Cases Flashcards
(100 cards)
Hawkins v. McGee
hairy hand
expectation damages
[value of perf hand] - [value of hand now]
Nurse v. Barns
iron mills
damages not limited by value of consideration
Sullivan v. O’Connor
stripper nose
reliance only
J.O. Hooker
contractor K + subcontractor K
UCC v. CL: look at nature of K (here, about duties, so CL)
KGM Harvesting
lettuce
buyer’s right to cover (UCC 2-712)
Groves
didn’t leave in uniform grade
CoC > DMV
subjective value of land
dissent: CoC grossly disproportionate, should go with objective view
Peevyhouse
coal mining and a bit of restorative work (restorative not done)
DMV > CoC; court favors relative economic benefit (both parties profiting from mining, not a major breach here, no economic waste)
Hadley v. Baxendale
crankshaft special circumstances not communicated, not foreseeable that lost profits = consequence of breach
Hector Martinez
whole machine delayed; more foreseeable, Q of fact
Morrow
coin collection storage
Tacit Agreement Test
Chicago Coliseum
boxing match
only recover if reasonable certainty, no recovery for pre-K expenditures
Winston Cigarette
WHY UNCERTAINTY = LIMIT:
1. Damages based on lost profits = “shadowy, uncertain, and speculative and therefore incapable of legal computation”
2. would foster a disregard of the just rights of parties
3. Consequence of giving unlimited discretion to jury
4. Parties can specify otherwise if they disagree (e.g. liquidated damages clause)
Anglia Television
movie K
lost revenues not proven with reasonable certainty; RELIANCE instead
recover ALL reliance expenditures including pre-K reliance
Security Stove
booth but shipment delayed
TYPICALLY: [market value at time of delivery] - [market value at time should’ve been delivered]
If notice of peculiar circumstances but no lost profits, RELIANCE (not expectancy)
Luten Bridge
“bridge to nowhere”
avoidability; can’t recover damages from performance after notice of repudiation
Shirley MacClaine
wrongful termination of employment
[agreed salary] - [comparable/substantially similar employment (duty to mitigate)]
not required to take diff/inferior employment
Neri v. Retail Marine
boat sale repudiation
lost-volume seller
Kemble v. Farren
comedy act, drops out
LDC can’t be a penalty (express lang of K)
Wassenaar
terminated manager early
valid LDC
Lake River Corp
LDC: 1 sum for all breaches
penalty
Loveless
breach of K to sell land P already improved
land sale Ks = specific performance
Scholl
auto parts
not unique enough; default for sale of goods Ks = monetary damages
Sedmak
rare corvette
unique enough; specific performance for sale of unique goods
Mary Clark
no specific performance for personal services Ks