critical reasoning Flashcards
(25 cards)
modus ponens
if P, then Q
P
therefore Q
modus tollens
if P, then Q
not Q
therefore not P
deductively valid
deductive arguments only
if the conclusion is guaranteed by the premises
soundness
if a deductively valid argument has strong inferential moves it is sound
cogency
if an inductive arguments premises are true and the inferential moves are strong it is cogent
inductive
common sense
deductive
fact
antecedent
P
consequent
Q
analytic statement
true by definition e.g. all bachelors are unmarried men
synthetic statement
cannot decide if its true or false only by thinking of the words meaning
used to assert a relationship or opinion
e.g. doctors are rich
appeal to adverse consequences
action a is bad
designed to persuade you against something
false dichotomy
making it out as if there are only two options when there are more than just two
either/or
begging the question
when the conclusion of the argument is the same as one of the premises and the argument goes in a circle
e.g. i am good looking therefore i am handsome
the straw man argument
criticising a misrepresentation of the other’s argument and attacking them for something they did not say/imply
e.g. i am a feminist
ur a feminist? so u hate men?
ad populum
when something is thought to be true bc a large number of people believe it to be true
e.g. book a is a bestseller, therefore it is a good book
non sequitur
when the conclusion does not follow from the premises
e.g. our product is so good film stars buy it, so what????
definist fallacy/biased definition
when a key term is used in a way that is not based on the generally accepted meaning of the word
e.g. abortion is wrong because it’s murder
post hoc ergo propter hoc
thing a happened and then after that thing b happened, so a must have caused b to happen
generally applies to one time happenings and is used to show causation
confusion of correlation and causation
every time thing a happens, thing b also happens so thing a must be the cause of thing b. there might be correlation but that’s not evidence of a causal relationship
slippery slope fallacy
used negatively to deter from the original point
e.g. lower legal drinking age
everyone will drink
including psychos
the drunk psychos will kill everyone
humans will become extinct
weasel words
give the impression that the speaker has more justification than they do
vague/ambiguous/euphemistic
vague
unclear
ambiguous
up to interpretation