Consulting in General Practice Flashcards
A 78-year-old patient attends with a gift following referral for an MI.
According to the NHS England Standard GMS Contract, what is the threshold at which gifts should be recorded in a register?
A. £25
B. £10
C. £250
D. £100
E. £50
Answer: D. £100
Justification: NHS England requires gifts ≥£100 from patients or relatives be recorded unless unconnected to service provision.
Resources:
- BMA. Receiving gifts from patients (2020)
- GMC. Good Medical Practice (2013, updated 2014, 2019)
A 54-year-old patient has severe restless leg syndrome affecting sleep and work.
What is the SINGLE MOST appropriate management?
A. Lifestyle changes
B. Gabapentin
C. Quinine sulphate
D. Diazepam
E. Zopiclone
Answer: B. Gabapentin
Justification: First-line for significant RLS is alpha-2-delta ligands (gabapentin, pregabalin) or dopamine agonists.
Resource: West R. Restless legs syndrome. InnovAiT 2019; 12(12): 714–719.
You work in a 10,000-patient practice.
What is the SINGLE MOST likely number of carers among the patient population?
A. 200
B. 600
C. 800
D. 400
E. 1000
Answer: E. 1000
Justification: Census data shows ~1 in 10 people are carers. Extrapolates to ~1000 in a 10,000-patient practice.
Resource: ONS. Census analysis – Provision of unpaid care in England and Wales (2011).
A 38-year-old man with MUS and normal investigations is attending joint consultations with his family and mental health team.
What is the BEST description of this approach?
A. Collaborative care
B. Reattribution
C. CBT
D. Psychodynamic therapy
E. Brief intervention therapy
Answer: A. Collaborative care
Justification: Involves working with patient + family to define solutions. Effective for MUS.
Resource: GMC; NICE; InnovAiT guidance.
Fitness to drive scenarios:
1. First seizure at work (21yo)
2. 3-hour arm weakness abroad (61yo)
3. Diet-controlled diabetic taxi driver (47yo)
What is the correct advice for each?
Answers:
1 → Driving must cease for at least six months
2 → Driving must cease for at least one month
3 → Need not notify DVLA
Justification: Based on DVLA Group 1 & 2 criteria for seizures, TIA, and diabetes.
Resource: DVLA. Assessing fitness to drive: guide for professionals.
A man with leg fracture requests a fit note. He already self-certified the first week.
What is the SINGLE MOST appropriate action?
A. Issue from today, <3 months
B. Back-date to 1 week after injury, <3 months
C. Back-date to date of injury for 4 months
D. Issue today for 4 months
E. Refuse to issue
Answer: B. Back-date to a week from injury, <3 months
Justification: Fit note must follow some assessment or hospital documentation. Max 3 months in first 6 months.
Resource: DWP. Fit note: guidance for GPs.
Which recommendation did the GMC make to reduce self-harm in doctors under investigation?
A. Emotional resilience training during undergraduate training
B. Mandatory OH exams
C. More health examiner reports
D. Random drug/alcohol testing
E. Weekly psychological support
Answer: A. Emotional resilience training
Justification: GMC recommends resilience training for students/doctors to improve coping under stress.
Resource: GMC. Doctors who commit suicide while under GMC investigation (2014).
A 55-year-old woman post-ICU for pneumonia presents with low mood, tiredness and malaise.
What is the MOST likely diagnosis?
A. Post ICU syndrome
B. Anaemia
C. PMR
D. Delirium
E. PTSD
Answer: A. Post intensive care syndrome
Justification: Common post-ICU effects include fatigue, mood changes, weakness.
Resource: Karavadra M, Bell R. InnovAiT 2020; 13(9): 550–556.
Which consultation technique improves understanding during consultations?
A. Calgary–Cambridge
B. SPIKES
C. Elicit–provide–elicit
D. Ask me three
E. Active listening
Answer: D. Ask me three
Justification: Encourages patients to ask: “What’s my main problem?”, “What do I need to do?”, “Why is it important?”
Resource: Reilly J. Health literacy. InnovAiT 2020; 13(8): 490–494.
A hairdresser with work-related dermatitis from dyes asks about managing her condition and work.
What is the BEST consultation technique?
A. Catalytic intervention
B. Cathartic intervention
C. Housekeeping
D. Safety netting
E. Shared management plan
Answer: E. Shared management plan
Justification: Essential to involve patient in decisions, especially for chronic/occupational conditions.
Resource: RCGP. Curriculum Topic Guide: consulting in general practice (2019).
42-year-old man with PHQ-9 score of 6 post-diabetic review. No psych history.
What is the SINGLE MOST appropriate management?
A. Amitriptyline
B. St John’s wort
C. Psychiatry referral
D. Fluoxetine
E. Computerised CBT
Answer: E. Computerised cognitive behavioural therapy (CCBT)
Justification: PHQ-9 score of 6 = mild depression. NICE advises low-intensity psychological interventions.
Resource: NICE CG91 – Depression (amended guidance).
25-year-old woman with 1-week tiredness. Normal exam. No mood issues.
What is the MOST appropriate initial approach?
A. Reassure and advise watchful waiting
B. Routine blood tests
C. Express diagnostic uncertainty
D. Further testing + depression screen
E. See another GP
Answer: A. Reassure and advise watchful waiting
Justification: Serious causes unlikely with short symptom duration and no red flags. Reassurance appropriate.
Resource: BMJ; NICE – Fatigue in primary care.
Which of these decisions may be INAPPROPRIATE when managing uncertainty?
A. Refer symptomatic gallstones for surgery
B. Menopause labs in 52yo with 2y amenorrhoea
C. Reassure 35yo with rectal bleeding after normal tests
D. Ask colleague to review skin lesion
E. Discuss smoking cessation with COPD patient
Answer: B. Menopause labs in 52yo with 2y amenorrhoea
Justification: Manage based on clinical picture rather than testing in clear menopausal scenarios.
Resource: GMC. Managing Uncertainty; RCGP guidance.
31yo woman with 6-week tiredness. Normal tests. Later reveals poor sleep, low mood.
What is the SINGLE MOST appropriate next step?
A. Hepatitis serology
B. Depression screen
C. Abdo US
D. Reassure
E. Glandular fever test
Answer: B. Depression screen
Justification: Depression common in persistent fatigue. Screen after ruling out physical causes.
Resource: Hamilton W, Watson J. BMJ 2010; 341: c4259.
Which is CORRECT about using interpreters in consultations?
A. Professional interpreters don’t affect outcomes
B. Declining professional interpreters → stop consult
C. Record interpreter use in notes
D. Family members best for context
E. Interpreter responsibility lies with patient
Answer: C. Record interpreter use in notes
Justification: NHS must provide interpreters; patients may refuse, but documentation is essential.
Resource: NICE; RCGP; GMC – Interpreting guidance.
During the ‘golden minute’ of a consultation, what is MOST important?
A. Detailed questioning
B. Rapport with personal anecdotes
C. Check understanding
D. Open questioning + active listening
E. Structured condition-based Qs
Answer: D. Open questioning + active listening
Justification: Encourages disclosure of patient’s concerns and priorities early.
Resource: Moss B, Moss S. InnovAiT 2018; 12(1): 18–22.
Patient with mitral valve prolapse seeks advice re antibiotics before dental filling.
What is the MOST appropriate response?
A. Prescribe phenoxymethylpenicillin
B. Prescribe cefalexin
C. Prescribe erythromycin
D. Reassure – antibiotics not required
E. Prescribe amoxicillin
Answer: D. Reassure – antibiotics not required
Justification: NICE CG64 advises against routine prophylaxis for dental work.
Resource: NICE CG64 (2008, updated 2016).
Which statement aligns with Michael Balint’s consulting theory?
A. Communication = sender/receiver interpretation
B. Patients = drugs without side effects
C. Doctor behaviour/personality affects relationship
D. Illness = psychosocial perspective
E. Consult = game of social exchange
Answer: C. Doctor behaviour/personality affects relationship
Justification: Balint proposed the idea of the doctor as a therapeutic agent.
Resource: Neighbour R. InnovAiT 2018; 12(1): 24–29.
52-year-old with bladder carcinoma in situ post-TURBT.
What is the MOST likely additional treatment?
A. No further treatment
B. Brachytherapy
C. Intravesical BCG
D. Annual monitoring
E. Radiotherapy
Answer: C. Intravesical BCG
Justification: CIS is high risk; BCG reduces recurrence and progression.
Resource: NICE NG2. Bladder cancer: diagnosis and management (2015).
Tired GP ends a long consultation early without addressing all concerns.
What is the MOST appropriate action?
A. Bring patient back soon to address needs
B. Refer to specialists
C. Ask patient to see another GP
D. Leave note for next time
E. Assume patient will return if needed
Answer: A. Bring patient back soon to address needs
Justification: Recognising HALT states (Hungry, Angry, Late, Tired) protects patient care and safety.
Resource: Papanikitas A. InnovAiT 2017; 10(8): 452–457.
A 37-year-old patient is asking for advice regarding fitness to fly. She has just broken her ankle and was put in a full plaster cast. She is due to fly to Egypt on holiday. The duration of the flight to Egypt is about 4–5 hours.
Which SINGLE option is MOST appropriate?
A. The patient can fly straight away without restriction
B. The patient can fly straight away provided she starts oral aspirin
C. The patient should delay flying by 48 hours
D. The patient can fly straight away provided she starts an oral anticoagulant
E. The patient should delay flying by 24 hours
Answer: C. The patient should delay flying by 48 hours
Justification: If a full plaster cast has been applied, the traveller should avoid flying for 48 hours for flights longer than two hours due to the risk of circulatory compromise from tissue swelling. Risk may be reduced by a bivalve cast or back slab.
Resource: Godden A. Passenger fitness to fly. InnovAiT 2021; 14(9): 540–545.
Which ONE of the following statements regarding treatment of young people is true?
A. A 15-year-old girl wishing to commence the oral contraceptive should always have parental consent
B. Once a child is deemed to be Gillick competent this competence applies to all future forms of medical treatment
C. The parents of an 18-year-old girl with severe anorexia nervosa have the right to override her decision to refuse feeding even though she is deemed competent
D. A 15-year-old deemed Gillick competent has the right to accept treatment
E. Gillick competence only applies to contraceptive issues
Answer: D. A 15-year-old deemed Gillick competent has the right to accept treatment
Justification: Gillick competence gives a young person the right to accept treatment, though not necessarily to refuse it. Fraser guidelines specifically relate to contraception.
Resource: GMC. Consent. 0–18 years: guidance for all doctors. 2018.
Which of the following consultation models introduced and described the concept of ‘housekeeping’?
A. Calgary–Cambridge
B. Neighbour
C. Tait
D. Helmann Folk
E. Pendleton
Answer: B. Neighbour
Justification: Roger Neighbour’s five tasks include connecting, summarising, handing over, safety netting, and housekeeping.
Resource: Harmon M, Ellender M, Draper R. Innovative new ways of consulting. InnovAiT 2018; 11(9): 483–488.
You see a 55-year-old man who is troubled by involuntary movements of his legs during sleep. This has caused him to be increasingly tired during the day and is affecting his daily activities.
Which of the following deficiencies is the MOST likely cause?
A. Iron
B. Vitamin B12
C. Thiamine
D. Folate
E. Vitamin D
Answer: A. Iron
Justification: Restless leg syndrome can be caused by iron deficiency, anaemia and diabetes mellitus.
Resource: Strickland SR. Sleep disorders. InnovAiT 2023; 16(1): 27–33.