foreign nation
* Inhabitants from a foreign country where damages occurred in a foreign country
— Statute of Limitations
* Two years (same as FTCA)
— Damages
* US not liable under strict liability rules
* Up to individual to prove what they claim
* No punitive damages are awarded. Only awards are for what it costs to bring the person/item back to whole.
Differentiate between the tort and non-combat provisions under the Military Claims Act (MCA). (W)
–MCA (Act of Grace) Negligent or Wrongful Act or Omission (tort)
* Requires negligent act or omission and scope of employment
* Claimant must prove negligence
* Claims arising in U.S. – State law where the act or omission occurred
* Claims arising overseas – multiple rules for determining
—Noncombat Activity
* Essentially military in nature (has no similar civilian equivalent activity).
* Sonic boom, EOD, etc
* No proof of negligence (causal connection)