GS1 Flashcards
(37 cards)
I. Indian History -1.Extremists and Gandhi
Extremists and their methods wider social base national pride, vedic history swaraj different meanings for different leaders tilak -not absolute freedom, aurobondo-self rule, pal-absolute freedom. hindu-muslim division wider social base national pride, vedic history swaraj different meanings for different leaders tilak -not absolute freedom, aurobondo-self rule, pal-absolute freedom. hindu-muslim division Gandhian methods and principles critique of western civilisation involvement of women and peasants tactical-struggle and truce. experience in south africa hindu muslim unity critique of western civilisation involvement of women and peasants tactical-struggle and truce. experience in south africa hindu muslim unity Is Gandhi more radical ? Mass base more fundamental critique of british also western civilisation. method of ahimsa and swadeshi Mass base more fundamental critique of british also western civilisation. method of ahimsa and swadeshi Gandhi redefined the contemporary meaning of radicalism methods guiding principles of INM from 1920s, influenced later congress, leaders and british response to INM. redefined the contemporary meaning of radicalism methods guiding principles of INM from 1920s, influenced later congress, leaders and british response to INM.
2.GOI Act 1858
GOI act 1858 changed fundamental relations between Britain and colonial India
context
rebellion of 1857
resentment against british
corruption of company officials and backlash in britain
US independent.
technological developments in UK
second British empire
telegraph etc, british can directly see.
before the act
colonial India and east india company relation
annexation of native states (doctrine of lapse)
exploitative revenue policy
trade monopoly
charter act of 1833
end as a commercial body
governor general of india
provisions of GOI act 1858
liquidation of company
queen became the ruler of india-british colony
birtish parliament -secretary of state (MP) and accountability to british people
ICS and provision for Indians
changes brought by the act
single authority (secretary of state ) from dual government (BoC and CoD) -vigorous and steady home control
indifference and apathy of parliament after 1858-finances were not paid from british finance bill, but from indian revenues.
india office (in london ) had members from BoC and CoD -so effectively erstwhile company officials controlled matters
governor general began to become powerful
conclusion
GOi Act 1858 was an extension of the administrative reforms of British in India
Responsibility of the british parliament made indian affairs a moral and political one
gave filip to national movement
indian matters could be influenced by british public opinion
india officially became part of british colonial system
other european countries wanting land. colonialism bigger . scramble of africa, to world war 1.
context
rebellion of 1857
resentment against british
corruption of company officials and backlash in britain
US independent.
technological developments in UK
second British empire
telegraph etc, british can directly see.
before the act
colonial India and east india company relation
annexation of native states (doctrine of lapse)
exploitative revenue policy
trade monopoly
charter act of 1833
end as a commercial body
governor general of india
provisions of GOI act 1858
liquidation of company
queen became the ruler of india-british colony
birtish parliament -secretary of state (MP) and accountability to british people
ICS and provision for Indians
changes brought by the act
single authority (secretary of state ) from dual government (BoC and CoD) -vigorous and steady home control
indifference and apathy of parliament after 1858-finances were not paid from british finance bill, but from indian revenues.
india office (in london ) had members from BoC and CoD -so effectively erstwhile company officials controlled matters
governor general began to become powerful
conclusion
GOi Act 1858 was an extension of the administrative reforms of British in India
Responsibility of the british parliament made indian affairs a moral and political one
gave filip to national movement
indian matters could be influenced by british public opinion
india officially became part of british colonial system
other european countries wanting land. colonialism bigger . scramble of africa, to world war 1.
3.Constitutional reforms and indian political development
Intro
Context of political developments
Consolidation of INC
Change of leadership in INC
Moderates -extremists-gndhi
groups outside the INC
revolutionaries
muslim league and hindu maha sabha
move towards independence, parliamentary democracy with provincial units and a strong central government.
Context of political developments
Consolidation of INC
Change of leadership in INC
Moderates -extremists-gndhi
groups outside the INC
revolutionaries
muslim league and hindu maha sabha
move towards independence, parliamentary democracy with provincial units and a strong central government.
body paragraphs
morley-minto reforms
context
provisions
Morley-Minto reforms
separate electorate for muslims,increase in indian representation especially in provinces
opposition-territorial electorate,reduction of official block
Montague-Chelmsford Reforms
context
provisions -expansion of provincial legislative councils, GG’s power in centre, dyarchy, officials responsible to indian legislatures
opposition-failed promises during WW1, regressive legislations like Rowlatt Act
Government of India Act 1935
autonomy +Assertion of centre
provision for britain to intervene-WW2, GG’s powers and resignation of congress ministries.
Impact on Indian political development
response to new situations affected how INC has evolved
weakening of the moderates, extremist rise and religious turn
increased responsibility to elected officials following 1909 Act-increased importance of leaders
lead to strong executive within INC, well defined electorate and negotiations mechanisms within
imitation of 1909 Act and centralisation within INC
non-cooperation, official control over legislatures led to creation of parallel governments-INC into PCCs based on linguistic provinces
more devolution on power after 1920s by Britain,more importance to central units of INC
nehru report, secular nature of state and FRs
poona pact-anti-communal award conference of upper caste hindus
separation of congress organisation and congress ministries.
morley-minto reforms
context
provisions
Morley-Minto reforms
separate electorate for muslims,increase in indian representation especially in provinces
opposition-territorial electorate,reduction of official block
Montague-Chelmsford Reforms
context
provisions -expansion of provincial legislative councils, GG’s power in centre, dyarchy, officials responsible to indian legislatures
opposition-failed promises during WW1, regressive legislations like Rowlatt Act
Government of India Act 1935
autonomy +Assertion of centre
provision for britain to intervene-WW2, GG’s powers and resignation of congress ministries.
Impact on Indian political development
response to new situations affected how INC has evolved
weakening of the moderates, extremist rise and religious turn
increased responsibility to elected officials following 1909 Act-increased importance of leaders
lead to strong executive within INC, well defined electorate and negotiations mechanisms within
imitation of 1909 Act and centralisation within INC
non-cooperation, official control over legislatures led to creation of parallel governments-INC into PCCs based on linguistic provinces
more devolution on power after 1920s by Britain,more importance to central units of INC
nehru report, secular nature of state and FRs
poona pact-anti-communal award conference of upper caste hindus
separation of congress organisation and congress ministries.
conclusion
constitutional assembly and conservative turn of congress
congress retaining tones of british reforms
stability of union vs revolutionary aspirations
unity for fight against british + fights within the party -accommodation of diverse trends
increased role of central leadership
towards partition.
constitutional assembly and conservative turn of congress
congress retaining tones of british reforms
stability of union vs revolutionary aspirations
unity for fight against british + fights within the party -accommodation of diverse trends
increased role of central leadership
towards partition.
4.Marginalised sections and freedom struggle
Intro
Dominant view of the social situation of India
INC-separated social issues from political issues
caste, gender and class
unity and harmony of cultures
removing british is the most important and probably the first step towards independence
INM and the dominant view
INC had this view but other streams of thought also affected INM
Phule, Narayana Guru, Ambedkar, Bhagat Singh, Gandhi etc
Dalit and marginalised perspective
no meaning for independence as long as the social relations in India are changed
hence caste system has to be changed
women’s empowerment should go hand in hand with political struggle against British
adivasi land was exploited by the British and so it will be under independent India
India is deeply divided along these stratification lines
change of leadership will only make the upper caste men replacing British- white by brown -maintaining the status quo for the marginalised and dalits
INM and marginalised views
INM= a broad movement accommodating diverse voices
industrialisation vs village
primacy of caste in indian society
INM was not just against British -included debates from within also
nehru-gandhi, gandhi ambedkar
socialists in INC
tribal question -elvin v/s assimilation policy
INM -mass movement as a result of accommodation
challenges to accommodation
token representation to women, dalits and adivasis
‘others’ representing voices of the marginalised
hold of the elites in the leadership of INM
conclusion
how it shaped INM and further developments
was able to bring in the perspectives of the marginalised and bring our caste, gender and class issues to the forefront
opened debates about indian society and the evils within
affected the constitution making
reservation for Sc/ST
DPSPs
socialist emphasis
equal pay for men and women
fifth and sixth schedule.
Dominant view of the social situation of India
INC-separated social issues from political issues
caste, gender and class
unity and harmony of cultures
removing british is the most important and probably the first step towards independence
INM and the dominant view
INC had this view but other streams of thought also affected INM
Phule, Narayana Guru, Ambedkar, Bhagat Singh, Gandhi etc
Dalit and marginalised perspective
no meaning for independence as long as the social relations in India are changed
hence caste system has to be changed
women’s empowerment should go hand in hand with political struggle against British
adivasi land was exploited by the British and so it will be under independent India
India is deeply divided along these stratification lines
change of leadership will only make the upper caste men replacing British- white by brown -maintaining the status quo for the marginalised and dalits
INM and marginalised views
INM= a broad movement accommodating diverse voices
industrialisation vs village
primacy of caste in indian society
INM was not just against British -included debates from within also
nehru-gandhi, gandhi ambedkar
socialists in INC
tribal question -elvin v/s assimilation policy
INM -mass movement as a result of accommodation
challenges to accommodation
token representation to women, dalits and adivasis
‘others’ representing voices of the marginalised
hold of the elites in the leadership of INM
conclusion
how it shaped INM and further developments
was able to bring in the perspectives of the marginalised and bring our caste, gender and class issues to the forefront
opened debates about indian society and the evils within
affected the constitution making
reservation for Sc/ST
DPSPs
socialist emphasis
equal pay for men and women
fifth and sixth schedule.
- Gupta Era
Intro
arguments for gupta age as the golden age of India
economy, textile sector, gold coins , cities , literature, art and architecture flurished
revival of hinduism and gradual decline of Buddhism and Jainism started during tis period
associated with golden age during the 19th and 20th century as response to colonial rule
was gupta age golden age of India ?
differing opinions
trade showed declining trend
solidification of caste segregations
position of women lowered= exchanged for family gains and sati
feudalism and related impoverishment of land holdings for the majority
thus golden age only for the richer class and upper castes.
gupta age as golden age of sanskrit
sanskrit flourished in the Gupta empire
Prose, Lyrics, poetry, plays, and epics in sanskrit
major figures
kalidasa- abhinjalashakunthalam (play), kumarasambhavam (epic poem ), raghuvamsam (poem), malavikagnimitram (drama ) etc
vatsyayana -nyaya sutra, kama sutra
vishakadatta -mudrarakshasa ,devichandraguptam(plays)
vishnu sharma-panchatantram
magha, bharavi etc
epics- ramayana and mahabharata, smritis were given final additions. some chapters added
philosophies - samkya, yoga, nyaya, vaisheshika, mimasa, and smriti literature flourished
poetics, grammar and dictionary
mathematics, medicine, science and astrology , literature-varahamihira, brahmagupta, aryabhatta, susruta etc
Subtopic 8
arguments for gupta age as the golden age of India
economy, textile sector, gold coins , cities , literature, art and architecture flurished
revival of hinduism and gradual decline of Buddhism and Jainism started during tis period
associated with golden age during the 19th and 20th century as response to colonial rule
was gupta age golden age of India ?
differing opinions
trade showed declining trend
solidification of caste segregations
position of women lowered= exchanged for family gains and sati
feudalism and related impoverishment of land holdings for the majority
thus golden age only for the richer class and upper castes.
gupta age as golden age of sanskrit
sanskrit flourished in the Gupta empire
Prose, Lyrics, poetry, plays, and epics in sanskrit
major figures
kalidasa- abhinjalashakunthalam (play), kumarasambhavam (epic poem ), raghuvamsam (poem), malavikagnimitram (drama ) etc
vatsyayana -nyaya sutra, kama sutra
vishakadatta -mudrarakshasa ,devichandraguptam(plays)
vishnu sharma-panchatantram
magha, bharavi etc
epics- ramayana and mahabharata, smritis were given final additions. some chapters added
philosophies - samkya, yoga, nyaya, vaisheshika, mimasa, and smriti literature flourished
poetics, grammar and dictionary
mathematics, medicine, science and astrology , literature-varahamihira, brahmagupta, aryabhatta, susruta etc
Subtopic 8
conclusion
guptas contributed immensely towards arts,literature, science, and mathematics
sanskrit played the key role here and development of sanskrit reached its peak
influence of epics, shastras, and other works can still be seen.guptas carried these literature to other parts of their empire.
but the period was also marked by social inequality,economic decline and segregations. use of sanskritwas also restricted to the upper sections of the society.
guptas contributed immensely towards arts,literature, science, and mathematics
sanskrit played the key role here and development of sanskrit reached its peak
influence of epics, shastras, and other works can still be seen.guptas carried these literature to other parts of their empire.
but the period was also marked by social inequality,economic decline and segregations. use of sanskritwas also restricted to the upper sections of the society.
- Quit India movement
Intro
At the time when Japan was advancing towards colonial India and Cripps Mission had failed (8th aug , 1942)
Gandhi and INC gave call to ask the British to ‘Quit India’
opposed dragging India into WW2 and rejected the dominion status granted to India and asked for an immediate withdrawal of Britain.
Major leaders were arrested. New leaders from socialist party- Lohia, JP, Aruna Asaf Ali etc led the movement
Brutally suppressed by Britain and lakhs of people were put behind bars.
At the time when Japan was advancing towards colonial India and Cripps Mission had failed (8th aug , 1942)
Gandhi and INC gave call to ask the British to ‘Quit India’
opposed dragging India into WW2 and rejected the dominion status granted to India and asked for an immediate withdrawal of Britain.
Major leaders were arrested. New leaders from socialist party- Lohia, JP, Aruna Asaf Ali etc led the movement
Brutally suppressed by Britain and lakhs of people were put behind bars.
Body
Quit India Movement, NCM and CDM
Leadership
Absence of entire Congress LEadership-all of them were arrested within a week of the declaration
Showcased the ability of local congress leadership to guide the struggle when directives from centre were absent
Disillusionment of local leaders with Gandhian methods of Satyagraha, and non-violence especially students and youth.
Participation
Paticipation of peasants was bereft of anti-zamindari politics unlike NCM and CDM and focussed on overthrow of Britsh. New array of women leadership emerged -Asaf Ali, Klapana Joshi, Preeti Waddadar, Karnataka Barua etc
More of a spontaneous revolution across India for first time in such a scale
Had elements of violence in movement and local members equated their methods with Gandhian ideals
Sustainability
INC was also seeing its support base sinking for first time -it was a cry of a party in distress also
new dimension of grassroot politics emerged
established parallel governments
consolidated anti-british sentiments in the local level
showed competence of Indians to conduct own affairs
Sustained in Talcher (orissa, satara (maharashtra) and Midnapur (bengal)
massive use of vernacular literature pamphlets and posters
conlcusion
Quit India movement was final blow to rule of British Raj
INC as a party changed
RSS, Hindu Mahasabha and Muslim LEague became stronger
many state level leaders emerged and CPI enlarged its base
showed deviation from Gandhian path , and there were differing opinions about what Gandhi meant by ‘Do or Die’
showed the autonomy of regional political units. Involved women, students and peasants from rural India Hindu-Muslim division in National movement also reached its climax in Quit India movement. Quit India Movement, NCM and CDM Leadership Absence of entire Congress LEadership-all of them were arrested within a week of the declaration Showcased the ability of local congress leadership to guide the struggle when directives from centre were absent Disillusionment of local leaders with Gandhian methods of Satyagraha, and non-violence especially students and youth. Participation Paticipation of peasants was bereft of anti-zamindari politics unlike NCM and CDM and focussed on overthrow of Britsh. New array of women leadership emerged -Asaf Ali, Klapana Joshi, Preeti Waddadar, Karnataka Barua etc More of a spontaneous revolution across India for first time in such a scale Had elements of violence in movement and local members equated their methods with Gandhian ideals Sustainability INC was also seeing its support base sinking for first time -it was a cry of a party in distress also new dimension of grassroot politics emerged established parallel governments consolidated anti-british sentiments in the local level showed competence of Indians to conduct own affairs Sustained in Talcher (orissa, satara (maharashtra) and Midnapur (bengal) massive use of vernacular literature pamphlets and posters conlcusion Quit India movement was final blow to rule of British Raj INC as a party changed RSS, Hindu Mahasabha and Muslim LEague became stronger many state level leaders emerged and CPI enlarged its base showed deviation from Gandhian path , and there were differing opinions about what Gandhi meant by 'Do or Die' showed the autonomy of regional political units. Involved women, students and peasants from rural India Hindu-Muslim division in National movement also reached its climax in Quit India movement.
d39economic politique critique of colonial rule not social critique
intro
colonialism and indian critique
early phase, drain of wealth theory
naoroji and how britain is looting India
INC and movement towards political critique, critique of colonial governance
bhagat singh and political economy critique of colonialism
Subtopic 6
Subtopic 5
economic critique
drain of wealth, use of wealth for british benefit
trade manipulation
oppressive land revenue systems
extraction by company officials
colonialism and indian critique
early phase, drain of wealth theory
naoroji and how britain is looting India
INC and movement towards political critique, critique of colonial governance
bhagat singh and political economy critique of colonialism
Subtopic 6
Subtopic 5
economic critique
drain of wealth, use of wealth for british benefit
trade manipulation
oppressive land revenue systems
extraction by company officials
body
economic critique to political critique of colonialism
moderates of INC forwarded the economic critique initially
which soon gained traction as economic nationalism, backwardness of India is not because of internal factors but because of colonialism
related this economic loot to political rule of britain-economic essence of capitalism to colonialism
thus british are not patrons who wish to develop india but organised looters
gave filip to the political mobilisation -foreing rule cannot serve indian interests-political self determination is necessary
thus call for swaraj , self rule , dominion status and independence.
Place of social critique of Indian in the anti colonial struggle
separation of the social issues from political issues -INC’s resolution
need to accommodate landed aristocracy, local kings and domestic industrialists in the INM.
low representation of Dalits, adivasis, and women in leadership role of INM
support to british education and western value by phule, ambedkar etc
early critique of social system, from the likes of Ram Mohan Roy,was not a critique of colonialism.
conclusion
social critique, though not dominant, was also part of the colonial critique
revolutionaries talked about the oppression of the peasants and the workers at the hand of Indian landlords
gandhi extended his critique to the critique of social evils
INM adopted measures to bring in voting rights for women even when it was absent in many western countries.
temple entry movements, measures against untouchability and redistribution of wealth was also part of INM
Impact on post independent developments
affirmative action for socially disadvantaged groups
constitutional protection against social discrimination.
economic critique to political critique of colonialism
moderates of INC forwarded the economic critique initially
which soon gained traction as economic nationalism, backwardness of India is not because of internal factors but because of colonialism
related this economic loot to political rule of britain-economic essence of capitalism to colonialism
thus british are not patrons who wish to develop india but organised looters
gave filip to the political mobilisation -foreing rule cannot serve indian interests-political self determination is necessary
thus call for swaraj , self rule , dominion status and independence.
Place of social critique of Indian in the anti colonial struggle
separation of the social issues from political issues -INC’s resolution
need to accommodate landed aristocracy, local kings and domestic industrialists in the INM.
low representation of Dalits, adivasis, and women in leadership role of INM
support to british education and western value by phule, ambedkar etc
early critique of social system, from the likes of Ram Mohan Roy,was not a critique of colonialism.
conclusion
social critique, though not dominant, was also part of the colonial critique
revolutionaries talked about the oppression of the peasants and the workers at the hand of Indian landlords
gandhi extended his critique to the critique of social evils
INM adopted measures to bring in voting rights for women even when it was absent in many western countries.
temple entry movements, measures against untouchability and redistribution of wealth was also part of INM
Impact on post independent developments
affirmative action for socially disadvantaged groups
constitutional protection against social discrimination.
d43- Young Turks movement and Indian national movement
Intro
young turks movement
vouched for turkish nationalism against pan -ottoman identity
revolted for greater constitutionalism and a popular government against the ottoman sultanate
succeeded in establishing a centralised, secular legal system and promoted industrialisation
joined WW1 supported the Central powers (germany )
failed in the WW1 , but had opened debates about pan-Islamism , and Turkish nationalism
how it boosted Indian National Movement
the Pan Islamist identity dominated debates in Turkey caught the attention of the Indian Muslim Leaders
Indian muslims , pleaded the British to restore the caliphate, and the areas.
The western educated Indian muslims viewed the attack on caliphate as an attack on the idea of islam, and hence Indian muslims
Made anti-British sentiments stronger among Indian muslims, and gave boost to the Lucknow Pact of 1916 between League and INC
MAss mobilization using religious symbols worked, and it gave power to the first mass movement -NCM
Khilafat movement took up the call of Swaraj as well. Hindu Muslim unity reached its peak in many parts of India
religious division following Turkish nationalist movement and WW1
many leaders in the Khilafat movement treated it as not a movement primarily against the british , but as a religious movement thus causing fissure in the unity among Hindus and Muslim on the long term
feeling of betrayal among a section of the Muslim leaders following the unilateral withdrawal of NCM by gandhi
the unity among Indian muslims, and success of INC , created fear among the extremist Hindus and they carried propaganda
LEague also felt threatened by the reach that Khilafat-NCM gave to INC.
The extremist faction in INM was using Hindu religious symbols, Hindu Maha Sabha and League started using religion much more openly and religion took a central stage in INM.
young turks movement and its impact
brought the question of pan-islam identity and its threat to Islam to the forefront and made the Indian Muslims critical of British rule
Made the INM mass based, and gave it a pan-Indian movement
the rejection of pan-Islamism by Ataturk gave the final blow to the Indian Khilafat movement but it was successful in creating Hindu-Muslim unity at an unprecedented level
But it also sow the seeds of religious division among Indian muslims -that pan Islam identity is better than national identity -and the extremist elements in the Hindu and Muslim side used it for political gains.
young turks movement
vouched for turkish nationalism against pan -ottoman identity
revolted for greater constitutionalism and a popular government against the ottoman sultanate
succeeded in establishing a centralised, secular legal system and promoted industrialisation
joined WW1 supported the Central powers (germany )
failed in the WW1 , but had opened debates about pan-Islamism , and Turkish nationalism
how it boosted Indian National Movement
the Pan Islamist identity dominated debates in Turkey caught the attention of the Indian Muslim Leaders
Indian muslims , pleaded the British to restore the caliphate, and the areas.
The western educated Indian muslims viewed the attack on caliphate as an attack on the idea of islam, and hence Indian muslims
Made anti-British sentiments stronger among Indian muslims, and gave boost to the Lucknow Pact of 1916 between League and INC
MAss mobilization using religious symbols worked, and it gave power to the first mass movement -NCM
Khilafat movement took up the call of Swaraj as well. Hindu Muslim unity reached its peak in many parts of India
religious division following Turkish nationalist movement and WW1
many leaders in the Khilafat movement treated it as not a movement primarily against the british , but as a religious movement thus causing fissure in the unity among Hindus and Muslim on the long term
feeling of betrayal among a section of the Muslim leaders following the unilateral withdrawal of NCM by gandhi
the unity among Indian muslims, and success of INC , created fear among the extremist Hindus and they carried propaganda
LEague also felt threatened by the reach that Khilafat-NCM gave to INC.
The extremist faction in INM was using Hindu religious symbols, Hindu Maha Sabha and League started using religion much more openly and religion took a central stage in INM.
young turks movement and its impact
brought the question of pan-islam identity and its threat to Islam to the forefront and made the Indian Muslims critical of British rule
Made the INM mass based, and gave it a pan-Indian movement
the rejection of pan-Islamism by Ataturk gave the final blow to the Indian Khilafat movement but it was successful in creating Hindu-Muslim unity at an unprecedented level
But it also sow the seeds of religious division among Indian muslims -that pan Islam identity is better than national identity -and the extremist elements in the Hindu and Muslim side used it for political gains.
d51- revolutionaries and freedom struggle
Intro
revolutionaries in Indian freedom struggle
disillusionment with the methods of the moderates and failure of extremists to bring in any real change
Gandhian methods were considered as a way forward but the abrupt withdrawal of NCM led to dissatisfaction
Anushilan Samiti in Bengal, India House in London, HRA (later Hindustan Socialist Republican Association ) were hub of revolutionary activities.
Members of these organisations as well as independent activists , believed that armed struggle against the British rule is the way forward.
they were crushed by the British but had significant impact on the INM during the 20th century
revolutionaries in Indian freedom struggle
disillusionment with the methods of the moderates and failure of extremists to bring in any real change
Gandhian methods were considered as a way forward but the abrupt withdrawal of NCM led to dissatisfaction
Anushilan Samiti in Bengal, India House in London, HRA (later Hindustan Socialist Republican Association ) were hub of revolutionary activities.
Members of these organisations as well as independent activists , believed that armed struggle against the British rule is the way forward.
they were crushed by the British but had significant impact on the INM during the 20th century
body
Philosophy of the revolutionaries
varied with each organisation and leadership
all of them believed that armed struggle and violence be a means for fighting the british
Reasons for violence varied from individual brutality of british officers to british policies to revenge on governmental repression to violence as a means to attract attention
Chapekar brothers aimed at the actions of Gen.Rand in Pune, PRafullaChowki, Khudiram Bose aimed un unpopular magistrate.,Rash Behari Bose aimed at Lord HArdinge, Surya Sen aimed at establishing a parallel governance machinery, Bhagat Singh aimed at British Imperialism and capitalism through violence
Organisations like HSRA and revolutionaries like Bhagat Singh related british colonialism with capitalism and gave a deeper critique of colonialism than his contemporary freedom fighters in INC and outside.
they pointed out at the limits of the methods of their contemporaries and attracted a whole generation of youth into INM.
they revealed the contradictions in British liberalism-freedom at home at the cost of brutal suppressions abroad.
at the same time excessive violence alienated people and gave legitimacy to brutal suppression by the British.
Bose and INA sided with Fascists during WW2 and could not see the racism and genocidal tendency of the axis powers
Philosophy of the revolutionaries
varied with each organisation and leadership
all of them believed that armed struggle and violence be a means for fighting the british
Reasons for violence varied from individual brutality of british officers to british policies to revenge on governmental repression to violence as a means to attract attention
Chapekar brothers aimed at the actions of Gen.Rand in Pune, PRafullaChowki, Khudiram Bose aimed un unpopular magistrate.,Rash Behari Bose aimed at Lord HArdinge, Surya Sen aimed at establishing a parallel governance machinery, Bhagat Singh aimed at British Imperialism and capitalism through violence
Organisations like HSRA and revolutionaries like Bhagat Singh related british colonialism with capitalism and gave a deeper critique of colonialism than his contemporary freedom fighters in INC and outside.
they pointed out at the limits of the methods of their contemporaries and attracted a whole generation of youth into INM.
they revealed the contradictions in British liberalism-freedom at home at the cost of brutal suppressions abroad.
at the same time excessive violence alienated people and gave legitimacy to brutal suppression by the British.
Bose and INA sided with Fascists during WW2 and could not see the racism and genocidal tendency of the axis powers
Conclusion
While some of the revolutionaries had progressive philosophies to guide their actions , not all shared similar critique of colonialism.
some of them went to the extend of supporting colonial government and proposing that muslims and other minorities were the real enemies.
most of them acted on individual capacity and did not connect with the masses and hence did not derive support during their active phase.
their activities put pressure on the INC and its leaders to press for freedom and popularised anti colonial struggle across India.
While some of the revolutionaries had progressive philosophies to guide their actions , not all shared similar critique of colonialism.
some of them went to the extend of supporting colonial government and proposing that muslims and other minorities were the real enemies.
most of them acted on individual capacity and did not connect with the masses and hence did not derive support during their active phase.
their activities put pressure on the INC and its leaders to press for freedom and popularised anti colonial struggle across India.
II.World History-World War 1
First World War and fall of ottoman empire
WW 1 context
involved France, Britain,Russia , Serbia etc on one side and Germany, Hungary,Italy, and Turkey on other side
major reasons include
imperialism, nationalism, militarism, defence alliances etc
Immediate reason was the murder of Archduke Franz Ferdinand by a Serbian nationalist and imperial attitude of Austria-Hungary
Imperialist expansion of europe in 119th and 20th century
new imperialism and scramble for africa
industrial revolution-raw materials, labor and market
german and italian nationalisms and aspirations to become a colonial power
Britian france and russian empires
fall of ottoman empire
eastern question
crimean war-british and french expansion to russian expansion
european banking-german involvement in politics and interest of france
controlling balkan regions
russia moved closer to Britain and France following Germany’s step to put Bosnia and Herzegovina under Austria following its independence from Ottoman
Interest of European Nations over Ottoman Empires
Tilting of balance of power that Ottoman maintained
conclusion
formation of new nation states
turkey, saudi, yemen, lebanon etc
nationalist uprising against imperialism
india, egypt etc
imperialist agenda of european powers and seeds for WW2
humiliation of germany
revolution in Russia
WW 1 context
involved France, Britain,Russia , Serbia etc on one side and Germany, Hungary,Italy, and Turkey on other side
major reasons include
imperialism, nationalism, militarism, defence alliances etc
Immediate reason was the murder of Archduke Franz Ferdinand by a Serbian nationalist and imperial attitude of Austria-Hungary
Imperialist expansion of europe in 119th and 20th century
new imperialism and scramble for africa
industrial revolution-raw materials, labor and market
german and italian nationalisms and aspirations to become a colonial power
Britian france and russian empires
fall of ottoman empire
eastern question
crimean war-british and french expansion to russian expansion
european banking-german involvement in politics and interest of france
controlling balkan regions
russia moved closer to Britain and France following Germany’s step to put Bosnia and Herzegovina under Austria following its independence from Ottoman
Interest of European Nations over Ottoman Empires
Tilting of balance of power that Ottoman maintained
conclusion
formation of new nation states
turkey, saudi, yemen, lebanon etc
nationalist uprising against imperialism
india, egypt etc
imperialist agenda of european powers and seeds for WW2
humiliation of germany
revolution in Russia
d32-French revolution and rise of nationalism
French Revolution
Replaced ancient regime characterised by feudal relationships and raised motto of liberty, equality and fraternity
created french nation-with a sense of common heritage and imagination of a community
Nationalism
feeling of nation-hood , devotion to interest of a nation (characterised by territory, people, government and sovereignity)
power from monarchy to the citizens
began to rise throughout the world following French Revolution, 1789
French revolution and nationalism
created a sense of collective identity among people of France
fatherland, citizenship, national flag, election to assembly, national songs and french language
celebrated individuality and its virtues
equality and liberty- change of status of people from being subjects of king to equal right bearing citizens
fraternity - brotherhood between people of various social groups and imagination of a shared community
equated despotism with feudal world order and produced literature that exalted the virtues of nation-state
french army and sense of nationalisms abroad
feeling of nation-hood , devotion to interest of a nation (characterised by territory, people, government and sovereignity)
power from monarchy to the citizens
began to rise throughout the world following French Revolution, 1789
Replaced ancient regime characterised by feudal relationships and raised motto of liberty, equality and fraternity
created french nation-with a sense of common heritage and imagination of a community
Napolean , French Revolution and rise of nationalism across Europe
Made use of institutions of modern nationalism - a modern army, efficient administration, dynamic economy, abolition of feudalism etc
conquered almost all of Europe and extended Napoleonic code to all the conquered lands
overall improvement in trade, economic activities and poverty across administered terriories
uniform standards contributed to the rise of business class who supported nationalism in their own territories.
spirit of french revolution created aspirations in the conquered lands and national imaginations emerged in these areas.Businessman and monarchs found nationalism more useful than feudal order for their cause
eg: of Italy, germany etc
created a sense of collective identity among people of France
fatherland, citizenship, national flag, election to assembly, national songs and french language
celebrated individuality and its virtues
equality and liberty- change of status of people from being subjects of king to equal right bearing citizens
fraternity - brotherhood between people of various social groups and imagination of a shared community
equated despotism with feudal world order and produced literature that exalted the virtues of nation-state
french army and sense of nationalisms abroad
Made use of institutions of modern nationalism - a modern army, efficient administration, dynamic economy, abolition of feudalism etc
conquered almost all of Europe and extended Napoleonic code to all the conquered lands
overall improvement in trade, economic activities and poverty across administered terriories
uniform standards contributed to the rise of business class who supported nationalism in their own territories.
spirit of french revolution created aspirations in the conquered lands and national imaginations emerged in these areas.Businessman and monarchs found nationalism more useful than feudal order for their cause
eg: of Italy, germany etc
conclusion
french revolution contributed to the philosophy and practice of nationalism across Europe and the world..
Colonies began to aspire for independent nations-a political entity ruled by native population
nationalism has many manifestations -democracy, state , socialism, fascism, authoritarianism
spirit of revolution has been incorporated in almost all world constitutions, including India.
french revolution contributed to the philosophy and practice of nationalism across Europe and the world..
Colonies began to aspire for independent nations-a political entity ruled by native population
nationalism has many manifestations -democracy, state , socialism, fascism, authoritarianism
spirit of revolution has been incorporated in almost all world constitutions, including India.
Industrial revolution and colonialism mutually aiding
Industrial revolution
The revolutionary change in production process and output owing to a shift from agrarian, small scale sector to one dominated by industry and manufacturing
from 18th c, from britain to other parts of Europe
brought in technological, socio economic and cultural changes
colonialism
practice of domination , which involves subjugation of one people to another
as a practice existed throughout history but the European political domination from 16th to 20th century was peculiar because of the technological developments in navigation that connected more remote parts and scale and range of it.
Industrial revolution’s contribution to colonialism
manufacturing output of world increased 24 times from 18th to 20th century , concentrated in a small sets of countries
this surplus contributed to further development in technology, and demanded to find raw materials and new markets for finished goods
advancement in technology , navigation , transportation , communications, military and modern trade practices meant that European powers were at an advantageous position to conquer others
Improved productivity in European countries made their goods cheaper, and colonies domestic markets became dependent on them
the wealth of European countries gave social and moral superiority to the colonisers over the colonial subjects
colonialism contribution towards industrial revolution
provided necessary raw materials and a market for finished goods
drain of wealth from colonies provided the capital for further development in technological development
provided for cheap labour for producing surplus (in countries like US)
quest for new colonies and potential revenue from them pushed rulers of European countries to invest more in technological developments
Subtopic 5
conclusion
Britian, Belgium were early, France and GErmany followed
coincided with deindustrialisation of colonies and made them dependent on colonial masters for technology and products
even after end of colonial rule , erstwhile colonies acted as markets and source of raw materials.
highly uneven distribution of wealth in world can be related with how colonialism and industrial revolution unfolded in last two centuries
Britian, Belgium were early, France and GErmany followed
coincided with deindustrialisation of colonies and made them dependent on colonial masters for technology and products
even after end of colonial rule , erstwhile colonies acted as markets and source of raw materials.
practice of domination , which involves subjugation of one people to another
as a practice existed throughout history but the European political domination from 16th to 20th century was peculiar because of the technological developments in navigation that connected more remote parts and scale and range of it.
The revolutionary change in production process and output owing to a shift from agrarian, small scale sector to one dominated by industry and manufacturing
from 18th c, from britain to other parts of Europe
brought in technological, socio economic and cultural changes
manufacturing output of world increased 24 times from 18th to 20th century , concentrated in a small sets of countries
this surplus contributed to further development in technology, and demanded to find raw materials and new markets for finished goods
advancement in technology , navigation , transportation , communications, military and modern trade practices meant that European powers were at an advantageous position to conquer others
Improved productivity in European countries made their goods cheaper, and colonies domestic markets became dependent on them
the wealth of European countries gave social and moral superiority to the colonisers over the colonial subjects
provided necessary raw materials and a market for finished goods
drain of wealth from colonies provided the capital for further development in technological development
provided for cheap labour for producing surplus (in countries like US)
quest for new colonies and potential revenue from them pushed rulers of European countries to invest more in technological developments
Subtopic 5
highly uneven distribution of wealth in world can be related with how colonialism and industrial revolution unfolded in last two centuries
III.Art and Culture-D29-6th C BC and religious reform movements
Intro
Religious reform movements in 6th C BCE
movements away from Brahmin superiority during later vedic times
52 different sects;Buddhism and Jainism -major examples
Emphasis less on rituals and caste purity
Emphasis on action, speech, livelihood, effort and other material domains of human society.
Second urbanisation
rise of urban centres in the Indo-Gangetic planes during 6th C BCE
movement of Indo-Aryan groups into Gangetic Planes, with iron rods
Agrarian economy- trade economy
Rise of rulers, various professional classes and trade networks
increased production, surplus, and importance of cattle in sustaining agricultural base
second urbanisation and religious reform movements
rise of urban centres, trading communities demanded that existing social relations be changed
demanded recongnition and status for groups engaged in trading -break from vedic tradition
maintaining of trade networks-strong rulers, hence importance of Kshatriya class over Brahmin class
increased importance of agriculture to support urban centres -importance of cattle- ritual sacrifice needed to be cut down-non violence
urbanisation -need for peace-philosophies that emphasised brotherhood and materiality
increased importance of political over religious
conclusion
urbanisation and religious reform movements mutually reinforced each other
further developments in development of centralising states and religious movements
eg: how the rise of Mauryan empire coincided with religious reforms and urbanisation
contribution towards arts and architecture.
eg: Gandhara school of art.
d47-buddhism and jainism philosophy rituals
introduction
buddhism and jainism-philosophies
emphasise on the material world humans live in, the actions and karma of humans are decisive, and place human action at the centre of their philosophy
roleof gurus who are models, and hence whose path can be followed
presence of soul in all human beings/other life forms brings in equality as a fundamental feature
validity , and presence of clergy for guiding people and rejection of a creator God
different from later-vedic religion , which emphasised on strict social code and rituals for satisfying gods , in terms of all these aspects
later-vedic period
marked by the religious controls of the Brahmins, and the social rigidity that their religion emphasised.
placed limits of free movement of social groups and interaction between members of caste groups
women’s freedom was curtailed and strict monogamy with male head of the family became the norm
emphasis on ritual sacrifice of animals, especially cattle
power of religious over the political-priestly class’s superiority over political class.
changes that Buddhism and Jainism brought about
empahsised on non-violence , renunciated ritual sacrifice and rejected the primacy of the priestly class
emphasised on equality - between man/woman, different social groups/occupations and human/nature
rejection of god and acceptance of gurus >temples, images, monasteries, etc as sites of religion >new forms of art and architecture.
used local languages -pali, magadhi etc , which the common people also used thus enriching these languages and making religious discussions a part of everyday life
empahsis on peace and non-violence and missionary character of buddhism and jainism- support for ruling class, and getting support from ruling class
conclusion
the emphasis on materiality, human action and sense of equality was synchronous with the economic and political developments of the times
mauryan empire (especially ashoka ) was greatly influenced by Buddhist teachings and this contributed to the art , literature, and architecture of the times
following the decline of Buddhism and Jainism, the orthodoxy of the Vedic religion returns , and so is the reduced status of women and rigidity of caste structure.
IV.Post Independence-Reservation policies of 1990s
mandal commission reforms
27 % in central services and public undertakings
identified castes based on social educational and economic backwardness
more than 50% of indian belonged to BC and are poorly represented in administration
had a significant impact on polity and played a major role along with market and masjid to change trajectory of India during 1990s.
created political consciousness among BCs( anti-mandal agitations)
emergence of parties like SP and RJD
impact on dalit politics and emergence of BSP-social engineering politics
represenation in institutions and formation of elites and intellectuals
d44-Emergency 1975, mainstreaming debates about civil liberties
introduction
emergency of 1975
Indira Gandhi declared internal emergency in 1975 using article 352, citing internal disturbance
fundamental rights that guaranteed liberty to the citizens-art 14,19, 21 and 22 were suspended
there was widespread political repression, large scale arrest of opposition leaders, censoring media and state violence
SC had declared that FRs will get eclipsed and Habeas Corpus cannot be filled during emergency
38th Constitutional Amendment act had given overriding power to President to declare emergency
emergency of 1975
Civil liberty and internal emergency India had a long history of the fight for civil liberties from time of INM It was assumed that independent India will foster civil liberties and secure rights of Indians Emergency declaration in 1975 and related atrocities shook the foundations of this assumption Indians realised the built in authorianism in indian democracy and need to strenghten non governmental civil society and ensure separation of powers Rajan case in kerala, forced sterilization campaigns,arresting editors of newspapers and heavy hand of police Courts and executive became agents of the government Emergency gave rise to a wave of political and social movements across kerala opposition to congress rule and formation of organisation like PUCL 44th Amendment Act made it difficult for another proclamation of emergency internal disturbance was replaced by armed rebellion article 19,20 and 21 will not get suspended cabinet nod in writing will be needed gave rise to a strong civil society, armed with judicial overview,to check the unmitigated power of the government
conclusion
legacy of emergency and struggle for civil liberties
was seen in J&K, Punjab, North East India, Central India;fight against TADA,POTA, AFSPA etc.
Now the slogans which derived from anti-emergency movements have given boost to fight the rights of the Adivasis, Dalits, Women and Muslims if the country who are on the other side of the state with respect to development
It has made extensive use of PILs to check the overeach of the government,and movements vouch for judicial accountability as well.
The democratic consciousness that Emergency instilled among Indian people can be seen their everyday struggle against injustice and oppression.
legacy of emergency and struggle for civil liberties
d41-social movements of 1970s and 1980s and their impact
Context of the social movements on 1970s and 80s
mostly environmental movements, which included social issues of exclusion,eviction, marginalisation, and priorities of the state
values of the freedom movement was being replaced by values of industrialisation and commercialisation
Silent Valley in Kerala, Chipko, Narmada Bachao Andolan, Namantar Andolan in Maharashtra were the notable movements
Saw the participation of civil society, local people and garnered attention throughout the world
Criticised as movements stopping the developmental state from achieving its objectives
Body
social movements’ perspective on development
questioned development at the cost of local people, indigenous knowledge, environmental destruction, social impact and large scale eviction of tribals.
questioned the primacy of the state in formulating policies which have long term consequences on the local population
offered alternative models on development, and put forward people’s plan , and forced state machinery to recognise local culture, and social context
how they helped development to be inclusive
acted as pressure groups to change developmental paths
contributed towards the drafting of rights based laws-RTE,RTI, FRA,MGNREGa
contributed towards making social and environmental impact studies a necessary condition for mega projects
deepened the democratic processes in India and gave voices to the excluded
rehabilitation and compensation to local people
Land acquisition and rehabilitation bill
social movements’ perspective on development
conclusion
legacies of these movements in the later decades
anti-nuclear power plant struggle , struggle against multi-national companies like Coca-Cola , power to Gram sabhas to decide developmental route and attention of media and judiciary ensured
changes in discourse of independent India from big industrial/manufacturing sector to small and medium enterprises.
development relevant to the local population became a mantra that states can no longer ignore
rehabilitation and compensatory packages are parts of any developmental projects now
still role to play to further these causes.
V.Society-Social reform movements
19th c was marked by presence of many reform movements aimed at reforming indian society in general and hindu religion in particular.
arya samaj, brahmo samaj, prarthana samaj, theosophical society,
ram mohan roy, debendranath tagore, sen, vidyasagar, phule etc
influenced by english education, western and indian literature.
Reform within caste
Reform of Hindu family , without affective relative hierarchy of various castes in Indian society and altering boundaries between castes.
Reform of caste system : abolition of caste system, breaking superiority of brahmins and inferiority of dalits.
what did reforms do in 19th c
aimed at widow remarriage , abolition of sati, prohibition of child marriage, intercaste marriage, fight against untouchability,education of lower castes
all of them are aimed at hindu family restructuring within each caste-upper caste response to enlightenment rationality and western morality
while aimed at lower castes, emphasis not on breaking ritual purity of Brahmins but on ‘lifting; lower castes to the level of upper caste-no change in relative position
Exceptions of efforts like phule-reform as social and political
conclusion
many of the reforms were not aimed at structural change
Political reform -INC got seperated from social reform
but they contributed to later developments
movements like temple entry, ambedkar’s rise could be attributed to 19th c reforms.
Ambedkar idea about political freedom
Role that the constitution would play in independent India
Social revolution and political freedom
social relations have to be altered for political freedom to have meaning. so what does transfer of power mean ?
critique of indian national movement
INM and INC as separating social reform from political reform and keeping it as a ‘separate ‘ aim
Political freedom’s meaning for Ambedkar
transfer of political power from British masters to Indian masters
sovereignity
formal equality between all citizens
conditions of the social
caste system-unchallenged
hierarchy and not equality marks citizens
continued oppression and socially privileged enjoying political privilege
INM and INC as separating social reform from political reform and keeping it as a ‘separate ‘ aim
social relations have to be altered for political freedom to have meaning. so what does transfer of power mean ?
caste system-unchallenged
transfer of political power from British masters to Indian masters
sovereignity
formal equality between all citizens
hierarchy and not equality marks citizens
continued oppression and socially privileged enjoying political privilege
examples in india
fruits of political freedom still out of reach of the marginalised
under representation in all walks of public life
discrimination- overt and covert
all the menial job still performed by caste groups
high proportion of upper castes relative to their population in positions of power
atrocities against dalits
has been increasing over the years
universities becoming sites of violence
decreasing social security measures and impact on dalits
from physical violence-symbolic ,social and cultural violence and exclusion
conclusion
evidence of meaninglessness of political freedom in the light of social segregation
use as mere vote banks
fundamental changes in social relations are needed
increasing representation and political power in the hands of the marginalised.
fruits of political freedom still out of reach of the marginalised
under representation in all walks of public life
discrimination- overt and covert
all the menial job still performed by caste groups
high proportion of upper castes relative to their population in positions of power
atrocities against dalits
has been increasing over the years
universities becoming sites of violence
decreasing social security measures and impact on dalits
from physical violence-symbolic ,social and cultural violence and exclusion
conclusion
evidence of meaninglessness of political freedom in the light of social segregation
use as mere vote banks
fundamental changes in social relations are needed
increasing representation and political power in the hands of the marginalised.
Religious fundamentalism and communalism
there is a strong tendency , both in mainstream media,politics and academic scholarship , to equate religious fundamentalism to communalism , thereby blurring the clear distinction between them
because fundamentalism and communalism have certain ideological elements in common
attach concept of separation of religion from politics and state
oppose the concept of equal truth in all religions or the unity of different religions
advocate control over education by followers of dominant religion
oppose secularism and believe that it corrupts society.
differences
in multireligious society fundamentalist tends to be communal while communalists are quite often not fundamentalists
eg: India right wing parties, subscribe to various religions are communal parties but not fundamentalist.
fundamentalists seriously urge the actual revival of the pristine past
communalists who may appeal to past as ideology or nostalgia but whose gaze is clearly fixed on modern world.
former are deeply religious, their entire ideology relates to religion and they want to base the state and society on religion
communalists hardly much to do with religion, except they base their politics on religious identity.
communal state not necessarily a theocratic state.
eg:pakistan and bangladesh declared as islamic states are communal states not theocratic states.
fundamentlists want to islamize or hinduise the world
communalists want to communalize and can only communalize their own society.
attach concept of separation of religion from politics and state
oppose the concept of equal truth in all religions or the unity of different religions
advocate control over education by followers of dominant religion
oppose secularism and believe that it corrupts society.
in multireligious society fundamentalist tends to be communal while communalists are quite often not fundamentalists
eg: India right wing parties, subscribe to various religions are communal parties but not fundamentalist.
fundamentalists seriously urge the actual revival of the pristine past
communalists who may appeal to past as ideology or nostalgia but whose gaze is clearly fixed on modern world.
former are deeply religious, their entire ideology relates to religion and they want to base the state and society on religion
communalists hardly much to do with religion, except they base their politics on religious identity.
communal state not necessarily a theocratic state.
eg:pakistan and bangladesh declared as islamic states are communal states not theocratic states.
fundamentlists want to islamize or hinduise the world
communalists want to communalize and can only communalize their own society.
communalits have not only not been fundamentalists but not have even been religious . eg>M.A jinnah, or liaqat ali khan not religous. V D savarkar, atheist.
Caste issues
Khap Panchayats
for intercaste and inter religious marriage
shows social milieu under sway of medieval minded.
2011 SC told Khaps as kangaroo courts , declared them illegal and wanted them to be stamped out.
current
eg: murder of ankit saxena, who was in love with a muslim girl
family choosing violence over perceived dishonour caused by an inter-religious relationship.
harassment, social boycott, discrimination or incitement to violence.
Solution
social transformation or legislative change
for intercaste and inter religious marriage
shows social milieu under sway of medieval minded.
2011 SC told Khaps as kangaroo courts , declared them illegal and wanted them to be stamped out.
current
eg: murder of ankit saxena, who was in love with a muslim girl
family choosing violence over perceived dishonour caused by an inter-religious relationship.
harassment, social boycott, discrimination or incitement to violence.
Solution
social transformation or legislative change
2. Reservation demand by dominant castes(d23)
is it because of globalization ?
intro
demand for reservations
jats in haryana, patidars in gujarat, marathas in maharashtra, gujjars in rajasthan, kapus in AP
demand reservation for their castes, or inclusion in the OBC/SC/ST list of the centre or the respective states
all these castes are the dominant castes in terms of landholding or hierarchcial position in the caste dynamics
hailing from states which made use of green revolution and technological interventions in agriculture
impact of globalisation on these castes
rural elites -impact due to shift from agriculture to service economy
increasing inequality between rural and urban india
neglect of agriculutral sector by the state and emphasis on export orientation
technological input -benefit to richer sections of the dominant castes only
inability of local business communities to complete with multinational companies
urbanisation and skills required in urban economy
education, english and technical skills.
Improvement of the plight of the others in caste hierarchy
upper castes in cities -made use of urban exposure. inability of dominant castes to compete with them (english as a major filtering factor )
lower castes-benefitted from reservation policies. so poor among the dominant are lagging behind the affluent OBCs and Dalits
growth without employment and uncertainity in informal sector
poor working condition and pay in private sector
lack of jobs from ‘mega projects’
entry barrier in business and other sectors due to caste dynamics (jats for eg;)
how do the dominant caste connect their plight to reservations ?
it could give them access to publicly funded educational institutions and guarantee jobs in public sector
address their historical neglect of education
can make them competitive with other upper castes, address rural/urban division and maintain caste superiority with lower castes
security of formal sector
also points towards abolition of resevations to increase their chances vis-a-vis the OBCs and Dalits seen as a method to turn the focus away from class divisions within caste conclusion only a fraction of the dominant castes are lagging in socio-economic terms w.r.t OBCs or SC/STs govt jobs account for only a very small portion of total jobs reservation is unviable and cannot cover for all of social and economic issues movement away from constitutional objective of affirmative action focus on rural employability , farm and agricultural sector, MSME sector which gives more jobs-increase credits and support. is it because of globalization ? intro demand for reservations jats in haryana, patidars in gujarat, marathas in maharashtra, gujjars in rajasthan, kapus in AP demand reservation for their castes, or inclusion in the OBC/SC/ST list of the centre or the respective states all these castes are the dominant castes in terms of landholding or hierarchcial position in the caste dynamics hailing from states which made use of green revolution and technological interventions in agriculture impact of globalisation on these castes rural elites -impact due to shift from agriculture to service economy increasing inequality between rural and urban india neglect of agriculutral sector by the state and emphasis on export orientation technological input -benefit to richer sections of the dominant castes only inability of local business communities to complete with multinational companies urbanisation and skills required in urban economy education, english and technical skills. Improvement of the plight of the others in caste hierarchy upper castes in cities -made use of urban exposure. inability of dominant castes to compete with them (english as a major filtering factor ) lower castes-benefitted from reservation policies. so poor among the dominant are lagging behind the affluent OBCs and Dalits growth without employment and uncertainity in informal sector poor working condition and pay in private sector lack of jobs from 'mega projects' entry barrier in business and other sectors due to caste dynamics (jats for eg;) how do the dominant caste connect their plight to reservations ? it could give them access to publicly funded educational institutions and guarantee jobs in public sector address their historical neglect of education can make them competitive with other upper castes, address rural/urban division and maintain caste superiority with lower castes security of formal sector also points towards abolition of resevations to increase their chances vis-a-vis the OBCs and Dalits seen as a method to turn the focus away from class divisions within caste conclusion only a fraction of the dominant castes are lagging in socio-economic terms w.r.t OBCs or SC/STs govt jobs account for only a very small portion of total jobs reservation is unviable and cannot cover for all of social and economic issues movement away from constitutional objective of affirmative action focus on rural employability , farm and agricultural sector, MSME sector which gives more jobs-increase credits and support.
Women issues
discrmination because of absence of unified voice
context
social
discrimination within the family
female foeticide and sex ratio
disciplining and policing
economic
feminisation of poverty
lack of inheritance rights
wage gap
political
absence from decision making bodies
low representation
constitutional protection
Art 14- right to equality
art 15-right against discrimination
art 39-equal pay for work
art 44-uniform civil code
fundamental duty- humanism and the spirit of reform.
but most of the se safeguards are often ignored or blatantly violated
can it be attributed to the lack of unified voice of women ?
divergent views among women
entry into religious places
uniform civil code
opposition to reservations
procedures about sexual harassment-recent naming and shaming incident
reasons for the lack of unified voice
low levels of awareness
poor economic development
long history of discrimination and deprivation
lack of support from family and society for progressive women
leadership issues
caste, religion, region and ethnic divisions.
conclusion
to an extend it can be concluded that lack of unified voice is a reason
historically women were never a homogenous group
often used as instruments for caste, religious or ethnic means
carried the honour of communities -limiting their freedom substantially
empowerment of women is an end in itself and also a means to the inclusive and developmental end.
Regionalism-subnationalism
tendency of people belonging to a region (geographic , linguistic or ethnic ) to identify with regional identities and interests than national identities
has been equated with secessionism, disintegration, and something which rejects sovereignity of nation
also as people’s political aspiration to preserve their culture , language, resources and region
can arise out of neglect from the nation or rise of strong regional identity markers
eg: J&K, north eastern states, karnataka, tamil nadu, khalistan, maratha nationalism
benefits of subnationalism
what does sub nationalism create ?
common regional identity -sense of pride and belonginess to the region and the people
sense of duty and commitment
positive measures towards progress and development
case of kerala, tamil nadu, karnataka etc in india
direct correlation between social development indicators and growth of regionalism
promotes co-operative federalism, and binds diverse identities within sub-nationalist imaginations -contributes to the stability of indian federalism and union.
more decentralisation and involvement of people’s movements in policies - move away from centrally conceived schemes
further deepening of democratic accountability mechanisms
also hampers majoritarian tendencies and unitary tendencies of indian state-more power to people than central administrative systems.
conclusion
sub-nationalism if not violent or secessionist, contributes to national interest
caused by marginalisation of a particular culture, language, ethnicity, or region by the cenre
eg:Tamil, kannada, maratha, ne etc
maintains plurality and contributes to diversity
but violent tendencies need to be checked and measures should be taken so that sub-nationalist tendencies find it ill-conceivable to leave indian union
d38-multiculturalism in India
Intro
Multiculturalism
coexistence of different cultures in the same geographical space.
a policy aimed at protecting cultural diversity and ensuring that minority cultures are protected and given equal share of importance.
follows the idea that cultural identities are relevant and important to people , and the state ought to protect and nourish them.
has existed throughout history-greece, ancient india , ottoman sultanate and Mughal India
but in a democracy it achieves special meaning.
multiculturalism -contestations across the world
comes into conflict with xenophobia , racism, religious fundamentalism, ethnic politics, autocracy
eg: Middle eastern countries, european countries, countries from Africa, (sudan , somalia etc), US
strict definition of secularism /atheirsm
france, china etc
backlash and sense of alienation from minority communities
case of India
from ancient to modern times
indo-aryan settlers to modern india-different cultural groups have made india their home.
rulers from ashoka to democratic India have respected and protected diverse faiths , ethnic groups , castes and religions , did not try to impose one culture over other
communities have coexisted and depended on each other
dependency one reason why everyone could exist each other.
various fatihs, saints, food habits, and festivals are common to many different cultural groups- onam, holi, dargas, chistis, case of sabarmala in kerala etc
case of modern indian union and constitution
indian definition of secularism,and constitutional protection of minorities, idea of fraternity in the preamble
no special treatment for majority religion, and emphasis on plurality
federal units are also culturally diverse within themselves.
conclusion
multiculturalism has helped maintain unity in India inspite of various diversities
but challenges exist as groups force homogenous identities over diverse population and groups
debate about use of Hindi, caste-Hindu symbols, and increasing atrocitires and alienation of minorities.
education, and cultivation of the feeling of brotherhood towards others are important.