Did Bonhoeffer present a realistic view of Christian Life?

Question 1

For: It makes sense that Christian life should be centred on the ultimate leadership of God, shown through Jesus Christ

Answer 1

Against: The community at Finkenwalde might be said to have been ideal for those training for ministry but it cannot be said to be realistic for those who have jobs and families

Question 2

For: The Bible provides a realistic focus for this view as revelation from God but also as a book that contains prayers as well as ethics

Answer 2

Against: Different Christians express their faith in different ways and this does not make one way superior to the other

Question 3

For: It makes sense that a well-formed conscience, through prayer and study, will allow a Christian to act appropriately in the world

Answer 3

Against: Christianity is about making a personal commitment to Jesus, not making a commitment to a community

Question 4

For: Bonhoeffer’s approach to community life could be said to be in line with the Biblical ideal of community

Answer 4

Against: It is not realistic that most Christians should be able to understand the Bible to the extent that might be required by Bonhoeffer’s community because not all Christians have done theology degrees