Chapter 2 Flashcards
(68 cards)
Constitutional Powers of Government
- Federal Form of Government
- Regulatory Powers of the States
- Relations among the States
- Separations of Powers
- Commerce Clause
- Supremacy Clause/Federal Preemption
- Taxing Power
- Spending Power
Constitutional Powers: Federal Form of Government
- Power is divided between national government and state governments (partnership)
Constitutional Powers: Regulatory Powers of the States
STATES SHOULD HAVE MORE POWER
- sovereignty
- police powers
Sovereignty
Power to govern themselves stems from the 10th amendment
- currently moving towards a bigger federal government (bail out checks, student loan forgiveness, eviction mortatorium)
Police Powers
Right of state governments to regulate private activities to protect or promote the public order, health, safety, morals, and the general welfare
Constitutional Powers: Relations among the States
- Privileges and Immunities Clause
- Full Faith and Credit Clause
Privileges and Immunities Clause
Article IV, Section 2 of the Constitution
“If citizens of one state engage in basic and essential activities (EARN A LIVING, ACCESS TO HOUSING) in another state they must be treated the same as citizens of the foreign state unless the foreign state has SUBSTANTIAL REASONING.”
Full Faith and Credit Clause
Article IV, Section 1 of the US Constitution
1. Applies only to CIVIL matters
2. Rights established under deeds, wills, and contracts will be honored in other states
Constitutional Powers: Separation of Powers
Legislative: makes laws
Executive: enforces laws
Judicial: judges whether laws have been violated
Constitutional Powers: Commerce Clause
Article I, Section 8 of the US Constitution
- Regulates commerce with foreign nations and between states (INTERstate)
- Federal power (pretty significant)
- Expansion of Federal power
Gibbons v. Ogden (1824)
Federal government can regulate INTRAstate if the commerce concerns one or more state
Wickard v. Filburn (1942)
Farmer’s crop production to be used wholly for consumption on his farm was subject to federal regulation because it affected interstate commerce
- affects supply and demand
Heart of Atlanta Motel v. U.S. (1964)
Motel’s arguments:
1. Civil Rights Act is unconstitutional
2. Their policies don’t affect interstate commerce
Small shop but… off of a major highway in Atlanta, Georgia
CONSTITUTIONALIZED THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT
(Consistent with Wickard v. Filburn)
US v Morrison (2000)
Congress exceeded its authority in passing federal Violence Against Women Act
- Ruling gave the power back to the state, the act has nothing to do with commerce
Gonzales v. Raich (2005)
Medical Marijuana
- two women with cancer grew weed to numb pain
- violated the FEDERAL Controlled Substances Act, but lived in California/Colorado (where weed is legal)
WHAT CAN BE LEGAL AT A STATE LEVEL CAN BE ILLEGAL AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL
Dormant Commerce Clause
States do not have the authority to regulate interstate commerce
- State regulations can affect interstate commerce
- “Balance” states’ interests and the burden placed
Raymond Motor Transportation Inc. v. Rice
Wisconsin had a rule regulating how long 18-wheeler could be
- as a trucking company the rule affects commerce…costs time and money to follow
- law is unconstitutional
- favor usually goes to the federal government
Constitutional Powers: Supremacy Clause/Federal Preemption
- US Constitution, laws, and treaties are the supreme law of the land
- Preemption
Preemption:
Federal law preempts state law in conflict
- Congress chooses to act exclusively in an area of the law “concurrent area”
- Present anytime there is a direct conflict between state and federal law
Constitutional Powers: Taxing Power
- Congress has the power to tax, but must be uniform/consistent throughout the states
- Courts allow tax if it is a valid revenue-raising measure
Constitutional Powers: Spending Power
- Congress pays debts and provides for defense and general welfare of the US
- Rarely challenged (problem with standing) plaintiff must find a direct and personal injury
- Congress can spend revenues to promote any objective it deems worthwhile
Spending Power: Promote Any Objective it Deems Worthwhile
(1980s) US offered to give every state money to fix roads… but they had to raise the drinking age to 21. Mothers Against Drunk Driving. Every state but Louisiana agreed, and their roads are still bad
Bill of Rights
Originally applied only to the federal government
- incorporated into the states through the 14th amendment
- US is the final interpreter of the Constitution
Rights are NOT absolute..
When unreasonable, they are unconstitutional