Dent Lectures Flashcards
Heredity and Behaviour
- selective breeding emphasizes certain traits, including physical and behavioural attributes.
- genetics play a significant role in the distinct characteristics of different breeds, shaping behaviours such as aggression, trainability, or herding instincts.
Greg Mendel Work
- demonstrated heredity through discrete traits in pea plants (round vs unwrinkled) -> at first, focus on discrete traits, hindered understanding complex behaviours, which are often influenced by multiple genes & environmental factors.
- researchers based ideas on Darwanian concepts.
Behaviour Genetics
- distribution of behaviour can vary by breed.
- within single breed, behaviours tend to cluster more narrowly.
- across breeds, behaviour sows a wider distribution, reflecting genetic diversity.
Francis Galton & Gaussian Distribution
- Galton introduced statistical tools (mean, STDEV, correlation to study heredity).
- Reversion to the mean: observed that offspring traits often regress toward the population mean.
- genetic factors - traits that correlate with parents.
- environment factors: introduce randomness, causing a pull toward the mean.
- did a Galton board experiment to demonstrate this.
Hereditary Genius (1869)
- Galton agreed
- first-degree relatives of a ‘genius’ are more likely to be geniuses due to shared genes.
- eugenics -> aiming to enhance the “human gene pool” through selective breeding.
- included ‘inferior race’/racial biased -> had controverses.
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
- analyze variance in distributions and partitioning it among different factors. (genetic vs environmental factors/contributions)
- in 1918, ronald fisher demonstrated that mendelian inheritance of discrete genes could explain continuous traits if phenotypes were additive. traits such as skin pigmentation result from additive effects of many genes.
Henry H. Goddard & IQ testing
- moron
- imbecile
- idiot
- objective measure of intelligence
- proposed that ‘feeble-mindedness’ was a mendelian trait - classified individuals based on their genotype.
- received criticism and eventually had to retract his idea.
Ellis Island Testing
Administered IQ tests to immigrants, concluding that many had “low intelligence” -> findings influenced restrictive immigration policies.
Army testing during WWI.
conducted intelligence tests on recruits, linking scored to nationality.
results used to justify immigration act of 1924, restricted immigration to northern europeans, halted immigration from asian countries (mirrored in canada).
Harmful policies - highlights dangers of pseudoscience and misuse of statistics.
Alpha army tests
written intelligence test administered to army recruits during WWI.
criticized for being culturally biased, required knowledge of english & specific culture references (agriculture terms)
Disadvantage to immigrants and non-native english speakers.
Army beta test
a nonverbal alternative test created for recruits with limited english proficiency.
used picture based task.
still biased, as it assumed familiarity with western culture objects and contexts.
Eugenics & forced sterilization
- prevent individuals deemed ‘feeble-minded’ or “unfit” from having children.
- women did it without their knowledge or consent.
- happened in Alberta and Germany (inspired by US policies)
JB Watson & Behaviourism
- focused on observable behaviour and behaviour modification.
- little albert experiment, to fear a white rabbit by pairing it with loud noises.
- radical behaviourism: watson claimed that he could mold any child into any professional role regardless of genetic background. this emphasized the whole of environment over heredity.
Competing Politico-Genetic Ideologies in 1930s
1) Soviet Union:
- rejected mendelian genetics in favour of Lysenkoism (which prioritized environment influence over heredity), led to agriculture failures due to unscientific policies.
2) Germany:
- adopted extreme eugenic policies under Nazi regime.
- sterilization and euthanasia of individuals deemed “unfit”
- expanded to include racial and social cleansing.
Eugenics after WWII
- eugenics: set of beliefs and practices that aim to improve the genetic quality of a human population.
- became stigmatized due to its association with nazi astrocities.
- term was avoided.
- the reason fro rejection was driven by political and moral shifts. Cold war and civil rights movements forced western nations to confront their own racist and eugenicist histories.
Explain the long struggle to find behavioural genes. Is correlation between parental & progeny behaviour necessary and sufficient to demonstrate a genetic contribution to behaviour?
- necessary but not sufficient
- a lack of correlation would rule out genetic contribution. But a contribution does not necessarily indicate genetic contribution, non-genetic factors could also explain the correlation.
- Ronald fisher proposed that continuously distributed phenotypes (behaviour) could be explained by action of discrete genes, aligning with ideas of Galton (evolution through selection) and Mendel (inheritance of traits).
First attempts at evidence.
1) Retrospective studies
2) search for mendelian behaviours
Better approaches:
1) model organisms.
2) experimental breeding.
can select for behaviour in mammals, experiment demonstrated that behaviour could bred into an animal population in relative short amount of time, supporting that behaviour has a genetic basis. (ex., fast rats make fast rats)
Candidate Genes
A candidate gene is a gene suspected to be linked to a specific trait, condition, or behavior based on its known biological function or how its mutation affects other traits. Instead of searching for a single gene responsible for a behavior, researchers study single-gene mutants with known effects to identify potential links between the gene and the behavior.
Pleiotropy
Single gene influencing multiple traits.
ex.) eye colour in fruit flies effecting behaviour.
Back-crossing to control genetic behaviour
- in genetics, back-crossing is used to minimize the genetic background variation between two strains while retaining the specific gene of interest.
- for example, when studying the effect of a dominant red-eye gene on behaviour, researchers back-cross the offspring to one parental strain (brown eye strain) repeatedly.
- each time, the red-eye trait (dominant gene) is selected for, but the genetic background of the offspring is made same as brown-eye strain. Ensures that the only remaining genetic difference is the one responsible for red eye colour.
- background eliminated = clearer comparison.
example with fruit flies:
- testing behavioural effects of a specific gene, involves measuring the time spent in a tunnel.
- suggest that red-eye gene does not have effect on time spent in the tunnel behaviour, instead the other genes in the genetic background are likely influencing the observed behaviour.
Geotaxis in Fruit Flies
- geotaxis can be influenced by genetic background.
- refers to the organisms response to gravity, (+) moving towards gravity, down) or (-) moving away, upwards.
Measurements of Heritability
Phenotype = Genotype + Environment
Var (P) = Var (G) + Var (E) + 2Cov (G,E)
Set Cov(G,E) = 0 (ie., a particular genotype is not more likely to be found in a particular environment)
h2 = Var (G)/ Var (P) = heritability (broad sense)
- more things affecting phenotype, more it spreads out, variance is a measure of how spread out the distribution is.
H2 is measure of relative effect of genetics, not absolute contribution to variance.
Can see if heritability is high cause of increased genetic variability, if environment has not changed.
Estimating heritability from putative isogenic lines
- genetically identical individuals
- Var (P) = 0
- Var (G) = 0
Therefore, variance in selected strain is Var (E)
So any variance between them must be Var (E) (by subtracting this, we can determine genetic variance)
Probably multigenic phototaxis, result reflective of additive genes.
Difference between monozygous (Mz) and dizygotic (DZ) twins is known.
- Mz (share all genes)
- Dz (share half genes)
- model based on variance genes: ACE model
A + C + E = 1
A = additive genetics
C = common environment
E = unique environment
E = 1 - Rmz (r = correlation coefficient)
Rmz = A + C
Rdz = 1/2 * A + C
H2 = 2(Rmz - Rdz) is the equation for the correlation of behaviours difference between Mz and Dz twins.
Mz = higher correlation and heritability.
Anything you can measure, can measure heritability.
- correlation is the flip side of variance.
- genetic techniques are now powerful enough to identify many genes of small effect.
- big peak = high correlation and strong linkage of gene & correlation linked to a particular disorder.
- can do the same thing with dog breeds.
Genes do contribute to behaviour. Need to understand how individual genes work - need mendelian. How can we partially get around this?
- can partly get around this by artificially introducing variation, combining mutagenesis and selection: phototaxis
- look for mutants that effect phototaxis.