HIST 123 Quiz 3 Flashcards
What was Smallpox in the 18th Century?
- 1/3 of all childhood deaths in 17th and 18th c. Europe from smallpox
- Feared also because of scarring it produced
- Example: Chester, England — 1774
- 1200 cases out of a population of 14,700
- 202 deaths
- Affected people of all ranks:
- eg. King William III of England lost his father, mother, and wife all to smallpox in the later 17th century; Emperor Highashiyama of Japan died 1710, aged 34.
- Smallpox went from milder to more virulent in medieval England → increased in severity in 17th and 18th centuries.
- Fear of smallpox laid in potential of mortality and scarring
- when you got the disease you would get the pustules on face and hands and elsewhere and it would leave severe scars
What was Smallpox Like in Chester, England
- 1774
- 1200 cases out of a population of 14,700
- 202 deaths
- Affected people of all ranks:
- eg. King William III of England lost his father, mother, and wife all to smallpox in the later 17th century; Emperor Highashiyama of Japan died 1710, aged 34.
- Smallpox went from milder to more virulent in medieval England → increased in severity in 17th and 18th centuries.
- Fear of smallpox laid in potential of mortality and scarring
- when you got the disease you would get the pustules on face and hands and elsewhere and it would leave severe scars
What was smallpox?
- orthopox virus (genus)
- first disease for which a vaccine was developed.
- Cowpox, monkeypox separate species
- But overlapping immunities
What was Variolation?
- some of first references to this from China 16th century texts
- Would take matter out of smallpox legions (the pus) and then take it and place it in the nostrils or the skin of the person they were trying to variolate.
- Goal was to provoke a mild attack of the disease so that the person gets sick, recovers and has immunity to it going forward
- and/or would have a much milder cases if they got it later on
- People would also intentionally expose their children to ppl who had smallpox in hopes that they would have a mild case and going forward be immune
- In Europe it was largely a folk practice → changed in 18th c. because the disease became more serious
- Hans Sloan (1660-1753) and Charles Maitland (1668-1748) were physicians who advocated for and practiced smallpox variolation
- Caroline, Princess of Wales (1683-1737), asked for experiments on variolation, after which she chose variolation for her own children.
- Tested variolation on 6 prisoners → got sick and recovered and 6th showed no symptoms (probably lied and had it when he was younger) → either way showed variolation was a success
- Also tested on orphans
Who were the pro-variolation people in Europe in the 17th-18th centuries?
- Pro-variolation included ministers, clergymen
- Cotton Mather (well-known minister: learned of the practice from Onesimus an enslaved black man) and Onesimus
- Cotton Mather (in Boston) was a religious leader and surprisingly supported variolation
- In Europe and the colonies
- Cotton Mather (well-known minister: learned of the practice from Onesimus an enslaved black man) and Onesimus
- Anti-variolation included physicains, community leaders
- Because some people would get smallpox and die from it.
- Benjamin Franklin originally opposed variolation until his son got it and died → then became pro variolation (bc he thought he should have tried and done sth more to proect his son)
- Part of it was that they thought it was Gods will whether you got smallpox and died of it → thought clergymen were being hypocritical
What was Benjamin Franklin’s Role in Variolation in the 18th century?
- Initially opposed to variolation
- Argued that it was hypocritical for clergy to promote variolation (went against God’s Providence/Will)
- Then changed his mind after the loss of a son in 1736 to smallpox.
- James Kirkpatrick practiced variolation in the 1740s.
- Claimed he had a safer method.
- Physicians, surgeons, apothecaries detailed that variolation should be preceded by bleeding, purging, and proper diet to bring the body’s humours into balance.
- In some respects variolation wasn’t like 20th c vaccination campaigns that actually had signiifcnat effects on mortality
When was the Smallpox pandemic and what was it?
c. 1775-82
- “Pox Americana”
- Mexico City to Portage La Loche (today: Canada)
- killed a lot of ppl in what is now Manitoba and Saskatchewan
- Continental pandemic
- Coincided with American Revolution (1775-82)
In the Americas, who was most vulnerable to smallpox in the 1750s and 1760s?
- People fighting for the revolution → poor hygiene, wounded, malnourished (weak immune systems), close quarters
- The British hired German soldiers who were coming from Europe → much more likely to be exposed to smallpox as children
- Those born and raised in the Americas → many children of colonists were more vulnerable to smallpox than the Europeans they were fighting against
- Meant that George Washington’s soldiers were more vulnerable to smallpox than the British
The Politics of Differential Immunity
- Washington required his troops to be variolated.
- SEE IMAGE
- During the American Revolution, George Washington also imposed a “vaccination mandate”
- Said there was more to fear from smallpox than the enemy army
- In general, the variolation served to protect the Americans
What was the relationship between smallpox and Washington/the American Revolution in 1775-82?
- Washington required his troops to be variolated/innoculated against smallpox.
- SEE IMAGE
- During the American Revolution, George Washington also imposed a “vaccination mandate”
- Said there was more to fear from smallpox than the enemy army
- In general, the variolation served to protect the Americans
Who was Edward Jenner (1749-1832)?
- practicing physician
- was also an amateur scientist
- approached natural knowledge in a general way
- realized those who got cowpox did not usually contract smallpox
- Disease went from the cows to the dairymaids → those who milked the cows saw inflamed spots appear on different part of the hands and on the wrists
- Cowpox made person kind of sick and had bumps on wrist, but not sick like with smallpox.
- Published his studies
- Began to practice experiments:
- with ppl who are marginal
- orphan → gave him cowpox and then tried to variolate him with smallpox → when the boy didn’t get any sickness with smallpox after being sick with cowpox, this confirmed his hypothesis.
- At the time this was perceived as potentially benefiting those children
- Did these experiments on his own children as well bc he had successful attempts
- Vacca - latin for Cow
- Could take mild, non-scarring disease (cowpox) and it would give you immunity to smallpox
- Vaccine was lymph material from those already infected with cowpox → inject it into the skin
- Not universally well-received by everyone at the time
- Faced opposition from ppl who didn’t like variolation in the first place; opposition also from variolators (stealing their business with the vaccination)
What was the Hudson’s Bay Vaccination Progam?
1838-39
- Vaccination and variolation
- Jenner said vaccination would confer lifelong immunity
- By 1809 it was recognized that you would need to get multiple vaccinations and that it would not have lifelong immunity
- Every time smallpox broke out, they would try to encourage ppl to get vaccinated
- Widespread dissemination of vaccine
- Via Hudson’s Bay company to Canada
- Outside of military conflict, it was in the HBC’s best interest to not have smallpox spread → in the self interest of trade with the Hudson’s Bay Company they did try to provide indigenous ppl with some sort of healthcare, including providing vaccination.
- Encouraged isolation to avoid spread
- Lymph could be preserved by drying and the ivory points used as needles were easy to transport
- could vaccinate one person and use that person to vaccinate others
- some success in 1830s, but lymph was not always working by the time it crossed the Atlantic/made its way there
- other challenges: opposition and support; sometimes indigenous ppl and their families would hear about vaccinations and come into the trade posts to seek them out; in other stories mercenaries would have to chase them down to vaccinate them
When was the Hudson’s Bay Vaccination Program?
1838-39.
What was the Medicine Chest Clause, Treaty 6?
“That a medicine chest shall be kept at the house of each Indian Agent for the use and benefit of the Indians at the direction of such agent.”
- in response to smallpox in the 19th c.
What are other examples of vaccination programs?
- State vaccination programs:
- Russian 1812, Sweden 1816, Britain 1853, France 1902
- Vaccination did not confer life-long immunity
- Liberal states hesitated to compel vaccination; needed also an enforcement bureaucracy
- Public health
- After 1898, England required that vaccine lymph be produced from calves.
What was the result of vaccination programs started in the 19th century?
- Eventually lead to eradication of smallpox in 20th century.
- Smallpox vaccination campaigns, vaccination mandates, and anti-vaccination sentiment.
- Long-standing, historical, shared themes.
Who was Thomas Sydenham (1624-89)? And what did he study?
- Began practicing in London in 1655 investigating smallpox and other fevers
- 1665 Great Plague
- Also the subject of Daniel Defoe’s 1722 novel. (”A Journal of the Plague Year”
- Emphasized environmental conditions and characters of epidemics
- Founder of clinical medicine and epidemiology
- “English Hippocrates”
- trying to understand diseases as a product of their environments
- Clinical Medicine: Deals with the diagnosis and treatment of dieases in human beings. It is also concerned with the prevention of disease and the promotion of health.
- Epidemiology: The study of the determinants, occurrence and distribution of health and disease in a defined population.
What is Clinical Medicine?
Deals with the diagnosis and treatment of dieases in human beings. It is also concerned with the prevention of disease and the promotion of health.
- Sydenham was the founder.
What is Epidemiology?
The study of the determinants, occurrence and distribution of health and disease in a defined population.
- founded by Edward Sydenham
What were Bills of Mortality?
- Used to inform the royal court and other elites about the number of cases of plague that were circulating in London so if it got really bad they could get out of town.
- Used as a means to chart cases of disease and their spread through time
- They were collected by parish clerks → when a death was reported to them, they reported it.
- eg. King’s Evil → Scrofula
- Systematic record → has accuracy and consistency to it as well
- This is a bad plague week
- They only applied to people who were the members of the Church of England
What is the role of urbanization in spread of disease?
- Role of urban environments in the spread and control of disease
- SEE images
- A lot more travel between urban centres → bring in more disease
- Dramatic rate of urbanization: top: London relative to other cities
- Bottom: dark black at bottom is London
What were the major infectious diseases in the 19th century?
→ all except tuberculosis were thought to be miasmatics (bad air diseases)
- Whooping cough (pertussis)
- Measles
- Scarlet Fever
- Diphtheria
- Smallpox
- declining importance bc of vaccinations
- Typhoid
- called “filth disease” → directly connected to unsanitary conditions found in urban environments
- Typhus
- called “filth disease” → directly connected to unsanitary conditions found in urban environments
- Cholera
- Tuberculosis
→ caused a lot of deaths in 19th c.
→ by 20th c. steep decline in death from disease
What were Miasmas?
- Belief that most, if not all disease, arose from inhaling air that had been corrupted by decaying matter.
- Eg. waste that was breaking down → believed the smell was signalling that you were inhaling sth that is making you sick
- Apparent in the smell and texture of the air.
- SEE Edwin Chadwick quote
- All smell is “immediate acute disease […] all smell is disease”
- Diseases are bad smells
What was Cholera like in the 19th century according to the Annual Deaths from Infectious Disease 1853-1882?
- Cholera → comparatively low death count but then it has peak years
- Marked as being not neccessarily the worst disease in terms of mortality but did have dramatic impacts
- episodic impacts
- prominent in 19th c imaginations of disease → people terrified of it → but overall it was not that bad
What was Cholera like in the 19th century imagination?
- Cholera tramples the victors then vanquished both
- Cholera in the 19th c. European imagination
- Cholera came and arrived in Europe through a series of Pandemics
- People would get word that it was spreading → frightened of the imminent arrival of it before it arrived
- Cholera product of new technology → steamships, printing → brought disease and news of cholera
- When it reached the industrial slums → ideally suited fro the spread of the disease due to bad quality of water and hygiene
- 1837 (Victorian era) → so concerned about modesty so if you have a disease like cholera that causes vomitting and runny diaherra → part of fear of cholera was modesty based