C2. Pacemaking- full Flashcards
(46 cards)
Headings pneumonic
CMCDDCDL
Headings (list)
Introduction
Clinical context/ future therapies
Membrane clock
Calcium clocks
Disputing calcium clocks
Debate between hypotheses
Coupled clock
Dysregulation of coupled clock
Localisation of pacemaker activity to the SAN
Introduction subheadings (list)
Spontaneous action potentials and diastolic depolarisation
Membrane clock vs calcium clock
(Introduction) Spontaneous action potentials and diastolic depolarisation
● The sinoatrial node (SAN) is the primary origin of the spontaneous electrical activity in the heart.
● Understanding this pacemaker activity is important for the treatment of SAN arrhythmias and future development of biological pacemakers.
● Cells within the SAN can generate action potentials due to the absence of inwardly-rectifying K+ channels.
● Spontaneous action potentials are preceded by diastolic depolarisation.
● The origin of this diastolic depolarisation (DD) has been the subject of intense debate between two prominent groups over the past 25 years.
(Introduction) Membrane clock vs calcium clock
● The DiFrancesco group in Milan focuses on the role of funny current (If), and the ‘membrane clock’.
● In contrast, the Lakatta group at Georgetown has argued that spontaneous electrical activity is driven by oscillations in local calcium release, termed the ‘calcium clock’.
● There are several limitations to the experiments used by both groups, such use of guinea pig or rabbit models, that typically have much higher resting heart rates compared to humans.
● Furthermore, many experiments in the field use the whole-cell configuration for electrophysiological measurements, which can result in cell dialysis and the dilution of signalling molecules.
● Recently there has been a re-evaluation of the two predominant theories, focusing on the interaction between membrane ion channels and intracellular calcium handling machinery.
● This is known as the coupled clock mechanism, and this model allows for a degree of redundancy in the pacemaker mechanisms, potentially an evolutionary advantage.
Clinical context/ future therapies subheadings (list)
Keith & Flack 1907
Pacemakers
Protze 2017 and stem cells
HCN channels, stem cells and connexin-43 proteins
Qu 2003
(Clinal/ future) Keith & Flack 1907
● Keith & Flack in 1907 reported on the presence of a region in the sino-auricular junction responsible for the heart’s automaticity.
● They described the passage of electricity from this fibrous tissue to the interauricular septum.
● These findings validated early physiological studies that showed the heart’s rhythm began in the neighbourhood of the great veins.
(Clinal/ future) Pacemakers
● In patients with abnormal heart rates, it is not uncommon for pacemakers to be used to artificially control heart rate.
● Many of the patients who require the fitting of artificial pacemakers do so because of atrioventricular disease, therefore it may be pertinent to better understand the roles of secondary pacemaker regions in the heart.
● PMs can be either temporary or permanent.
● Temporary PMs are used for short-term heart problems, such as arrhythmias caused by myocardial infraction and also in emergencies.
● A PM consists of a pulse generator which contains all the computerized information to sense the intrinsic cardiac electric potentials and to stimulate cardiac contraction, and a battery; leads, which are wires with electrodes at their tips.
● There are a number of limitations to the implantation of permanent pacemakers, including the risks associated with the procedure, as well as questions about the longevity of both the batteries and leads in the pacemaker.
● Given these risks, the development of a biological pacemaker remains an attractive therapeutic solution.
(Clinal/ future) Protze 2017 and stem cells
● Cardiomyocytes can also be generated from human pluripotent stem cells.
● Previous attempts to develop SAN-like cells had been unsuccessful as a heterogeneous population of cells was developed in culture.
● However, Protze et al in 2017 exploited the understanding of cardiomyocyte development to develop sino-atrial node-like cells from hPSCs.
● They observed a population of NKX2-5-negative cells that had pacemaker like-phenotypes and pacemaker-like gene expression, as assessed by qPCR.
● The authors were able to increase the efficiency of culturing these cells by the addition BMP4 and a TGF-beta inhibitor at the mesodermal stage, which was further increased by culturing with right-atrial segments.
● These cells had pacemaker activity in vitro, as well as in vivo, as was demonstrated by transplantation of these cells into the ventricular myocardium and assessing the frequency of ectopic beats.
● However, the survival of these grafts was limited; a barrier to their therapeutic use as a biological pacemaker.
(Clinal/ future) HCN channels, stem cells and connexin-43 proteins
● Despite conflicting reports as to the necessity of HCN channels for pacemaking activity, these ion channels have been described as a potential therapeutic option for delivery of a biological pacemaker.
● Other biological pacemaker avenues of research have focused on transplantation of pacemaker-like cells developed from embryonic stem cells into the SAN.
● Furthermore, it may not be essential for cells to express all pacemaker currents, if these cells can be made to couple with existing pacemaker cells with connexin-43 proteins.
(Clinal/ future) Qu 2003
● Qu et al in 2003 were the first to use the HCN2 channel as a target for gene therapy.
● This channel has intermediate kinetics when compared with the HCN4 and HCN1 channels expressed in the HCN.
● The authors developed adenoviral vectors to express the HCN2 channel and GFP in the left atrium of an adult canine model, where there was direct injection of the vector.
● Electrodes were implanted to artificially stimulate vagal tone to the SAN to block endogenous pacemaker activity, whilst ECG recorded the electrical activity in the induced pacemaker region of the left atrium.
● The authors observed pacemaker firing in the left atrium, and study of dissociated isolated myocytes under patch clamp showed funny current when cAMP was present in the patch pipette.
● However, these studies were only performed 3-4 days after direct cardiac injection, which is no indication of the longevity of the treatment.
Membrane clock subheadings (list)
Funny current
DiFrancesco & Tortora 1991
Shi 1999
(Membrane clock) Funny current
● If channels spontaneously open at the maximum diastolic potential, enabling inward flow of current carried by predominantly sodium ions.
● This depolarisation increases the open probability of voltage gated CaT channels in late DD, causing sufficient depolarisation to open L-type voltage gated calcium channels (VGCCs), triggering the upstroke of the SAN action potential.
● The funny current was proposed to be the target of autonomic modulation of heart rate.
● As such, research was directed into a number of factors that may influence the intensity of funny current in sinoatrial node cardiomyocytes.
(Membrane clock) DiFrancesco & Tortora 1991
● DiFrancesco & Tortora in 1991 excised patches with large-tipped pipettes from rabbit SAN cells, and measured funny current in response to a rapid hyperpolarising pulse.
● The authors showed that cAMP addition to the test solution to the internal side of the patch increased the funny current compared to control test solutions.
● However, perfusion with PKA catalytic subunit alone was not sufficient to increase funny current.
● These data show that mimicking the increase in cAMP (within a physiological range) seen in sympathetic stimulation of beta-adrenoreceptors is sufficient to promote the diastolic depolarising current.
● The authors went on to show that cAMP shifted the activation curve for If to more positive membrane potential values, as opposed to increasing maximal If current.
● However, the use of excised patches negates other cellular factors which would otherwise be acting on HCN channels if they were studied in situ.
● Parasympathetic stimulation is also known to decrease heart rate.
● Thus, if funny current is the site of autonomic modulation of automaticity, the neurotransmitter acetylcholine would be expected to influence funny current.
(Membrane clock) Shi 1999
● Shi et al in 1999 used RT-PCR to verify that HCN1 & HCN4 (as they were later named), were selectively expressed in the SAN.
● These findings have been used to argue that If is fundamental to pace-making, as the expression of the channels facilitating If is localised to the SAN and other neurons that exhibit pacemaker-like activity.
● The funny current channels are not the only membrane channels involved in automaticity in the sinoatrial node.
● Indeed, there has been some suggestion that both L-type and T-type voltage gated calcium channels may contribute to the diastolic depolarisation.
Calcium clocks subheadings (list)
Sparks and SR in pacemaking
Rigg & Terrar 1996
Model- spontaneous release triggers oscillations
Capel & Terrar 2015
(Calcium clocks) Sparks and SR in pacemaking
● The release of Ca2+ also occurs spontaneously under the form of sparks or openings of single RyR2 sensitive Ca2+ channels.
● This is the result of the small, but non-zero open probability of these ryanodine receptor channels.
● The importance of sarcoplasmic reticulum in pacemaking was first noticed by Rigg & Terrar in the late 1990s.
(Calcium clocks) Rigg & Terrar 1996
● Rigg & Terrar in 1996 used extracellular electrodes to measure the heart rate in a guinea-pig atrium.
● Ryanodine was sufficient to impair heart rate in these atrial preparations, as was cyclopiazonic acid, a SERCA inhibitor.
● This was verified at a single-cellular basis using microelectrodes to record cellular membrane potential.
● The authors observed that single SAN cell action potential firing decreased, as did the gradient of the diastolic depolarisation.
● However, it would have been interesting for the authors to see if this was due to effects on funny-current, by administering hyperpolarising pulses.
(Calcium clocks) Model- spontaneous release triggers oscillations
● These findings formed the basis of the calcium clock model.
● This model argues that spontaneous calcium release from the SR, due to the non-zero open probability of RyR2 channels, triggers oscillations in local calcium release.
● This calcium release is proposed to activate the electrogenic NCX protein, which drives depolarisation and spontaneous electrical activity.
● Rhythmic depolarisations are maintained by calcium reuptake into the SR by SERCA.
(Calcium clocks) Capel & Terrar 2015
● Capel & Terrar in 2015, using isolated guinea-pig SAN myocytes, found that addition of BAPTA (calcium chelator) to the pipette solution in whole-cell voltage clamp conditions resulted in rapid cessation of rhythmic cellular pacemaking activity, which was not seen in control myocytes.
● Concurrently loading the cells with Fluo5F and imaging under confocal microscopy showed that these oscillatory calcium transients proceeded until BAPTA addition, thus supporting the calcium clock hypothesis.
Disputing calcium clocks subheadings (list)
Lakatta group and different isoforms of SERCA and Ca2+-activated AC
Superfusion of Li+
Rigg 2000 and PKA-dependent mechanisms
PKA/exercise and arrhythmias
Vinogradova 2002
(Disputing) Lakatta group and different isoforms of SERCA and Ca2+-activated AC
● Critics of the calcium clock also question the ubiquitous expression of calcium handling machinery throughout the heart.
● They argue that this would predispose individuals to ectopic firing and arrhythmias.
● Although, the Lakatta group argues to the contrary, by demonstrating that different isoforms of SERCA and Ca2+-activated adenylate cyclase are expressed in the SAN compared to the ventricles.
● Furthermore, those critical of the calcium clock argue that when cells are isolated from the SAN, their calcium homeostasis is dysregulated yet they still rhythmically fire, and thus this leads to potentially erroneous results regarding the importance of the calcium clock.
(Disputing) Superfusion of Li+
● Rapid superfusion of cells with Li+ blocks the NCX transporter, which attenuated the inward current in response to ramp depolarisation.
● When action potentials were observed in current-clamp mode, superfusion of Li+ inhibited action potential generation.
● The rate and amplitude of SR Ca2+ cycling is proposed to be controlled by the amount of free Ca2+ in the system, the SR Ca2+ pumping rate and the number of activated RyR’s.
● The LCR period and amplitude determine the time and amplitude of the late exponential phase of the DD, respectively, and thus determine whether the membrane achieves its excitation threshold to generate the next rhythmic APs via activation of INCX.
(Disputing) Rigg 2000 and PKA-dependent mechanisms
● Rigg et al in 2000 showed a potential mechanism for the regulation of heart rate by SR calcium release.
● Ryanodine administration shifted the dose-response curve for isoprenaline to the right, with the response being percentage change in heart rate, recorded by extracellular electrodes in isolated hearts.
● These findings indicate that beta adrenergic stimulation increases heart rate by an SR calcium-dependent mechanism.
● Isoprenaline administration increased calcium transients as measured by Indo-1 AM addition.
● However, the frequency of pacemaking was reduced in Indo-1 loaded cells, which the authors concluded was a result of the inherent buffering capacity of the calcium dye.
● Furthermore, ryanodine was sufficient to attenuate isoprenaline-induced calcium transients.
● It would have been interesting if these experiments were conducted in the presence of nifedipine to determine that the calcium transients were completely intracellular in origin.
● Basal PKA-dependent phospholamban phosphorylation modulates kinetics of SR Ca2+ pumping, and phosphorylation of RyRs alters threshold of spontaneous activation of RyRs by Ca2+ within the SR.
● PKA-dependent mechanisms also regulate function of surface electrogenic proteins and couple M and Ca2+ clocks.