Final Flashcards
How do you select between alternatives when a present or analysis is used?
You use the MARRRI and solve for present worth a single project is economically justified if present worth is greater than than zero and you select the alternative with the largest present worth
How do you evaluate projects or compare alternatives when capitalized cost is used
This is present worth with the service period of infinity. You use the MARR or I and your Cost needs to be greater than zero for single project to be economically justified select the alternative with the largest capital.
How do you select an alternative when using future worth?
Do you use an MARR or interest rate and you calculate the future worth a single project is economically justified a future worth is greater than zero and you select the alternative with the largest future worth.
How do you evaluate projects when using annual worth?
You use the MARR or interest rate and you look for a project with an annual worth greater than zero for it to be economically justified then you select the alternative with the largest annual worth.
Return on invest
ROI represents an alternative approach to comparing alternatives and in theory it can be used instead of the approaches covered earlier in the course
External rate of return
If you have to discard both values when using an ROR
How did the conclusion recommendations change based on approach?
All approaches will lead to the same conclusion or recommendation provided that the least common multiple method rather than the study period method is used
What are the issues with ROI?
In some cases, ROI will give more than one potential numerical result which may differ from other methods. That’s an engineering economic analysis. The preferred methods are not ROI. All is ideally used to supplement where decision makers are specifically interested in understanding ROI, but it is not recommended as the primary basis for making decisions on a project or comparing alternatives.
Rate of return
ROR is the rate paid on the unpaid balance of borrowed money for example a loan at $1000 and an interest rate of 10% is to be repaid and equal installments over four years. Each of the four years the interest rate is applied to the unpaid balance of borrowed money.
Internal rate of return
IROR. The interest rate i* that makes present worth annual worth future worth of a cash flow series 0
How does RoR different from present worth capitalized cost future worth and annual worth?
The four methods use cash flows and MARR. Whereas ROR uses one input, which is cash flows and does not consider an interest rate. Single projects are economically justified if I is greater than MARR.
Using ror
ROR assumes any net positive cash flows are reinvested at the interest rate. For projects where I is substantially different to MARR reinvestment at I may be unrealistic. The calculation of eye is more labor-intensive than the calculations for other methods. Non-conventional cash flow can kneeled multiple eye values and then some cases ROR analysis does not lead to a usable eye and it is necessary to resort to EROR.
Recommendation aboutRoR
It is not recommended as the primary method for analysis. It should only be used supplementary.
Incremental cash flow
We need to consider the difference in cash for every year in our evaluation.
Incremental cash flow
= cash flow larger than initial investment-cash flow smaller than initial investment
Logic for incremental ROR analysis
Find i* for both alternatives. Is that greater than the MARR? if no reject alternatives. If yes, find the incremental change or Delta eye to determine whether that additional expense can be justified.
What is the incremental cash full capture?
How the alternative with the higher initial investment differs from the alternative with the lower initial investment
Incremental ROR for more than two alternatives
- Order alternatives from smallest to largest initial investment.
- Calculate i* of the CF and eliminate all values lower than the MARR. Remaining alternative with lowest cost is the defender.
- Determine CF between defender and challenger, which is the next lowest alternative. Set up incremental RR relations using present worth annual worth or future worth.
- Calculate. Delta i* on incremental CF using factors or IRR function.
- If. Delta i* is greater than MARR eliminate defender challenger becomes new defender against next alternative if high is less than MIRR remove challenger defender remains alternative remains
Public sector project
Is a product service or system used financed and owned by the citizens of a government level. The project is designed and constructed to serve citizens for the public good at no profit.
Public sector project terminologies
C-cost estimated expenses to government unit
B-benefits, estimated advantages to be experienced by the public
D-benefits, undesirable consequences to public
i-discount rate term used instead of interest rate
The point or perspective on public projects
Must be determined before cost for benefit or dis benefit estimates are made their typically several potential viewpoints and the perspective taken may result in cash flows being classified differently
Types of contracts for public sector projects
Contractor does not share in the project risk or contractor shares in project risk
Contractor does not share and project risk
Fixed price contract lump sum payment cost reimbursable contract