Cultural variations in attachment Flashcards
(16 cards)
Procedure of Van Ijzendoorm and Kroonenberg
A meta-analysis using the strange situation to measure the proportions of each attachment category
Van Ijzendoorm and Kroonenberg sample
32 studies across 8 countries
What countries were used in Van Ijzendoorm and Kroonenberg’s study
Britain
USA
China
Japan
Germany
Which country had the highest amount of secure children
Britain 75%
Why did Britain have the highest amount of secure children
Strange situation reflects individualistic cultures that have the norm of secure attachment
Which country had the highest amount of avoidant children
Germany 35%
Why did Germany have the highest amount of avoidant children
‘Cold’ mothering style is used to encourage independence and obedience
Which country had the highest level of resistant children
Japan 27%
Why did Japan have the highest level of resistant children
Dependency is encouraged
Which country had the lowest levels of secure children
China 50%
Why did China have the lowest levels of secure children
Collectivist cultures emphasise community and whole family, there is no official primary caregiver.
Variation within the cultures
1.5 times higher within cultures than between them.
Simonelli procedure
76 one year old babies in Italy
Findings of Simonelli
50% more secure
36% more insecure
Explanation of Simonelli’s findings
Mothers work longer hours and use more childcare.
Weaknesses of cultural variations study
Assumes whole country is one culture,
Socially sensitive
Economic implications
Culturally biased.