Final Exam Flashcards
What did Roese (1994) do for experiment 1 and the results for counterfactual?
- Experiment 1: half sample do upward and other do downward and asked how events made SS feel
- Result: downward = more relief than upward, direction of counterfactual influence emotional well being (self protective function makes SS feel better about negative event)
What did Roese (1994) do for experiment 2 and the results for counterfactual?
- Experiment 2: manipulate upward and downward and ask SS to report intentions to engage in specific behavior
- Result: Upward report greater intentions to perform success facilitating behavior than downward, direction of counterfactual may have preparative function (self improvement by increase motivation to engage in behavior)
What did Roese (1994) do for experiment 3 and the results for counterfactual?
- Experiment 3: SS did anagram and got failure feedback, then asked upward or downward, then do another anagram
- Result: SS with upward improved more than downward, direction for counterfactual may result in better performance (self improvement by using knowledge for what to do better next time)
What makes counterfactual thoughts adaptive?
- Allow us to learn to be able to apply to later and gives advantage to achieving a desired or undesired outcome
- Adaptive for humans to evolve capacity to construct counterfactual thoughts to help with deal with life and survive human species
What is a counterfactual thought?
- Construct alternative to what happens in reality
When do we create counterfactual thoughts?
- In a surprising event which may help explain things and find causes for events (something you did not expect)
- In a negative event where it may help to cope with the event and future life (when something goes wrong)
What is the difference between upward and downward counterfactual thinking?
- Upward: imagine a scenario that would have resulted in a better outcome
- Downward: imagine a scenario that would have resulted in a worse outcome
What is the function of upward counterfactual thoughts?
- Preparative function: prepare for future behaviors
- Provide useful information: achieve improved outcomes later on
- May support self improvement: in terms of what is important in the future
What are the functions of downward counterfactual thoughts?
- Affective function: thinking that we could have been much worse and give sense of relief
- May elicit positive affect: relief
- Self protection: by creating scenario that could have been much worse than we experienced it, it protects our emotional well being
What are moderating factors of upward counterfactual thoughts?
- Can be uplifting if it gives hope for future improvement
- If controllable
What are moderating factors of downward counterfactual thoughts?
- Maladaptive if people have good opportunities for improvement
- If controllable downward thoughts are not useful bc need to learn from mistakes
What is regret?
- More or less painful cognitive and emotional state of feeling sorry for misfortunes, limitations, losses, transgression, shortcomings, mistakes
- Associated with negative emotions
What are the links and differences with regret and counterfactuals?
- Regret relates to upward counterfactual thoughts and also involves emotional experiences
- Regret relate to our behaviors (action or inaction) whereas counterfactual can come from many things
What are things people regret the most?
- Education, career, then romantic , parenting, your own self
What is the difference between co-omission and omission?
- Omission: regret something you did not do
- Co-omission: regret something you did
What is the type of regret that is seen as worst the most by people (inaction or action)?
- 92% of people find that co-omission leads to more regret (doing something) instead of omission (not doing anything)
What is the type of regret that is the worst long term versus short term (action or inaction)
- Short term: 76% regret action taken (co-omission) bc more salient and less malleable
- Long term: 63% regret doing inaction (omission) bc when life does not turn out the way we want it is easier to generate omissions
What are the types of emotions in regret?
- Despair emotions: feeling desperate, helpless or sorrow
- Hot emotions: feeling embarrassed, angry or irritated (short run)
- Wistful emotions: feeling sentimental, nostalgic or contemplative (long run)
What is the future opportunity principle?
- People regret most if they have opportunity in the future to undo negative consequences of the regretted behavior
- Adaptive function: elicits active attempts to change undesired state
- Regret minimized if outcome cant be changed so dissonance happens
- Regret maximized after negative outcome that can be changed
What is the lost opportunity principle?
- Previously available and now lost opportunities that elicit intense regret
- Intense regret felt if people feel they could have changed undesired outcome in past but have no more opportunity to do so
What did Bieke et al., do for their first study and results for regret?
- Ask SS to report regret that involves future opportunity and regret without future opportunity, then asked to report intensity, thought and ease of changeability
- Result: More intense regret for future with no opportunity (lost opportunity principle)
What did Bieke et al., do for their second study on regret?
- SS report greatest regret, rated intensity, past and future opportunity, closure, disappointment and responsibility of event, recency of regret
- Result: more intense regret with disappointment, how long ago it was, closure, and past opportunity
What are the effects of age for regret?
- Future opportunities declines with age
- Opportunities for undoing the consequence of regretted behaviors decline with age
- Regret intensity is the same with age
- Regret being a motivator for adaptative behavior if have good opportunities to undo regretted event (young adults)
What is self esteem?
- Relates to how much value people place on themselves
- Evaluative components of self knowledge