Earth Systems Flashcards
(175 cards)
On a reality TV program a family with children are monitored. As the children get noisy, the parents get more mad, and as the parents get mad, the children get more noisy.
a) Draw a systems diagram for the relationship.
b) Is there a positive or negative feedback loop?
c) Is the family unstable?
b) + x + = + , t.f. it is a positive feedback loop
c) Positive feedback loops are unstable

Using the planetary energy balance equation
σT4 = S/4 x (1-A)
Calculate the effective temperature of the Earth with an albedo of 0.8.
σ = 5.667 x 10<sup>-8</sup> W m<sup>-2</sup> K<sup>-4</sup> S = 1370 W m<sup>-2</sup>
T4 = [S/4 x (1-A)] / σ
T4 = 343 W m-2 x (1-0.8) / 5.667 x 10-8 W m-2 K-4
T4 = 1.22 x 109 K4 = 186 K
This would be the T of a snow covered world without an atmosphere.
Disturbing Daisyworld Again scenarios
From P1 remove lots of daisies
Surface T increases beyond limits of dasiy growth. They become extinct

Disturbing Daisyworld Again scenarios
From P2 plant lots of daisies
Surface T decreases and daisy cover increases, then decreases, until back at P1

Disturbing Daisyworld Again scenarios
From P2 remove a few daisies
T rises and daisies suffer immediate extinction

During the deglaciation from Snowball Earth, the ice coverage and resultant lack of sites for CO2 drawdown via photosynthesis and silicate weathering enabled volcanic CO2 to build up in the atmosphere and initiate warming.
a) Using four boxes (labelled with the following terms: CO2 drawdown; surface temperature; ice coverage; area for life and weathering) and four couplings, draw a systems diagram for the process.
b) Explaining your reasoning, state whether the system represents a positive or negative feedback loop.
Odd number of negative couplings = negative feedback loop
Remove CO2, increase ice and cover sites where CO2 removal ocuurs

Daisyworld has a companion planet on which all the daisies are black.
State whether an increase in black daisy coverage will increase or decrease surface temperature.
Support your answer with a systems diagram with three boxes (daisy coverage; daisyworld albedo; surface temperature) and three couplings.
- Increase black daisy coverage
- Decrease albedo
- Increase surface T
- Each are negative feedbacks

Consider a scenario where a planet is heated by a star but has no greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. The planet is home to two types of organism: black daisies and white rabbits. Using the concept of coupling in each of your responses, answer the following questions:
i) Draw a graph reflecting the relationship between black daisy coverage and planet surface temperature and explain your reasoning.
ii) Superimpose a graph reflecting the relationship between surface temperature and black daisy coverage and explain your reasoning.
iii) Mark on the graph the two equilibrium states and indicate whether they are stable (negative feedback loop) or unstable (positive feedback loop).
Black dasiyworld scenario
iii) Equilibrium states - 2 relationships coexist:
P1 + x + = + (unstable)
P2 + x - = - (stable)

Consider a scenario where a planet is heated by a star but has no greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. The planet is home to two types of organism: black daisies and white rabbits. Using the concept of coupling in each of your responses, answer the following:
Consider a scenario where the planet is in the lowest temperature equlibrium state before an extinction of white rabbits leads to an increase in black daisy coverage. Using either a graph or text describe how the system will react to the disturbance.
- Surface T and daisy coverage increases in positive feedback loops prior to Optimum T for daisy growth
- Increase in T beyond optimum T causes dasiy coverage to decrease, forming negative feedback loop
- Until at P2

Is the stable state on black daisyworld a higher or lower temperature than on white daisyworld?
Stable state for black daisyworld at higher temperature
i) Draw a graph reflecting the relationship between black daisy coverage and planet surface temperature and explain your reasoning.
ii) Superimpose a graph reflecting the relationship between surface temperature and black daisy coverage and explain your reasoning.
i) As black dasiy coverage increases, albedo decreases and surface T increases as more radiation can be absorbed
ii) Plants have an optimum growth temperature, resulting in an overall parabolic relationship between surface T and daisies.
This results in positive coupling below optimum (increase in T = increase in daisies), and negative coupling above optimum (increase in T = decrease in daisies).
Intersections represent two equilibrium states, where 2 relationships coexist

Explain how introducing more white daisies to Dasiyworld affects surface temperature.
This question is about the carbon isotopic record of atmospheric carbon dioxide levels in the Phanerozoic.
In the table, why are the values for d13C marine carbonate rock and d13C paleosol carbonate different for deposits of the same age?
- Carbon dioxide in marine water is primarily from one source, i.e. dissolved gas from the atmosphere.
- Calcium carbonate can ppt or be assimilated by organisms from marine water.
- d13C of carbonate rock faithfully maintains a constant relationship with d13C of the atmosphere.
- By contrast, carbon dioxide in soil water and air is a mixture of two sources.
- Some CO2 in soil water and pore spaces has diffused directly from the atmosphere while some is from the respiration of plants and bacteria.
- Isotopically, the two sources are distinct, atmospheric co2 is enriched in the heavier carbon isotope 13C whereas respired co2 is enriched in the lighter carbon isotop 12C
This question is about the carbon isotopic record of atmospheric carbon dioxide levels in the Phanerozoic.
Explain how can d13C values of paleosol carbonate reveal past changes in atmospheric CO2 levels.
- When atmospheric co2 levels are high, more diffuses into the soil and, conversely, when atmospheric co2 levels are low, less diffuses into the soil.
- The stable isotopic effects of the two situations are that low atmospheric co2 levels give more negative d13C values for soil carbonate and high atmospheric co2 levels give more positive d13C values for soil carbonate.
Describe the relationship between d13C marine carbonate rock (d13Ccarb) and the global fraction of buried organic carbon (forg).
Explain how this relationship is maintained.

- Heavier d13C values for carbonate rocks indicate periods of time when more organic carbon is buried.
- d13C of organic matter is enriched in the lighter carbon isotope and therefore its burial removes amounts of 12C from circulation.
- A residual enrichment in 13C is left behind leaving heavier d13C values in the atmosphere and surface ocean.
Which is the most reliable data source, d13C marine carbonate rock or d13C paleosol carbonate, for reconstructing past atmospheric carbon dioxide levels?

d13C carbonate is a more reliable data source for reconstructing past atmospheric carbon dioxide levels bc it involves fewer variables and assumptions.
What are the variables involved in the use of d13C palaeosol carbonate for reconstructing past atmospheric carbon dioxide levels?
- isotopic change induced by variations in
- soil T,
- moisture,
- porosity and
- plant respiration rates.
What are the assumptions involved in the use of d13C palaeosol carbonate for reconstructing past atmospheric carbon dioxide levels?

- That increased atmospheric co2 levels result in greater amounts diffusing into soil, and
- That amounts of respired co2 present in paleosols can be reliably estimated.
- That d13C plant co2 hasn’t changed over time. In this context it is interesting to note that d13C palaeosol carbonate can’t be used after 14 Ma bc of the evolution of an additional photosynthetic pathway illustrating that d13C plant co2 does change.
- Atmospheric co2 hasn’t changed in d13C over time. This assumption is clearly suspicious as the d13C marine carbonate rock values in the table indicate that d13C atmospheric co2 has changed significantly during Earth’s history.
Using the figure, explain the stable isotopic composition of hamburgers.
Reflects meat fed on a food source other than corn
Using the figure, explain the stable isotopic composition of chicken.
Reflects meat fed on a corn food source
Using the figure, explain the stable isotopic composition of chicken nuggets.
Reflects a mixture of corn-fed meat and other materials such as breadcrumbs
Add to the figure to indicate:
i) A human population existing exclusively on hamburgers
ii) Nursing infants from the same population

How could the data in the figure be used to determine the habitat of a human population?
Based on food sources. E.g. corn grows in hot climates, fish diets reflect proximity to coastline.
Other diets reflect temperate inland locations.
BS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: stable isotopes and space
Use plot to assign source regions for:
Sample A: dD -50; d13C -25
Sample B: dD 127400; d13C 435
Sample C: dD 1439; d13C -16.7


