Examples Flashcards
(60 cards)
(OLIGOPOLY) What happened initially with the Microsoft activation merger
Microsoft wanted to merge with activision to develop cloud gaming technology. The CMA said Microsoft would have too much power in a growing industry
Microsoft head said UK was a bad place to do business
(OLIGOPOLY) Why was the head of the CMA made redundant
What is the macro & micro evaluation of this
The government said they are too much of a barrier to growth
Macro evaluation: supports the governments heavy focus on growth by favouring business mergers that would lead to growth over other objectives (e.g. consumer interest)
Micro evaluation: The fact that the head of the CMA was made redundant as he prevented too many mergers (specifically Microsoft and activation), ie, looking out for consumer interests, this suggests that the CMA was in fact strict enough on businesses and possibly too strict, and the fact that the government has advocated for less strict regulation could be a form of government failure as they are favouring business growth over the consumer interest.
(WAGES) Give an example of an action taken by Goldman Sachs’s showing that gender inequality may be reducing
Goldman Sachs’s have stated its diversity policy has ‘served its purpose’ and they have removed their diversity policy following the USA removing all DEI departments
However it can be argued that the only reason we have got to a point where the pay gap is closing, is due to these policies, and if we return to a free market structure the pay gap may widen further
Give an example of firms returning to profit maximisation over other objectives such as the environment
Financial Times:
BP recently slashed renewables spending in pivot back to oil and gas
Give an example of how the structure of the free market means regulation may not be needed in an oligopoly market
Aldi & Lidl
Structure of the supermarket industry changed when Aldi & Lidl entered the market. No longer the same Big 4
Other supermarkets have done ‘aldi price match’
Lower prices for consumers
Another example is the ride-sharing market—the entry of firms like Uber and Bolt challenged traditional taxi monopolies, increasing competition, lowering prices, and improving service quality, reducing the need for heavy government regulation.
Also this week Santander rejected £11bn bid from NatWest for UK unit, indicating that firms aren’t just looking for lower AC and higher profits
Give an example of the banking industry being more competitive due to the free market (without regulation)
Switch guarantee scheme - yet imperial evidence suggest little effect due to strong brand loyalty in the banking sector
Introduction of online banks due to less barriers to entry & improvements in technology means that sector is more competitive
What is an intermediate solution between full on regulation and free market solutions to manage oligopoly behaviour
Increasing market contestability
Altering market conditions to make it more competitive
Creating the threat of entry through removing barriers to entry which will regulate behaviour of existing firms in the market
Give 2 examples of increased market contest ability (intermediate between free market & regulation)
E.g. Airline industry:
- Rise of low cost airlines such as Ryanair & easyJet
- EV open skies agreement gave new airlines access to take of and landing spots
E.g. Rise of Uber & Bolt
- Removed the need for some licenses for cab drivers
How does elasticity change as you go down on a straight demand curve
Where does a monopoly produce on the curve
The top is more elastic, the bottom is more inelastic
The monopoly produces on the elastic part of the demand curve
Give an example of a merger in the mobile market
Vodafone & three (To be finalised in coming months)
O2 and virgin (2021)
Why has the gov allowed Vodafone and three to merge despite their huge market share
The condition of the merger is they will spend billions upgrading the uk 5G network
How has the Vodafone three merger display regulatory failure
The government may be thinking of the benefit to macro objectives (supply side policies) (5G) rather than the consumer interest
What are two concerns with Vodafone and three merging
Increase in concentration ratio since there have been 2 large mergers in the last 5 years (Vodafone and 3 this year and O2 and virgin in 2021)
The trade union unite said the deal could add an extra £300 a year to customers bills and lead up to 1600 jobs being lost
Give an example of firms showing
Sales maximisation
Increased market share/market dominance
Social/environmental concerns
Sales maximisation: Netflix kept prices low early on to attract millions of users, then raised prices after securing a large customer base
Increased market share/market dominance:
Aldi grew rapidly by offering low prices and a limited product range, gaining market share from bigger supermarkets.
Social/environmental concerns: Patagonia promotes sustainability by using recycled materials and encouraging product repairs to reduce waste. Its “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign exemplified its commitment to reducing overconsumption while building a loyal, values-driven customer base, indicating that, at face value, profit is certainly not their main objective. (Can also argue this is just a marketing strategy)
Give two examples of product versioning
Premium petrol
Priority boarding
Give 2 examples of price discrimination
-A petrol station offers cheaper petrol on specific days (those with elastic demand would capitalise on this)
- Insurance premiums
Give 3 examples of how changes in technology may bring industries closer to the market structure of perfect competition
1 - E-commerce platforms such as amazon and shopify: Lowered barriers to entry for small businesses and independent sellers. Entrepreneurs can also now sell directly to consumers without having to pay for large warehouses to hold stock (drop shipping)
However this also strengthens Amazon and shopify in terms of their oligopoly power as e commerce gets more popular. This means whilst the e commerce sector is becoming closer to perfect competition, the industries facilitating this are becoming more oligopolistic.
2- Price comparison websites: For example booking.com and compare the market.com. This leads to price transparency and encourages competition. Therefore prices within the market will be similar in order for firms to remain competitive. However prices transparency may lead a greater ease in implicit collusion due to a more efficient way in indirectly communicating price.
However, it may be said that only the largest firms appear on price comparison websites, and the firms willing to give up a larger commission on these sites, which tends to be larger firms making more profit , meaning in realistic price comparison websites strengthen an oligopolistic market.
3- The rise of online streaming services: Such as Netflix and Spotify. Makes movie and film industry more competitive. Record labels previously control access to production, promotion and distribution services. No services such as ditto allows independent artists to join the market at little cost, increasing competition. (However more artists may mean the product is becoming less homogeneous due to different genres)
Cinemas also previously control access to films, now licensing agreements between online services such as Netflix and film producers mean greater competition.
Give a real example of de - regulation
Laws which introduced competition into the postal services industry
Give two examples of tough laws on anticompetitive behaviour
-Companies breaching UK competition rules risk fines of up to 10% of global turnover
- Senior executives can be jailed if negative outcomes occur due to their actions
Give 3 real examples of laws which display market liberation
Deregulation of the Bus Industry (1985) – The Transport Act allowed private companies to compete with public transport services outside of London.
Gas Market Liberalization (1996-1998) – The UK opened up the domestic gas market to competition, ending British Gas’s monopoly
The Big Bang occurred on October 27, 1986, when the London Stock Exchange (LSE) was deregulated and became a private limited company leading to increased competition and foreign investment. (fixed commissions removed so firms could compete on price )
Give 2 examples of increased market contest ability (intermediate between free market & regulation)
E.g. Airline industry:
- Rise of low cost airlines such as Ryanair & easyJet
- EV open skies agreement gave new airlines access to take of and landing spots
E.g. Rise of Uber & Bolt
- Removed the need for some licenses for cab drivers
Give 4 examples of natural monopolies
Water
Gas
Electric (national grid)
Railways
Give 2 examples of regulatory (watchdog) bodies
OFWAT
OFCOM
Give an example of a failure of a natural monopoly
Thames water
Lack of timely investment in renewing their pipelines leading to waste being released into the ocean causing environmental concerns
in August 2024, Ofwat imposed a £168 million penalty on Thames Water, Yorkshire Water, and Northumbrian Water for routinely releasing sewage into rivers and seas