Dispute Resolution Flashcards
What is the overriding objective of the CPR?
Deal with cases justly and at proportionate costs
Two important considerations for litigants in person?
Solicitors must not take unfair advantage of them.
Court may be more lenient regarding case management decisions.
Who operates legal aid for civil matters? 2 excluded categories of legal work?
Legal Aid Agency.
Nearly all personal injury work and most civil/commercial litigation cannot be funded by the LAA
What is ATE insurance? What is an important warning you must give the client?
After the Event insurance provides cover for any adverse costs which the client may have to pay if unsuccessful.
Warn client that the premium is NOT recoverable from an unsuccessful opposing party and must be paid (with certain limited exceptions, eg defamation, privacy, some clinical negligence)
Distinguish between discounted CFA and success fees?
Discounted CFA usually requires client to pay costs and disbursements as matter progresses, but at a DISCOUNTED hourly rate with the BALANCE DUE payable only on success.
Success fee CFA usually only requires payment on conclusion of the matter (and it may be no win no fee depending on the CFA).
Requirements for enforceable CFA?
- In writing
- Must not relate to exempted proceedings (e.g. criminal and family)
Five warnings to give client when entering into CFA?
- Success fee generally NOT RECOVERABLE from opposing party
- MAXIMUM SUCCESS FEE that can be charged under the CFA
- When client MAY BE LIABLE FOR COSTS (both their own and opponent)
- Client’s ENTITLEMENT TO AN ASSESSMENT of costs
- Whether the legal representative has any INTEREST IN A CORRESPONDING FUNDING POLICY
What is a DBA? What are the 3 caps, and what is excluded?
Damages Based Agreement - fees based on a % of damages recovered by a successful client.
Capped at:
1. 25% for personal injury (excluding damages for future care/loss)
2. 35% for employment
3. 50% for other civil cases
Disbursements are excluded.
Two important clarifications on scope of permissible DBA?
- Cannot be used for appeals
- Can only be used for clients pursuing a financial remedy (by claim or counterclaim)
Three usual provisions in a DBA?
- No legal fees payable until conclusion of matter
- If unsuccessful, no need to pay costs and disbursements subject to the DBA
- If successful, must pay lawyer an agreed percentage of the recovered sum LESS any sum recovered for costs and disbursements.
*The sum payable to the legal representative under the DBA will also cap client’s claim for costs and disbursements
Two important clarifications for litigation funding?
- Usually does not extend to an adverse costs order if client is unsuccessful
- Funding agreement must comply with DBA regulations (in writing, etc)
When can formal proceedings be stayed in relation to ADR?
Where: (1) the parties wish to attempt ADR or (2) the court considers it appropriate
2 situations where court may stay proceedings for ADR purposes?
- Where one party wishes to attempt ADR and the opposing party cannot show good reasons why ADR is unlikely to work
- Where the court feels ADR is appropriate PROVIDED (i) does not impair essence of C’s right to proceed to a judicial hearing and (ii) is proportionate to the legitimate aim of a fair, quick and cost-efficient settlement of the dispute
Warning to give client who doesn’t want to do ADR?
May be penalised in costs if the matter proceeds to trial, even if successful. In awarding costs, court must consider efforts made before and during the proceedings to try and resolve the dispute
Precaution for solicitor to take in relation to ADR?
Keep detailed paper trial about the occasions on which ADR was discussed with the client and the opponent.
What is the most common ADR for commercial disputes
Executive Tribunal (comprised of panel of senior party reps not involved in the dispute plus an independent advisor)
If agreement cannot be reached, independent advisor issues NON-BINDING OPINION
3 important features of adjudication?
- REFERRAL NOTICE will set out adjudicator’s directions on timeline for written subs
- Strict time limits = decisions are usually reached within 28 DAYS of service of Referral Notice
- Issues determined can be RELITIGATED at any time through court or arbitration
2 important clarifications about the role of the mediator?
- He does not act as a judge and will not rule on the merits
- He will not impose or propose settlement terms
What are three phases normally observed during a “mediation hearing”?
- Begins with a PLENARY SESSION where mediator explains the rules and process and invites opening statements
- May involve CAUCUS where mediator explores each party’s position confidentially
- May involve SHUTTLE DIPLOMACY - mediator moves between rooms in series of private sessions to identify common ground, concessions and offers
What are the two preliminary questions when determining jurisdiction?
- D’s domicile - EU rules set out basic principle that D should usually be sued in his country of domicile
- Date the proceedings were instigated - if claim was instigated by 11 PM on 31 Dec 2020, European Rules apply; if instigated from 1 Jan 2021, common law rules apply.
What is the basuc test for whether the English courts have jurisdiction over a claim?
- If D can be served within the jurisdiction OR
- Outside the jurisdiction with permission (i.e. meets the connecting factor and forum non conveniens tests)
What are the monetary thresholds for a High Court claim? 2 exceptions?
- Exceeds 100,000 for normal claims
- Exceeds 50,000 for personal injury
Exception:
(i) where STATUTE requires it
(ii) Relates to certain other exceptions like professional negligence, fraud, undue influence, defamation, police claims, contentious probate claims
When is a litigation friend required to conduct proceedings on C’s behalf (2 examples)?
Usually (1) child under 18 or (2) person lacking mental capacity to conduct the proceedings
How do partnerships commence legal proceedings?
Partnerships lack legal personality, so partners usually sue (and are sued) in their individual names OR in the name of the firm (the words “(a firm)” must be added to the title)