exam 1 Flashcards
(98 cards)
chapter one; slides
why study religion from a sociological perspective?
1) importance to many
a) spectrum of significcane of beliefs/ practices in their lives
b) religious values influence behaviours(if you adhere to your faith, then it influences your behaviour /can shape value system )
c)religious meanings influence interpretation of experiences
2) society <-> religion influence
a) foundational to classical sociology
society has a great deal of influence on religion
what are the limittations of functional approach?
1) breadth: potentially includes those things that we do not
2) assumes religion is necessary
e.g. - for mortality, for being ‘good’
3) typically assumes religion is always beneficial
- we know that religion can be beneficial cos it can contribute to person’s identity / bring meaning in person’s lives
- but in an institutional level, religion is always not beneficial because it
can impose its own moral order on others
ex: european witch hunts
what is religion?
substantive definition
A substantive definition defines what religion is. It attempts to establish categories of religious content that qualify as religion and other categories speci fied as nonreligion.
what is religion?
functional definition
A functional definition of religion emphasizes what religion does for the indi vidual and social group. Accordingly, religion is defined by the social functions it fulfills. The content of religious belief and practice is less important for this definitional strategy than the consequences of religion.
what is religion?
functional definition
comprehensive worldview based on sets of assumptions and arguments
belief and behaviour system whose adherents collectively refuse to question its fundamental assumptions
in groups, if people have doubts, they tend not to express them
why? they may feel like an outsider
limitations: may overlook positive aspects of religion like the community / friendship / guidance
classical sociologists; emile durkheim (1858 - 1917)
what are his goals?
- not divinely/ supernaturally inspired (he believed that God was subjectively real )
- a product of society (people create a belief in order to explain the world around them)
- having origins in communal emotion
- to identify common things that religions place emphasis upon (trying to generalize some statements about religion)
- to examine the effects of religious beliefs on society
Emile Durkheim wanted to define religion as?
He wrote:
“A religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, that is to say, things set apart and forbidden—beliefs and practices which unite into one single moral community called a Church, all those who adhere to them” (Durkheim
, 1912)
what are Durkheim’s sacred and profane realms?
sacred: objects and behaviours set apart as superior, powerful, deserving of respect that are collectively important (e.g. rituals, objects of reverence)
– religious rather than secular.
profane: ordinary, uneventful, practical aspects of life that tend to be of individual importance
(e.g. people, places, behaviours and those disrespectful utterances (profanities)
outside of the sacred)
– relating or devoted to that which is not sacred or biblical; secular rather than religious.
he said that both the good and bad can be found in both realms
Durkheim also proposed that every religious groups has three features. What are they?
1) a system of beliefs that expresses the sacred and defines the sacred and profane.
2) a moral community that develops along with these beliefs and enforces the norms & rules of the group/society.
3) a set of collective behaviours & rituals.
For Durkheim:
religion is?
religion is
- socially created (it is human constructive)
- collective at its core
- there’s cognitive + behavioural components
- functional
- social control — can contribute to social cohesion and smooth running of society
- works at homogenous setting
what is ritual?
ritual is a symbolic action that represent religious meanings
- a behavioural component
- those things we set apart, ritualize and form emotional connections to
ex: communion (bread & wine sacralized through Catholic ritual)
- Within the community, the bread and wine is a highly symbolic feature -> God’s body and wine
- can connect people historically / overtime
Durkheim focused on the relationship between __ behaviour and the adherence to _____
Durkheim focused on the relationship between ritual behaviour and the adherence of social order.
collective veneration of the sacred fosters social solidarity and social control
→call to obey communally defined morality (a bringing of order in the community)
what can ritual do? what did Durkheim call this feeling?
Rituals provide a focal point for emotional processes and generate symbols of a group membership.
- rituals help people to experience a shared sense of exaltation and group transcendence
- Durkheim explains that this feeling, which is only experienced through ritual veneration, is collective effervescence.
what is collective effervescence that Durkheim described?
this is the sense of energy, and harmony people feel when they come together in a group around a shared purpose (performing a religious ritual)
according to Durkheim, eople systematically misunderstand the emotional energy they experienve in the ritual process as having a supernatural origin
ex: playing music / he says that this is a misattribution / that it is a human construction
according to Durkehim, this misunderstanding confirms their religious beliefs
- it contributes to a sense of awe, reverence, etc
- ritual connects believers over time and space; it is highly symbolic
- Durkheim proposes that greeted understanding of the natural and social world reveals social origins of religion
examples of rituals
- meditation (e.g. Buddhism)
- religious ecstasy (e.g. Shaminism)
- bar and bat mitzvah (Judaism)
- prayer (many religions e.g. Sikhism, Islam, Judaism, Christianity)
- baptism (e.g. Christianity)
- confession (e.g. Catholicism, Mormonism)
- communion (Catholicism)
- self-flagellation (e.g. some Shia Muslims, some Catholics [historically and today]) casting a circle (Wicca)
- evangelism (JWs, Mormons, evangelical Christians)
- auditing (Scientology)
- fasting & forms of denial (many religions)
- pow-wow (many indigenous communities)
- food offerings (e.g. many Hindu traditions)
- reading of central texts (the Vedas, bible, Q’uran, Talmud etc. Many religions require–or at least advise–some kind of reading of central texts)
what does Durkheim’s theory of ritual implies?
1) any object could become socially defined as sacred
- parody religions like pastafarianism
2) repeated veneration of sacred objects creates stable social relations
chapter two: the provision of meaning and belonging
religion can be understood as:
→a basis of association
→an expression of shared meanings
→the creation of community (things that are more important to us are more meaningful if we can share it because we get that creation of community)
processes of meaning/ belonging
1) acceptance of worldviews
what is a worldview?
worldview is a comprehensive meaning systems used by believers to interpret life experiences/events (Berger)
all religions have a worldview / there are political or educational and philosophical worldviews as well as religious worldviews
available meaning systems
according to Berger, meaning is not ___??
- religious
- other multiple, competing ones
- meaning is bestowed (Berger) (It’s not inherent)
meaning systems are __ and ___
meaning systems are
1) explanatory: the why’s of the world / they explain things like life experiences and the origins of the world and the end of the world
2) normative: how things should be and how they should remain
they maintain a normative rules and certain ways in a society
why do religions have meaning systems?
- religious meanings offer a legitimation of the social order or a challenge to it (ex: power, authority, hierarchy, gender roles, etc)
- suggestion of human design / masked de-emphasized
- references to tradition become absolute truths
ex: Christian marriage
what are the components of meaning systems?
what is cosmologies and theodicies?
1) cosmologies: teachings that explain the origins of the world as well as its ultimate fate
-> eschatology (final events)
2) theodicies: theodicies
explanations that provide meaning for meaning-threatening experiences
(ex: suffering, death, and pain for sin etc. the existence of evil)
- this is to answer the question of why suffering // death exists and to answer the question of why evil exists in the world
- ONE explanation is that it is part of God’s plan
as part of God’s plan, we shouldn’t question it - God has assigned humans to tests of free will (what people will do in that free will)