Chapter 7 Flashcards
Financial Statement Fraud (63 cards)
Three General Questions of Fraud
- Who commits FS fraud?
- Why do people commit?
- How do people commit FS fraud?
Who Commits FS Fraud?
- Senior management
- Mid & Lower Level Employees
- Organized Crime
Why do people commit FS fraud? &
How to deter and detect?
Cook the books
- To conceal true business performance
- To perserve personal status/control
- To maintain personal income/wealth
Understand the different pressures that drive fraud
Common Reasons Senior Management might Overstate Performance
- Meet or Exceed earnings or revenue growth expectations of stock analysts
- Comply w/ loan covenants
- Increase amount of financing available from asset-based loans
- Meet Lenders criteria for granting or extending loan facilities
- Meet corp performance criteria - set by parent comp
- Meet personal performance criteria
- Trigger performance related compensation
- Support stock price in **anticip of M&A **or sale of stock
- Show growth to support securities offering or bus sale
Common Reasons Senior Management might Understate Performance
- To defer surplus earnings to next acc pd
- Take all possible write-offs in one big bath, so future earnings consistently higher
- Reduce expectations now so future growth perceived and rewarded
- Perserve a trend of consistent growth and avoid volatile results
- **Reduce value ** of owner man bus for divorce settlement
- Reduce the value of corp unit, whose management is planning to buy out
Differences between Public vs. Private Company Fin Rep Fraud
Public Comp Fraud
- Stronger antifraud env: Perps use timing differences for frauds more
- Larger fraud teams to circumvent controls
- Larger frauds than priv comp fraud
- More likely to detect by formal means, not accident
Recognition & Measurement Concepts: Assumptions
ACC principals and fraud conceptual framework
Eco Entity, Going Concern, Monetary Unit, Periodicity
1. Economic Entity - Activity of a business enterprise should be kept separete and distinct from its owners and other bus entities
2. Going Concern - Assumed business is one that will continue into the future - fraud used to conceal GC issue
3. Monetary Unit - Common Denominator is money
4. Periodicity - Principal of dividing economic activity in specific time intervals - monthly, quarterly, and annually
Recognition & Measurement Concepts: Principles
ACC principals and fraud conceptual framework
Historical cost, reve recog, matching, full disclosure
1. Historical Cost - GAAP reqs assets carried at price established by exchange transaction
2. Revenue Recognition - GAAP accrual basis of accounting should be used for fin reporting
3. Matching - Books, records, & FS match revenue and expense in the proper acc period
4. Full Disclosure - Disclose any material info required to understand FS and deviations from GAAP be explained
Recognition & Measurement Concepts: Constraints
ACC principals and fraud conceptual framework
Cost benefit, materiality, industry practice, conservatism
1. Cost Benefit -FASB considers trade-off btw cost of providing certain info and benefit derived by users
2. Materiality - FS not perfectly accurate, only reasonable & Fail –> materiality is user oriented –> based on effect on users
3. Industry Practice - Reporting practices within certain industies deviate from GAAP to be fair and clearly presented
4. Conservatism - Whn in doubt, avoid overstating assets and income or understating liabilities and expense
Qualitive Characteristics
ACC principals and fraud conceptual framework
Relevance and Reliability
Comparability and Consistency
1. Relevance & Reliability - Primary characteristics for decision makind
2. Comparability & Consistency - Necessary for analytical purposes
Who is Responsible for Financial Statements and why? Who is fraud instigated by?
Expand on who sets org culture
Who: Company management is responsible: hard to commit fraud without their knowledge
Why: Bod and Senior Mngmt set the orgs culture
- Tone at top: high integrity leads to more honest employees
Who: Members of management generally instigated
Who are the users of FS and what are the uses?
Users of FS
- Company owners: monitor performance and make operational decisions
- Lending organizations: Evaluate ability to pay debt - loan approval
- Vendors/Customers: Evaluate ability to pay for inventory - credit approval
- Investors: Evaluate whether to sell/buy stock and performance - decision
Uses of FS
- Increase the apparent prosperity of the organization
- Dispel negative perceptions
- Judge employee of management performance
Types of Financial Statement Fraud and Distribution
5 types
- Fictitious Revenues
- Timing Differences
- Concealed Liabilities and Expenses
- Improper Disclosures
- Improper Asset Valuations
Distribution is fairly uniform
Definition of Financial Statement Fraud and types
Deliberate misstatements or omissions of amounts or disclosures of financial statements to deceive financial statement users
- Typically to deceive investors and creditors
Arise from fraudulent fin reporting and misappropriation of assets
FS Fraud Schemes
List 4
- Falsification, alteration, or manipulation of material financial records, supporting docs, or business transactions
- Material intentional omissions or misrepresentations of events, transaction, accounts, or other signif information from which FS are prepared
- Deliberate misapplication of Acc princips, policies, & procedures used to measure, recognize, report, & disclose economic events & business transacs
- Intentional omissions of disclosures or presentation of inadequte disclosures regarding accounting principles and policies and related fin amounts
What are the costs of FS Fraud?
avg loss, enron loss in mark cap, costs not considered
- In 2000, >50% of US corps fraud victims w/ avg loss > 500k for each comp
- Enron collapse: Loss of about $70b in market cap to investors, employees, pensioners
- Shareholders los $460b in enron, worldcom, quest, global crossing & Tyco Debacles
- Many indirect costs, that were not considered in stats
Ways FS Fraud is Harmful?
- Undermines reliability, quality, transparency, and integrity of fin rep process
- Jeopardizes the integrity and objectivity of the auditing profession
- Diminishes confidence of the cap mkts in reliability of fin info
- Makes the cap mkts less efficient
- Adversely affects the nation economic growth and prosperity
- Leads to huge litigation costs
- Destroys careers of those involved
- Cause bankruptcy or big eco losses for the company
- Encourages regulatory intervention
- Causes devastation in the normal ops and performance of alleged comps
- Raises serious doubt about the efficacy of FS audits
- Erodes public confidence & trust in acc and audit profession
What are fictitious revenues and how may they occur?
What: The recording of sales of goods or services that did not occur
How: Artificially inflate or alter invoices of legitimate customers
Typically when is revenue recognized and what is the criteria?
When: Rev recognized either when realized/realizable or earned
Criteria:
- Persuasive evidence of an arrangement exist
- Delivery has occurred or services have been rendered
- Sellers prices to the buyer is fixed or determinable
- Colletability is reasonably assured
Sources of Guidance for Revenue Recognition
FASB under ASC
FASB: Concepts Statement 5 and 6
FASB: Accounting Standards Codification
- ASC 605: Revenue Recognition
- ASC 606” Revenue from contracts w/ customers
Types of Fictitious Revenue Entries
1. Sales w/ Conditions: should not be booked as rev until all conditions are satisfies –> company may book when terms not complete and rights and risk of ownership not passed to purchaser to inflate rev
Pressures to Boost REvenues
- External pressure to succeed common motivation
- meet loan reqs - Internal pressure to meet certain target
- department budget reqs
Red Flags Associated w/ Fictituous Revenues
- Rapid growth or unusual profitability
- Inability to generate cash flows from ops while reporting earnings
- Significant transaction w/ related parties or SPE no in ordinary course of bus
- Significant, unusual, or highly complex transactions
- Unusual growth in # of days’ sales in receivable
- Signif volume of sales to entities whose substance and ownership is not known
- Unusual surge in sales by a minority of units within a company
Describe the Timing of Differences FS Fraud
Type of FS fraud
What: recording revenue and/or expenses in improper period
- Shift revs or exp btw one pd to the next to either increase or decrease earnings to desired amount