CHAPTER 1: DIAGNOSIS, CONCEPTUAL ISSUES AND CONTROVERSIES Flashcards
(75 cards)
What is the difference between a system of classification and diagnosis in mental illness?
A system of classification is an overarching taxonomy of mental illness, whereas diagnosis is the act of placing an individual into a category within that taxonomy based on signs and symptoms.
What are syndromes in the context of mental illness?
Syndromes are constellations of signs and symptoms that co-occur across individuals and are at the lowest rung of the hierarchy of understanding.
What does the term ‘syndrome’ mean in Greek?
Syndrome means ‘running together’ in Greek.
Provide an example of a syndrome and its characteristics.
Antisocial personality disorder is an example characterized by signs like the use of an alias and symptoms like lack of remorse.
What is the current understanding of the pathology and etiology of antisocial personality disorder?
The pathology and etiology of antisocial personality disorder are largely unknown.
What is the argument regarding psychopathic personality (psychopathy) by some authors?
Some authors argue that psychopathy may not be a classical syndrome but a configuration of several largely independent constructs.
List the constructs that may define psychopathy.
- Boldness
- Coldness
- Disinhibition
What is Gerstmann’s syndrome characterized by?
Gerstmann’s syndrome is marked by:
* Agraphia
* Acalculia
* Finger agnosia
* Left-right disorientation
What distinguishes disorders from syndromes?
Disorders are syndromes that cannot be readily explained by other conditions.
What are the criteria for diagnosing obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)?
OCD can be diagnosed if symptoms and signs cannot be accounted for by a specific phobia.
What is the highest rung of the hierarchy of understanding in mental illness classification?
Diseases are the highest rung, where pathology and etiology are reasonably well understood.
Provide an example of a prototypical disease and its characteristics.
Sickle-cell anemia is a prototypical disease characterized by crescent-shaped erythrocytes containing hemoglobin S and two autosomal recessive alleles.
What is the primary pathology identified in Alzheimer’s disease?
The primary pathology includes senile plaques, neurofibrillary tangles, and granulovacuolar degeneration.
What is a significant limitation of the current psychiatric classification system?
Most diagnoses in the current system are almost exclusively syndromes or, in rare cases, disorders, indicating that pathology in most cases is largely unknown.
True or False: Few mental illnesses are classified as disorders in the strict sense of the term.
True
Fill in the blank: The act of placing an individual into a category based on signs and symptoms is known as __________.
[diagnosis]
What are the three principal functions of diagnosis?
- Diagnosis as Communication 2. Establishing Linkages With Other Diagnoses 3. Provision of Surplus Information
What does diagnosis as communication allow professionals to do?
It allows professionals to be reasonably confident that they are referring to the same condition.
What is nosology?
The branch of science that deals with the systematic classification of diseases.
What is the purpose of establishing linkages with other diagnoses?
To understand the relationships between different conditions and their etiological links.
What does a valid diagnosis provide according to Robins and Guze?
- Clinical description 2. Laboratory research 3. Natural history 4. Family studies
Fill in the blank: A diagnosis helps us to learn new things; it affords us _______.
[surplus information]
What is meant by differential diagnosis?
The task of distinguishing a diagnosis from similar diagnoses.
What is the significance of validity in a diagnosis?
It measures whether a diagnosis accurately reflects what it purports to measure.