Democracy in the UK Flashcards
(70 cards)
What is direct democracy?
A political system where the people THEMSELVES make political decisions.
i.e. referendums.
Advantages of direct democracy
Everyone gets a say - the 2016 EU referendum was one of the greatest democratic exercises where more than 33 million people voted.
Organisation is easier due to modern technology - growth of e-petitions.
Gives equal weight to all votes
Encourages popular participation - turnout for referendums often exceeds general election turnout.
Develops a sense of community
Encourages genuine debate
Disadvantages of direct democracy
Can cause political instability - the EU referendum severely compromised the UK’s political stability.
Impractical for large populations.
It can lead to the ‘tyranny of the majority’ - only 51% voted to leave the EU.
Lack of accountability.
It can divide communities.
What is representative democracy?
A political system where the citizens elect representative who make decisions on their behalf and are accountable to them.
Advantages of representative democracy
Accountability - representatives can be voted out.
Representatives can become experts.
Practical for complex issues.
Gives a voice to minority opinion - HRA and Freedom of Information Act.
Trains future leaders of the country.
Disadvantages of representative democracy
Representatives do not always do what the people want and may just do what they want - Lib Dem MPs had signed a pledge not to raise tuition fees after the 2010 general election but subsequently voted to do so.
Political parties are dominated by individuals pursuing their own agendas.
Politicians can be incompetent or corrupt - former cabinet minister Chris Huhne MP was found guilty of preverting the course of justice.
Minority groups might still find that their concerns are unmet.
Not all voters get the representative they want.
What is pluralist democracy?
A political system and/or society where there is widespread acceptance of different groups and lifestyles, where freedom of expression and association are respected, where many parties and pressure groups may operate and where there are independent media. The term also implies that power is dispersed and not concentrated.
What is a democratic deficit?
Where standards of a functioning democracy have fallen short.
How does PLURALISM work in practice in the UK?
What is preventing this from working effectively?
The 2017 Article 50 decision on Britain leaving the EU involved a number of institutions, not just the PM, Parliament voted on it, judges ruled on it and the people expressed their opinion in a referendum.
However, the Institute of Economic Affairs has been accused of using cash to gain influence over ministers.
How does FREE AND FAIR ELECTIONS work in practice in the UK?
What is preventing this from working effectively?
All adults can vote, and the results are trusted and accepted.
However, 16 and 17yo and prisoners cannot vote in GE. FPTP is unfair and leads to ‘elected dictatorship’
How does CORRUPTION IS PUNISHED work in practice in the UK?
What is preventing this from working effectively?
In 2019, two MP’s Onasanya and Davies were successfully recalled.
However, in 2020, Johnson failed to explain the £15,000 holiday he received from Carphone Warehouse tycoon David Ross.
How does CITIZENS’ RIGHTS ARE PROTECTED work in practice in the UK?
What is preventing this from working effectively?
The HRA allows for citizens to use the UK courts to protect their rights under the ECHR (European Convention on Human Rights)
However, the HRA is not entrenched, which means that it could be scrapped with the act of parliament.
How does DEVOLVED DECISION MAKING work in practice in the UK?
What is preventing this from working effectively?
Devolution has resulted in the transfer of power from central government to regional and local bodies, such as the Scottish and Welsh Parliaments.
However, devolution is still limited.
What is franchise/suffrage?
Both terms essentially mean the right to vote. In modern democracies suffrage is extended to all adults, with no groups excluded. A system which does exclude some or all citizens from voting cannot be described as democratic.
What are forms of political participation?
- voting in elections
- joining a political party
- becoming an active member of a party
- joining a trade union
- standing for election to office
- joining a pressure group
- becoming an active member of a pressure group
- taking part in a political campaign
- signing a petition
What are possible reasons why turnout at elections is falling?
- Disillusionment with political parties, especially among younger people, and a failing commitment to parties (partisan dealignment)
- people being more concerned with a single issue rather than broad politics (issue voting)
- a lack of distinction between the parties since the 1990s.
- wasted votes in FPTP
What evidence shows there is a participation crisis in the UK?
Voting in GE - 67.3% turnout in the 2019 GE which is down 1.5% from 2017
Joining a PP - only around 1.7% of the population are members of a PP.
What evidence shows there is NOT a participation crisis in the UK?
Voting in GE - from 2001 and 2017, GE turnout steadily increased.
Joining a PP - Labour party membership rose considerably after 2015 when Corbyn became leader.
What methods are there to improve participation?
Lowering the voting age for general elections
compulsory voting
voting online
Arguments for lowering the voting age
16 and 17yo in Scotland and Wales can already vote in local and regional elections.
Youth turnout in the Scottish independence referendum reached 80%
Arguments against lowering the voting age
many young people do not vote - only 43% of 18-24yo voted in the 2015 GE.
Arguments for compulsory voting
turnout would reach 100%
Other countries have compulsory voting, such as Australia.
Arguments against compulsory voting
voting is a right, not a duty.
people may spoil their ballot paper.
Arguments for voting online
online voting has proven successful in Estonia.
it may boost youth turnout.