Courts, Tribunals and the Constitution Flashcards
(65 cards)
Who largely bears the burden of proof in criminal proceedings?
The prosecution - beyond reasonable doubt
What is tried in the Magistrates’ Courts?
All summary criminal offences, and some triable either way offences
What power does the MC have?
Impose an unlimited fine
Impose a maximum prison sentence of 6 months for one offence
What Courts bind the MC?
Administrative Court
Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
What offences does the Crown Court hear?
Indictable only offences - even these still will begin in the CC
Where can a criminal case appeal from Magistrates’ Court?
Crown Court
How will an appeal from the Magistrates’ Court be heard in the Crown Court?
Heard de novo - entirely fresh case
Crown Court Judge + 2x Magistrates
Where can criminal cases apply if they think that the Magistrates’ decision was legally flawed?
Administrative Court
Where can a criminal defendant appeal if convicted in Crown Court?
Can appeal conviction / sentence / both in Court of Appeal
Can the prosecution appeal to the Court of Appeal?
Yes - quashing the acquittal of someone acquitted of a serious offence
AG can appeal against an unduly lenient sentence
Is there an automatic right of appeal from Crown Court to COA?
No - Appellant must apply for permission to appeal - granted by a single judge - if rejected, can be appealed again
When / how will the Court of Appeal quash a criminal conviction of the Crown Court?
If satisfied that the conviction is unsafe - court will hear oral argument from counsel for both sides, but not hear evidence again
What are grounds for appeal against sentence imposed by Crown Court?
Sentence not justified by law
Sentence was based on an incorrect version of the evidence
Judge took irrelevant matters into account when sentencing
Judge misapplied / failed to give sufficient weight to sentencing guidelines
When will Supreme Court hear criminal appeals?
Only on a point of law of general public importance
Are English Courts bound by JCPC (Privy Council)?
No - but highly persuasive
What is the CCRC?
Body responsible for reviewing miscarriages of justice in the UK
What powers does the CCRC have?
Can send a case back to the Court of Appeal for review if there is a real possibility that the Court will overturn the conviction or sentence
If decision was made by MC / Youth Court - send back to Crown Court
Generally only when new evidence / new legal argument found which was not originally considered
What is the standard / burden of proof in criminal proceedings?
On the balance of probabilities - on claimant
Where do most civil claims begin?
County Court
What is the hierarchy of judges in the County Court?
Deputy District Judges - most junior
District Judges
Circuit Judges - more complex cases in a County Court will be heard by a Circuit Judge - also hears appeals by DJs and DDJs
What are tribunals?
Specialist judicial bodies dealing with administrative and regulatory cases - no jurisdiction in criminal matters
What are the two Tribunal levels?
First Tier Tribunal, Upper Tribunal
What is the Upper Tribunal equivalent to
It is a senior court - equivalent to the High Court - hears appeals from the First Tier Tribunal
How many first tier tribunals are there? What do they hear?
7 - hear appeals from citizens against the decisions made by government departments or agencies