Final Flashcards

(384 cards)

1
Q

Homans “exchange relationship” and possible evolution

A

two people will be in a relationship when each gets something out of the relationship; sometimes these relatonhips become institutionalized, incorporated into a bureaucracy, social relations; sometimes this will lead to them being more friendship instead of just transactional

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What type of way of thinking is “exchange relationship”

A
  • Way to think about society/social structure as series of ties between individuals, groups, nation states
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Georg Simmel features of a dyad (3)

A

Group dissolved as soon as one person decides
High levels intimacy (less room for play acting, low secrecy, you know who took the beer in the fridge)
Egalitarianism (otherwise you would leave)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

George Simmel features of a triad (4)

A
  1. birth of politics (two people can form coalition)
  2. birth of secrecy
  3. creates new roles (mediator, arbitror when two people disagreeing)
  4. One of the parties could take advantage of other two (third world countries milking USA/Soviets)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Simmel’s typology of groups

A

Small group
Party
Large group

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Simmel small group (and examples)

A

people in face-to-face contact that critically have shared focus of attention, all doing some thing,

ex. Old Cuban men playing cards together; egalitarian/friendship organizations generally. A lot of symbolic interactionist studies focus on small groups.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Simmel parties (3)

A

like a cocktail people, people milling around;
multiple foci of attention, very different interaction patterns, people focused on different things,
probably great increase in social complexity

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Simmel large group (2)

A

governed more formally, often by written rules

tend to be status distinctions and formal roles/procedures

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is Charles Horton Cooley’s typology of groups

A

primary and secondary groups

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Cooley Primary groups (3)

A

very important to invidual
members not replaceable
enduring intense ties that involve many aspects of social life

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Cooley secondary groups

A

Take up much less of life, maybe only one segment

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Examples of Cooley secondary groups

A

*work friends - if one retires or takes job elsewhere, less devastating than losing family member; professional sports teams that swap players

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Difference in how people will behave between Cooley’s primary and secondary groups

A

Generally make bigger sacrifices for primary group

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Reference group (2)

A

who you benchmark yourself against

psychological category and has implications for self-esteem

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Why is reference group significant for sociological research?

A

(have to keep this in mind when asking questions in sociology, since don’t know what reference group people have in mind when ask questions like do you think you make enough money)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Example of reference group

A

o Immigration example: new immigrants often use people back in original country as reference group, and then people from original country that moved to the new country; but people’s children often benchmark against the people they go to school with.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

in-group and out-group (subjective meaning)/example

A

People that are like you/not like you (maybe determined on basis of race, people in same denomination, etc.)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

In group and out-group (power-relations meaning)/example

A

society has in-group (powerful people) and out-group (marginalized people) – often used in contexts with ethnicity involved, ethnic minority and majority (in-group might be ethnic group in power

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Examples of in and out groups (2)

A

Italians/Jews went from out group to in group in terms of power when becoming honorary white people; or like in England, new outgroup is Middle Eastern people, whereas Black/Afro/Caribbean people are now part of ingroup – maybe due to personal relationships, colleagues, sports – Black people now seen as “truly” English),

Hutus vs. Tutsis

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Examples of the sorts of things networks can influence/we can ivestigate (3)

A

Information cascades like parents talking about autism

social norms creeping through networks

remittances with migrants in US sending money back to family back home

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Diffusion/example

A

things in networks tend to diffuse out in a very broad way (like belief in the Qanon conspiracy)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Ways to measure diffusion through a network (5)

A

Past behaviors (ask people who did they contact/meet/see, maybe in survey, source of information)

survey (who did you meet last week/how many times in week have you met certain people),

hypotheticals (imagine you needed to buy 10 dollar for bus fare, which of five friends would you first go to? Gives insight into who you think close friends are),

documents (shipping reports from East India Company to reconstruct network ties between ship captain

medical records – if you have a health emergency who should we contact)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Embeddedness (2)

A

fact that no one in society is free-floating, everyone is embedded in a network

could be heavily/lightly embedded depending on how many ties you have in that specific network

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Embededness example

A

you might be a religious person, but are embedded in a network of a church; descriptor for when people are in a network

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Density
how many people are connected to each other in a network; more ties connecting more people in more ways; dense network has lots of ties crisscrossing and connecting individuals
26
Centralized network (3)
pinwheel set-up: person at the center is the most powerful, since they know about all the things connecting to it, have control over information or distribution of resources feature of many dictatorships, the peripheries don’t know what they are doing, all information flows from the core
27
Decentralized network (1 feature, 2 examples)
less clear that there’s a strong power differential between members of the network often used by terrorist networks, like Chinese triads, since if police investigate you, no one can name more than three people, very little flow of information outside of the group, slow the police down to go through whole network another example is Internet, designed with concept that if Russia did nuclear strike on data hub, would still have capacity to communicate, so Internet designed on this principle, emerged as highly robust decentralized network, deliberately have a network that has low density.
28
Structural hole (2)
Have two networks very dispersed one, very dense one..someone might fill the structural hole between the two networks; that person has a lot of power because everything has to flow through them; place where there’s a gap in society and stuff isn’t getting through, if you can occupy it you become a very powerful player (brokers, middlemen, translators); get a lot of power purely from their structural location
29
Mark Granovetter “strength of weak ties”
Says that weak ties have been underestimated: they enable networks to extend out throughout time and space in a way that strong ties cannot; you only have so much energy/ties to expend on strong ties, but it’s easy to have lots of weak ties
30
Example proving weak ties
o Only about half of people get first job through formal channel (like card at employment agency, ad); other half of people got job since heard from other people that someone needs a job, like friend at Walmart who says mnager is looking for new hires)
31
Weak tie (3)
only comes along occasionally/occupies a smaller part of your life (person that fixes your car once a year), not very emotionally involved/don’t know much about them weak ties extend out and have more social capital social media successful since it’s easy to collect hundreds of weak ties, also Linkedn
32
Strong ties examples
strong tie would be like tie to family group, close friends, where much is shared, to your drinking buddy
33
3 disadvantages of strong ties
everyone knows stuff limited pool of information not useful for getting a job
34
Two ideas about networks
Stanley milgram's "six degrees of separation" Manuel Castells's network society and informationalism
35
Stanley Milgram "six degrees of separation"
” (in theory, anyone on the planet can be connected through six degrees of separation) - experimental approach (told people in Nebraska to get a letter to Dr. Smith in New York City, people had to guesstimate how to get the letter there, send the letter to people who might know someone else; might send it to your cousin who lives in New York City; who sends it to their English friend from work; always try to guesstimate who can get closer to the target; 20% of letters made it in 5 mailings
36
Manuel Castells Network society (3)
consists of communication technologies becoming more important than ever; pelple more connected than ever thanks to the networks they live in; information/knowledge flows through the networks of our society. Uses terms like “decentered” – think today there’s no center of knowledge, authority, or power, but everyone flows around (capital, symbols, etc.). his twist on postmodernity: Contrasted between modernity (individual nation states, industrial production as basis of wealth, Karl Marx power, flows of capital) with postmodernity (ideals, flows, decentered) way of coopting network to think about social networks today
37
Manuel Castells informationalism/example
information and knowledge and symbols is what generates power in our society, not agricultural/industrial power. Google, Apple, Nvidia, social media – these giant cooperations involved in flow of networking, information flows, etc. are the most influential. Example of theory/metaphorical application.
38
Collective action/example
a lot of people doing something doing something good for society as a whole – not just about crowds and demonstrations, not just about social issues digging a well, people coming together
39
Key aspects of a social movement (5)
1. tend to be sustained effort to bring about social change, not just one-off; has a goal 2. Might have political aims, but not part of formal politics 3. Can be organized or fragmented (BLM deliberately fragmented, NAACP more centralized) 4. Attract people often deemed to be activists 5. can have single issue or endure over time on multiple fronts (social movement stops once succeeding in foiling plans for nuclear power plant v. Sierra Club to save Yosemite Valley but now rolling targets)
40
New social movements distinction
imagined distinction old social movements being class-based movements like trade unions, about things like money and pay, voting rights (with MLK and women) new social movements being valued and identity based (recognition for gay marriage/trans based, diversity, social justice
41
Why might new v. old social movement be problematic distinction (2)
something like race might tag onto housing, social justice campaigns often have an issue to do with pay; also maybe problematic because the “new” social movements have been around for a long time (Thoreau and John Muir as examples of environmentalism, slavery and abolitionism seems like a social movement)
42
Most of sociology studies social movements from the left, but also have historically come from the right: examples
Proud Boys temperance inspired by Christian moralists KKK arguably MAGA is often value and identity based the Tea Party the Nazi party started off as a social movement Hindu nationalists)
43
Resource mobilization theory (2)
social movements get somewhere if they mobilize their resources; used to focus more on material things, now shift to cultural/Human Resources
44
Examples of material resources in resource mobilization theory
(communal space, money, means of communication) organizational resources (social network of the members, access to media platform, some internal sense of organization – local committees and chapters, protocol for holding meetings);
45
Examples of cultural/Human Resources for resource mobilization theory
1. Personnel 2. framing
46
Example of framing for resource mobilization theory
find a way to pitch message so that it resonates with people, boil it down to a core that works; might use PR/advertising firms to help them shape their message; example framing nuclear power plants as having risks for children; for abortion you wouldn’t frame it as women having the right to kill a 6-month fetus, would say that women have right to choose; or would say have right to life, not that we are forcing women to have babies
47
Example of personnel for resource mobilization theory
volunteers, doorknockers at grassroots level, legal expertise preferably free/in house, accountants for donations coming in, leadership – preferably charismatic, good speakers, people who are good with the media, have soundbites, attention-grabbing; moral resources (able to convince people they were on the right side of history/doing just and right thing – this is why some social movements succeed despite their lack of resources; example MeToo didn’t have a bureaucracy but got a lot of public attention),
48
What is a problem for participation in social movements?
Free rider problems/collective action o Require sacrifices from members (time, participation, etc.) o Free rider – can benefit without paying in, so rational strategy is to let everyone else work while you don’t contribute
49
What predicts success in social movements (4)?
1. mobilization of social networks (if your friends will do it, you will do it too…what do people who are similar to you do, your social network sets a norm/script for you to follow); bring in a risk of shaming (worried that if you don’t show up, your esteem in the eyes of your friends will go down) – so many current social movements try to work through social media 2. Personal experience (if you’ve been assaulted or been subject to policing discrimination, you’ll have a sense of outrage and might show up); also not all the people involved had personal experience that still have a sense of moral obligation 3. Moral obligation (sense that something is deeply unjust) 4. Risk reduction (if you protest against Gaza, could have student visa retracted) – so successful social movements will reduce risk for members (example wearing masks to reduce identification) or making sure that enough people turn out
50
What is a theory for what leads social movements to mobilizaoitn/success?
Resource mobilization theory
51
3 phases in evolution of social movements over time
1. Emergence 2. Coalescence 3. Routinzation
52
Emergence step in social movement evolution/example
Emergence – there’s an issue that some people know about/care about/have researched, others don’t. Example: HIV aids in gay community San Francisco 1980s – people saw their friends were dying; often a bunch of enthusiasts or people affected by it, no wider awareness
53
Coalsence in a social movement
something inchoate becomes more solid; start to get literature, pamphlet and websites, lobbying politicians, regular meetings with speakers, efforts at advocacy and fundraising, get more organized rather than just a bunch of people trying to find out about people
54
Routinization in social movement evolution/examples
having formal social movement organization, bureaucratization of social movement, becomes legally incorporated and has a headquarter building, formal rules and procedures of voting and membership, predictable stream of income, get full time salaried staff (examples: Sierra Club probably has lots of employees and cash flow; NAACP); gradually form bureaucratic organization that shifts them in certain ways
55
Potential problems with highly routinzed social movement organization (3)
1. only requires relatively weak commitment from most members, doesn’t require deep moral commitment, can become ritualized and shallow, not good at generating moral fervor and belief 2. susceptible to factionalism (will have been formed against value-based set of ideas, so some people are really passionate and will want more radical steps taken…but once it’s bureaucratically incorporated, can’t break the law as much as individuals could (Sierra Club can’t bomb the pipelines ), so tensions within the organization between people who want radical steps and other people who want to make cool yet unsatisfying solution) – infighting over strategy and splitting over factionalism, another organization might splinter off - so sometimes they are too successful and become too incorpated into political system; 3. also once you become too bureaucratic, can’t ever solve any of the problems you set out to solve, since then would lose their jobs; always finds new frontier of problems to deal with)
56
Crime
When you break the law, subset of deviance
57
Deviance
violates social norms; cross-dressing, farting, standing too close to people; some are crimes, some are not. Generally a lot more deviance than crime (lots oof rude, annoying, insensitive things)
58
Examples of crime/deviance being socially constructed and culturally relative (3)
1. Homosexuality is crime/deviant in the Middle East; alcohol in ME vs. New Orleans 2. laws for marijuana (now considered vaguely deviant, 20 years ago considered evil gateway drug) 3. age of consent
59
What does social order mean in the context of crime/deviance
Narrow definition: following law and not being deviant, people following rules/conforming (close to way Hobbes thought about social order, less expansive than traditional sociologists)
60
What does crime/deviance emphasize as solution to problem of social order?
Need for social control
61
What happens when someone violates social order with criminal/deviant acts?
Social control in form of sanctions (formal/informal)
62
Formal sanctions/examples
rule governed, administered by institutions; have procedures going to prison, traffic fines, someone expelling you from Yale
63
Informal sanctions
take place interpersonally, much more casual; policing each other to make sure people are reasonably civil; (rolling your eyes when you someone tells a racist joke, telling someone to stop being a jerk, giving a dirty look); if someone cuts you in line, might invoke informal sanction
64
4 reasons why society doesn't have a lot of deviants relative to what is possible?
1. Socialization/morality 2. Rewards and punishments 3. Visibility 4. Social approval
65
1. Socialization/morality
most of us believe in doing the right thing, because of socialization and morality (taught as children what is right and wrong); people socialized to be moral beings and do the right thing
66
Rewards and punishments (examples of each)
Society sets up rewards/punishments to incentivize certain lines of action aware there might be punishments if you plagiarize, so people self-police due to risk of punishment for infractions. Also rewards for being conformist (people will praise you for being a good person/resisting temptation)
67
Visibility/examples
many spaces in society designed so we have a lot of visibility of each other, makes deviance difficult (in marketplace, having lots of people around makes stealing harder)
68
Social approval
Rewards for conformity
69
Why are formal sanctions just tip of iceberg/formal criminal justice system does almost none of the lifting?
b/c most people not doing crime in the first place; deviance more common, death with by informal sanctions formal criminal justice system only deals with more serious stuff
70
Two lenses through which sociologists can look at crime
Crime as either "real" problem or "invented"
71
When sociologists view crime as "real" problem (3 examples)
people working on criminal justice policy or policing going to research murders going to find out demographic correlates of murders,
72
When sociologists view crime as "invented" problem (2)
slippery concept/culturally and historically relative certain crimes boosted in significance b/c criminal justice and formal sanction policies
73
Example of viewing crime as an "invented" problem
want to understand how definitions of marijuana use changed over time, sometimes considered a crime sometimes not;
74
Howard Becker constructivist theory of deviance (3)
deviance is invented/doesn’t really exist, treat it as something result of social process deviance is culturally relative, focuses on culture more than power, power can still play a role cultural relativism, cultural values that make, socially constructd
75
Howard Becker Labeling Theory (3)
what the powerful people label as deviant; a deviant is someone to whom the label of deviant has been successfully applied (doesn’t matter what they actually did, what matters is society considers them to be deviant) sociology shouldn’t focus on deviant action itself, instead process by which people are labeled (in symbolic interactionism includes mentally ill, pervert, drug user, law breaker, gang member) by powerful people – Dodging:powerless people generally labeled by more advantaged, more advantage people usually able to dodge these labels (better financial resources/lawyers, often commit their crimes in private settings) – ex: Harvey Weinstein sexual predator with young women alone in hotel rooms, people can’t see what they were doing;
76
Examples of labeling theory
maybe lobby group, there’s a more instrumental level; Christian temperance person motivation is religious; to benefit themselves or because they don’t understand; subtext way that people trample on diversity and interest in society; what sociolgy should focus on; within constructivist theory
77
Example, according to Labeling theory, how more powerful people can dodge these deviance labels while poor people cannot
poor people more visible in public settings, selling drugs on the street more visible powerful peope insultaed by resources, reptuation, types of crimes they can do in private settigns
78
Social control agents defintion/example
powerful groups and organizations label certain people as deviant. Example: police, psychiatrics, drug addiction counselors, school principals; have the power to call you crazy, criminal, drug user, delinquiet; courts also powerful labelling institution
79
Moral entrepreneurs (4)
Tends to say we need more attention to certain crimes Pushing for more labeling of more people as “deviant” sometimes push for something to be moved from deviant to illegal category (temperance movement) can be whole social movements or government agencies
80
Example of moral entrepreneurship
ICE prioritizing immigration issues
81
Becker primary and secondary deviance
Primary: minor things, someone smoking a joint, fighting in a bar; the first deviance things someone do Transition: often get involved in spiral that sends life downhill (fight in bar, caught, go to court, labeled as violent offender). Has repercussions that shuts off legitimate opportunities for employment/social interactions with “normal” society. Secondary: Apparently drives people to interact with other people like them (get sucked into criminal subcultures, become more serious offender), commit secondary deviance
82
Moral narrative implicit in Becker's primary/secondary deviance (3)
social control agencies somewhat responsible for crime labeling people too readily makes people shuts off legitimate opportunities and makes more serious criminals cascade effect
83
Deviance as "master status" (2)
trumps every other status you might have, drowns out alternative opportunities for identification; cuts off opportunities for positive social interactions, leading to negative spiral and secondary deviance
84
Steps of Becker's labeling theory
minor deviance - label - major deviance – self identity
85
Why is labeling theory a self-fulfilling prophecy?
Self-fulfilling prophecy; labeled as a criminal and eventually become one, think of yourself in terms of the subculture you are driven into
86
Media and moral panics def/ex
Society gets worked up about something that is not a big deal, disproportionate reaction related to some kind of deviance (often either no deviance or not a big deal) Satanism and children, not a lot of Satanists running around abusing children, should actually be focused on all the people dying from drunk driving
87
Reasons to be skeptical about Durkheim's social correlates for crime (poverty and masculinity)
Police/authorities of social control more concerned with certain types of crimes than others, like those in public spaces that men tend to do (young men take to take over public spaces in visible/noisy way, the crimes they do tend to come to the attention of the authorities) Poor neighborhoods more heavily policed than affluent communities, maybe less moral entrepreneurs for tax evasion and white-collar crime and crime from rich people, different age groups/cagtegories maybe doing different types of crimes, some crimes prioritized, more visible, ones young men do (guns, violence, drugs)
88
Edwin Sutherland Differential Association theory and three important keywords
if you hang out with deviant people, you become deviant; if you hang out in church choir, you do not become deviant); we get socialized from the other people into values, motivations, techniques values, motivations, techniques!
89
Subculture theory
Differential association theory morphed into this A lot of deviance done by subcultures where people belong to groups that teach them to certain ways of interpreting things/doing things not that bad pedophile priests
90
Merton strain theory (3)
says that USA has more crime than comparable nations (Italy, Germany)…USA has American dreams, high aspirations for success, but limited means, so maybe people start to cheat…means ends. Maybe different values too (Asian nations with Confucianism might value loyalty to family more, but in USA big emphasis on material success, so people start cheating because of gap between their means and ends). Applied to money, but generalizable in some senses (taking performance-enhancing drugs for sports)
91
Agnew modification to strain theory (2)
lots of people experience this gap between means and ends, but often there’s some triggering emotion that blocks this gap (divorce, loss of relationship, something happens in home country that radicalizes terrorists, getting sacked generate powerful emotions that lead you to trying to close the gap between means and ends).
92
Relatie deprivation theory
If there is strain, the strain is relative to other people who are kind of like you if you find that people like you/your imagined peer group are doing better than you are, experience extreme strain, might start turning to crime to close means and ends gap. Specification of strain theory to something narrow.
93
Travis Hirshi control theory
Builds on/flips Differential Association Theory to try to explain why most people are not criminals. Role of social bonds to conformity (invested in social life so have less incentive to cheat, although might think it’s morally wrong to do so).
94
Travis Hirshi control theory
Builds on/flips Differential Association Theory to try to explain why most people are not criminals. Role of social bonds to conformity (invested in social life so have less incentive to cheat, although might think it’s morally wrong to do so). Bonds to conformity in high school students were predictive of not being delinquent; if you think you’re doing well in school, have stakes in conformity, have positive feedback from teachers, more olikely to be conformist
95
What did Travis Hirshi control theory pay attention to
to time details. if you have social bonds to conformity, they soak up a lot of free time (go to choir practice, baseball practice) – you’re not sitting around at home engaging in risky/illegal activity.
96
Lifecourse criminology (2 things that change)
Notices that many young boys are delinquent, but stop when become 25 or 26; at this point, many people find a serious relationship (the “good woman” keeps you in the house at night, so less likely to boost cars with friends); in a way you are invested in conformity here as well; women stop men doing crazy things. Other thing you get is job with prospects: start to feel you have a future, have a stake in conformity, stop doing crazy things (now you have stuff to lose)
97
What accounts for life course criminology/underlying mechanism?
Role in conformity
98
Explanatory theories for crime/deviance (7)
Durkheim social correlates Sutherland Differential Association subculture theory Relative deprivation theory Travis Hirschi control theory (why not criminals) Lifecourse criminology merton Strain theory Agnew trigger
99
Crime explanatory -Durkheim social correlates
social correlates of suicide (male, Protestant); looking at crimes in the world today, find strong social correlates for who is doing certain crimes (often men under age 10-25 do most of crimes, girls are conformists/sensible, boys eiher crimanals, risk-takers, poorly socialized, outsider)
100
More possible explanatory theory for crime/deviance
Rational choice theory Moral émotions theory Situational/opportunity theory routine activity theory Psychology Environmental/biological/medical
101
Rational choice theory as explanation for crime
will commit crimes when you think the benefits exceed the costs, including the risk of being caught; people do a calculation to see how much they’ll gain, risk of being caught, if they’ll get away with it.
102
Challenge to Rational choice theory as explanation for crime
Challenges to this: people who go to prison lose a lot of money.
103
Jack Katz Moral emotions theory/examples
Opposite of rational choice theory; crime is irrational and driven by powerful emotional dynamics; almost no crime about making money more, about the thrill you get Ex: Ex: teenagers stealing not valuable stuff, pleasure they get from playing game appearing to be normal/engaged in legitimate enterprise but actually doing something sneaky.
104
Situational/opportunity theories of crime (2)
Switch attention from the offender to the context. Think about setting and opportunity (unlocked bicycle, bathroom windows left open) – a lot of the crime we have is b/c crime is possible and easy to do.
105
Routine activity theory (and 3 main components)
Focused on predatory crime of people in streets for how situations drive crime. Ex for mugging: probably something been drinking, motivated offender lurking around, no one else on the street. Eligible victims, motivated offender, absence of capable guardian
106
Psychological explanation for crime
Not ‘criminal mind’; but impulsiveness, risk taking traits, etc. – might be driven by biological processes, maybe evolutionarily adapted
107
Environmental/biological/medical explanations for crime (3 examples)
o lead in petrol seems to make people more impulsive o possible that tumors effect the way you think o maybe hormones/testosterones
108
Official crime statistics sources
police reports, court records, prison census, arrest/eviction record
109
Why should you take official crime statistics sources with grain of salt
there’s always more crime going on then they report (some is unreported/undetected)
110
Problems with official crime statistics sources (3)
reported v. invisible, which could reflect institutional priorities. (Ex: FBI making more drug arrests might not mean drug use is on the rise, could just be institutional priority to clamp down on drugs Filtering through the system, more and more stuff drops out (arrest records more than convictios more than prison sentences). Can pick up speeding offenses better in ticketing/arrest records than in prison records. Things show up in different places in the data. Crime not reported in the first place
111
Why is crime not reported? (7)
o People don’t like the police, don’t want to escalate the situation o You’ve already had contact with police, was very negative, worried they will start framing you o You have something to hide yourself (stolen car), don’t want police poking around o Might be embarrassed by what happens (could expose you having an affair) o Person who committed crime is friend/family member you don’t want to get in trouble o Threat of retribution from perpetrator (ex. Domestic violence) o Not worth your time (know the will never solve the case), net drain on your time in terms of rational choice theory, no point
112
FBI Uniform Crime Reports.
Collect info from all police information in America Report trends/aggregate crime.
113
What might be problems with FBI uniform crime reports (3)
Institutional priorities Underestimate property crime Differences in reporting protocols for different police departments
114
Crime victimization surveys.
Aimed to get at the “dark figure of crime” – ask them if you’ve been a victim of crime; reveals a lot of trivial crime that never gets reported to the police. Pick up that there’s way more crime going on then FBI ones.
115
Problems with crime victimization surveys
fitting the crimes people report into standardized legal categories, what counts as “assault,” so therefore would have to be very specific with lots of tedious questions, people don’t have a common language; tend to focus on people that live in fixed abodes; oversupply of retired white people from picket sense suburbia, affluent/older people who have time and are excited to answer surveys but these people are often not the victims of crime, but we should really focus on poor/marginal/documented/homeless people who are more eligible people but less likely to report to the police, rodeo workers, migrant workers, people who work on fair grounds, so surveys might underestimate the amount of activity going on
116
Reasons Durkheim gives for why crime/deviance sometimes good for society (2)
innovation (these innovative, creative thinks just labeled as crime/deviance, actually part of broader civilizational project) good for morality building (the act of denouncing crime enables us to talk about what is valuable) –
117
Examples for why crime sometimes good for society (Durkheim)
talking about sexual predators help reinforce norms about normal sexual behavior, reinforces our moral boundaries through act of contemplation
118
Durkheim on crime as a movable bar
we move the bar on what is considered a transgression (in a monastery, the monk was naughty because he had a second piece of cake, small thigns take on big significance in certain contexts; in the Sound of Music when Maria is told off for being late for mass, “How do you solve a problem like Maria”, even in a society of saints there is deviance, which is needed to reaffirm importance of showing up on time for religious services
119
Sport is just fun, so why bother to study it? (5)
BUT it is linked to class, race, and gender orders (reflects and generates these) – ideal models of male/female bodies, provides us with ideal ways of thinking about race, sports imagery tied into our vision of social class and privilege Important sector of economy (jobs, $, etc.) – a lot of income that relates to sports and leisure There’s also people catering to people in terms of sports medicine Reflects modernity and postmodernity (sport you get reflects the society you are in/the place you are in social evolution) – sport as a mirror of society Connected to body (norms and ideals), self-identity (nationalism; people feeling nationalistic when watching Olympics or soccer) and ideology
120
Allen Guttmann “Ritual to Record”
Weberian analysis (legal-rational authority, bureaucracy, iron cage of modernity) all of these Weberian elements fell into place over last centuries in evolution of sport: Standardized rules Bureaucracy Statistics Disenchantment/secularization (not connected to meaning) Specializaition (specific roles)
121
Trobriand cricket (4)
cricket brought by missionaries in the South Pacific, but the natives adopted the game and took it in their own direction took this modern game and brought it back to “ritual": lots of group chants and music, reintroducing ritual element (people also cheer if opposing team scores almost reversion of modernity for example, the host team always winseveryone takes part (team can be as big as you like, even most feeble man can participate) it’s an excuse for feasting
122
Norbert Elias/Eric Dunning reduction in violence (2)
In West become less and less used to violence, threshold changed over time (duels banned, ice hockey going to blood bay from cut) more rules to regulate violence
123
Foucoultian perspectives on sport (3)
Discipline (training to be good at a sport, maybe by you discipling yourself since you’ve internalized the world of discipline and order). Science (scientific approaches on nutrition, improving performance time; Foucault thought experts were evil and controlling people). Surveillance (monitor sports people with cameras, time with stopwatches). Lots of stories of sports people being abused/bullied for underperforming might give credence to this.
124
3 other things to note about sports in the modern era (3)
Globalization (transition from cheese-rolling to FIFA). Capitalism (corporations making money off it it). Nationalism (most people feeling very nationalistic during sporting events).
125
5 challenges to modernity narrative in sports
1. Emergence of sports rejecting modernist forms (Tribordian cricket) 2. Survival of premodern elements in today's sport culture 3. Retro and nostalgia sports 4. Rise of virtual/online sports 5. Shift toward play
126
Shift towards play sports
E.g. snowboarding (much more supportive than competitive environment, focused on pulling off cool trickets), skateboarding culture (also supportive) v. skiing (much more organized and success driven), soul surfing (people who are into going to romantic, quiet places; interested in retro technology like wooden boards instead of fiberglass) v. pro-circuit (professional sponsors involved)
127
Rise of online and virtual sport
sports involving simulation of imagery world
128
Retro and nostalgia sports
sports (playing tennis with wooden rackets; flyfishing with a bamboo rod). Ironic sports. Expressive.
129
Survival of premodern elements in today’s sport culture (2)
violence (still celebrate people that are violent in rugby), sacred aura (people who are best at sports we think of as having magical properties, carry with them sense of having special charismatic gifts, doesn’t seem like they are soul-trained to be uninteresting), etc.
130
Bourdieu on sport and class (3)
mechanism of exclusion: different levels of cultural capital associated with them; largely helps classify/segregate people people in dominant social classes familiar/reasonably competent at these sports (yachting, polo, tennis, shooting); working class (basketball, football, darts); dominant class collects cultural capital in forms of excellence in certain sports, whereas working class people excluded (don’t have point of entry through a network, often don’t have the money to sustain it);
131
Body types and class for sports (examples for each class)
ideal body types vary by social class these are reflected in sporting bodies for upper/middle class; prototype for this is a tennis player, Novak Jocavich, muscular but not muscle bound); working class men like a more muscular body (body of boxer, basketball player); these body class ideals reinforced by sports
132
Sports influence on ideology (3)
Normalizes/naturalizes the idea that social life should consist of competition that generates winners and losers (winners/losers are an aspect of capitalism); provides vanilla vaneer of why capitalism is normal/natural/the way things are (if it was always art on television, you would think life is about contemplation/creating beautiful things) some people who are very capitalist like Trump use a lot of sporting metaphors
133
Mike Messner on sport and gender (3)
sports celebrates hegemonic masculinity (likes rough guys who can fight). Reinforces gender order (shows that men are strong, women less strong) Connects to violence and sexual assault (inspired by sports to go home and beat up women).
134
Why do sports present problems for female athletes? (2)
dominant form of femininity – a watcher, passive, sexually available; women often depicted as doing watching and waiting activities creates a problem for women, who must be sporty, muscular, and brave – how can you be both female and a good athlete at the same time
135
Result of women in sports the problem
gender displays and impression management (sexualized advertising for Nike; female athlete tries to show that she’s heterosexual, sexually available, not a lesbian, not too muscular; photos will also likely feature the male spouse and children);
136
Evidence that perhaps women in sports image is changing (2)
David Beckham wears wife’s clothes, likes nail varnish (gender bended?) Roller Derby involves women wearing sexy clothing, but fighting each other, have violent names (maybe challenging the gender order in some ways)
137
Stereotypes of race in sport (2)
African considered to be “naturally” good at sport; physically demanding roles go to black people, cerebral” means you’re Asian or white; can argue that it impacts what positions you get into, more cerebral positions like quarterbacks go to white people, coaches usually white
138
How are sports used as domain of protest for racial order
people using visibility of sport to say something about the racial order, Colllin Capernick
139
Sport status order/jobs/prestige/rewards and affect on gender order (process)
often go to white people... since advertisers like white people more than black people since white people have more money to buy stuff advertisers appeal to people who have more money to buy stuff by including images of people that look like them
140
Economists view of education as (4)
education = human capital. More human capital the better, as it makes society more productive and better. Can look at human capital individually (common sense view) or for “system” needs (“labor economics” loves education) Teaches skills for workforce.
141
What else is included in sociologists "beyond common sense" view of education
networks/romance Socialization (adult, politeness, sharing) The self (less family influence, more tolerant) sorting (different life prospects, signal to employers) Stratification/inequality (educational outcomes translate to social outcomes) Elite reproduction (elite universities --> CEO) The state (regulation) Economy (educated people gerate wealth) Politics (political protest) ideology (meritocracy)
142
social reproduction
society keeps going, keep fueling industrial system and stuff; but also refers to reproduction of the class system/inequality – middle class parents have kids that enter middle class themselves
143
Why is meritocracy problematic idea
not level playing field, if you are smart might just be life chanecs you have
144
How might you measure educational attainment over different groups?
Race, class, migration Shows diverse outcomes (affluence, human capital, language, etc.)
145
Differentiation in education
separates out from religion/theology etc. (education institutions used to be religious)
146
The state in education
state intervenes in education, linked to state power, reinforces ideas of nation (inculcating national values, particularly through teaching of history)
147
Democracy/citizenship in education
seen as right of modern individual (modern thing, human rights didn’t exist until 200 years ago)
148
What is growth of education tied to?
Rise of knowledge economy/postindustrial economy
149
Education and modernity: 5 features
Differentiation Bureaucracy State Democracy and citizenship Knowledge economy
150
5 important theories of education
1. Durkheim's Moral education 2. Boles and Gintis hidden cirriculum 3. Paul Willis "Learning to Labor" 3. Max Weber's occupational closure 4. Randall Collins' Credential inflation
151
Durkheim Moral Education theory of education
education plays important role in forming citizens; when kids go to school learn what it means to be an adult, drags them way from family and own religion; education in France got people to realize there was a serious world out there, “la vie serieuse,” helped people realize they had a duty and responsibility.
152
Paul Willis. “Learning to Labor.” theory of education
says how does education lead to reproduction, it has nothing to do with curriculum/teacher, outcomes dependent on the culture of the working class boys where you get high social value for disobeying. (ethnography in city school, mostly white; flips things away Resistance leads to working class jobs (since they didn’t take school seriously); masculinity also tied in here (if a boy is good at school, might mean they are a wimp/unmanly, listen to authority/obey instructions, since code of masculinity involves showing disobedience; also goes well with differential association theory
153
Max Weber occupational closure
Role of educational credentials to be in authorized in-group. (when people shut the doors of their occupation/pull up the ladder for high status positions like accountants, doctors, lawyers). Law (state punishes people who are not authorized to do these things). Exclusion. The state is typically heavily involved, groups will go to the state and say we do this properly, other people don’t do things properly, you must stop them; they say it’s in the public interest for this to be regulated/only educated people participate). So education influences whether you can get thee state to make laws that gives you monopoly on certain types of income.
154
Randall Collins credential inflation theory of education
more and more people chasing jobs, qualification level for jobs keep going up, too many applicants so need way to filter people, do so by asking for credentials.
155
Does Randall Collins credential inflation think the qualifictaions mean you do a better job
No - just way for employers to filter out people, leads to inflationary spiral where more people keep pursuing more jobs
156
Why does Randall Collins say credential inflation is collectively dysfunctional? (2 reasons)
since lots of people have degrees, not enough jobs, can lead to arms race in getting degrees to try to get to top of the list. Also waste of time chasing jobs
157
Example of credential inflation
: degree in creative writing, might need degree to get degree as adjunct professor; a lot of great writers in the past are self-trained
158
Meritocracy (2)
society rewards people who is smart and works hard Education plays level field where poor kids can get ahead
159
What does sociology show about meritocracy?
Once we control for background variable, individual talent and skill do a lot less
160
What did James Coleman do social background v. school quality
went around and investigated a bunch of schools and their properties (teacher qualifications, structural things, student to staff ratio, number of books in library) then compared it to the kids’ performance on test,
161
What did James Coleman find with school background v. school quality
only income and occupation of parents back home actually had an impact on improving people’s test schools even in a really well resourced school, kids will suffer); social background is the most important thing here, not the quality of the school.
162
What are some resources at home that account for greater success in eduucation (2)
Parenting styles Habitus
163
Parenting styles leading to better education (3)
1. middle class parents explain things to their kids, doesn’t happen as much in working class families 2. middle class parents interact/get along with teachers, working class maybe intimidated by teachers 3. working class parents feel like it’s school’s job to educate,
164
Habitus
your knowledge of high culture, sense of confidence and ease
165
What does Bordeau say about education and habitus (3)
teachers have teacher’s pets/favorites, often the ones that have this habitus; kids that don’t make trouble, are at ease with materials; schools are a sham because teachers reward people like them, homophily in the classroom); feedback affects, since if get rewarded with teacher feel more confident
166
Summer slide
all kids go down between May and Setpember, since not in school and forgot skills, but in the summer the working class kids go down more than the working class kids since parents not as active in their education, compounding into middle class kids getting ahead
167
How might summer slide be used as a counterargument to resources at home being all-important argument
shows that school does something, even for poorer kids, their scsores go up during school year; middle class kids getting two sets of inputs, home plus school; but everyone does benefit from school
168
Tracking
separates kids into different groups based on intelligence;
169
Implications of tracking (2)
1. unfair since centers on habitus, gives privileged kids advantage; 2. people seem to perform to the level they are told they are
170
Education and inequality talking points
1. Meritocracy 2. James Coleman school background v. school quality 3. Resourecs at home 4. Summer slide 5. Tracking
171
School segregation
Different schools have different qualities, schools in more affluent areas often do better.
172
Why does school segregation occur?
Rational choice and collective action Rational action is to put all kids in same school; disadvantaged kids would be helped by smarter kids in the classroom; but can’t do this since we believe in freedom in America, so people self-sort (move to area that have better schools if you can move, other people get left behind)
173
Problem of expectations about diversity and intersection with class
when survey rich white parents, they want diversity BUT really they want kids to be in school with kids of color with high achieving parents, want right amount/type of diversity, white people tend to bail out when diversity hits a certain level
174
Why can’t we do anything/much to turn schools around
“choice” is maybe a problem not a solution (individually rational for some people to do things that are not good collectively), but removing choice is an attack on “freedom” and seems to be going too far
175
Why is media important?
We are in information society Media affects spread of info
176
Why do Marxists say media is important?
Media is main source of reproducing ideology, beliefs that make them happy and keep them uncritical of capitalism
177
Why do journalists say media is important?
Preserving democracy; need information for informed choices/voting, source of culture and value
178
Positive view of the media (a few)
preserves democracy investigative journalism of corruption and abuses good for children (Sesame street helping poor children learn to read and write) keeps citizens informed and politicians powerful
179
Negative view of the media
insufficiently critical of existing institutions things like Love Island trivial don’t lead to good citizens
180
Why are most sociologists not big fans of mass media
tends to accept/reproduce status quo instead of questioning it in a radical way; tends to focus on blips instead of big questions like what is wrong with race/gender order,
181
Why might media be a challenge to symbolic interactionalism?
Technological evolution/globalization For the first time disembedded people from face-to-face contact in everday life, form opinions by reading information from people you’ve never went o Symbolic interactionists are resistant to the idea that people can change their minds/values without these face-to-face interactions
182
What are some implications of technological evolution/globalization with media
o Gave people chance to think about world could become beyond their embedded networks o Now don’t rely on town crier, sense of bigger scale, locality matters less and less
183
How might media be a source of power (4)
1. Distance: t’s power over information and storytelling that can operate at a distance over thousands of people 2. (Amplify) effects of any one individual if you can get control of forms of symbolic production to the many 3. Fame: can also become famous by being visible in mass media 4. can influence opinions
184
collective identity (def/ex)
feeling like you’re part of something more than just yourself identifying as black or an Eagles fan
185
How does media play role in sustaining/building natioanlism/nation-state?
Printing press and newspaper important for rise of national identity
186
Benedict Anderson “imagined community
never meet all the people in your nation, but still feel like you have something in common with them;
187
Explanation for Anderson's "imagined community"
; this came about because people were opening the newspaper, which told you about national events, give you idea that you’re a member of a nation with certain interests; in 1830s people may have had stronger ties to their local town or ethnic group instead of to their nation; newspapers made people elevate sense of national identity much more in Victorian Era
188
What is key in creating imagined communities?
Media like newspapers q
189
Michael Billig "banal natoinalism"
“banal nationalism” – tend to think that nationalism takes place during big parades, July 4, inauguration of a president, but it is actually churning around all the time in the background, way that people classify/identify themselves
190
What is example of banal nationalism
postage stamps on your letter with American hero reading about U.S. soccer team
191
Katz and Dayan “media events
places where nation state/national identity comes to the forefront; they existed up until 1990, when people would gather to watch big news events on TV
192
Importance of media events
these were all organized around the nation, important part of making people feel like part of nation
193
Why have media events become more fragmented?
Internet
194
Examples of media events
election results world cup soccer Olympics moon landing celebrations disasters competitions
195
Talking points for media and modernity (6)
Technological evolution/globalization Media as source of power Role in building nation-state "imagined community" banal nationalism media events
196
What does production of culture perspective look at?
Looks at how media content and industries are organized and what jobs are like (values, folkways, etc.) that produce “content”
197
How is production of culture perspective similar to symbolic interactionism?
people know what the norms are/what to do, even if they don't know why
198
Themes of selection, editing, sponsoring, rejecting, gatekeeping, etc. from ethnographies of newsrooms
Select things based one what people think is interesting Editing based on professional norms
199
Herbert Gans “Deciding What’s News” (1979) what was it
Ethnography to see what happens when people do news; looked at newspapers
200
Herbert Gans “Deciding What’s News” (1979) findings (4)
they supported law and order over disorder selected stories they thought were “newsworthy” based upon journalist’s common sense Jounralists like to quote credible sources that could be named Journalists are working to a tight deadline, go to rule of thumb/template to get job done
201
Implications of newspapers selecting things they thought were "newsworthy" based on it being an event you can tell a story about
bad for long, extended discussions of structural issues like racial problems or structural housing problems
202
Implications of newspapers liking to quote credible sources that can be name
gives privilege to people in privilege of power because if you can quote police chief/mayor, little people are excluded from the news (people in position power tend to be quotable since have konown identity, people not known have less credibility)
203
Implications of newspapers working tight deadline/sticking to rule of thumb
News due to these standards in industry and time constraints sometimes means lower quality
204
What does Consumption/reception of culture explore?
o Explores impacts and interpretations of audiences
205
Mass society and the hypodermic mode
huge audience, small number of people producing content audiences are strongly moved by emotional content of speeches society consisted of a mass of dupes and elites who did broadcasting, dictators could control people with control of media/persuasive rhetoric
206
Implication of the mass society/hypodermic model
no longer a critical and engaged citizenship
207
Example of hypodermic model
Hitler says something, people believe it like it’s injected ingo them
208
What does C. Wright Mills say about “mass” vs. “public?
too much of a mass, not enough of an engaged public thought USA used to be a public thinking critically about the news, wanting to evaluate policy in sensible way
209
Paul Lazarsfeld “two step flow”
noticed that speeches were first interprated by people in authority who controlled interaction setting, then told to other people; not everyone gets the message directly, there’s an authority figure/"opinion leader" they trust who tells them what it means.
210
How did Paul Lazarsfeld get the findings for “two step flow”
looked at political speeches and asked people what they thought of it,
211
Examples of Paul Lazarsfeld two step flow
example family sitting in home, father telling family which aspects of the speech were good trade union representative telling people which parts of politicaisn speech were good)
212
Agenda setting
the media can’t tell media what to think, only what to think about) - set agenda of what’s newsworthy/should be thinking about, tells us where our concern should be
213
Two implications of media agenda setting
1. form of power 2. other issues stay off the radar
214
How does agenda setting fit well with Marxism?
Trivial stuff distracting from more important structural matters
215
Stuart Hall encoding/decoding model
1. Says the media does reproduce things in the interest of capitalism, but Herbert Gans had some good ideas; media professionals have a set of vocational understandings 2. Different way media professionals encode things 3. Different ways audiences read things
216
What is encoding in encoding/decoding model?
news story infused with pro-capitalist values but packaged as professional news story according to those norms (so hard to get structural issues on the table)
217
What is decoding in encoding/decoding model?
what people do watching the news (if journalist says “national interest,” that actually means its in the “capitalist interest”)
218
different readings within encoding/decoding model
Dominant Oppositional Divergent
219
Dominant reading within encoding/decoding model
the one capitalist system wants you to get, this strike is a bad thing, national reading
220
Oppositional reading in encoding/decoding model
you push back against that capitalist narrative, those workers deserve more pay
221
Divergent reading in encoding/decoding model
the person doesn’t get the story at all, it means something different to them, commenting that Trump should get a haircut and don’t actually pay attention to what they are saying
222
Talking points for production of culture perspective (5)
1. Herbert Gans “Deciding What’s News” 2. Agenda setting 3. Mass society and hypodermic model Paul Lazarsfeld "two step flow" 4. Stuart Hall's encoding/decoding model
223
Darnell Hunt “Screening the LA Riots”
a guy beat up by American police, the cops got off; Hunt showed news footage of the riots to white/black people in different neighborhoods, found two different readings of same footage; black people saw this as protest against injustice, white people saw lawlessness and violence (the white people were encoding dominant model of white order, black people encoding oppositional one maybe)
224
Janice Radway “Reading the Romance’
historical romance novels ideologically problematic (dark mysterious stranger that takes advantage of woman but she falls in love); the women reading the book are aware they are reading problematic products that don’t correspond to real lives, but reading is still a way of recovering time from the woman’s others responsibilities
225
Two examples of audience ethnographies
1. Darnell Hunt “Screening the LA Riots 2. Janice Radway “Reading the Romance’
226
Why is there difficulty in reading off "impacts" in audience ethnography?
hard to prove causaility to the media product, since we lead complex lives
227
2 examples of it being hard to read off impacts in audience ethnography due to proving causality?
1. found that people who like Hitler like watching war movies, teenage pregnancies linked to watching too many barbie movies 2. Hard to know if your choice of newspaper influenced who you are voting, or if you selected it in the first place due to your disposition,
228
Major new differences with new media and social media (4)
1. People can produce stuff for themselves 2. much more democratic 3. a lot of filtering and hierarchy has disappeared 4. can communicate directly at low cost with each other
229
Potential of new/social media?
voices of repressed can be heard (since no longer have hierarchy, potential for more democratically inclusive forms of content)
230
Counteraguent that new/media is more democratic and good development?
seems that internet is still biased against black people, just like traditional news, so did it really change?
231
Sherry Turkle “Alone Together”
people in coffee shops just go and fiddle on their own devices, not interacting together thinks it makes people more lonely, lower-quality interactions, making people more isolated than before
232
Melissa Wall “Africa on YouTube”
looked at uploads on Africa in Ghana and Kenya – uploads on YouTube tagged Ghana or Kenya had tourists uploading stereotypes of wild animals and tribesmen, the locals weren’t posting political monologues about capitalism/colonialism, instead posting sports and pop musicians
233
Implications of “Africa on YouTube”
the locals weren’t posting political monologues about capitalism/colonialism, instead posting sports and pop musicians (YouTube is not a transgressive media challenging colonialism, maybe argument that new media does not change much)
234
Dennis Waskul. “Sex in Second Life”
inhabit an Avatar; online, people double down on conventional gender characteristics, “people just wanted to have outrageous sexual fun in this digital universe” (Professor Smith), don’t try to escape from the binary as they could have
235
findings about racial/sex bias with interaction with bots
reinforce bigoted opinions AI summaries problematic and biased
236
Four examples of pushback to new media/social media
1. "Alone together: 2. "Africa on YouTube" 3. Sex in Second Life" 4. AI/bots reinforcing bigotry
237
Findings from 1990s on digital divide
demographics was aspect of digital divide; now not so much
238
Global North v. South digital divide/why its problematic
most world sites available in English but not other languages; so Internet is not utopian, but actually reproduces colonial relations since most material is in the colonial language
239
Why is Arab springs good news for digital divide?
protestors against nasy dictators, social media helped people organize protests and feel confidence about confronting power
240
Why is technology getting cheaper good news for digital divide?
so exclusion being reduced
241
How can digital technology leapfrog development phases?/2 examples?
poorer nations might be able to catch up 1. people in Africa using cellphones to pay; 2. Somalia, cell phone tower still exist and are not vandalized since war lords put them in their compounds and get money from cell phone corporations for protecting them, everyone in Somalia can get service
242
Three good signs for the digital divide decreasing/technology being used for good
1. Arab springs 2. Technology getting cheaper 3. Leapfrog development phases
243
Gestalt switch
“people’ to “bodies”, personality drops away and you are left with vision of society just as a bunch of biological creatures objective view
244
Why can Gestalt switch be good for sociology?
Can look at society more objectively
245
There general views of the body
1. Resource (lets society do stuff) 2. Liability (problem that hs to be solved) 3. Both (problem converted into a resource)
246
Chris Schilling what 4 changes brought attention to the body?
1. Social trends and body sociology (feminism, abortion) 2. Technology (surgery, medicine) 3. Consumerism (sports industry, cosmetics) 4. Aging (aging population)
247
Bryan Turner somatic society
Every known society must convert bodies from liability to resource; 4 things to be solved
248
4 things to be solved in Bryan Turner somatic society
1. Reproduce 2. Regulate 3. Train 4. Represent
249
Reproduce in somatic society
have babies, children being brought up bring to attention function of medical systems, nutrition systems, what do we do to produce new people and keep them happy/healthy
250
Regulate in somatic society (2 main mechanisms)
Why: otherwise might not perform social functions properly, bodies potentially disorderly, could go and perform crime; How: could do this either through coercion or socialization; regulating crowds of people like in Disney Land
251
Train in somatic society
Foucault, robotized movements, drilled, working on assembly line, trained to do activities for industrial production/warfare
252
Represent in somatic society
Coordinate with other bodies, come together in networks and be in joint tasks Weberian/Foucaultian vision of modernity (society consists of increasingly more ways of controlling bodies)
253
What did Michel Foucault say about the body?
Historical shifts in control of the body (sovereign, disciplinary, biopower)
254
What was Foucault's three-fold model of control of the body?
Force Training Desire (society can shape/control desire in appropriate ways)
255
Why might Foucault's theory of the body be pushback against Chris Schilling?
Foucault also researching the body brought it into the body, not soley from external forces
256
Sovereign body in Foucault
before 1800, was king over the people, physical power involving whipping people, tying them up, etc.; either exerted power on people or used the fear to get people to stay in line
257
Disciplinary body in Foucault
the factory, roboticized motions, training body to be docile, get people to stop being individuals, start performing functions
258
Biopower body in Foucault
need babies for factory/armies, sexology – counting bodies, census came up in historical era
259
Norbert Elias civilizing process
800 years ago much less control over body, fart loudly, urinate publicly, public sex; like sports – originally violent, became less and less violent over time;
260
Two aspects/examples of Elias' civilizing process for body
Display (increasing level of shame for public nakedness, less sex in public) Regulation (eating peas with fork, folding napkins)
261
What is the causal model within Elias' civilizing process? (5 steps)
1. Middle Ages - chaotic, payoff to be angry person 2 End of MA - power consolidated in centralized states 3. Now - world full of court and intrigue, double dealing and whispering, violence is not way to get ahead but rather having high levels of self-control/civility 4. Shift in nature of power/how to get ahead led to people regulating their behaviors 5. Norms trickle drown through society to lower classes
262
Emile Durkheim. Homo duplex
man on the one hand is a biological organism, driven by instincts, with desire and appetite and on the other hand is being led by morality and other elements generated by society.
263
Elaborate on body being liability/problem for Durkheim (and example)
Linked to material, desire, sensory pleasure/sensation, somehow closer to nature than to culture take people away from culture, stops you from being a fully cultural person and engaging in higher life example, you are hungry when watching a movie, body stuff takes over higher-order cultural function, or even it.
264
Examples of body being led by morality/society for Durkheim
Ritual use and Prohbitions
265
Expand on ritual in Durkheim's homo duplex
body very useful for rituals, many cultures found way to turn from liability into resource
266
Expand on use and prohibition in Durkheim's homo duplex
prohibitions on sex and other kinds of activities allows body to star to become a source through which they can find the sacred
267
Extension of homo duplex with Randall Collins
Centrality of body in interaction ritual wherever bodies are in sync, the people feel good about each other, sense of solidarity and powers them up emotionally, little tiny gestures that people do, rhythmic entrainment Body released by certain music like at a rave, feel comfortable dancing
268
Bourdieu class in relation to habitus
People's certain way of being cultured/self working class clunky and clumsy, will look more uncomfortable; middle/upper class have more ease/confidence
269
Marcel Mauss "techniques of the body"
we like to think that we are doing the most effficienct thing to do/biological, but in reality body is highly socialized in way it moves/does tasks.
270
Three examples of Marcel Mauss "techniques of the body"
1. French women started walking differently after watching American movies 2. French/American men dig trenches differently 3. Preferred sexual positions varied cross-culturally
271
Some talking points for body as sociological topic (5)
Chris schilling on why it emerged Bryan Turner somatic society Michel Foucault three-fold model Norbert Elias civilizing process Emilie Durkheim Homo Duplex
272
Tacit/embodied knowledge
know stuff that don’t know that you know it; turn on iPhone, scroll on iPad, no one ever taught you, not reflexive of it, driving Body is clever/knowledgable
273
Example of tacit/embodied knowledge
Example of David Sundown's "Ways of the Hand" taught himself to become jazz pianist, gradually becomes competent pianist, was doing stuff automatically and didn’t know why his hands were doing it, missing link of consciousness, like sightreading
274
Iris Marion Young “Throwing Like a Girl
In our society, girls don’t throw as well as boys (fragile, restricted) Shaped by gender order: girls are not encouraged to be athletic, girls’ sports don’t encourage throwing if you’re a girl who throws well, you become liability to won gender identity, whereas guys get bonus points for throwing well) (fragile, restricted, shaped by gender order). ;
275
Donna Haraway. Posthuman. Cyborg body
world is changing, need to be able to theorize interface between humans and machines better; having hip replacement makes you a cyborg; what is a human body when it interfaces with technology
276
More talking points for body (5)
Pierre Bordeau habitus and body Marcel Mauss "techniques of the body" Tacit/embodied knowledge "Throwing Like a Girl" Cyborg/posthuman
277
What are some unhealthy behaviors connected to beauty
anorexia, vomiting, diety, teenage suicide
278
Where do ideas about beauty come from?
Mass media and celebrity culture
279
In what ways are ideas about beauty problematic
Racialized (white features valued more) Class structure (middle-class woman thinner, so ideal body_ Eurocentric (devalues large parts of the world)
280
Rewards for beauty/meeting conventional beauty norms (2)
Might make more money to other people otherwise equivalent can make more advantageous marriage (physical attractiveness of women could be leveraged to person looking to marry)
281
Why does no one much study rewards for beauty/meeting conventional beauty norms?
because beauty seems to be randomly distributed, so sociologists would struggle to find any structural factors
282
Body work. Body project. Body regime
People trying to work on/improve their bodies, good for low-level ethnographic studies (people lifting, training for marathon, yoga)
283
Michael Atkinson 3-part typology for beauty
1. camouflaging 2. extending 3. adapting 4. redesigning
284
camouflaging in Atkinson beauty typology
women with makeup, people with disfigurements and how it is hidden
285
extending in Atkinson beauty typology
do things to make body better than what it is already, eye glasses
286
adapting in Atkinson beauty typology
body-building, trying to make it a different body; dieting
287
Redesigning in Atkinson beauty typology
plastic surgery, breast enhancement, leg lengthening, tattooing – how are you responding to world around you/sense of self
288
Commodification of the body
ties to capitalism - body becomes something through which people can make money, many corporations that have something to do with the body not in a strictly health way, ties to racial/gender order Examples: beauty and weightlifting magazines, websites, so
289
Example of control theoyry
Bonds to conformity in high school students were predictive of not being delinquent; if you think you’re doing well in school, have stakes in conformity, have positive feedback from teachers, more olikely to be conformist
290
Marx view on religion (2)
a component of an ideology - makes them put up with lot in life, since even if life terrible might be afterlife, instead of challenging capitalism. Didn’t think religion did a lot of listing
291
Weber's view on religion (3)
Unlike Marx, Weber thought that that religion had made big difference in the world/economic life; says modern capitalism/economic system has religious origins. Comparative sociology of world religions. “Idealist” explanation of modernity with role of religion (focus on doctrine; every religion has to have answer to problem of suffering and salvation, view on what happens after death and what purpose of life is (predestination)
292
Weber's theory on Protestant ethic and predestination (4)
predestination is psychologically traumatic for Protestants wanted to know if they go to heaven or hell; so developed mechanism…if they do well in life financially, means God likes you, you are going to heaven, looked for beliefs of God’s favor translated itself into relentless economic activity and rational accumulation of wealth and reinvesting money…so careful counting of money rational money/acquisition led to capitalism
293
This worldly activism and connection to capitalism
Protestants attempt to build God’s kingdom on earth, build perfect communities that worship God, so Protestants became super engaged and active in trying to make things better, “this worldly activism” drove pilgrims to Plymouth Rock to form perfect religious community, etc., also leading to capitalism.
294
Weber's Asceticism and capitalism
Even if had money, not flashing it around.
295
Weber's "Iron Cage”
modernity is an iron cage full of rationality
296
Consequence of "iron cage" for Protestants
colossal unintended consequence; they started off being super religious, but process of rational cumulating and investing led to emergence of soulless modern world where God disappeared
297
Key terms to connect with Weber on Protestant ethic?
Predestination "This worldly activism" Asceticism Iron Cage
298
Eastern religions (3)
Retreatism and meditation as way to salvation for these people revered for being a hermit found salvation by turning inwards/retreating from world,
299
Consequences on Eastern religions
catastrophic in terms of developing industrial modernity with science, technology, world conquest, etc.
300
West: Disenchantment
Protestantism stripped of religious foundations, left with dull world of rationality, emotionally unsatisfying, secularization
301
secularization
secularization (religion becoming less important in society - ironic consequence
302
Two perspectives from classical sociology on religion
Marx Weber
303
How do we measure secularization? (6)
Behavioral measures Cultural things What peoples about their own religion Politically, separation church/state Rise of scientific explanations and justifications Declining influence of the Pope
304
Examples of behavioral measures to measure secularization
church attendance measures, prayer, if donate to religious organization
305
Examples of cultural measures for secularization (3)
modesty and dress codes marriage ceremonies and where they were held/religious officiator what proportion of educational institutions are religious;
306
Examples of people's own thoughts on their religion (3)
Spiritual/belief in God Surveys: atheist/agnostic How often do you feel sacred in your life
307
Reasons for secularization (2)
1. Rise of science 2. Growth of tolerance
308
Why is growth of tolerance leading to secularization? (2)
since a lot of religion thrives on the idea that there is a literal truth to religion, things start to become relativized  Migration/contact with people from other religions
309
Common pushback arguments against secularization (4)
White Christian nationalism Eurocentric set of beliefs Displayed in different ways (spiritual just not doctrine) American exceptionalism
310
Why might you say secularization is Eurocentric set of beliefs?
secularization literature obsessed with things in Europe, but Islam, Mormonism, evangelical Christianity is on the rise
311
What is American exceptionalism argument against secularization?
maybe Europe becoming more secular, but people still going to church a lot in America
312
Sect (5)
people self-select into it because of powerful beliefs charismatic community fairly egalitarian makes big demands on your time, little less extreme than cult
313
Church (5)
bureaucratic more paperwork and organized doctrine more hierarchical, born into it, don’t self-select into it; makes less demands on you
314
Examples of sect
: pilgrims on the Mayflower, put up with the misery because they were with other people who believed
315
Ideal types
some churches have adopted sect-like behaviors (example: megachurches are bureaucratic, large cash-flower, yet simultaneously demand ecstatic displays of contract with the sacred with followers, try to get back to sect-type experience
316
In what way are sects/churches kind of like social movement organizations?
start out in coffee house/bedroom, then end up being large bureaucracy, original people think they are too complacent so maybe a cycling where successful sect has to become a church since a certain number of followers require organization, but as it becomes more churchlike they become disaffected, feel sideline, lacking from intense religious feeling.
317
Church and sect typology components (4)
Church Sect Ideal types Similarities to social movements
318
A religious sociology (3)
religious element to everything in every life Vision of religion opposite to Weber's iron Cage the sacred has always/will be around, sacred = persistent, non-material social fact;
319
The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (Durkheim)
– looked at ethnographic materials from aboriginal Australia, looked at their religious ceremonies
320
What did The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (Durkheim) note? (2)
Sacred vs. mundane Australian corroborate/totem/ritual remnants of sacred
321
Sacred vs. mundane distinction (Durkheim) - 3
something set aside from the mundane Profane everyday, humdrum stuff Universal to all religions
322
Australian corroboree
tribal gathering, religious ceremonies with dance, music, chanting and contact with the totem.
323
Totem
sacred thing for the tribe, could be a rock or a stick; ceremonies involved worshipping totem/working with it.
324
Examples of ritual in Australian corroboree
The profane had to be set aside through fasting, self-denials of food or other things in advance feel excited/had contact with higher power
325
Durkheim still thinking sacred with us today? (4)
soldier dying for flag in battle, sacred emblem of the nation, we think our nation is special people queasy at blood since it has supernatural power associated with it people who think the environment gives them contact with special powers, renewing family, law, property, the self (giving people personal space, people surrounded by little bubble of the sacred)
326
Edward Shils and Michael Young coronation study
coronation of the queen not that different from the corroboree still a ritual with a goal of national renewal, the sacred nation is affirmed by the people
327
W. Lloyd Warner. “Yankee City” study (4)
studied key rituals in annual calendar year, zeroing in on Memorial Day saw that everyone came out for it people felt sense of civic belonging and connection to the past sense of what we owe to ancestors.
328
Robert Bellah. Civil Religion in America. (2)
bit more diffuse than Christianity and Judaism; they just talk about God in Constitution, but not Christianity; God somehow chose America, people kind of believe this, major national ceremonies celebrate this, speechmakers often talk about God and American destiny.
329
Arguments for why civil religion can be good (2)
Can call upon people to be the best they can be for America to be better nation (democracy, freedom, inclusion, improvement) civil religion sets higher standard people can aim for in trying to make better country
330
Three things supporting Durkheim's "religious sociology"
coronation study "Yankee City" Civil Religion in America
331
Social determinants of health and illness (2)
health and illness map onto social inequality Tend to be poorer people and minorities
332
Things already disussed medical sociology
social determinants of health and illness
333
Health care "political economy"
19% of GDP, people involved in health and caring professors (doctors, nurses, cleaners, cooks), pharmaceutical taking up more and more of GDP since we have aging population 11% of workforce
334
Universal care systems (2)
like Canada/British National Health Service everyone pays through tax dollars, get health coverage for free
335
Why do sociologists like universal care systems? (2)
efficient, less bureaucratic overload helps poor people; the people that benefit most are people who use them a lot (older, with children, pregnant, enduring health care conditions)
336
Problems with universal care systems (2)
people who paying taxes might not get sick not great for young, single people who are robust
337
Market systems of health insurance
people pay for what they need or for health insurance
338
Disadvantges of health insurance market systems
; poor people lose out, since health care expensive, rich and poor people expected to say same for health care premium
339
Why is the U.S. a hybrid system? (3)
people over 65 have Medicaire, the population group that uses the most healthcare, so heavy users tend to be covered for free also complicated system of tax breaks for employers to provide health insurance for employees, so kind of subsidized by government; super poor people get Medicaid (emergency room treatment is free)
340
Why is U.S. system inefficient/is universal model better? (3)
have public, health sector, insurance providers; they all have different interests regarding making or saving money, so lets of bureaucratic friction; lots of government regulation, bureaucratic overload, Universal reduces bureaucratic overload
341
systems that exist cross culturally, throughout history; deeply rooted in meaningful culture and everday life
personalistic and holistic
342
Personalistic (2)
believe in curses, witchcraft, fate; you’re sick b/c someone’s mad at you, God willed it, so particular focus on cure. Cures often fusion of medicine and religion (prayer, purification rituals, might also take aspirin)
343
Holistic
focus on balance within body, example yin and yang in China, Greek’s four humors
344
Biomedicine rundown (3)
emerges as a result of modernity; strips away sets of meanings, replaces it with dispassionate, iron cage, much less personal and holistic
345
Elements of biomedicine (6)
1. belief in science, not supernatural 2. Separation of mind/body 3. standard playbook for cure 4. institutional forms of modernity 5. prestige of doctor 6. heroic medicine
346
Argues for separation of mind and body
body is series of mechanical system, chemical stuff
347
Standard playbook for cure (2)
instead of cure being adapted to who you are as a person/your social situation/life narrative mechanical fix for a mechanical system
348
Associated with institutional forms of modernity
hospitals, pharmaceutical cooperations, legal regulation of medicine, professional closure (educational credentials used by groups to seal off access to what the do, can charge more money for them)
349
Associated with prestige of doctor
so maybe healers have high status in all cultures, especially in modernity; doctors ranked highly on Wisconsin model)
350
Heroic medicine (2)
things like brain surgery, heart transplants, body scanners, high-tech equipment heroic interventions involving high levels of skill and expense are great source of status
351
Medicine taking over many aspects of social life that used to belong to communities/everyday culture
like how people became more uncomfortable with death, ti taking place in medical institutions instead
352
Takes away people’s rights to medicate/cure
legal restrictions, control
353
More and more things defined as medical problems might not actually be medical problems
the control of childbirth, used to be done by women in community; now become a medicalized thing, maybe intruding in women’s bodies, more meaningless form of childbirth
354
o Creeping goal post:
medical profession establishes something is a problem, the moves goalpost so more and more people swept up in category ex: standards for obesity seem to sweep up more than half Americans; autism and twitchy leg season (there’s a medicine for that)
355
Overmedicalization and overprescription
opioid epidemic, not looking for alternative cures
356
Interpersonal aspect
physicians bullying people and not listening to people; often alienating, 5-minute experiences
357
Institutionally
growth of pharmaceutical companies
358
Features of medical dominance (7)
1. taking over many aspects of social life used to belong to communities/everday culture 2. take away right to medicate/cure themselves 3. Overmedicalization/overprescription 3. More things defined as medical problems 4. creeping goalpost 5. interpersonal aspect 6. Institutionally
359
Foucault take on medical sociology (4)
suspicious of medicine didn’t like professions and experts (thought a vector for power over other people in our society) the medical gaze picture of objectification
360
Foucault the medical gaze
the fact that doctors look at patients, have power over them to diagnose and heal, this was authorized with birth of physician as a profession
361
Foucault picture of objectification
doctors used to try harder to understand/listen to people, now medicine become more formulaic/imposition of power
362
Marxism take on medical sociology (2)
pay differentials in medical professions: lower-status jobs get paid much less, exploitation very few people from lower-class backgrounds become surgeons role of medicine in reproducing the labor force (people are patched up so they can go back to work)
363
Feminist take on medical sociology (2)
medical system involved in oppressing ad overpolicing women/regulating their bodies Boston Women's Collective
364
Boston Women's Collective (4)
a book by female doctors and social movement many of feminists seemed to be more radical than others, maybe it imploded men medicalize women’s issues like childbirth, menstruation, breath-feeding; excuse to survey and control women political interventions counterproductive; medical technologies like birth control not well thought through
365
Two types of social movements within medicine
Illness-issue based Social justice based
366
Social justice-based medical movement example
Black Panthers (had food kitchens and medical clinics for people)
367
Social justice-based medical movement message (2)
Associate health with themes like liberation and equality arguing existing biomedical context serves affluent people
368
“Antipsychiatry (2)
movement of philosophers in 1960s, idea that many psychiatry conditions invented, people who were different/thought outside box were labelled as mentally ill mental illness diagnoses were linked to power (people who were dissidents in Eastern Block put into mental asylums)
369
Labelling theory in medical sociology
D.L. Rosenhan experiment – had people show up to mental asylums, had to say crazy things and be locked up, and then behave normally, and in no case was the person’s normality ever detected
370
What does labelling theory experiment in medical sociology show?
shows stickiness of labelled, once you are labelled as mentally ill hard to shake it off, people interpret your normal behaviors through the lens of mental illness
371
Doctor/patient interaction studies (4)
see what happens when patients mix with doctors they show doctors dominating the interaction; doctors don’t tend to listen to people, have a narrow frame for what they want to continue and want to deal exclusively with phsycial symptoms as quickly as possible higher status people get more attention, better at arguing and pushing and getting the treatment they want lower status people get bullied by doctors the most
372
Qualitative health research example
Illness narrative
373
Arthur Kleinman illness narrative (3)
whenever they’re ill, they always have stories about being ill, what was like before ill, how they became ill; whenever they get ill it’s deeply meaningful to them as a story, but medical establishment not interested in these stories unlike people from holistic/personalistic medicine when people listened to you
374
Latrogensis (2)
medical systems create problems when trying to solve them, or unintended consequences to medication; side effects and negative consequences as a result of biomedicine bleeding ulcer from medicine; might need to take more drugs to manage effects from other drugs;
375
Ordinary everday experiences in medical sociology/critical implication (3)
what’s it like to have cancer, give birth, etc.; people have different social meanings depending on social background and experiences (you lose a leg v. me losing a leg, means different things suggesting biomedicine one-size-fits-all not quite right
376
Wider cultural shifts sociology of medicine
suspicion of authority, expertise, trust. Etc. (people think they know better than experts) distrust leading institutins of U.S., eroding confidence in modern medicine/biomedicine
377
Important talking points for sociology of medicine (12)
Foucault Marxism Feminism/Boston Women's Collective Social Movements Antipsychiatry Labelling theory Latrogenesis Doctor/patient interaction Qualitative health research/illness narrative Ordinary everday experiences Wider cultural shifts
378
Public health (5)
tends to focus on populations, not individuals focuses on ways to save thousands of lives as much, wholesale not retail approach (“heroic medicine” v. “soap and water”); has focus on infrastructure (housing, clean water, sanitation); mantra is prevention is better than cure, can work with thigns in the community/try to moblize communities, thinks about social context of disease, heroic medicine saved far fewer lives than public health (typhoid in London disappeared when had clean water supplies); cheap fixes
379
* Complenetary and alternative medicine (“CAM”) (3)
accupunture, traditional Chiense/Mexican medicine, psychadelics undermining authority of biomedicine (biomedicine has struggled to deal with chronic conditions, arthritis, migraines, where CAM seems to work in many cases) the knowledge base is not scientific knowledge base, but many people use it anyway, seems to work for many people, but don’t know why scientifically
380
Internet “Dr. Google” (2)
undermining biomedical authority can look up own symptoms and medications and what their side effects are (previously would have to have medical textbooks),
381
Consumerism medical sociology (3)
linked to Dr. Google people start to shop around for medication/diagnosis they want (like in autism paper) with modernity, lots of options, referral networks play in, medical field no longer isolated, people keep going until they get what they want
382
Shifts in medical training. Cooptation or change? (2)
Medical training used to be heavily focused on science side of things today a lot more about interpersonal relationships, interaction with patients, cultural sensitivity, more exposure to community issues, MCAT has sociology component
383
Challenges to biomedicine (5)
Public health CAM Dr. Google/Internet Consumerism Shifts in medical training
384