Immigration Controls Structure

Question 1

Introduction:

Answer 1

1. What is IM Policy - Czaika & De Haas
2. Objectives
3. Policy Failure - Castles
4. Effect vs. Effectiveness - Czaika & de Haas
5. 3 Concerns - Cornelius
6. 2 Claims - Hollified
7. Argument: restriction is not more effective and results in adverse effects
   a) 4 substitution effects - de Haas
   b) Labour issues
   c) domestic, regional and international issues with restrictive policy making
8. will also explore how preferences are shpaed and what effective policy does

Question 2

Argument #1:

Answer 2

Strengths

1) effect composition
2) 3 types of control
3) public satisfaction (numbers game)

Question 3

Argument #2:

Answer 3

Issues:

1) 3 Factors - Castles
2) 4 Substitution Effects - De Haas
3) Labour
- migraiton industry - Czaika & de Haas
- DLMT - Massey
4) Domestic issues (stated vs. real objectives)
5) regional constraints (CAF and burden sharing)
6) international constraints (structural pull factors) Thielemann

Question 4

Argument #3:

Answer 4

Preferences

1) liberal constraint/international pressure
2) PAT
3) determinants
- reception capacity, settlement patterns etc

Question 5

Argument #4:

Answer 5

Things to Consider:

1. Human Capability and Agency - de Haas
2. Positive vs. Negative Freedoms
3. Legal Channels
4. Populism/Discourse/real research - de Haas myths