Exam 3 Flashcards
(40 cards)
Theories
Sets of propositions that help people to
understand events
- Help describe and explain events
- Can be used for predicting future actions
Diversity within Realism, but all realists subscribe to the 3 S’s
- Statism
- Survival
- Self-help
Essentials of Realism
Statism
• The state has sovereignty, which is the supreme
authority to make and enforce laws
• Realism assumes problems of domestic order and
security are solved, does not have a domestic level
analysis
• States compete for power and security in an anarchic
world
• World is a zero-sum game: One state gains, another
loses
Classical Realism
Politics is governed by
objective laws that have
their roots in human
nature. Human nature is
inherently flawed,
therefore conflict occurs
as a natural outcome of
conflicting nations’
search for power.
Liberalism
• Liberalism is both a theory of government within
states and good governance between them
- Tolerance, Freedom, Constitutionalism key Liberal Values
- Seeks to promote cooperation and understanding
- Economic Interdependence Causes Governments To Redefine their Interests in a Way that Makes War Less
Likely.
- Too Busy Making Money to Fight
- War Too Costly in Economic Disruption
- The Greater Economic Interdependence is, the Less
Likely is War.
• In contrast to realism then liberalism think that international
organizations can have some independence from states.
• Liberals believe that international organizations can shape the
preferences of states, influence how they view their interests
• Liberals believe in the idea of relative gains, that through cooperation
everyone can benefit. Versus realists who only believe in absolute or
zero sum gains.
Democratic Peace Thesis
• Democracies don’t fight each other. Therefore if there are more
democracies in the world peace becomes more likely.
• Based on Kant’s idea of perpetual peace
Kant’s Perpetual Peace
- “The civil constitution of every state should be republican”
- “The law of nations shall be founded on a federation of free states”
- “The law of world citizenship shall be limited to conditions of universal hospitality”
Problem solving vs critical theory
• Robert Cox “Theory is always for someone and some
purpose”
- Problem-solving theory
- Accepts the parameters of the present order while
attempting to fix its problems, and thus helps
legitimate an unjust and deeply iniquitous system
- Critical theory
- Attempts to challenge the prevailing order by seeking
out, analyzing, and where possible, assisting social
processes that can potentially lead to transformation
of the existing system
Essentials of Marxism
- History has been marked by the rise and demise of a series of world systems
- Modern world system emerged in Europe around the turn of the sixteenth
century
- Expanded to encompass the entire globe
- Driving force was capitalism
- Division between core and periphery
CONSTRUCTIVISM
- Constructivists believe that reality is socially constructed
- They also believe that the knowledge that we have about the reality is
socially constructed
• No single universal truth, role of identity central to international
politics
• Identity is a framework in which interests and politics of the states
evolve
The Essential Liberalism
- Neoliberalism
- Reaction to structural realism
- Conceded that core assumptions of structural
realism were correct
• Anarchic international structure, centrality of
states
• Interested in how to promote cooperation under
conditions of anarchy
• Neoliberals argue that actors would enter into
cooperative agreements if the gains were evenly
shared
• Cooperation is never without problems, but states
will shift loyalty and resources to institutions if
these are seen as mutually beneficial.
Post-positivism
Post-positivists accept that theories, background, knowledge and
values of the researcher can influence what is observed
No separation between the subject and the object of study
Theories about social reality may have an impact and might change
social reality itself
Theories invariably reflect in important ways the social context in
which they were produced; so in a sense the social world shapes the
theories made of it.
Also referred to a reflectivist approaches
Neorealism & Neoliberalism
• Neorealists dominate security studies and neoliberals focus on
political economy, human rights & environment.
Norms, Institutions, Organizations
• Norms: Collectively shared
understandings of appropriate
behavior.
• Institutions: Sets of rules which
stipulate how to
cooperate/compete.
• Organizations: Institutions
endowed with autonomy and
actor qualities.
Post-Structuralism
- Post-Structuralism is a constitutive theory.
- Constitutive theories differ explanatory theories in that they
define theoretical concepts, explain how they are linked, and
instruct us how to use them in analysis of world politics
- Theories about how we should theorize
- Central concepts are: Discourse, deconstruction, genealogy,
intertextuality
Poststructuralism elements: Discourse
Poststructuralism understands language not as a
neutral transmitter, but as producing meaning
• Things do not have an objective meaning
independently of how we constitute them in language
• The prevalent discourse thus forms and informs our
take on things and events
Poststructuralism elements: Deconstruction
• The codes of words are never truly fixed, because the
connections between words (that create meaning)
is never given once and for all
• Hierarchical dichotomies (such as “civilized” –
“barbaric”) can make a description seem objective
and factual, when it is in fact a structured set of
values
Jacques Derrida
French philosopher, whose work
originated the school of deconstruction
Deconstruction shows the multiple
layers of meaning at work in language
all cultures construct autonomous
self-contained worlds of meaning
Thus ethnographic description
distorts native understandings by
forcing them into our own society’s
ways of conceptualizing the world
Much of his writing he is concerned
with the deconstruction of texts
Derrida argues that the author’s
intentions in speaking cannot be
unconditionally accepted.
Poststructuralism elements: Genealogy
• What political practices have formed the present,
and which alternative understandings and discourses
have been marginalized and often forgotten?
• What constructions are dominant, and
how do these constructions relate to past discourses
• Power comes about when discourses constitute
particular subject position as the ‘natural’ ones
Poststructuralism elements: Intertextuality
• We can understand the social world as comprising
texts
• Texts for an ‘intertext’ – they are in some ways linked
to texts that came before them
• Intertextuality may also involve images, or interpreting
events that are not exclusive written or spoken
• Popular culture is thus a reasonable object of study –
because it links to other ‘texts’
Wallerstein’s World-System Theory
- History has been marked by the rise and demise of a series of world systems
- Modern world system emerged in Europe around the turn of the sixteenth
century
- Expanded to encompass the entire globe
- Driving force was capitalism
- Division between core and periphery
Michel Foucault
French philosopher who argued that social
relations between people are characterized
by dominance and subjugation
Dominating people or classes control the
ideological conditions under which
knowledge, truth, and reality are defined
Because modernity is viewed alongside
other configurations of knowledge, as the
product of power, the objective character of
scientific knowledge is shown to be an
historical construct
his work upsets the conventional
understanding of history as a chronology of
inevitable facts and replaces it with layers of
suppressed and unconscious knowledge in
and throughout history
Identity and foreign policy
- Identities’ needs to be constantly reproduced
- Identities are simultaneously a product of and the
justification for foreign policies
Feminism and Gender
Gender for most feminists is socially constructed.
Gender reflects the imposition of a particular view of the right
social order.