Criminal Law Flashcards
(96 cards)
Mens Rea states under MPC
Purposefully : D had conscious objective to engage in the conduct cause the prohibited result
Knowingly : D was aware that the conduct, by its nature and circumstances, will cause the prohibited result
Recklessly: D had conscious disregard for a substantial and unjustifiably high risk of causing the prohibited result and this was GROSS deviation from std of care expected from reasonable person in the same circumstances
Negligently: D failed to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiably high risk of causing the prohibited result and this was SUBSTANTIAL deviation from std of care expected from reasonable person in the same circumstances
Common Law Murder
Unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought.
Malice aforethought
- if no facts (e.g., provocation) reducing the killing to voluntary manslaughter or excusing it (that is, giving rise to a defense)
And
- State of mind :
* Intent to kill (can be inferred from intent to use deadly weapon)
* Intent to inflict great bodily injury
*Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life (“abandoned and malignant heart” doctrine or “depraved heart” murder); or
* Intent to commit a felony (felony murder)
Intentional use of a deadly weapon authorizes a permissive inference of intent to kill.
Causation for Murder
- Factual Causation or cause-in-fact of the result:
result would not have occurred “but for” the defendant’s conduct. - Proximate causation:
if death is a natural and probable consequence of the D’s conduct, even if the D did not anticipate the precise manner in which the death occurred. - D intends to and factually causes but death occurs in unexpected manner. Still guilty.
Superseding Factors
Interjects into the chain of causation and breaks Proximate causation. Must be:
* Independent of the D’s actions
* Unforeseeable, and
* The sole immediate cause of the victim’s death
Felony Murder
If D is in the commission of a felony and accidental death occurs. Malice implied in the intent to commit felony
Not applicable if D has defense for the underlying felony
D need not be convicted of the felony though
Death must be foreseeable - even for co-felons if they can foresee
Merger Rule - Felony Murder
Cannot base felony murder on:
Assault, Aggravated Assault, Battery, or child abuse
Limits to Felony Murder
- Agency Theory: Not applied if shot was not fired by team Felon
- Bad guy killed: if person killed is from Team Felon
Statutory Degrees of Murder
Default Ordinary - Malice Aforethought - Second Degree Murder
Unless
First Degree Murder :
- committed during some other felony
- Premeditated killing - some conscious consideration on killing
Voluntary Manslaughter
Killed on purpose - so would be murder but for presence of adequate objective provocation and no time for cool-off
Obj reasonable provocation (n to just mere words)
D was actually provoked
Insufficient time for cool-off
D in fact did not cool off
Imperfect Self-defense
D starts the fight and D’s true honest belief that there was need to respond with deadly force resulted in killing
But D’s belief was not reasonable
Then murder downgraded to voluntary manslaughter
Involuntary Manslaughter / Accidental killing
Killing with criminal negligence
OR
During commission of an unlawful act (misdemeanor or felony not included in felony murder rule)
VA : Aggravated Murder
Willful, deliberate and premeditated murder committed under 14 different aggravating circumstances
VA: First Degree Murder
Murder - other than aggravated murder- committed by :
Poison
Lying in wait
Imprisonment
Starvation
Any willful, deliberate and premeditated killing not under the aggravated category
VA: Second Degree Murder
Default presumed Second degree murder.
Burden on Prosecution to elevate it to first degree or aggravated murder
Burden on defense to reduce it to manslaughter
VA: Felony Murder
Ordinary Felony Murder:
- considered First Degree murder
- murder committed intentionally or accidentally during commission of or during attempt of :
Arson
Rape
Forcible Sodomy
Robbery
Burglary
Abduction
Inanimate/animate obj sexual penetration
Felony Homicide:
- committed during a felony that is not on the felony murder list
VA: Voluntary Manslaughter
Unlawful killing without malice (heat of passion)
VA: Involuntary Manslaughter
Committed in the commissions of unlawful acts but not felonies
OR
curing commission of act amounting to criminal negligence`
Omission can raise liability/guilt
When D had a legal duty to act under any law,
D knows the fact that give rise to the duty, and
D must also have the necessary mens rea.
Possession Crimes
D has actual physical control (more than momentary control)
Enough to have constructive possession with awareness of ability to exercise actual physical control and do it for a period sufficient to get rid of drugs
Strict Liability Crimes
Statutory Rape
Bigamy
Regulatory Offenses
Accomplice Liability
Participation in offense ( encouraging /assisting primary actor - not just merely present)
Necessary intent ( known the primary actor and intent to aid them - want them to accomplish)
Accessory After the Fact
Separate crime
principal need not be convicted and you still can be convicted
must be evidence that actual crime was committed
VA Withdrawal from accomplice liability
BEFORE the completion of felony
signal to principal of her disapproval of planned felony
Take steps to prevent completions of felony
Robbery
Taking of a personal property of another
from their person or presence
with force or threat of death/injury
with intent to permanently deprive them of it.