Comparing The Constitutions Of Britain And America: Comparing Devolution & Federalism

Question 1

What are the two comparison structural theory demonstrates about devolution and federalism between the two countries?

Answer 1

Federalism is embed in the US constitution, with the tenth amendment, while devolution is only granted by parliamentary statute, and federalism applies across the whole country while devolution applies across some of the country

Question 2

What are the two comparison rational theory demonstrates about devolution and federalism between the two countries?

Answer 2

The US has more competitive state/local elections, pressure groups often focus more on Parliament and Whitehall in UK while US is more spread across state and regional legislatures, the UK devolved assemblies have quite a few nationalist parties

Question 3

What are the two comparison cultural theory demonstrates about devolution and federalism between the two countries?

Answer 3

The rights of states are much more deep-rooted in American history, while UK devolved assemblies are a lot more recent arrival